A high sensitivity tool for geophysical applications: A geometrically locked Ring Laser Gyroscope
Extracted source text · arXiv 2207.04942
\documentclass{osa-article}
%% Select the journal you're submitting to
%% oe, boe, ome, osac, osajournal
\journal{osajournal}
% Key:
% Express journals must have the correct journal selected:
% {oe} Optics Express
% {boe} Biomedical Optics Express
% {ome} Optical Material Express
% {optcon} Optics Continuum
% Other OSA journals may use:
% {osajournal} Applied Optics, Advances in Optics and Photonics, Journal of the Optical Society of America A/B, Optics Letters, Optica, Photonics Research
% Uncomment if submitting to Photonics Research.
% ONLY APPLICABLE FOR \journal{osajournal}
% \setprjcopyright
% Set the article type
\articletype{Research Article}
% Note that article type is not required for Express journals (OE, BOE, OME and OSAC)
\usepackage{lineno}
%\linenumbers
\begin{document}
\title{A high sensitivity tool for geophysical applications: A geometrically locked Ring Laser Gyroscope.}
\author{
E.~Maccioni,\authormark{1,2} N.~Beverini,\authormark{1} G.~Carelli,\authormark{1,2,*} G.~Di~Somma,\authormark{1,2} A.~Di~Virgilio,\authormark{2} and P.~Marsili\authormark{1,2}
}
\address{
\authormark{1}University of Pisa, Pisa, Italy,
\authormark{2}INFN Sezione di Pisa, Pisa, Italy
}
\email{\authormark{*}giorgio.carelli@unipi.it}
\begin{abstract}
This work demonstrates that a middle size ring laser gyroscope (RLG)
can be a very sensitive and robust instrument for rotational seismology,
even if it operates in a quite noisy environment. The RLG has a
square cavity, $1.60\times 1.60$ m$^2$, and it lies in a plane
orthogonal to the Earth rotational axis. The Fabry-Perot optical
cavities along the diagonals of the square were accessed and their
lengths were locked to a reference laser. Through a quite simple
locking circuit, we were able to keep the sensor fully operative for
14~days. The obtained long term stability is of the order of 3~nanorad/s and the
short term sensitivity close is to 2~nanorad/s$\cdot$Hz$^{-1/2}$.
These results are limited only by the noisy environment,
our laboratory is located in a building downtown.
\end{abstract}
\section{Introduction}
Large frame ring laser gyroscopes (RLG) are the most sensitive
absolute angular rotation sensors, they are able to combine the status of art
sensitivity with a bandwidth above 100~Hz, long term operation
and very large dynamic range.
The same device can efficiently records extremely low amplitude
signals and large shocks.
They are based on the Sagnac effect that appears as a difference in
the optical path between waves propagating in opposite direction in a
rotating closed loop. As a consequence, in a rotating RLG a difference
arises between the frequencies emitted by the laser in the two opposite
directions (Sagnac frequency). For a RLG rigidly connected to the ground,
the Earth rotation velocity is by far the dominant component of $\Omega$.
Eq. (\ref{eq:general}) gives the general relation connecting
the Sagnac frequency $f_s $,
and the modulus of the local angular rotation rate $\Omega$:
\begin{equation}
f_s = 4 \frac{A}{P \lambda} \Omega\cdot \cos(\theta)
\label{eq:general}
\end{equation}
where $A$ is the area enclosed by the optical path,
$P$ is the ring perimeter length,
$\lambda$ the intracavity laser wavelength, and
$\theta$ is the angle between the area vector and the rotational axis.
Our prototype, GP2, is a square laser gyroscope
with a perimeter of 6.40~m, that is operative
in a laboratory placed inside the basement of the Pisa INFN building,
see Fig.\ref{photo}.
\begin{figure}[htbp]
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=\columnwidth]{DSC_9789.jpeg}
\caption{GP2 gyroscope inside the building of the INFN Pisa section}
\label{photo}
\end{center}
\end{figure}
It was built as a test bench to develop the optical and electronic technologies
that will be implemented in GINGER. The last is
a very high sensitivity three dimensional array
of large frame RLGs, currently in the design phase,
which has the aim of verifying general
relativity theories on a laboratory scale \cite{angela2017}.
Nevertheless, GP2 has also the aim of contributing to the development
of reduced scale RLGs (4 - 8 m in perimeter) with a bit lower performance,
devoted to geophysical and seismic applications.
The quality of the performances of a RLG are strictly related to the control
of the geometrical scale factor $S=4 \frac{A}{P \lambda}\cos(\theta)$,
and of the laser kinematics.
In a previous papers we addressed the complex problem of the reduction
of the non-linear laser dynamics perturbation \cite{Angela2019,Angela_epj2020},
elaborating a procedure that was applied to the $3.60\times 3.60~$m$^2$~ RLG
"Gingerino", placed in the deep underground Gran Sasso laboratory.
In spite of its limitation, due to the reduced dimension and to the noisy location,
GP2 can give important information about the procedures for the control
of the scale factor, thanks to its peculiar properties.
First of all, the ring is oriented with its axis nearly parallel to the Earth axis,
so that the accuracy is improved and the disturbances induced on the Sagnac signal
by local tilting are minimized.
Furthermore, the vacuum chamber includes also additional pipes connecting
the opposite mirrors along the two diagonals .
In this way, the four mirrors define, besides the square optical cavity,
also two Fabry-P\'erot (FP) linear resonators along the diagonals,
that can be used to better define and control the ring geometry.
We already demonstrated in \cite{Stefani2018,Beverini_2020}
to be able to measure and to stabilize the lengths of the diagonals of GP2
with a statistical accuracy of some tens of nanometers.
This results was obtained through an interferometric technique,
by using for each diagonal
of a double Pound-Drever-Hall (PDH) control loop.
In this work we investigate the geometrical properties of GP2,
by testing new simplified procedures to measure and control the geometrical shape
and the scale factor that could be profitably applied to the reduced scale RLGs.
\section{The apparatus}
\subsection{The mechanical structure}
The optical cavity of GP2 is a square defined by four high-quality dielectric mirrors.
It is mounted inside a vacuum room composed by four corner chambers, hosting the mirrors,
connected, through bellows, by pipes along the sides and the diagonals of the square.
Each mirror is rigidly fixed to the chambers that are mounted on a piezoelectric
slide (PZT), screwed on a massive granite table that warrants the stiffness
of the apparatus.
The PZTs can drive displacements along the direction of the diagonals within
an $80\ \mu$m range.
The whole vacuum volume is filled by a 6.4 millibar of He and 0.2 millibar
of a mixture of $^{20}$Ne and $^{22}$Ne, with a 1:1 ratio of the two isotopes.
A pyrex capillary, 5~mm inner diameter, is inserted halfway of one side
where the gas is excited by a capacitive rf discharge.
In order to minimize the losses and maximize the resonator quality factor,
no windows are inserted inside the laser optical paths.
A getter-pump provides to keep clean from any contamination the noble gas mixtures.
The granite slab is fixed on a concrete base, tilted in the N-S direction
by about $46.6^{\circ}$, which is the value of the local colatitude.
Besides, in order to have the ring axis oriented in the local meridian plane,
it was taken specific care of the positioning of the base .
\subsection{The optics}
~
We mounted very high quality mirrors 1" in diameter on GP2.
Recently, we changed the optics with respect to that reported
in Ref. \cite{Stefani2018,Beverini_2020}, mounting a more performing set of mirrors
and realigning the optical cavity.
The new mirrors were tested, demonstrating at 45° s-polarized incidence
a reflectivity of 0.999995(1) and a transmission of 0.35(5) ppm,
in accordance with the supplier's specifications.
By means of ring-down measurements, the quality factor of the ring cavity
was obtained equal to approx$10^{12}$, corresponding to overall losses of 100~ppm.
Note that overall losses include also the losses for diffraction in the capillary.
The reflectivity of the mirrors at normal incidence is quite lower,
so that the Q factor of the FP optical cavities along the diagonals is
of the order of $10^{10}$.
Also the reference metrological laser (RfL) is presently
a Winters Electro-Optics Helium-Neon laser locked to a saturated absorption transition
of molecular iodine. Following the specification, the emission frequency is
$f_{Winter}=473 612 622.97\pm 0.01 $~MHz.
By means of an optical hetherodyne technique between the RLG emission beam and
the reference laser on a fast photo-diode we can measure the RLG frequency
in the new alignment with an accuracy of 1~MHz, limited by the RLG vibration noise.
\subsection{Data acquisition and elaboration}
The Sagnac interferometric signal is the beat note, obtained by a photo-diode,
between the clock-wise and counter-clock-wise beams.
The two beams are extracted by the same mirror, and the beat note is stored
continuously at a rate of 5 kSample/s.
In parallel at the same rate, we also record the intensity of
the two counter-propagating beams ($monobeam~signals$) exiting from a second mirror,
see Fig.\ref{setup}.
Data are elaborated off-line by a \textsc{Matlab}$^{\circledR}$
procedure in order to correct
the interferometric signal for mirrors back-scattering effects.
Following the algorithms described in \cite{Angela2019},
we identify and correct these effects by using the monobeam signals.
The procedure can be elaborated quickly, producing the reduced data quasi on-line,
in a few seconds, and includes the largest correction terms,
usually referred as backscatter noise.
In a second step, \cite{Angela_epj2020} linear regression methods could be applied
to evaluate and correct the null-shift, related to the time evolution
of the losses of the laser optical resonator.
This procedure requires the off-line elaboration of extended sets of data,
of the order of $10^4 - 10^5 $~s.
However, in RLG equipped with high quality mirrors the effects are quite small
with a slow evolution time, and can be neglected at the Fourier frequencies
of interest in seismic applications, frequency window spanning from 0.01 to 100~Hz.
\begin{figure}[htbp]
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=\columnwidth]{Fig_setup.jpeg}
\caption{Operational setup for geometrical stabilization.
AOM Acoustic Optical Modulator;
VCO Voltage Controlled Oscillator; PZT piezoelectric device; PD photo diode;
$I_{1t}$, $I_{2t}$ transmission signal of the diagonal 1 and 2 resonators;
$V_1$, $V_2$ error signal of diagonal 1 and 2.}
\label{setup}
\end{center}
\end{figure}
\section{Stabilization of the RLG scale factor}
In order to stabilize the scale factor $S$, the standard techniques are to lock
the ring perimeter length by comparing the RLG emission frequency
with an optical frequency standard or the RLG cavity FSR with a radio-frequency standard.
The presence of the two FP resonators along the square ring cavity allows
the implementation of a procedure that optimise the ring shape and
stabilize $S$ \cite{Santagata2015} by stabilizing the length
of the two diagonals.
Our procedure acts symmetrically on the PZTs, moving the four mirrors
along the diagonal direction. It gives the advantage of keeping invariant the ring shape
and, as a consequence, the phase of the radiation back scattered by the mirrors,
which is the principal source of error due the non-linearity of the laser kinematics.
The new simplified scheme is shown in Fig.\ref{setup}.
The radiation coming from our RfL is sent through two polarization maintaining
single-mode fibers into the Fabry-P\'erot resonators build by the diagonal
opposite mirrors to interrogate the two diagonal FP.
Into the fiber path is inserted an acousto-optics modulator (AOM),
operating around 200~MHz.
Each FP transmission signal is collected on a photodiode, then it's amplified
by a transimpendance modulus and finally it's sent to a data acquisition card
National Instrument USB-6363.
A VCO sweeps the in-fiber AOM every 100~ms of some MHz.
A LabVIEW program visualises the two transmission signals. At the beginning of each run,
the PZTs that move the mirrors are manually driven by a DC voltage in order
to center the transmission peaks inside the AOM sweep. Eventually, the sweep is reduced
to about 1~MHz and the LabView program will calculate in two independent
parallel ways the voltage of the PZTs corresponding to the maxima
of the transmission signals, sending the error signal to the PZTs to close the loop.
The high frequency response of the servo loop is limited to a few tenths of Hz,
because each PZT slide must move the whole chamber mass, bigger than 2~kg.
We underline that the correction signal is sent symmetrically on the two PZTs
of each diagonal. This solution allows a correction of the temperature dilation
without deforming the geometry of the optical path, which would affect
the back-scattering phase.
\begin{figure}[htbp]
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=\columnwidth]{Allan.jpg}
\caption{
Allan plot of the Sagnac frequency relative to a run with active locking condition 14 days long (blue points) and to a selected free running 3-hours recording (red circles)
}
\label{Allan}
\end{center}
\end{figure}
\section {Discussion of the experimental results}
We compared Sagnac signal of two 2-days long runs, recorded respectively with and
without the active stabilization of the diagonals, in slightly different environmental condition.
The raw data were in both cases reduced for backscattering.
For the run without stabilization, we obtained a mean Sagnac frequency
value of 184.1593~Hz with a standard deviation of 0.0734~Hz,
while for the locked diagonals run, we find
a mean Sagnac frequency value of 184.1327~Hz with a standard deviation of 0.0536~Hz.
Moreover, in locked condition no data point were lost
in the whole run, while in the free running case it was necessary to discard
the 26\% of the data.
The efficacy of the stabilization is further demonstrated in Fig. \ref{Allan}
that shows the Allan plot of the Sagnac frequency relative to a 14 days long locked run.
No data were discarded and the Allan is certainly affected by the
environmental disturbances produced by the everyday activity.
At high frequency the signal is dominated by the environment vibration noise,
while it is achieved a long time stability better than
$3 \times10^{-9}~$rad/s over one day.
By comparison, we superimpose the Allan plot of a selected time interval
(about two hours) in unlocked operation. Note that also in the best condition
of the free running mode it was possible to acquire a continuous set of data
without spikes or jumps for no more than two or three hours.
The location guesting GP2 is a building downtown and it's quite noisy.
An evaluation of its instrumental sensitivity in locked configuration can be deduced
from the plots of Amplitude Spectral Density shown in Fig. \ref{fig:ASD},
calculated in selected lime interval with the lowest environment noise.
\begin{figure}
\centering
\includegraphics[width=\columnwidth]{ASD_sel_2Hz.jpg}
\caption{Amplitude Spectral Density calculated on two selected time intervals}
\label{fig:ASD}
\end{figure}
A level of 2 nanorad/s/Hz$^{-1/2}$ is achieved in 0.02-0.3 Hz range.
Note that in present configuration the high frequency locking efficiency
is limited by the PZT, as stated in section 3.
The technique described in the previous chapter allows the stabilization
of the ring geometry and of the scale factor of the RLG,
but it does not give the opportunity of optimizing the ring geometry following
the procedure suggested in \cite{Santagata2015}.
For this purpose it is necessary to measure the absolute values of the ring optical path
and of the diagonals length. Knowing this quantities, it is possible to evaluate
an expected value of the scale factor $S$ and to compare it with the measured one.
The perimeter of the optical path can be calculated as $p=n c / $FSR,
where the refraction index of the intracavity medium $n$ can be estimated as
$1+2.1\times 10^{-7} $ \cite{Hurst2017}.
The ring laser FSR is measured by observing on a fast photo-diode
the frequency spectrum of the RLG emission while increasing a bit
the laser excitation up to the onset of a second longitudinal mode.
We find a ring $p=6.3963216$~m.
To measure the absolute diagonal length we described in
Ref \cite{Stefani2018,Beverini_2020} a complex procedure requiring for each diagonal
a double PDH locking circuit. Here we used an alternative more simple method
by eliminating the second PDH locking. It is a
less performing method, but it's accurate enough for our purpose,
.
As in \cite{Stefani2018}, the diagonal are measured one at a time in sequence.
The light beam coming from the RfL is injected through polarization maintaining
single-mode fibers in the two diagonal resonators and
the single diagonal resonance frequency is locked to the RfL frequency
through a PDH circuit.
Then, through an in-fiber EOM the laser radiation is frequency swept
around a multiple of the resonator FSR.
A LabVIEW software analyzes the transmitted signal fitting the data in order to find
the central FSR resonance frequency.
The diagonal length is then given by $L= c / (2n$~FSR).
We found a value of the lengths of $2 261 341 \mu$m and $2 261 541~\mu$m,
with an estimated error of the order of 1~$\mu$m.
We can observe that the perimeter $p'$ of a rhombus whose diagonals are equal
to the measured one, which is $p'=6.396~320$~m,is almost identical
to the value $p=6.396~321~6$ found before.
By using the observed values of the diagonals and of the perimeter,
we have also calculated the expected value of the scale factor $S$ of the GP2,
assuming a perfect rhomboid shape, perfectly aligned to Earth rotation axis, as:
$S=4A/(\lambda p)$
where $A$ is the area enclose by the optical path.
The intracavity wavelength $ \lambda $ is calculated as $c/f_0 $,
where $f_0= 473 612 683$~MHz is the frequency emitted by the RLG,
measured beating on a fast photodiode the RLG radiation against the RfL.
Then, the scale factor of the RLG is $S=4A/(\lambda p)=2.52768\times 10^6$,
giving a theoretical Sagnac frequency due to the Earth rotation rate
$\Omega_E = 7.29211586 \times 10^{-5}$ rad/s :
$f_{th}=S \Omega_E =184.216 Hz$.
This can be compared with an experimentally detected Sagnac frequency of 184.133 Hz.
The difference could be consistent with a misalignment of the ring resonator axis
of $1.7^\circ $, but also with residual non compensation
of the laser non-linear dynamics.
\section{Conclusions}
Rotational seismology requires instrumentation able to provide long term operation
with sensitivity close to nrad/s and suitable response in the frequency range from 0.01 to 100~Hz.
Middle size RLGs, such as our GP2 RLG prototype, have a simple and compact control apparatus and are
suitable to be installed in common geophysical observatories.
This paper shows that they can satisfy the listed requirements.
The duty cycle of a RLG is limited in principle by the dynamics of the laser,
which is affected by mode jumps and split mode operation.
The duty cycle of our free running prototype is effectively less than $80\%$.
The control strategy, tested on GP2, allows to recover the $100\%$ of the duty cycle in 14 days long continuous unattended operation, without affecting the sensitivity response.
Note that the present work make use of an expensive metrological laser with an accuracy better then $ 10^{-10}$ as reference length standard, but more simple commercially available reference lasers with a stability of 1 part on $10^7$ can provide a likewise efficient control for geophysical application.
\section{Acknowledgments}
Work funded by INFN
\section{Disclosures}
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
\bibliography{library}
\end{document}
\begin{thebibliography}{1}
\newcommand{\enquote}[1]{``#1''}
\bibitem{angela2017}
A.~D.~V. Di~Virgilio, J.~Belfi, W.-T. Ni, N.~Beverini, G.~Carelli, E.~Maccioni,
and A.~Porzio, \enquote{Ginger: A feasibility study,}
{\protect\JournalTitle{The European Physical Journal Plus}} \textbf{132}, 157
(2017).
\bibitem{Angela2019}
A.~D.~V. Di~Virgilio, N.~Beverini, G.~Carelli, D.~Ciampini, F.~Fuso, and
E.~Maccioni, \enquote{Analysis of ring laser gyroscopes including laser
dynamics,} {\protect\JournalTitle{The European Physical Journal C}}
\textbf{79}, 573 (2019).
\bibitem{Angela_epj2020}
A.~D.~V. Di~Virgilio, N.~Beverini, G.~Carelli, D.~Ciampini, F.~Fuso,
U.~Giacomelli, and E.~Maccioni, \enquote{Identification and correction of
sagnac frequency variations,} {\protect\JournalTitle{The European Physical
Journal C}} \textbf{80} (2020).
\bibitem{Stefani2018}
F.~Stefani, N.~Beverini, G.~Carelli, D.~Ciampini, A.~Di~Virgilio, F.~Fuso, and
E.~Giacomelli, U.and~Maccioni, \enquote{{Long term stabilization of large
frame laser gyroscopes},} in \emph{{3020nd} European Frequency and Time Forum
(EFTF),} (IEEE, Torino, Italy, 2018), pp. 119--121.
\bibitem{Beverini_2020}
N.~Beverini, G.~Carelli, A.~D. Virgilio, U.~Giacomelli, E.~Maccioni,
F.~Stefani, and J.~Belfi, \enquote{Length measurement and stabilization of
the diagonals of a square area laser gyroscope,}
{\protect\JournalTitle{Classical and Quantum Gravity}} \textbf{37}, 065025
(2020).
\bibitem{Santagata2015}
R.~Santagata, R.~Beghi, J.~Belfi, N.~Beverini, D.~Cuccato, A.~Di~Virgilio,
A.~Ortolan, A.~Porzio, and S.~Solimeno, \enquote{Optimization of the
geometrical stability in square ring laser gyroscopes,}
{\protect\JournalTitle{Classical and Quantum Gravity}} \textbf{32}, 055013
(2015).
\bibitem{Hurst2017}
R.~B. Hurst, M.~Mayerbacher, A.~Gebauer, K.~U. Schreiber, and J.-P.~R. Wells,
\enquote{High-accuracy absolute rotation rate measurements with a large ring
laser gyro: establishing the scale factor,} {\protect\JournalTitle{Applied
Optics}} \textbf{56}, 1124 (2017).
\end{thebibliography}