New resonance scattering model in AtomDB: application to line suppression in galaxy clusters and elliptical galaxies
Extracted source text · arXiv 2310.03892
%% Beginning of file 'sample631.tex'
%%
%% Modified 2022 May
%%
%% This is a sample manuscript marked up using the
%% AASTeX v6.31 LaTeX 2e macros.
%%
%% AASTeX is now based on Alexey Vikhlinin's emulateapj.cls
%% (Copyright 2000-2015). See the classfile for details.
%% AASTeX requires revtex4-1.cls and other external packages such as
%% latexsym, graphicx, amssymb, longtable, and epsf. Note that as of
%% Oct 2020, APS now uses revtex4.2e for its journals but remember that
%% AASTeX v6+ still uses v4.1. All of these external packages should
%% already be present in the modern TeX distributions but not always.
%% For example, revtex4.1 seems to be missing in the linux version of
%% TexLive 2020. One should be able to get all packages from www.ctan.org.
%% In particular, revtex v4.1 can be found at
%% https://www.ctan.org/pkg/revtex4-1.
%% The first piece of markup in an AASTeX v6.x document is the \documentclass
%% command. LaTeX will ignore any data that comes before this command. The
%% documentclass can take an optional argument to modify the output style.
%% The command below calls the preprint style which will produce a tightly
%% typeset, one-column, single-spaced document. It is the default and thus
%% does not need to be explicitly stated.
%%
%% using aastex version 6.3
%\documentclass[linenumbers]{aastex631}
\documentclass{aastex631}
%% The default is a single spaced, 10 point font, single spaced article.
%% There are 5 other style options available via an optional argument. They
%% can be invoked like this:
%%
%% \documentclass[arguments]{aastex631}
%%
%% where the layout options are:
%%
%% twocolumn : two text columns, 10 point font, single spaced article.
%% This is the most compact and represent the final published
%% derived PDF copy of the accepted manuscript from the publisher
%% manuscript : one text column, 12 point font, double spaced article.
%% preprint : one text column, 12 point font, single spaced article.
%% preprint2 : two text columns, 12 point font, single spaced article.
%% modern : a stylish, single text column, 12 point font, article with
%% wider left and right margins. This uses the Daniel
%% Foreman-Mackey and David Hogg design.
%% RNAAS : Supresses an abstract. Originally for RNAAS manuscripts
%% but now that abstracts are required this is obsolete for
%% AAS Journals. Authors might need it for other reasons. DO NOT
%% use \begin{abstract} and \end{abstract} with this style.
%%
%% Note that you can submit to the AAS Journals in any of these 6 styles.
%%
%% There are other optional arguments one can invoke to allow other stylistic
%% actions. The available options are:
%%
%% astrosymb : Loads Astrosymb font and define \astrocommands.
%% tighten : Makes baselineskip slightly smaller, only works with
%% the twocolumn substyle.
%% times : uses times font instead of the default
%% linenumbers : turn on lineno package.
%% trackchanges : required to see the revision mark up and print its output
%% longauthor : Do not use the more compressed footnote style (default) for
%% the author/collaboration/affiliations. Instead print all
%% affiliation information after each name. Creates a much
%% longer author list but may be desirable for short
%% author papers.
%% twocolappendix : make 2 column appendix.
%% anonymous : Do not show the authors, affiliations and acknowledgments
%% for dual anonymous review.
%%
%% these can be used in any combination, e.g.
%%
%% \documentclass[twocolumn,linenumbers,trackchanges]{aastex631}
%%
%% AASTeX v6.* now includes \hyperref support. While we have built in specific
%% defaults into the classfile you can manually override them with the
%% \hypersetup command. For example,
%%
%% \hypersetup{linkcolor=red,citecolor=green,filecolor=cyan,urlcolor=magenta}
%%
%% will change the color of the internal links to red, the links to the
%% bibliography to green, the file links to cyan, and the external links to
%% magenta. Additional information on \hyperref options can be found here:
%% https://www.tug.org/applications/hyperref/manual.html#x1-40003
%%
%% Note that in v6.3 "bookmarks" has been changed to "true" in hyperref
%% to improve the accessibility of the compiled pdf file.
%%
%% If you want to create your own macros, you can do so
%% using \newcommand. Your macros should appear before
%% the \begin{document} command.
%%
\newcommand{\vdag}{(v)^\dagger}
\newcommand\aastex{AAS\TeX}
\newcommand\latex{La\TeX}
\usepackage{graphicx,subfigure}
\usepackage[utf8]{inputenc}
\usepackage{longtable}
%\usepackage{subfig}
%\usepackage{graphicx}
\usepackage{booktabs}
\usepackage{multirow}
\usepackage{savesym}
\savesymbol{tablenum}
\usepackage{siunitx}
\restoresymbol{SIX}{tablenum}
\usepackage{natbib}
\usepackage{amsmath}
\graphicspath{{./}{figures/}}
\DeclareUnicodeCharacter{2009}{\,}
%% Reintroduced the \received and \accepted commands from AASTeX v5.2
%\received{March 1, 2021}
%\revised{April 1, 2021}
%\accepted{\today}
%% Command to document which AAS Journal the manuscript was submitted to.
%% Adds "Submitted to " the argument.
%\submitjournal{PSJ}
%% For manuscript that include authors in collaborations, AASTeX v6.31
%% builds on the \collaboration command to allow greater freedom to
%% keep the traditional author+affiliation information but only show
%% subsets. The \collaboration command now must appear AFTER the group
%% of authors in the collaboration and it takes TWO arguments. The last
%% is still the collaboration identifier. The text given in this
%% argument is what will be shown in the manuscript. The first argument
%% is the number of author above the \collaboration command to show with
%% the collaboration text. If there are authors that are not part of any
%% collaboration the \nocollaboration command is used. This command takes
%% one argument which is also the number of authors above to show. A
%% dashed line is shown to indicate no collaboration. This example manuscript
%% shows how these commands work to display specific set of authors
%% on the front page.
%%
%% For manuscript without any need to use \collaboration the
%% \AuthorCollaborationLimit command from v6.2 can still be used to
%% show a subset of authors.
%
%\AuthorCollaborationLimit=2
%
%% will only show Schwarz & Muench on the front page of the manuscript
%% (assuming the \collaboration and \nocollaboration commands are
%% commented out).
%%
%% Note that all of the author will be shown in the published article.
%% This feature is meant to be used prior to acceptance to make the
%% front end of a long author article more manageable. Please do not use
%% this functionality for manuscripts with less than 20 authors. Conversely,
%% please do use this when the number of authors exceeds 40.
%%
%% Use \allauthors at the manuscript end to show the full author list.
%% This command should only be used with \AuthorCollaborationLimit is used.
%% The following command can be used to set the latex table counters. It
%% is needed in this document because it uses a mix of latex tabular and
%% AASTeX deluxetables. In general it should not be needed.
%\setcounter{table}{1}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%
%% The following section outlines numerous optional output that
%% can be displayed in the front matter or as running meta-data.
%%
%% If you wish, you may supply running head information, although
%% this information may be modified by the editorial offices.
%\shorttitle{AASTeX v6.3.1 Sample article}
%\shortauthors{Schwarz et al.}
%%
%% You can add a light gray and diagonal water-mark to the first page
%% with this command:
%% \watermark{text}
%% where "text", e.g. DRAFT, is the text to appear. If the text is
%% long you can control the water-mark size with:
%% \setwatermarkfontsize{dimension}
%% where dimension is any recognized LaTeX dimension, e.g. pt, in, etc.
%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%\graphicspath{{./}{figures/}}
%% This is the end of the preamble. Indicate the beginning of the
%% manuscript itself with \begin{document}.
\begin{document}
\title{New resonance scattering model in AtomDB: application to line suppression in galaxy clusters and elliptical galaxies}
\author[0000-0002-4469-2518]{Priyanka Chakraborty}
\affiliation{Center for Astrophysics $\vert$ Harvard \& Smithsonian \\
}
\email{priyanka.chakraborty@cfa.harvard.edu}
\author[0000-0003-3462-8886]{Adam Foster}
\affiliation{Center for Astrophysics $\vert$ Harvard \& Smithsonian \\
}
\author[0000-0003-4284-4167]{Randall Smith}
\affiliation{Center for Astrophysics $\vert$ Harvard \& Smithsonian \\
}
\author[0000-0002-8704-4473]{Nancy Brickhouse}
\affiliation{Center for Astrophysics $\vert$ Harvard \& Smithsonian \\
}
\author[0000-0002-7868-1622]{John Raymond}
\affiliation{Center for Astrophysics $\vert$ Harvard \& Smithsonian \\
}
\begin{abstract}
In this paper, we present a simple, one-step, self-consistent, and fast resonance scattering model \texttt{rsapec} based on the AtomDB database. This model can be used as an alternative to the commonly used APEC model for fitting such X-ray spectra with optically thick lines. The current model is intended, in general, for verifying the presence of the effect and for spectral modeling of galaxy clusters and elliptical galaxies under applicable assumptions. We test \texttt{rsapec} to derive the line suppression in the elliptical galaxy NGC 4636 and the Perseus cluster of galaxies, and obtain resonance suppression of $\sim$ 1.24 and $\sim$ 1.30, respectively.
\end{abstract}
\section{Introduction:}
X-ray spectral lines are subject to being distorted by resonant scattering (RS). Resonant scattering occurs when optically thick line photons are absorbed by ions with similar resonant transition energies and are
immediately re-emitted in another direction. This process redirects photons, suppressing resonance line emission in some areas with matching enhancements in others. For example, in galaxies and clusters of galaxies, the resonant line intensities
are reduced towards their center and enhanced towards their outskirts.
Over the years, several studies reported the detection of the RS effect and demonstrated the importance of incorporating resonance scattering in modeling the X-ray spectra \citep{1987SvAL...13....3G, 1998ApJ...497..587S, 2004MNRAS.347...29C, 2006MNRAS.370...63S, 2023MNRAS.522.3665N}. RS is crucial for the accurate determination of the abundances of heavy elements in the intra-cluster medium \citep{2000AdSpR..25..603A, 2022MNRAS.516.3068S}, measurements of velocity fields and anisotropy of gas motion \citep{2010SSRv..157..193C, 2022ApJ...935L..23S, 2023ApJ...944..132S}, and the polarization of bright X-ray emission lines in galaxy clusters and elliptical galaxies \citep{2010MNRAS.403..129Z}. RS can be important
for diagnostics of density or ionization state using He-like ions, Fe L shell ions, or the ratios of
He-like to H-like ions \citep{1992ApJ...398L.115S}. RS
has also been suggested as an explanation for the weakness of O VII lines in the
shell of the Cygnus Loop supernova remnant, which otherwise would
imply a low oxygen abundance or charge transfer \citep{2019ApJ...871..234U}.
Tackling the problem of RS is not straightforward. Monte Carlo radiative transfer simulations have been extensively used in the context of RS in galaxies and clusters of galaxies \citep{1987SvAL...13....3G, 2002MNRAS.333..191S, 2006ApJ...643L..73M, 2011AstL...37..141Z}. Examples include the \texttt{Geant4} toolkit used for simulating the passage of photons through matter with functionalities like complex geometries and tracking \citep{2003NIMPA.506..250A, 2018PASJ...70...10H} and radiative Monte Carlo simulations used for the cluster ICM \citep{2002MNRAS.333..191S, 2004MNRAS.347...29C, 2010MNRAS.403..129Z}.
The above techniques are rigorous and time-consuming.
%It includes a complete range of functionality, including tracking, geometry, physics models
%nd Radiative monte carlo simulations
In this paper, we present a simple, one-step, and fast RS model for collisionally-ionized plasma for elliptical galaxies and galaxy clusters. Our new RS model, \texttt{rsapec}, can be used as an alternative to the commonly used APEC model for fitting the X-ray spectrum with optically thick lines.
This model aims to verify the presence of the effect and for spectral modeling of galaxy clusters and elliptical galaxies under relevant assumptions outlined in \citet{1998ApJ...497..587S}.
Sections \ref{s:2} and \ref{s:3} elaborate on the theoretical background and the model parameters used for constructing the \texttt{rsapec} model. Section \ref{s:4} shows the application of the \texttt{rsapec} model to the elliptical galaxy NGC 4636 and the Perseus cluster of galaxies. Section 5 discusses our results.
%causing suppression/enhancement in resonance lines.
%Here we show theoretical model spectra with and without resonant line scattering, as well as with and without turbulence (Zhuravleva et al., 2013).
\section{Theoretical Background:}\label{s:2}
\subsection{What drives intensity change in resonance lines?}
Line intensities in observed spectra is suppressed if line photons are scattered or destroyed.
In resonance scattering, photons in the lines considered are not destroyed but just scattered out of the line of sight, effectively causing a migration of photons from the dense to the more diffuse regions of astrophysical objects. This model does not include photons scattered into the line of sight, which
is only important in the outer parts of a cluster and can even enhance the
resonance line strength \citep{1987SvAL...13....3G}. Resonance enhancement will be addressed in a future paper.
Photons can also be scattered due to electron scattering escape, as a result of photons scattering off high-speed electrons, and receiving large Doppler-shifts from their line-center \citep{2021ApJ...912...26C, 2022ApJ...935...70C}. In addition, photons can be destroyed due to processes like Case A (optically thin) to Case B (optically thick) transfer and resonant Auger destruction \citep{1996MNRAS.278.1082R, 2020RNAAS...4..184C, 2020ApJ...901...68C, 2020ApJ...901...69C}. While the above processes become important at large hydrogen column densities (N$_{H}$ $\sim$ 10$^{23}-$10$^{24}$ cm$^{-2}$), RS effects can noticeably alter line intensities at the much smaller hydrogen column densities (N$_{H}$ $\sim$ 10$^{20}-$10$^{21}$ cm$^{-2}$) typically found in galaxy clusters and elliptical galaxies considered in this paper.
%Photons can be scattered due to resonance scattering or electron scattering escape.
%It would be good to be very clear that the photons in the lines considered
%are not destroyed, but just scattered out of the line of sight. I've seen
%a lot of misunderstanding of that point. It would be good to be clear that
%the model does not include photons scattered into the line of sight, which
%is important in the outer parts of a cluster and can even enhance the
%resonance line strength. I am also guessing that conversion of photons,
%such as Case A going to Case B is not included.
\subsection{Calculating the RS factor}
Optical depth at a line's center ($\tau_{0}$) is defined as:
\begin{equation}\label{e:gamma1}
{\tau_{0}} = \int_{{0}}^\infty \frac{{\sqrt{ \pi}} h r_{e} cf n_{p} Z \delta_{i}}{\Delta E}dr
\end{equation}
where $h$ is the Planck constant, $c$ is the speed of light, $r_{e}$ is the classical electron radius, f is the oscillator strength for the given transition, $n_{p}$ is the proton number density, $Z$ is the elemental abundance, $\delta_{i}$ is the ion fraction at the given temperature, $\Delta E$ is the Doppler velocity width described by the following equation:
\begin{equation}\label{e:gamma2}
{\Delta E} = E_{0} \left(\frac{2kT}{Am_{p}c^{2}} + 2\frac{V_{1,turb}}{c^{2}}^{2}\right)^{1/2}
\end{equation}
where $E_{0}$ is the energy of the transition, $A$ is the atomic weight of the element, $m_{p}$ is the proton mass, and $V_{1,turb}$ is the the line of sight velocity dispersion \citep{2018SSRv..214..108G}.
We adopt a similar approach as used by \citet{1998ApJ...497..587S} for calculating the emergence of resonance lines of line-center optical depth $\tau_{0}$ from optically thick plasma.
\iffalse
Solving radiative transfer equations for a hydrostatic isothermal model , \citet{1987SvAL...13....3G} reported the spectral intensity ratio for the resonance lines with and without resonance scattering towards the center of the spherical cloud to be:
\begin{equation}\label{e:rs1}
{\frac{I_{RS}}{I_{0}}} = 1-\frac{\tau_{0}}{2\sqrt{2}}
\end{equation}
The above equation is valid for small optical depths ($\tau$ $\leq$ 1), where only the first scattering of the resonance line photon has been taken into account (see their appendix).
\fi
\citet{1998ApJ...497..587S} investigated the effect of resonance line scattering in altering the surface brightness profile of resonance line emissions by numerically solving radiative transfer equations for an isotropically emitting radiation source by $\Lambda$-iteration method , and estimated the RS factor ($f$, spectral intensity ratio with and without resonance scattering) at the line-center (see figure 4 in their paper).
%\begin{equation}\label{e:rs2}
%{\frac{I_{RS}}{I_{0}}} \sim \frac{1-exp(-\tau_{0})}{\tau_{0}}
%\end{equation}
We use their reported $f$ values and interpolated for the optical depths which didn't have the information for the RS factor.
For computational efficiency, we exclude lines with $\tau$ $<$ 0.05 with negligible line scattering ($<$ 2\%) from the RS calculation. The fraction of photons scattered away due to RS at the line-center is therefore f$_{scattered}$= 1-$f$.
%We designating resonance scattering factors ($f$ = $\frac{I_{RS}}{I_{0}}$) at the center of the emission lines with line-center optical depths greater than 0.05.
Line optical depths vary along the line profile following a Voigt profile distribution. Line photons are absorbed and re-emitted, diffusing slowly in space until they reach the wings of the line with small optical depth and freely escape the cloud \citep{1962ApJ...135..195O}. For simplicity, it can be assumed that the scattered photons follow the Doppler line profile $\alpha (x)$=
exp(-x$^{2}$), where x =(E - E$_{0}$)/{$\Delta$ E} \citep{1983ASPRv...2..189P}. This Gaussian approximation is sufficient given the resolving power and signal-to-noise of the current and near-future X-ray observatories.
We construct a Gaussian line profile G(x) = I$_{0}$ f$_{scattered}$ exp(-x$^{2}$) to account for the photons scattered away from our line of sight, where I$_{0}$ is the maximum intensity of the unscattered default AtomDB line profile.
We further subtract G(x) from the default AtomDB line profiles to produce the RS-corrected line profiles.
%1) About line wings and Gaussian
%3) discuss integral over ner- probably over model description?
\begin{figure}[h!]
\centering
%\includegraphics[scale=0.4]{NGC4636.pdf}
\subfigure{\includegraphics[width = 3in]{NGC_1.pdf}}\hspace{2cm}
\subfigure{\includegraphics[width = 3in]{NGC_2.pdf}}
\caption{Top: X-ray spectrum of the elliptical galaxy NGC 4636 observed by RGS/XMM-Newton within the energy range 0.33-2.5 keV using m$_{1}$(=\texttt{tbabs*bapec}, blue line) and m$_{2}$ (\texttt{=tbabs*rsapec}, red line) Bottom: The same spectrum fitted with m$_{1}$ and m$_{2}$ within a narrower energy range (0.8-0.85 keV) around the optically thick Fe XVII line.}
\label{f:2}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\subfigure{\includegraphics[width = 3in]{Perseus_1.pdf}}\hspace{2cm}
\subfigure{\includegraphics[width = 3in]{Perseus_2.pdf}}
\caption{Left: X-ray spectrum of the Perseus cluster core (outer region)
fitted with m$_{1}$(=\texttt{tbabs*bapec}, blue line) and m$_{2}$ (\texttt{=tbabs*rsapec}, red line) within the energy range 6.0-7.0 keV. Right: The same spectrum fitted with m$_{1}$ and m$_{2}$ within a narrower energy range (6.5-6.6 keV) around the Fe K$\alpha$ complex.}
\label{fig:FeXXIII_FeXXIV_FeXXV_FeXXVI}
\end{figure}
\begin{table*}
\centering{
\caption{\label{t:o1} Archival RGS/\textit{XMM-Newton} observation of NGC 4636 and SXS/\textit{Hitomi} observation of Perseus cluster. The SXS data for 4 observations (observation id: 100040020–100040050) were combined
for a total exposure time of 243.53 ksec.}}
\begin{tabular}{ccccc}
\hline
Instrument & Observation ID & Start Date/Time & Exposure(ksec)\\
\hline
RGS/XMM-Newton & 0111190701 & 2000-07-13/03:44:33 & 64.41 \\
\hline
& 100040020 & 2016-02-25/02:14:12 & 97.44 \\
& 100040030 & 2016-03-04/02:17:32 & 72.51 \\
SXS/Hitomi & 100040040 & 2016-03-05 12:00:15 & 68.13 \\
& 100040050 & 2016-03-06 19:37:59 & 5.45 \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\end{table*}
%100040020, 100040030, 100040040, and
%100040050
\begin{table*}
\centering{
% \captionsetup{}
\caption{\label{t5percentper2} List of lines with $\tau$ $>$ 0.1 in NGC 4636 using best-fit parameters from Table \ref{t:ngc}.}
}
\begin{tabular}{c|c|c}
\hline
%\multicolumn{2}{c}{\hspace{200pt} Best-fit values} \\
%\cline{2 -3}
Lines & Transition energy (keV) & Optical depth \\
%w/o optical depth effects\\
\hline
%log $\alpha$ & - & -0.24$^{+0.01}_{-0.02}$ & -0.17$^{+0.02}_{-0.02}$ & 1.61 \\
%&& 0.3280 & 0.13\\
%&&0.3331&0.16\\
%&& 0.3400 & 0.11\\
%&& 0.3403 & 0.47\\
% O VIII& 0.6535 & 0.09 & 0.03 \\
O VIII & 0.6537 & 0.20 \\
Fe XVII& 0.8124 & 0.23\\
Fe XVII & 0.8258 & 0.90 \\
Fe XVIII &0.8441& 0.18\\
Fe XVIII& 0.8512 & 0.41\\
Fe XVIII &0.8644&0.27\\
Fe XVIII & 0.8726 &0.24\\
Fe XVIII &0.8763&0.19\\
Fe XVIII &0.8772&0.17\\
Fe XVIII &0.8775& 0.22\\
Fe XVIII &0.8821&0.30\\
%Fe XVII & 0.8968&0.11&0.03\\
Fe XIX &0.9172&0.17\\
Fe XIX &0.9186&0.25\\
Fe XIX & 0.9229 & 0.31\\
%Fe XX & 0.9337& 0.01 &0.11\\
%Fe XX & 0.9498&0.01&0.10\\
Fe XVII & 1.0108& 0.12\\
Ne X & 1.0220 &0.13\\
Fe XVII & 1.0226&0.13\\
Mg XI & 1.3522&0.15\\
Si XIII & 1.8560& 0.24\\
%Si XIII & 1.8560& 0.21 &0.14\\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\end{table*}
\begin{table*}
\centering{
% \captionsetup{}
\caption{\label{t5percentper} List of lines with $\tau$ $>$ 0.1 scattering in Perseus using best-fit parameters from Table \ref{t:xspec}.}
}
\begin{tabular}{c|c|c}
\hline
%\multicolumn{2}{c}{\hspace{200pt} Best-fit values} \\
%\cline{2 -3}
Lines & Energy (keV) & Optical depth \\
%w/o optical depth effects\\
\hline
%log $\alpha$ & - & -0.24$^{+0.01}_{-0.02}$ & -0.17$^{+0.02}_{-0.02}$ & 1.61 \\
Fe XXIV & 0.3817 & 2.93 \\
Fe XXIV & 0.3829 & 3.05 \\
%Fe XXIV & 0.3878 & 1.68\\
Fe XXIV & 0.4032 & 0.78 \\
%O VIII & 0.6537 & 0.10 \\
Fe XXIV & 1.1094 & 0.64 \\
Fe XXIV & 1.1242 & 0.70 \\
Fe XXIV & 1.1628 & 0.13 \\
Fe XXIV & 1.1676 & 0.24 \\
Fe XXV & 6.7004 & 1.00 \\
Fe XXV & 7.8815 & 0.16 \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\end{table*}
\begin{table*}
\centering{
% \captionsetup{}
%m1.setPars(0.019,0.5427,0.5132 ,-7.32929E-04, 1085.77, 1.22E-03 ,0.8018, 0.5132 ,-7.32929E-04, 1085.77,8.122E-04)
\caption{\label{t:ngc}Best-fit parameters for for m$_{1}$(=\texttt{TBabs $\times$ bapec)}) and m$_{2}$(=\texttt{TBabs $\times$ rsapec}) fitting the summed
first-order RGS spectrum of NGC 4636 within the energy range 0.33-2.5 keV. The \texttt{XSPEC} convolution model \texttt{rgsxsrc} has been used to account for the spectral broadening of the extended source. The redshift is taken from \citet{2000MNRAS.313..469S} and has been frozen.}
}
\begin{tabular}{c|c|c}
\hline
%\multicolumn{2}{c}{\hspace{200pt} Best-fit values} \\
%\cline{2 -3}
Parameter & m$_{1}$ & m$_{2}$ \\
%w/o optical depth effects\\
\hline
%log $\alpha$ & - & -0.24$^{+0.01}_{-0.02}$ & -0.17$^{+0.02}_{-0.02}$ & 1.61 \\
nH(frozen, in units of $10^{22}$ atoms cm$^{-2}$) & 2e-2 & 2e-2 \\
kT (keV) & 0.64 $^{+0.005}_{-0.006}$ & 0.65 $^{+0.005}_{-0.005}$ \\
Abundance (solar) & 0.45 $^{+0.03}_{-0.03}$ & 0.45 $^{+0.04}_{-0.03}$ \\
Redshift (frozen) & 0.003129 & 0.003129 \\
Velocity (km/s) & 153.35 $^{+62.06}_{-45.69}$ & 165.01 $^{+57.29}_{-49.23}$ \\
nL (cm$^{-2}$) & - & 8.12$^{+0.08}_{-0.07}$ $\times$ 10$^{20}$ \\
norm & 2.02$^{+0.14}_{-0.11}$$\times$ 10$^{-3}$ & 2.08$^{+0.12}_{-0.13}$$\times$ 10$^{-3}$ \\
%kT$_{2}$ (keV) & 0.79$\pm$0.01 & 0.81 $\pm$0.01 \\
%Abundance (solar) & 0.55$\pm$ 0.02 & 0.56$\pm$ 0.02 \\
%Redshift (frozen) & -7.32929E-04 & -7.32929E-04 \\
%Velocity (km/s) & 1085.77 $\pm$ 45 & 1094.75 $\pm$ 40 \\
%nL (cm$^{-2}$) & - & (1.43$\pm$0.12) $\times$ 10$^{21}$ \\
%norm & 7.62E-04 $\pm$ 6E-05 & 7.58E-04 $\pm$ 5E-05\\
$\chi^{2}$ & 3847.43/3222 & 3798.39 /3221 \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\end{table*}
\begin{table*}
\centering{
\caption{\label{t:xspec}Best-fit parameters for m$_{1}$(\texttt{TBabs $\times$ bapec})and m$_{2}$(\texttt{TBabs $\times$ rsapec}) fitting the Fe K$\alpha$ complex of Perseus core observed by \textit{Hitomi}.
Fits are done for the energy range 6.0 to 7.0 keV for the outer region of Perseus core. The redshift is taken from \citet{2020A&A...633A..42S} and has been frozen. }
}
\begin{tabular}{l|r|r}
\hline
%\multicolumn{2}{c}{\hspace{200pt} Best-fit values} \\
%\cline{2 -3}
Parameter & m$_{1}$ & m$_{2}$ \\
%w/o optical depth effects\\
\hline
%log $\alpha$ & - & -0.24$^{+0.01}_{-0.02}$ & -0.17$^{+0.02}_{-0.02}$ & 1.61 \\
nH(frozen, in units of $10^{22}$ atoms cm$^{-2}$) & 0.138 & 0.138 \\
kT (keV) & 4.07$\pm$ 0.02 & 4.08$\pm$ 0.02 \\
Abundance (solar) & 0.40 $\pm$0.001 & 0.39$\pm$0.002 \\
Redshift (frozen) & 1.7239E-02 & 1.72391E-02 \\
Velocity & 167.80$\pm$ 9.83 & 172.12$\pm$ 9.11 \\
nL (cm$^{-2}$) & - & (1.22$\pm$0.11) $\times$ 10$^{22}$ \\
norm & 0.93$\pm$ 0.01 & 0.96$\pm$0.02 \\
Cstat/d.o.f & 2390.51/1995 & 2314.05 /1994\\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\end{table*}
%Figure \ref{f:1} shows the optical depths of the optically thick lines for a 4 keV plasma with no turbulent broadening calculated using AtomDB.
\section{Model parameters:}\label{s:3}
The new resonant scattering model \texttt{rsapec} presented in this paper has been designed based on the modified version of \texttt{apec}, which models X-ray emission from collisionally ionized, optically-thin astrophysical plasmas \citep{2001ApJ...556L..91S, 2012ApJ...756..128F}. The \texttt{apec} model calculates the line emissivities using three external model parameters- electron temperature, metal abundances, and redshift.
However, solving for equations 1 and 2 is a prerequisite for accurately synthesizing the spectrum for an optically thick plasma subject to resonance scattering. For constructing \texttt{rsapec}, we added two additional model parameters to \texttt{apec} - line of sight velocity broadening
in one dimension ($V_{1,turb}$) and $nL$, where $nL$ is the electron density ($n_{e}$) integrated over line-of-sight:
\begin{equation}\label{e:gamma}
nL = \int_{{0}}^\infty n_{e} dr
\end{equation}
We chose $nL$ as a free parameter in \texttt{rsapec} as $n_{p}$ (and therefore $n_{e}$ \footnote{Assuming the majority of the free electrons in a collisionally-ionized cloud come from the ionization of hydrogen and helium, the following approximation was used: $n_{e}$ $\sim$ 1.2 $n_{p}$.}) is the only direct r-dependent quantity in equation \ref{e:gamma1}. The quantity $\delta_{i}$ depends on the temperature, which in galaxy clusters is only slightly dependent on radius \citep{2008MNRAS.390.1207R}, at least up to 100 kpc after which resonance suppression usually becomes unimportant. We, therefore, neglect the radial dependence of $\delta_{i}$ for simplicity.
%$n_{p}$
We also introduced \texttt{rsvapec} and \texttt{rsvvapec}, equivalent to \texttt{vapec} and \texttt{vvapec}, respectively. \texttt{rsvapec} has 14 extra model parameters with the option to change abundances of the elements: H, He, C, N, O, Ne, Mg, Al, Si, S, Ar, Ca, Fe, Ni. \texttt{rsvvapec} has 30 extra model parameters with the option to vary the abundances of all the elements
between H and Zn.
We also adjusted the above models to be compatible with pyXSPEC \citep{1996ASPC..101...17A}.
Equations \ref{e:gamma1}- \ref{e:gamma2} are simultaneously solved along with the $f$ factor and fitted with the observed spectrum within the AtomDB database to determine best-fit parameters for galaxies and clusters of galaxies
with optically thick emission lines.
Utilizing the fitted $nL$ value, abundances, and ionization fraction\footnote{ obtained from pyatomdb commands:
sess = pyatomdb.spectrum.CIESession(), ionfrac=sess.ionfraction(Temperature, Element, teunit=`K')}, it is also possible to get constraints on turbulent velocities.
\iffalse
The steps involved are: a) Calculating the optical depth of the lines using equation \ref{} to figure out which line intensities will be sensitive to RS. b) Identifying and incorporating a suppression factor in relation to the calculated optical depth which estimates the probability of a resonance photon escaping the source of interest.
determined by fitting a model to spectra extracted from lo
\fi
\section{Model applications:}\label{s:4}
We apply our new RS model to model the resonance line suppression in NGC 4636 observed by RGS onboard \textit{XMM-Newton} and the outer core of the Perseus cluster observed by \textit{Hitomi}. The observational log of the above observations is listed in Table \ref{t:o1}. In both cases,
best-fit results were
obtained by minimizing C-statistic
\citep{1979ApJ...228..939C}. The parameter errors were measured with 1$\sigma$ confidence.
The velocity listed in tables \ref{t:ngc} and \ref{t:xspec} is only the one-dimensional turbulent velocity, which dominates over thermal broadening in clusters and galaxies. The widths of the emission lines within AtomDB is calculated considering both thermal and turbulent broadening.
\subsection{NGC 4636 }
NGC 4636 is a giant elliptical galaxy shining brightly in the X-rays. High-resolution XMM-Newton observations of NGC 4636
revealed a wealth of characteristic soft X-ray emission lines from various ion stages of nitrogen, oxygen, neon, magnesium, and iron \citep{2002ApJ...579..600X}. We use the 64 ksec first-order RGS spectrum of NGC 4636 as a test case of the RS model on elliptical galaxies.
We used the \textit{XMM-Newton} tool \texttt{rgsproc} for RGS data reduction for a cross-dispersion region of 3.5' width. The first-order spectra from RGS1 and RGS2 was combined using the tool \texttt{rgscombine}.
Table \ref{t:o1} lists the observational log of the spectra.
Several detected has $\tau$ $>$ 0.1, Fe XVII 15.015
\AA~(0.8258 keV) line being the only transition with significant optical depth ($\tau$ $\sim$ 0.93). Refer to table \ref{t5percentper2} for the list of optical depths with more than $\tau$ $>$ 0.1.
Firstly, we attempted to fit the observed spectrum within the energy range 0.33-2.5 keV, including most of the line and continuum emission with a single-temperature \texttt{bapec} model multiplied with the pyXSPEC routine {\tt tbabs} to account for the galactic absorption.
The absorbing hydrogen column density is set to 2.0$\times$10$^{20}$ cm$^{-2}$ using the measurement of the galactic atomic hydrogen column density by \citet{2016A&A...594A.116H}.
The pyXSPEC routine {\tt rgsxsrc} was used to account for the spatial distribution of the X-ray emission along with the MOS1 image as done by \citet{2022MNRAS.514.4222F}. The boresight required in the {\tt rgsxsrc} routine was set to the
X-ray brightest point of the image.
Using the model m$_{1}$(=\texttt{tbabs*bapec}) modified by \texttt{rgsxsrc} we obtained a best-fit temperature of $\sim$ 0.64 keV, and reduced $\chi$$^{2}$ = 3847.43/3222.
Next, we fit the observed spectrum within the same energy range with the \texttt{rsapec} model multiplied with {\tt tbabs} (m$_{2}$=\texttt{tbabs*rsapec}) and convoluted with {\tt rgsxsrc} . The fit to the spectrum was improved, with $\chi$$^{2}$ = 3798.39/3221 and a best-fit temperature of $\sim$ 0.65 keV was obtained. The measured value of the one-dimensional turbulent velocity was 153.35 $^{+62.06}_{-45.69}$ km/s and 165.01 $^{+57.29}_{-49.23}$ km/s for m$_{1}$ and m$_{2}$ respectively, consistent with the turbulence measurement in NGC 4636 by \citet{2017MNRAS.472.1659O} (121 $^{+51}_{-35}$ km/s).
Table \ref{t:ngc} lists the best-fit parameters for m$_{1}$ and m$_{2}$ in 0.33-2.5 keV energy range. The measured value of $nL$ was 8.12 $\times$ 10$^{20}$ cm$^{-2}$, which agrees well with the estimate of $nL$ for NGC4636 as shown in the appendix.
%m1.setPars(0.02,-3,0.65,0.44725 ,-5.51565E-04, 148.523, 8e20, 2.0499E-03 )
%A two-temperature fit with two \texttt{bapec/rsapec} models dramatically improved the fit to the spectrum. The model m$_{1}$(=\texttt{tbabs*(bapec+bapec)}) with best-fit temperatures 0.54 keV and 0.79 keV produced a chi-square value of 2061.41/1821.
%The two-temperature \texttt{rsapec} model,
%m$_{2}$(=\texttt{tbabs*(rsapec+rsapec)}), with best-fit temperatures 0.55 keV and 0.81 keV further improved the fit to the spectrum with a chi-square value of 2012.75/1820.
The left panel of Figure \ref{f:2} compares the fit of m$_{1}$ and m$_{2}$ within the same energy range.
The emissivity of the 15.015\AA~Fe XVII line with optical depth close to unity is significantly affected, and the emissivities of the
other lines listed in table \ref{t5percentper2} are partially affected by resonance scattering.
%, and the emissivity of the 18.98\AA~O VIII line blend is slightly affected by resonance scattering.
As a result, we get a slightly better fit with m$_{2}$ compared to m$_{1}$. The right panel of Figure \ref{f:2} compares the two models within a narrow energy range (0.80-0.85 keV) around the 15.015\AA~Fe XVII
line. Within the narrow range, the fit of m$_{2}$ ($\chi$$^{2}$ = 120.97/85 is noticeably better compared to that of m$_{1}$ ($\chi$$^{2}$ = 146.23/86) with an F-
test probability $<<$ 0.01. We estimate the line suppression in Fe XVII due to RS to be $\sim$ 1.24.
Two-temperature/multi-temperature models showed no noticeable improvement in the fit to the spectrum.
\iffalse
Note that, \citet{2002ApJ...579..600X} modeled the gas emissivity of NGC 4636 using the APEC model for a range of temperatures between $\sim$ 0.53 keV and kT $\sim$ 0.71 keV using an older version of AtomDB (v 1.2.0). Since then, there has been a major update to the fundamental atomic structure and process data held within AtomDB \citep{2012ApJ...756..128F}. We find that with the newer version of AtomDB, a multi-temperature model is not necessary to produce a statistically good fit to the observed RGS spectrum of NGC 4636.
\fi
%\citet{2012ApJ...757..121L} fitted the \textit{XMM-Newton} spectrum of the elliptical galaxy NGC 4649 with the updated version of AtomDB (v 2.0.1).
\subsection{The Perseus cluster}
Possible suppression in the 6.7 keV line of the He-like iron in the X-ray spectrum of Perseus cluster has long been a topic of interest \citep{1987SvAL...13....3G, 1999AN....320..283A, 2004MNRAS.347...29C, 2004ApJ...600..670G, 2006MNRAS.370...63S, 2008MNRAS.390.1207R, 2013MNRAS.435.3111Z}.
However, given that the Fe K$\alpha$ spectral lines were unresolved, no compelling evidence of RS was detected in the observed spectra. For the first time, the Soft X-ray Spectrometer (SXS) onboard \textit{Hitomi} separated the resonance line in the Fe K$\alpha$ complex from other line components, detecting a suppression in the Fe XXV resonance (w) by a factor of $\sim$ 1.3 at the core of Perseus cluster.
An ad hoc technique using a negative Gaussian to compensate for the RS suppresion was used to estimate this factor alongside an optically thin APEC model.
%The disadvantage of using an external Gaussian is ignoring the sensitivity of the best-fit parameters on the RS factor modifying the line emissivities of the optically thick lines.
Our newly formulated models use theoretical scattering probability calculations to estimate the RS factor for the emergence of the Fe XXV resonance (w) line from a collisionally-ionized plasma as described in section 2. Optical depths were generated using the APED database (version 3.0.9).
Table \ref{t5percentper} shows the list of transitions with $\tau$ $>$ 0.1 for the best-fit parameters at Perseus core. The model details for estimating best-fit parameters are discussed below.
%Scattering effects were ignored outside this limit.
We extracted the spectra for the outer region of Perseus core (30-60 kpc) using HEAsoft\footnote{https://heasarc.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/software/heasoft/} for observations with observation IDs listed in table \ref{t:o1}. The observations' event files were merged and filtered using Xselect. Four distinct NXB spectra were derived from the four event files using \texttt{sxsnxbgen} and then averaged via \texttt{mathpha}. RMF, exposure map, and ARF are produced using \texttt{sxsmkrmf}, \texttt{ahexpmap}, and \texttt{aharfgen}, respectively.
We fitted the extracted without and with RS models: \texttt{bapec} and \texttt{rsapec} around the Fe K$\alpha$ complex. The multiplicative pyXSPEC routine {\tt tbabs} was included in each fit to account for the galactic absorption, with the absorbing hydrogen column density set to 1.38$\times$10$^{21}$ cm$^{-2}$ \citep{2005A&A...440..775K} towards the direction of the Perseus cluster.
Table \ref{t:xspec}
compares the best-fit model parameters fitting the observed spectrum between m$_{1}$(=\texttt{tbabs*bapec}), and m$_{2}$(=\texttt{tbabs*rsapec}) within the energy range 6.0-7.0 keV.
Using m$_{1}$, we obtained a best-fit temperature of 4.07 keV with a \textit{Cstat/d.o.f} of 2390.51/1995.
The model m$_{2}$ improved the fit to the observed spectrum with a best-fit temperature of 4.08 keV and
a \textit{Cstat/d.o.f} of 2314.05 /1994. The improvement to the fit is prompted by inclusion of the RS effect in the w line in m$_{2}$, the only optically thick line observed in the spectrum. The emissivity for the w line is noticeably suppressed by RS. The measured value of nL was 1.2 $\times$ 10$^{22}$ cm$^{-2}$, which agrees well with the estimate of $nL$ for the Perseus cluster as shown in the appendix.
The turbulent velocity was measured at 167.80 $\pm$ 9.83 km/s for m$_{1}$ and 172.12 $\pm$ 9.11 km/s for m$_{2}$, consistent with the value previously reported by \citet{2018PASJ...70...10H} (164 $\pm$ 10 km/s).
%In both cases, C-statistic was used to fit the spectrum.
%The parameter errors were measured with 1$\sigma$ confidence.
%The without RS models, m$_{1}$ and m$_{3}$
%did not fit the spectrum well with reduced C-stats of $\sim$ 1.36 and $\sim$ 1.33, respectively. The with RS models, m$_{2}$ and m$_{4}$ significantly improved the fit to the spectrum with reduced C-stats of $\sim$ 1.11 and $\sim$ 1.08, respectively.
The left panel of Figure \ref{f:2} shows the spectrum of the Perseus outer core within 6.0-7.0 keV fitted with m$_{1}$ (\textit{Cstat/d.o.f} = 2390.51 /1995) and m$_{2}$ (\textit{Cstat/d.o.f} = 2314.05/1994).
The right panel compares the two models within a narrower energy range
immediately around the Fe K$\alpha$ complex (6.5-6.6 keV). The fit of m$_{2}$ (\textit{Cstat/d.o.f} = 225.57/195) is significantly better than that of m$_{1}$ (\textit{Cstat/d.o.f} = 280.18/196) with the F-test probability of $<<$ 0.01, especially the fit to the w line. Comparing m$_{1}$ with m$_{2}$ we find a RS line suppression factor of $\sim$ 1.30 in w.
\section{Discussion}
We note that \citet{2006MNRAS.370...63S} constructed an \texttt{xspec} model for fitting spectra from clusters including resonance scattering. Their model calculated the emission spectrum from N annuli divided into multiple subannuli in the sky using the APED atomic database (version 1.3.1) to generate
a list of resonance lines.
Our RS model \texttt{rsapec} is self-consistently built into the AtomDB databse where the emission spectrum is estimated
solving thousands of atomic rates, just like \texttt{apec/bapec} but inclusive of the RS effects. \texttt{rsapec} is almost as fast as \texttt{apec}, and can be used to model resonance scattering in both elliptical galaxies and clusters of galaxies.
In the current
version of \texttt{rsapec}, scattering effects
are estimeted
based on a spherical geometry as described in \citet{1998ApJ...497..587S}, which used a gas density profile with a 1D-$\beta$ model
with $\beta$ = 0.5. In clusters, \texttt{rsapec} will model resonance scattering for the inner 100 kpc radius, beyond which resonance enhancement due to scattering into the line of sight becomes important. In future, we plan to extend the model to include a full radiative transfer
treatment of the resonance scattering, which will include the flexibility to adjust the $\beta$
values, resonance enhancement at radial distances larger than 100 kpc, and non-spherical geometries. The current model will also be used as a template for modeling RS processes in sources like cataclysmic variables for which the geometry or spatial resolution might differ but the approach to RS is the same.
%The same treatment can also be used to model sheets of gas seen edge-on as used in \citet{2003ApJ...584..770R} for supernova remnants, but the assumption of a slab geometry is atypical in galaxies or clusters.
We applied \texttt{rsapec} to fit the spectrum of the elliptical galaxy NGC 4636 and the Perseus clusters of galaxies. In perseus cluster, we estimated a suppression of $\sim$ 1.30 in the optically thick line Fe XXV K$\alpha$ w (6.7004 keV) line, which compares well with the previously measured RS factor ($\sim$ 1.28) by \citet{2018PASJ...70...10H}. For NGC4636, we estimated a suppression factor of $\sim$ 1.24 in the Fe XVII (0.8258 keV) line, without any prior studies available.
We ignored all lines with $\tau$ $<$ 0.05 from our resonance scattering treatment.
The \textit{XRISM} mission, scheduled to launch in the next few months, will observe a sample of galaxies and clusters with optically thick lines. The \texttt{rsapec} model will be a self-consistent and one-step tool for extracting the best-fit parameters from the observed \textit{XRISM} spectrum fitting the optically thin and optically thick lines simultaneously in place of the previously applied ad-hoc technique of using negative Gaussians alongside optically thin \texttt{apec} model to account for the RS suppression.
%An ad hoc technique using a negative Gaussian to compensate for the RS suppresion
%Instead of modeling the observed spectra with an optically thin APEC model along with negative Gaussians to account for the RS as was done to fit the \textit{Hitomi}
%observation of Perseus cluster \citep{2018PASJ...70...10H},
%%In this paper, we modeled
%Which is buil
%collisionion radiative model
%In the version here, up to 16 annuli can be fit,
%Requires the user to install AtomDB version 3.0.9 and
%Figure \ref{f:2} compares the fit to the Fe K$\alpha$ complex
\appendix
\section{Estimate for \lowercase{$n}L$ -- NGC 4636}
\citet{2015ApJ...803L..21V} estimated the radial profiles of electron density ($n_{e}$) of a sample of elliptical galaxies, including NGC 4636. Within the central 1 kpc region, $n_{e}$ is approximately constant in NGC 4636 ($n_{e}$ $\sim$ 0.12 cm$^{-3}$, refer to figure 1 in their paper), whereas within
1-10 kpc, the density profile steeply declines. The density profile integrated over the inner 10 kpc is:
\begin{equation}\label{eqn:nL1}
\begin{split}
\int_{{0}}^{10 \rm kpc} n_{e} dr & = \int_{{0}}^{1 \rm kpc} n_{e} dr +\int_{{1 \rm kpc}}^{10 \rm kpc} n_{e} dr\\
& = 3.70 \times 10^{20} \rm cm^{-2} + 4.62 \times 10^{20} \rm cm^{-2} \\ &= 8.32 \times 10^{20} \rm cm^{-2}
\end{split}
\end{equation}
\section{Estimate for \lowercase{$n}L$ -- the perseus cluster}
We can get an estimate of $nL$ for the Perseus cluster using the radial electron density profile reported by \citet{2018PASJ...70...10H} (up to 1000 kpc):
\begin{equation}\label{eqn:nL1}
\begin{split}
\int_{{0}}^{1000 \rm kpc} n_{e} dr & = 1.11 \times 10^{22} \rm cm^{-2}
\end{split}
\end{equation}
%% LaTeX will automatically break titles if they run longer than
%% one line. However, you may use \\ to force a line break if
%% you desire. In v6.31 you can include a footnote in the title.
%% A significant change from earlier AASTEX versions is in the structure for
%% calling author and affiliations. The change was necessary to implement
%% auto-indexing of affiliations which prior was a manual process that could
%% easily be tedious in large author manuscripts.
%%
%% The \author command is the same as before except it now takes an optional
%% argument which is the 16 digit ORCID. The syntax is:
%% \author[xxxx-xxxx-xxxx-xxxx]{Author Name}
%%
%% This will hyperlink the author name to the author's ORCID page. Note that
%% during compilation, LaTeX will do some limited checking of the format of
%% the ID to make sure it is valid. If the "orcid-ID.png" image file is
%% present or in the LaTeX pathway, the OrcID icon will appear next to
%% the authors name.
%%
%% Use \affiliation for affiliation information. The old \affil is now aliased
%% to \affiliation. AASTeX v6.31 will automatically index these in the header.
%% When a duplicate is found its index will be the same as its previous entry.
%%
%% Note that \altaffilmark and \altaffiltext have been removed and thus
%% can not be used to document secondary affiliations. If they are used latex
%% will issue a specific error message and quit. Please use multiple
%% \affiliation calls for to document more than one affiliation.
%%
%% The new \altaffiliation can be used to indicate some secondary information
%% such as fellowships. This command produces a non-numeric footnote that is
%% set away from the numeric \affiliation footnotes. NOTE that if an
%% \altaffiliation command is used it must come BEFORE the \affiliation call,
%% right after the \author command, in order to place the footnotes in
%% the proper location.
%%
%% Use \email to set provide email addresses. Each \email will appear on its
%% own line so you can put multiple email address in one \email call. A new
%% \correspondingauthor command is available in V6.31 to identify the
%% corresponding author of the manuscript. It is the author's responsibility
%% to make sure this name is also in the author list.
%%
%% While authors can be grouped inside the same \author and \affiliation
%% commands it is better to have a single author for each. This allows for
%% one to exploit all the new benefits and should make book-keeping easier.
%%
%% If done correctly the peer review system will be able to
%% automatically put the author and affiliation information from the manuscript
%% and save the corresponding author the trouble of entering it by hand.
%\correspondingauthor{August Muench}
%\email{greg.schwarz@aas.org, gus.muench@aas.org}
The \texttt{rsapec} model is now available at the main AtomDB website: http://www.atomdb.org/.
\section*{Acknowledgment}
We acknowledge support by NASA ADAP Grant 80NSSC21K0637.
\bibliography{sample631}{}
\bibliographystyle{aasjournal}
%% This command is needed to show the entire author+affiliation list when
%% the collaboration and author truncation commands are used. It has to
%% go at the end of the manuscript.
%\allauthors
%% Include this line if you are using the \added, \replaced, \deleted
%% commands to see a summary list of all changes at the end of the article.
%\listofchanges
\end{document}
% End of file `sample631.tex'.
\begin{thebibliography}{}
\expandafter\ifx\csname natexlab\endcsname\relax\def\natexlab#1{#1}\fi
\providecommand{\url}[1]{\href{#1}{#1}}
\providecommand{\dodoi}[1]{doi:~\href{http://doi.org/#1}{\nolinkurl{#1}}}
\providecommand{\doeprint}[1]{\href{http://ascl.net/#1}{\nolinkurl{http://ascl.net/#1}}}
\providecommand{\doarXiv}[1]{\href{https://arxiv.org/abs/#1}{\nolinkurl{https://arxiv.org/abs/#1}}}
\bibitem[{{Agostinelli} {et~al.}(2003){Agostinelli}, {Allison}, {Amako},
{Apostolakis}, {Araujo}, {Arce}, {Asai}, {Axen}, {Banerjee}, {Barrand},
{Behner}, {Bellagamba}, {Boudreau}, {Broglia}, {Brunengo}, {Burkhardt},
{Chauvie}, {Chuma}, {Chytracek}, {Cooperman}, {Cosmo}, {Degtyarenko},
{Dell'Acqua}, {Depaola}, {Dietrich}, {Enami}, {Feliciello}, {Ferguson},
{Fesefeldt}, {Folger}, {Foppiano}, {Forti}, {Garelli}, {Giani},
{Giannitrapani}, {Gibin}, {G{\'o}mez Cadenas}, {Gonz{\'a}lez}, {Gracia
Abril}, {Greeniaus}, {Greiner}, {Grichine}, {Grossheim}, {Guatelli},
{Gumplinger}, {Hamatsu}, {Hashimoto}, {Hasui}, {Heikkinen}, {Howard},
{Ivanchenko}, {Johnson}, {Jones}, {Kallenbach}, {Kanaya}, {Kawabata},
{Kawabata}, {Kawaguti}, {Kelner}, {Kent}, {Kimura}, {Kodama}, {Kokoulin},
{Kossov}, {Kurashige}, {Lamanna}, {Lamp{\'e}n}, {Lara}, {Lefebure}, {Lei},
{Liendl}, {Lockman}, {Longo}, {Magni}, {Maire}, {Medernach}, {Minamimoto},
{Mora de Freitas}, {Morita}, {Murakami}, {Nagamatu}, {Nartallo}, {Nieminen},
{Nishimura}, {Ohtsubo}, {Okamura}, {O'Neale}, {Oohata}, {Paech}, {Perl},
{Pfeiffer}, {Pia}, {Ranjard}, {Rybin}, {Sadilov}, {Di Salvo}, {Santin},
{Sasaki}, {Savvas}, {Sawada}, {Scherer}, {Sei}, {Sirotenko}, {Smith},
{Starkov}, {Stoecker}, {Sulkimo}, {Takahata}, {Tanaka}, {Tcherniaev}, {Safai
Tehrani}, {Tropeano}, {Truscott}, {Uno}, {Urban}, {Urban}, {Verderi},
{Walkden}, {Wander}, {Weber}, {Wellisch}, {Wenaus}, {Williams}, {Wright},
{Yamada}, {Yoshida}, {Zschiesche}, \& {G EANT4
Collaboration}}]{2003NIMPA.506..250A}
{Agostinelli}, S., {Allison}, J., {Amako}, K., {et~al.} 2003, Nuclear
Instruments and Methods in Physics Research A, 506, 250,
\dodoi{10.1016/S0168-9002(03)01368-8}
\bibitem[{{Akimoto} {et~al.}(1999){Akimoto}, {Furuzawa}, {Tawara}, \&
{Yamashita}}]{1999AN....320..283A}
{Akimoto}, F., {Furuzawa}, A., {Tawara}, Y., \& {Yamashita}, K. 1999,
Astronomische Nachrichten, 320, 283,
\dodoi{10.1002/1521-3994(199908)320:4/5<283::AID-ASNA283>3.0.CO;2-O}
\bibitem[{{Akimoto} {et~al.}(2000){Akimoto}, {Furuzawa}, {Tawara}, \&
{Yamashita}}]{2000AdSpR..25..603A}
---. 2000, Advances in Space Research, 25, 603,
\dodoi{10.1016/S0273-1177(99)00809-1}
\bibitem[{{Arnaud}(1996)}]{1996ASPC..101...17A}
{Arnaud}, K.~A. 1996, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series,
Vol. 101, Astronomical Data Analysis Software and Systems V, ed. G.~H.
{Jacoby} \& J.~{Barnes}, 17
\bibitem[{{Cash}(1979)}]{1979ApJ...228..939C}
{Cash}, W. 1979, \apj, 228, 939, \dodoi{10.1086/156922}
\bibitem[{{Chakraborty} {et~al.}(2020{\natexlab{a}}){Chakraborty}, {Ferland},
{Bianchi}, \& {Chatzikos}}]{2020RNAAS...4..184C}
{Chakraborty}, P., {Ferland}, G.~J., {Bianchi}, S., \& {Chatzikos}, M.
2020{\natexlab{a}}, Research Notes of the American Astronomical Society, 4,
184, \dodoi{10.3847/2515-5172/abc1dd}
\bibitem[{{Chakraborty} {et~al.}(2022){Chakraborty}, {Ferland}, {Chatzikos},
{Fabian}, {Bianchi}, {Guzm{\'a}n}, \& {Su}}]{2022ApJ...935...70C}
{Chakraborty}, P., {Ferland}, G.~J., {Chatzikos}, M., {et~al.} 2022, \apj, 935,
70, \dodoi{10.3847/1538-4357/ac7eb9}
\bibitem[{{Chakraborty} {et~al.}(2020{\natexlab{b}}){Chakraborty}, {Ferland},
{Chatzikos}, {Guzm{\'a}n}, \& {Su}}]{2020ApJ...901...68C}
{Chakraborty}, P., {Ferland}, G.~J., {Chatzikos}, M., {Guzm{\'a}n}, F., \&
{Su}, Y. 2020{\natexlab{b}}, \apj, 901, 68, \dodoi{10.3847/1538-4357/abaaab}
\bibitem[{{Chakraborty} {et~al.}(2020{\natexlab{c}}){Chakraborty}, {Ferland},
{Chatzikos}, {Guzm{\'a}n}, \& {Su}}]{2020ApJ...901...69C}
---. 2020{\natexlab{c}}, \apj, 901, 69, \dodoi{10.3847/1538-4357/abaaac}
\bibitem[{{Chakraborty} {et~al.}(2021){Chakraborty}, {Ferland}, {Chatzikos},
{Guzm{\'a}n}, \& {Su}}]{2021ApJ...912...26C}
---. 2021, \apj, 912, 26, \dodoi{10.3847/1538-4357/abed4a}
\bibitem[{{Churazov} {et~al.}(2004){Churazov}, {Forman}, {Jones}, {Sunyaev}, \&
{B{\"o}hringer}}]{2004MNRAS.347...29C}
{Churazov}, E., {Forman}, W., {Jones}, C., {Sunyaev}, R., \& {B{\"o}hringer},
H. 2004, \mnras, 347, 29, \dodoi{10.1111/j.1365-2966.2004.07201.x}
\bibitem[{{Churazov} {et~al.}(2010){Churazov}, {Zhuravleva}, {Sazonov}, \&
{Sunyaev}}]{2010SSRv..157..193C}
{Churazov}, E., {Zhuravleva}, I., {Sazonov}, S., \& {Sunyaev}, R. 2010, \ssr,
157, 193, \dodoi{10.1007/s11214-010-9685-4}
\bibitem[{{Foster} {et~al.}(2012){Foster}, {Ji}, {Smith}, \&
{Brickhouse}}]{2012ApJ...756..128F}
{Foster}, A.~R., {Ji}, L., {Smith}, R.~K., \& {Brickhouse}, N.~S. 2012, \apj,
756, 128, \dodoi{10.1088/0004-637X/756/2/12810.48550/arXiv.1207.0576}
\bibitem[{{Fukushima} {et~al.}(2022){Fukushima}, {Kobayashi}, \&
{Matsushita}}]{2022MNRAS.514.4222F}
{Fukushima}, K., {Kobayashi}, S.~B., \& {Matsushita}, K. 2022, \mnras, 514,
4222, \dodoi{10.1093/mnras/stac1590}
\bibitem[{{Gastaldello} \& {Molendi}(2004)}]{2004ApJ...600..670G}
{Gastaldello}, F., \& {Molendi}, S. 2004, \apj, 600, 670,
\dodoi{10.1086/379970}
\bibitem[{{Gilfanov} {et~al.}(1987){Gilfanov}, {Syunyaev}, \&
{Churazov}}]{1987SvAL...13....3G}
{Gilfanov}, M.~R., {Syunyaev}, R.~A., \& {Churazov}, E.~M. 1987, Soviet
Astronomy Letters, 13, 3
\bibitem[{{Gu} {et~al.}(2018){Gu}, {Zhuravleva}, {Churazov}, {Paerels},
{Kaastra}, \& {Yamaguchi}}]{2018SSRv..214..108G}
{Gu}, L., {Zhuravleva}, I., {Churazov}, E., {et~al.} 2018, \ssr, 214, 108,
\dodoi{10.1007/s11214-018-0544-z}
\bibitem[{{HI4PI Collaboration} {et~al.}(2016){HI4PI Collaboration}, {Ben
Bekhti}, {Fl{\"o}er}, {Keller}, {Kerp}, {Lenz}, {Winkel}, {Bailin},
{Calabretta}, {Dedes}, {Ford}, {Gibson}, {Haud}, {Janowiecki}, {Kalberla},
{Lockman}, {McClure-Griffiths}, {Murphy}, {Nakanishi}, {Pisano}, \&
{Staveley-Smith}}]{2016A&A...594A.116H}
{HI4PI Collaboration}, {Ben Bekhti}, N., {Fl{\"o}er}, L., {et~al.} 2016, \aap,
594, A116, \dodoi{10.1051/0004-6361/201629178}
\bibitem[{{Hitomi Collaboration} {et~al.}(2018){Hitomi Collaboration},
{Aharonian}, {Akamatsu}, {Akimoto}, {Allen}, {Angelini}, {Audard}, {Awaki},
{Axelsson}, {Bamba}, {Bautz}, {Blandford}, {Brenneman}, {Brown}, {Bulbul},
{Cackett}, {Chernyakova}, {Chiao}, {Coppi}, {Costantini}, {de Plaa}, {de
Vries}, {den Herder}, {Done}, {Dotani}, {Ebisawa}, {Eckart}, {Enoto}, {Ezoe},
{Fabian}, {Ferrigno}, {Foster}, {Fujimoto}, {Fukazawa}, {Furukawa},
{Furuzawa}, {Galeazzi}, {Gallo}, {Gandhi}, {Giustini}, {Goldwurm}, {Gu},
{Guainazzi}, {Haba}, {Hagino}, {Hamaguchi}, {Harrus}, {Hatsukade}, {Hayashi},
{Hayashi}, {Hayashida}, {Hiraga}, {Hornschemeier}, {Hoshino}, {Hughes},
{Ichinohe}, {Iizuka}, {Inoue}, {Inoue}, {Ishida}, {Ishikawa}, {Ishisaki},
{Iwai}, {Kaastra}, {Kallman}, {Kamae}, {Kataoka}, {Katsuda}, {Kawai},
{Kelley}, {Kilbourne}, {Kitaguchi}, {Kitamoto}, {Kitayama}, {Kohmura},
{Kokubun}, {Koyama}, {Koyama}, {Kretschmar}, {Krimm}, {Kubota}, {Kunieda},
{Laurent}, {Lee}, {Leutenegger}, {Limousin}, {Loewenstein}, {Long}, {Lumb},
{Madejski}, {Maeda}, {Maier}, {Makishima}, {Markevitch}, {Matsumoto},
{Matsushita}, {McCammon}, {McNamara}, {Mehdipour}, {Miller}, {Miller},
{Mineshige}, {Mitsuda}, {Mitsuishi}, {Miyazawa}, {Mizuno}, {Mori}, {Mori},
{Mukai}, {Murakami}, {Mushotzky}, {Nakagawa}, {Nakajima}, {Nakamori},
{Nakashima}, {Nakazawa}, {Nobukawa}, {Nobukawa}, {Noda}, {Odaka},
{Ogorzalek}, {Ohashi}, {Ohno}, {Okajima}, {Ota}, {Ozaki}, {Paerels},
{Paltani}, {Petre}, {Pinto}, {Porter}, {Pottschmidt}, {Reynolds},
{Safi-Harb}, {Saito}, {Sakai}, {Sasaki}, {Sato}, {Sato}, {Sato}, {Sawada},
{Schartel}, {Serlemtsos}, {Seta}, {Shidatsu}, {Simionescu}, {Smith}, {Soong},
{Stawarz}, {Sugawara}, {Sugita}, {Szymkowiak}, {Tajima}, {Takahashi},
{Takahashi}, {Takeda}, {Takei}, {Tamagawa}, {Tamura}, {Tanaka}, {Tanaka},
{Tanaka}, {Tashiro}, {Tawara}, {Terada}, {Terashima}, {Tombesi}, {Tomida},
{Tsuboi}, {Tsujimoto}, {Tsunemi}, {Tsuru}, {Uchida}, {Uchiyama}, {Uchiyama},
{Ueda}, {Ueda}, {Uno}, {Urry}, {Ursino}, {Watanabe}, {Werner}, {Wilkins},
{Williams}, {Yamada}, {Yamaguchi}, {Yamaoka}, {Yamasaki}, {Yamauchi},
{Yamauchi}, {Yaqoob}, {Yatsu}, {Yonetoku}, {Zhuravleva}, \&
{Zoghbi}}]{2018PASJ...70...10H}
{Hitomi Collaboration}, {Aharonian}, F., {Akamatsu}, H., {et~al.} 2018, \pasj,
70, 10, \dodoi{10.1093/pasj/psx127}
\bibitem[{{Kalberla} {et~al.}(2005){Kalberla}, {Burton}, {Hartmann}, {Arnal},
{Bajaja}, {Morras}, \& {P{\"o}ppel}}]{2005A&A...440..775K}
{Kalberla}, P.~M.~W., {Burton}, W.~B., {Hartmann}, D., {et~al.} 2005, \aap,
440, 775, \dodoi{10.1051/0004-6361:20041864}
\bibitem[{{Molnar} {et~al.}(2006){Molnar}, {Birkinshaw}, \&
{Mushotzky}}]{2006ApJ...643L..73M}
{Molnar}, S.~M., {Birkinshaw}, M., \& {Mushotzky}, R.~F. 2006, \apjl, 643, L73,
\dodoi{10.1086/505301}
\bibitem[{{Nelson} {et~al.}(2023){Nelson}, {Byrohl}, {Ogorzalek}, {Markevitch},
{Khabibullin}, {Churazov}, {Zhuravleva}, {Bogdan}, {Chakraborty},
{Kilbourne}, {Kraft}, {Pillepich}, {Sarkar}, {Schellenberger}, {Su},
{Truong}, {Vladutescu-Zopp}, \& {Wijers}}]{2023MNRAS.522.3665N}
{Nelson}, D., {Byrohl}, C., {Ogorzalek}, A., {et~al.} 2023, \mnras, 522, 3665,
\dodoi{10.1093/mnras/stad1195}
\bibitem[{{Ogorzalek} {et~al.}(2017){Ogorzalek}, {Zhuravleva}, {Allen},
{Pinto}, {Werner}, {Mantz}, {Canning}, {Fabian}, {Kaastra}, \& {de
Plaa}}]{2017MNRAS.472.1659O}
{Ogorzalek}, A., {Zhuravleva}, I., {Allen}, S.~W., {et~al.} 2017, \mnras, 472,
1659, \dodoi{10.1093/mnras/stx2030}
\bibitem[{{Osterbrock}(1962)}]{1962ApJ...135..195O}
{Osterbrock}, D.~E. 1962, \apj, 135, 195, \dodoi{10.1086/147258}
\bibitem[{{Pozdnyakov} {et~al.}(1983){Pozdnyakov}, {Sobol}, \&
{Syunyaev}}]{1983ASPRv...2..189P}
{Pozdnyakov}, L.~A., {Sobol}, I.~M., \& {Syunyaev}, R.~A. 1983, \apspr, 2, 189
\bibitem[{{Ross} {et~al.}(1996){Ross}, {Fabian}, \&
{Brandt}}]{1996MNRAS.278.1082R}
{Ross}, R.~R., {Fabian}, A.~C., \& {Brandt}, W.~N. 1996, \mnras, 278, 1082,
\dodoi{10.1093/mnras/278.4.1082}
\bibitem[{{Russell} {et~al.}(2008){Russell}, {Sanders}, \&
{Fabian}}]{2008MNRAS.390.1207R}
{Russell}, H.~R., {Sanders}, J.~S., \& {Fabian}, A.~C. 2008, \mnras, 390, 1207,
\dodoi{10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13823.x}
\bibitem[{{Sanders} \& {Fabian}(2006)}]{2006MNRAS.370...63S}
{Sanders}, J.~S., \& {Fabian}, A.~C. 2006, \mnras, 370, 63,
\dodoi{10.1111/j.1365-2966.2006.10497.x}
\bibitem[{{Sanders} {et~al.}(2020){Sanders}, {Dennerl}, {Russell}, {Eckert},
{Pinto}, {Fabian}, {Walker}, {Tamura}, {ZuHone}, \&
{Hofmann}}]{2020A&A...633A..42S}
{Sanders}, J.~S., {Dennerl}, K., {Russell}, H.~R., {et~al.} 2020, \aap, 633,
A42, \dodoi{10.1051/0004-6361/201936468}
\bibitem[{{Sarkar} {et~al.}(2022{\natexlab{a}}){Sarkar}, {Su}, {Truong},
{Randall}, {Mernier}, {Gastaldello}, {Biffi}, \&
{Kraft}}]{2022MNRAS.516.3068S}
{Sarkar}, A., {Su}, Y., {Truong}, N., {et~al.} 2022{\natexlab{a}}, \mnras, 516,
3068, \dodoi{10.1093/mnras/stac2416}
\bibitem[{{Sarkar} {et~al.}(2022{\natexlab{b}}){Sarkar}, {Randall}, {Su},
{Alvarez}, {Sarazin}, {Nulsen}, {Blanton}, {Forman}, {Jones}, {Bulbul},
{Zuhone}, {Andrade-Santos}, {Johnson}, \&
{Chakraborty}}]{2022ApJ...935L..23S}
{Sarkar}, A., {Randall}, S., {Su}, Y., {et~al.} 2022{\natexlab{b}}, \apjl, 935,
L23, \dodoi{10.3847/2041-8213/ac86d4}
\bibitem[{{Sarkar} {et~al.}(2023){Sarkar}, {Randall}, {Su}, {Alvarez},
{Sarazin}, {Jones}, {Blanton}, {Nulsen}, {Chakraborty}, {Bulbul}, {Zuhone},
{Andrade-Santos}, \& {Johnson}}]{2023ApJ...944..132S}
---. 2023, \apj, 944, 132, \dodoi{10.3847/1538-4357/acae9f}
\bibitem[{{Sazonov} {et~al.}(2002){Sazonov}, {Churazov}, \&
{Sunyaev}}]{2002MNRAS.333..191S}
{Sazonov}, S.~Y., {Churazov}, E.~M., \& {Sunyaev}, R.~A. 2002, \mnras, 333,
191, \dodoi{10.1046/j.1365-8711.2002.05390.x}
\bibitem[{{Schmelz} {et~al.}(1992){Schmelz}, {Saba}, \&
{Strong}}]{1992ApJ...398L.115S}
{Schmelz}, J.~T., {Saba}, J.~L.~R., \& {Strong}, K.~T. 1992, \apjl, 398, L115,
\dodoi{10.1086/186590}
\bibitem[{{Shigeyama}(1998)}]{1998ApJ...497..587S}
{Shigeyama}, T. 1998, \apj, 497, 587, \dodoi{10.1086/305498}
\bibitem[{{Smith} {et~al.}(2000){Smith}, {Lucey}, {Hudson}, {Schlegel}, \&
{Davies}}]{2000MNRAS.313..469S}
{Smith}, R.~J., {Lucey}, J.~R., {Hudson}, M.~J., {Schlegel}, D.~J., \&
{Davies}, R.~L. 2000, \mnras, 313, 469,
\dodoi{10.1046/j.1365-8711.2000.03251.x}
\bibitem[{{Smith} {et~al.}(2001){Smith}, {Brickhouse}, {Liedahl}, \&
{Raymond}}]{2001ApJ...556L..91S}
{Smith}, R.~K., {Brickhouse}, N.~S., {Liedahl}, D.~A., \& {Raymond}, J.~C.
2001, \apjl, 556, L91, \dodoi{10.1086/32299210.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0106478}
\bibitem[{{Uchida} {et~al.}(2019){Uchida}, {Katsuda}, {Tsunemi}, {Mori}, {Gu},
{Cumbee}, {Petre}, \& {Tanaka}}]{2019ApJ...871..234U}
{Uchida}, H., {Katsuda}, S., {Tsunemi}, H., {et~al.} 2019, \apj, 871, 234,
\dodoi{10.3847/1538-4357/aaf8a6}
\bibitem[{{Voit} {et~al.}(2015){Voit}, {Donahue}, {O'Shea}, {Bryan}, {Sun}, \&
{Werner}}]{2015ApJ...803L..21V}
{Voit}, G.~M., {Donahue}, M., {O'Shea}, B.~W., {et~al.} 2015, \apjl, 803, L21,
\dodoi{10.1088/2041-8205/803/2/L21}
\bibitem[{{Xu} {et~al.}(2002){Xu}, {Kahn}, {Peterson}, {Behar}, {Paerels},
{Mushotzky}, {Jernigan}, {Brinkman}, \& {Makishima}}]{2002ApJ...579..600X}
{Xu}, H., {Kahn}, S.~M., {Peterson}, J.~R., {et~al.} 2002, \apj, 579, 600,
\dodoi{10.1086/342828}
\bibitem[{{Zhuravleva} {et~al.}(2013){Zhuravleva}, {Churazov}, {Sunyaev},
{Sazonov}, {Allen}, {Werner}, {Simionescu}, {Konami}, \&
{Ohashi}}]{2013MNRAS.435.3111Z}
{Zhuravleva}, I., {Churazov}, E., {Sunyaev}, R., {et~al.} 2013, \mnras, 435,
3111, \dodoi{10.1093/mnras/stt1506}
\bibitem[{{Zhuravleva} {et~al.}(2011){Zhuravleva}, {Churazov}, {Sazonov},
{Sunyaev}, \& {Dolag}}]{2011AstL...37..141Z}
{Zhuravleva}, I.~V., {Churazov}, E.~M., {Sazonov}, S.~Y., {Sunyaev}, R.~A., \&
{Dolag}, K. 2011, Astronomy Letters, 37, 141,
\dodoi{10.1134/S1063773711010087}
\bibitem[{{Zhuravleva} {et~al.}(2010){Zhuravleva}, {Churazov}, {Sazonov},
{Sunyaev}, {Forman}, \& {Dolag}}]{2010MNRAS.403..129Z}
{Zhuravleva}, I.~V., {Churazov}, E.~M., {Sazonov}, S.~Y., {et~al.} 2010,
\mnras, 403, 129, \dodoi{10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.16148.x}
\end{thebibliography}