Comment on "Dark Matter with Pseudoscalar-Mediated Interactions Explains the DAMA Signal and the Galactic Center Excess"
Extracted source text ยท arXiv 1605.05868
\documentclass[aps,prl,showpacs,twocolumn]{revtex4-1}
%\documentclass[english,aps,nofootinbib,twocolumn,preprintnumbers,nobalancelastpage,floatfix,groupedaddress,superscriptaddress,prl,reprint]{revtex4-1}
\usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,graphicx}
\newcommand{\be}{\begin{equation}}
\newcommand{\ee}{\end{equation}}
\newcommand{\bea}{\begin{eqnarray}}
\newcommand{\eea}{\end{eqnarray}}
\newcommand{\non}{\nonumber}
\begin{document}
\noindent{\bf Comment on ``Dark Matter with Pseudoscalar-Mediated Interactions Explains the DAMA Signal and the Galactic Center Excess''}\\
%\pacs{ }
\noindent In a recent Letter \cite{Arina:2014yna}, the Dirac fermionic dark matter with pseudoscalar-mediated interactions has been proposed as an explanation for the Galactic Center excess, correct relic density and DAMA signal.
%
The DAMA regions may be rejected by flavor constraints \cite{Dolan:2014ska}. However, since the process is approximated by one-particle exchange in the simplified model approach, the inclusion of multi-particle exchange processes may change the form of WIMP-nucleus cross sections, and all bounds shall be reconsidered \cite{DelNobile:2015lxa}.
%
The authors of \cite{Arina:2014yna} assumed that contact interactions, with ${g_{\rm DM} g}/({|\vec{q}|^2 +m_a^2}$) replaced by $1/\Lambda_a^2$, remain roughly valid in calculating scattering rates at the direct detection even when the mediator mass $m_a$ is the same order as the typical momentum transfer $|\vec{q}|$.
To account for these observables, they find that $m_a$ is of order 50 MeV. They expect small changes occur in their fit to DAMA due to onset of the long-range region but conclusions will not be modified.
We will show that such a replacement is not suitable. We follow \cite{Arina:2014yna} for notations and inputs. Adopting full form of interactions, Figs.~1(a) and 2(a) show DAMA results for universal and Higgs-like couplings in the $m_{\rm DM}$-$m_a/\sqrt{g_{\rm DM} g}$ plane with respect to different values of $m_a$. $m_a$ dependence of $m_a/\sqrt{g_{\rm DM} g}$ is thus shown.
%For comparison, in the contact interaction limit $m_a\gg |\vec{q}|$, the allowed regions, smaller than that in \cite{Arina:2014yna}, are well consistent with \cite{DelNobile:2015lxa}.
In Figs.~\ref{fig:quc}(b) and \ref{fig:higgs}(b), we plot DAMA regions with dark matter mass $m_{\rm DM}\sim40$ GeV, further including uncertainties due to variations of quark masses and $\Delta{q}^{(N)}$, and $\gamma$-ray excess regions in the $m_{a}$-$m_a/\sqrt{g_{\rm DM} g}$ plane. The DAMA (gray shaded) regions satisfy that $m_a/\sqrt{g_{\rm DM} g}$ (or $g_{\rm DM}g$) is constant for $m_a$ $\gg$ (or $\ll$) 100 MeV. In Fig.~\ref{fig:quc}(b), the solid and dotdashed lines, corresponding to $\gamma$-ray excess best fits given in \cite{Arina:2014yna}, are for universal couplings to all quarks and only to heavy quarks ($c, b, t$), respectively, where shaded regions are uncertainties (3$\sigma$) from updated analyses \cite{Daylan:2014rsa}. It shows that DAMA and $\gamma$-ray excess regions do not overlap% (not only due to that the DM mass required for the GC excess is outside the DAMA iodine region)
, even for heavy-flavor-universal couplings, for which $m_{\rm DM}\approx30\sim50$~GeV in the $\gamma$-ray excess fit. %its allowed parameters are completely outside of the DAMA iodine 3$\sigma$ region.
(It was found in \cite{Dolan:2014ska} that for flavor universal couplings, the DAMA signal is incompatible with the thermal relic requirement.)
As for Higgs-like couplings, the two regions overlap for $m_a\lesssim$ 15 MeV, where long-range interactions, instead of contact interactions, occur at the DAMA.
%In conclusion,
In summary, we did not find the conclusion in \cite{Arina:2014yna} warranted.
\vspace{0mm}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\noindent {\it Acknowledgement.}
This work was supported in part by the Ministry of Science and Technology of R.O.C. under Grant No: 102-2112-M-033-007-MY3.
%
\\
\vskip30mm
\noindent{Kwei-Chou Yang}\\
{\small Department of Physics and Center for High Energy Physics, Chung Yuan Christian University, Taoyuan 320, Taiwan}
\vskip0mm
\begin{figure}[t!]
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=0.39\textwidth]{quc1.pdf}
\\
\includegraphics[width=0.39\textwidth]{quc2.pdf}
\caption{\label{fig:quc} (a) 2$\sigma$ (inner) and 3$\sigma$ (outer) DAMA regions in the $( m_{\rm DM}, m_a/\sqrt{g_{\rm DM}g})$ plane for (heavy-)flavor-universal couplings. The corresponding number in parentheses is $m_a$ in units of GeV. (b) 3$\sigma$ allowed regions for DAMA (gray) and for $\gamma$-ray excess with flavor-universal (blue) and heavy-flavor-universal couplings (red). The range between dashed lines is for the contact limit.}
\end{center}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}[t!]
\includegraphics[width=0.38\textwidth]{yuk1.pdf}
\\
\includegraphics[width=0.38\textwidth]{yuk2.pdf}
\caption{\label{fig:higgs} Same as Fig. \ref{fig:quc} except for Higgs-like couplings.}
\end{figure}
\vspace{3mm}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\begin{thebibliography}{999}
%\newcommand{\bb}{\bibitem}
%\cite{Arina:2014yna}
\bibitem{Arina:2014yna}
C.~Arina, E.~Del Nobile and P.~Panci,
%``Dark Matter with Pseudoscalar-Mediated Interactions Explains the DAMA Signal and the Galactic Center Excess,''
Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ {\bf 114}, 011301 (2015).
% doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.011301
% [arXiv:1406.5542 [hep-ph]].
%%CITATION = doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.011301;%%
%68 citations counted in INSPIRE as of 06 Apr 2016
%\cite{Dolan:2014ska}
\bibitem{Dolan:2014ska}
M.~J.~Dolan {\it et al.},
% F.~Kahlhoefer, C.~McCabe and K.~Schmidt-Hoberg,
%``A taste of dark matter: Flavour constraints on pseudoscalar mediators,''
JHEP {\bf 1503}, 171 (2015) Erratum: [JHEP {\bf 1507}, 103 (2015)]
% doi:10.1007/JHEP07(2015)103, 10.1007/JHEP03(2015)171
% [arXiv:1412.5174 [hep-ph]].
%%CITATION = doi:10.1007/JHEP07(2015)103, 10.1007/JHEP03(2015)171;%%
%39 citations counted in INSPIRE as of 02 May 2016
%\cite{DelNobile:2015lxa}
\bibitem{DelNobile:2015lxa}
E.~Del Nobile, G.~B.~Gelmini, A.~Georgescu and J.~H.~Huh,
%``Reevaluation of spin-dependent WIMP-proton interactions as an explanation of the DAMA data,''
JCAP {\bf 1508}, no. 08, 046 (2015).
% doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2015/08/046
% [arXiv:1502.07682 [hep-ph]].
%%CITATION = doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2015/08/046;%%
%8 citations counted in INSPIRE as of 13 Apr 2016
%\cite{Daylan:2014rsa}
\bibitem{Daylan:2014rsa}
T.~Daylan {\it et al.},
%D.~P.~Finkbeiner, D.~Hooper, T.~Linden, S.~K.~N.~Portillo, N.~L.~Rodd and T.~R.~Slatyer,
%``The characterization of the gamma-ray signal from the central Milky Way: A case for annihilating dark matter,''
Phys.\ Dark Univ.\ {\bf 12}, 1 (2016).
% doi:10.1016/j.dark.2015.12.005
%[arXiv:1402.6703 [astro-ph.HE]].
%%CITATION = doi:10.1016/j.dark.2015.12.005;%%
%283 citations counted in INSPIRE as of 13 Apr 2016
\end{thebibliography}
\end{document}