Computer-based Deceptive Game Design in Commercial Virtual Reality Games: A Preliminary Investigation
Extracted source text · arXiv 2504.00368
%%
%% This is file `sample-manuscript.tex',
%% generated with the docstrip utility.
%%
%% The original source files were:
%%
%% samples.dtx (with options: `all,proceedings,bibtex,manuscript')
%%
%% IMPORTANT NOTICE:
%%
%% For the copyright see the source file.
%%
%% Any modified versions of this file must be renamed
%% with new filenames distinct from sample-manuscript.tex.
%%
%% For distribution of the original source see the terms
%% for copying and modification in the file samples.dtx.
%%
%% This generated file may be distributed as long as the
%% original source files, as listed above, are part of the
%% same distribution. (The sources need not necessarily be
%% in the same archive or directory.)
%%
%%
%% Commands for TeXCount
%TC:macro \cite [option:text,text]
%TC:macro \citep [option:text,text]
%TC:macro \citet [option:text,text]
%TC:envir table 0 1
%TC:envir table* 0 1
%TC:envir tabular [ignore] word
%TC:envir displaymath 0 word
%TC:envir math 0 word
%TC:envir comment 0 0
%%
%%
%% The first command in your LaTeX source must be the \documentclass
%% command.
%%
%% For submission and review of your manuscript please change the
%% command to \documentclass[manuscript, screen, review]{acmart}.
%%
%% When submitting camera ready or to TAPS, please change the command
%% to \documentclass[sigconf]{acmart} or whichever template is required
%% for your publication.
%%
%%
\documentclass[sigconf,screen]{acmart}
\copyrightyear{2024}
\acmYear{2024}
\setcopyright{rightsretained}
\acmConference[CHI PLAY Companion '24]{Companion Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play}{October 14--17, 2024}{Tampere, Finland}
\acmBooktitle{Companion Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play (CHI PLAY Companion '24), October 14--17, 2024, Tampere, Finland}\acmDOI{10.1145/3665463.3678820}
\acmISBN{979-8-4007-0692-9/24/10}
% Authors, replace the red X's with your assigned DOI string during the rightsreview eform process.
\makeatletter
\gdef\@copyrightpermission{
\begin{minipage}{0.2\columnwidth}
\href{https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/}{\includegraphics[width=0.90\textwidth]{4ACM-CC-by-sa-88x31.png}}
\end{minipage}\hfill
\begin{minipage}{0.8\columnwidth}
\href{https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/}{This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike International 4.0 License.}
\end{minipage}
\vspace{5pt}
}
\makeatother
%%
%% Submission ID.
%% Use this when submitting an article to a sponsored event. You'll
%% receive a unique submission ID from the organizers
%% of the event, and this ID should be used as the parameter to this command.
%%\acmSubmissionID{123-A56-BU3}
\input{02-Commands}
%%
%% For managing citations, it is recommended to use bibliography
%% files in BibTeX format.
%%
%% You can then either use BibTeX with the ACM-Reference-Format style,
%% or BibLaTeX with the acmnumeric or acmauthoryear sytles, that include
%% support for advanced citation of software artefact from the
%% biblatex-software package, also separately available on CTAN.
%%
%% Look at the sample-*-biblatex.tex files for templates showcasing
%% the biblatex styles.
%%
%%
%% The majority of ACM publications use numbered citations and
%% references. The command \citestyle{authoryear} switches to the
%% "author year" style.
%%
%% If you are preparing content for an event
\settopmatter{printacmref=true}
\begin{document}
%%
%% The "title" command has an optional parameter,
%% allowing the author to define a "short title" to be used in page headers.
%\title[Deceptive Design in VR Games]{Deception Beyond the Screen: A Preliminary Investigation of Computer-based Deceptive Game Design in Commercial Virtual Reality Games}
\title[Deceptive Design in VR Games]{Computer-based Deceptive Game Design in Commercial Virtual Reality Games: A Preliminary Investigation}
%%
%% The "author" command and its associated commands are used to define
%% the authors and their affiliations.
%% Of note is the shared affiliation of the first two authors, and the
%% "authornote" and "authornotemark" commands
%% used to denote shared contribution to the research.
\author{Hilda Hadan}
\email{hhadan@uwaterloo.ca}
\orcid{https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5911-1405}
\affiliation{
\institution{Stratford School of Interaction Design and Business, University of Waterloo}
\city{Waterloo}
\country{Canada}
}
\author{Leah Zhang-Kennedy}
\email{lzhangke@uwaterloo.ca}
\orcid{https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0756-0022}
\affiliation{
\institution{Stratford School of Interaction Design and Business, University of Waterloo}
\city{Waterloo}
\country{Canada}
}
\author{Lennart E. Nacke}
\email{lennart.nacke@acm.org}
\orcid{https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4290-8829}
\affiliation{
\institution{Stratford School of Interaction Design and Business, University of Waterloo}
\city{Waterloo}
\country{Canada}
}
%%
%% By default, the full list of authors will be used in the page
%% headers. Often, this list is too long, and will overlap
%% other information printed in the page headers. This command allows
%% the author to define a more concise list
%% of authors' names for this purpose.
\renewcommand{\shortauthors}{Hilda Hadan, Leah Zhang-Kennedy, \& Lennart E. Nacke}
%%
%% The abstract is a short summary of the work to be presented in the
%% article.
\begin{abstract}
\input{00-Abstract}
\end{abstract}
%%
%% The code below is generated by the tool at http://dl.acm.org/ccs.cfm.
%% Please copy and paste the code instead of the example below.
%%
\begin{CCSXML}
<ccs2012>
<concept>
<concept_id>10003120.10003121.10011748</concept_id>
<concept_desc>Human-centered computing~Empirical studies in HCI</concept_desc>
<concept_significance>500</concept_significance>
</concept>
<concept>
<concept_id>10003120.10003121.10003124.10010866</concept_id>
<concept_desc>Human-centered computing~Virtual reality</concept_desc>
<concept_significance>500</concept_significance>
</concept>
<concept>
<concept_id>10011007.10010940.10010941.10010969.10010970</concept_id>
<concept_desc>Software and its engineering~Interactive games</concept_desc>
<concept_significance>500</concept_significance>
</concept>
<concept>
<concept_id>10010405.10010476.10011187.10011190</concept_id>
<concept_desc>Applied computing~Computer games</concept_desc>
<concept_significance>500</concept_significance>
</concept>
</ccs2012>
\end{CCSXML}
\ccsdesc[500]{Human-centered computing~Empirical studies in HCI}
\ccsdesc[500]{Human-centered computing~Virtual reality}
\ccsdesc[500]{Software and its engineering~Interactive games}
\ccsdesc[500]{Applied computing~Computer games}
%%
%% Keywords. The author(s) should pick words that accurately describe
%% the work being presented. Separate the keywords with commas.
\keywords{Deceptive Design, Dark Pattern, Virtual Reality, Player Experience, Autoethnography}
%\received{20 February 2007}
%\received[revised]{12 March 2009}
%\received[accepted]{5 June 2009}
%%
%% This command processes the author and affiliation and title
%% information and builds the first part of the formatted document.
\maketitle
\section{Introduction}
\label{sec:introduction}
\input{01-Introduction}
\section{Related Work and How It Informed Our Research}
\label{sec:related-work}
\input{02-RelatedWork}
\section{Methodology}
\label{sec:methodology}
\input{03-Methodology}
\section{Findings}
\label{sec:findings}
\input{04-Findings}
\section{Discussion and Next Steps}
\label{sec:discussion}
\input{05-Discussion}
%\section{Conclusion}
%\label{sec:conclusion}
%\input{06-Conclusion}
%%
%% The acknowledgments section is defined using the "acks" environment
%% (and NOT an unnumbered section). This ensures the proper
%% identification of the section in the article metadata, and the
%% consistent spelling of the heading.
\begin{acks}
\input{98-Acknowledgement}
\end{acks}
%%
%% The next two lines define the bibliography style to be used, and
%% the bibliography file.
\bibliographystyle{ACM-Reference-Format}
\balance
\bibliography{01-References}
%%
%% If your work has an appendix, this is the place to put it.
\appendix
\input{99-Appendix}
\end{document}
\endinput
%%
%% End of file `sample-manuscript.tex'.
%% packages
% \usepackage{comment}
\usepackage{float}
\usepackage{balance}
%to customize list prefix (e.g., Q1., Q2)
% \usepackage{enumerate}
\usepackage[shortlabels]{enumitem}
%to leave notes to myself.
%\usepackage[colorinlistoftodos]{todonotes}
%\newcommand{\hilda}[1]{\todo[color=pink!25,linecolor=pink]{\textcolor{magenta}{Hilda: #1}}}
\newcommand{\hilda}[1]{\textcolor{magenta}{Hilda: #1}}
%for the term
\usepackage{xspace}
\newcommand{\guide}{\textit{Assessment Guide}\xspace}
\newcommand{\wip}{WIP\xspace}
\newcommand{\WIP}{Work in Progress\xspace}
\newcommand{\Moss}{\textit{Moss2}\xspace}
\newcommand{\BS}{\textit{Beat Saber}\xspace}
\newcommand{\OW}{\textit{OW2}\xspace}
\usepackage{microtype} %define letter spacing
\newcommand{\codestyle}[1]{\textit{#1}}
\newcommand{\mechanics}[1]{\texttt{\textls[-40]{#1}}}
%to format table
% \usepackage{booktabs}
% \usepackage{graphicx}
% \usepackage[normalem]{ulem}
%\useunder{\uline}{\ul}{}
\usepackage{multirow}
% \usepackage{adjustbox}
\usepackage{fontawesome}
%for definition and correspondence literature icons
\newcommand{\deficon}{\faChevronCircleRight\xspace}
\newcommand{\coricon}{\faChevronRight\xspace}
%for use of: \cdashlinelr{1-8}
% \usepackage{arydshln}
\usepackage{colortbl}
% colortbl, lettrine, marginnote, picinpar and sidecap
\makeatletter
\def\adl@drawiv#1#2#3{%
\hskip.5\tabcolsep
\xleaders#3{#2.5\@tempdimb #1{1}#2.5\@tempdimb}%
#2\z@ plus1fil minus1fil\relax
\hskip.5\tabcolsep}
\newcommand{\cdashlinelr}[1]{%
\noalign{\vskip\aboverulesep
\global\let\@dashdrawstore\adl@draw
\global\let\adl@draw\adl@drawiv}
\cdashline{#1}
\noalign{\global\let\adl@draw\@dashdrawstore
\vskip\belowrulesep}}
\makeatother
%text color
%\usepackage[usenames,dvipsnames]{color} %using the color package, not xcolor
%for quotes
% \usepackage[rightmargin=1cm,vskip=0pt,noorphans,font={itshape},indentfirst=false]{quoting}
%generate pdf only for pages [x-y]
%\usepackage[1-8]{pagesel}
%highlights \hl{}
\usepackage{soul}
%svg format images
% \usepackage{svg}
%for the table coloring
% \usepackage{array}
\usepackage{xcolor,colortbl}
\definecolor{All-gray}{HTML}{dddcdc}
%%%%%%%%%%%% some other colors
\definecolor{palered}{HTML}{ffadad}
\definecolor{paleorange}{HTML}{FFCA85} %fa9c1d
\definecolor{paleyellow}{HTML}{fdffb6}
\definecolor{palegreen}{HTML}{caffbf}
\definecolor{palecyan}{HTML}{9bf6ff}
\definecolor{paleblue}{HTML}{a0c4ff} %a0c4ff
\definecolor{palepurple}{HTML}{bdb2ff}
\definecolor{palepink}{HTML}{ffc6ff}
\definecolor{palewhite}{HTML}{fffffc}
%icons in the table
%patterns identified, not identified, not entirely align with literature:
\newcommand{\found}{\faCircle}
\newcommand{\notfound}{\faCircleThin}
\newcommand{\notalign}{\faAdjust}
\usepackage{rotating}
\setlength{\rotFPtop}{0pt plus 1fil}
\setlength{\rotFPbot}{0pt plus 1fil}
\newenvironment{quoting}[1][]
{\par\small
\begin{list}{}{%
\setlength{\topsep}{1em}% Space above the list
\setlength{\partopsep}{0pt}% Space above and below when list starts a new paragraph
\setlength{\itemsep}{0pt}% Space between items
\setlength{\parsep}{0pt}% Space between paragraphs within an item
\leftmargin=1cm \rightmargin=1cm}
\item\relax
\begingroup\itshape
\ifx\relax#1\relax\else\textbf{#1:}\ \fi}
{\par\endgroup\end{list}\addvspace{1em}}
%verion 1 - word count =159
%In games, deceptive designs can manipulate players and create negative experiences. While literature has studied deceptive design in computer and mobile games, its presence and impact in Virtual Reality (VR) games remains unclear. Through an autoethnography diary study, we compared the manifestation of computer deceptive game designs in two popular VR games and examined how they persist or differ by modality. We found that many deceptive game designs vary significantly between modalities. Emotional and sensory manipulation has become more powerful due to VR’s immersive nature, and temporal manipulation has become harmful to players experience due to the constraints of VR technology. Others also have great potential to used for more advanced player manipulation in the future. We concluded by discussing our next steps and the potential broader implications of our final research outcomes for researchers to further their understanding of deceptive game design and for policymakers and designers to implement adequate user protection through VR product design and regulations.
%\hilda{I decided to not use it because the last assertation is too big a claim for a WIP.}
%version 2 - word count =141 (no word limit but don't go over line 16 for the page limit)
As Virtual Reality (VR) games become more popular, it is crucial to understand how deceptive game design patterns manifest and impact player experiences in this emerging medium.
%Deceptive game designs manipulate players and create negative experiences, but their presence and impacts in commercial Virtual Reality (VR) games remain largely unknown.
Our study sheds light on the presence and effects of manipulative design techniques in commercial VR games compared to a traditional computer game. We conducted an autoethnography study and developed a VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide based on a critical literature review. Using our guide, we compared how deceptive patterns in a popular computer game are different from two commercial VR titles. While VR's technological constraints, such as battery life and limited temporal manipulation, VR's unique sensory immersion amplified the impact of emotional and sensory deception. Current VR games showed similar but evolved forms of deceptive design compared to the computer game. We forecast more sophisticated player manipulation as VR technology advances. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of how deceptive game design persists and escalates in VR. We highlight the urgent need to develop ethical design guidelines for the rapidly advancing VR games industry.
%Through an autoethnography study and a VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide that we developed based on critical analysis of previous literature, we compared the manifestation of deceptive design patterns in a popular computer game to two commercial VR games to explore whether these patterns persisted across modalities or differed in VR. Our findings show that while VR's current technology limitations like device battery life constrained temporal manipulations, VR's unique features amplified the impact of emotional and sensory manipulations.
%Our work forecasts more sophisticated manipulation in the near future and highlights the need for the development of ethical design guidelines in the rapidly growing VR games industry.
%Our research contributes a VR Deceptive Design Assessment Guide that can inform future research and ethical VR game design. T
%We conclude by discussing our next steps and the potential broader implications of our final research outcomes.}
%\hilda{Please let me know if the contribution statement is strong enough for a WIP.}
%background - deceptive design is big problem in non-VR games. The problem is movireferred VR with the evolution of technology and migration of commercial games.
Deceptive game design has been a growing area of concern for player researchers. Literature has identified various deceptive game design patterns used in mobile and computer-based games to manipulate player behaviour for the benefit of game developers and publishers (e.g.,~\cite{fitton2019F2P,roffarello2023defining,geronimo2020UI,karlsen2019exploited}). These practices designed to manipulate player engagement and monetization through psychological and emotional tactics can escalate frustration and confusion~\cite{zagal2013dark,gray2021enduser,maier2019dark}, and damage game publisher reputations~\cite{hhadan2024ow2}.
%These practices, often designed to influence player engagement and monetization through psychological and emotional manipulation, can cause negative player experiences, as they can lead to frustration and confusion~\cite{zagal2013dark,hhadan2024ow2,gray2021enduser,maier2019dark}, and be detrimental to game publisher's reputation~\cite{hhadan2024ow2}.
Deceptive design research has primarily focused on games on traditional 2D interfaces (e.g.,~\cite{zagal2013dark,fitton2019F2P,karlsen2019exploited}). However, commercially available Virtual Reality (VR) technology opens a new frontier for immersive manipulative tactics.
%and could even foster more tactics that are unexpected in 2D screens.
%due to the immersive nature of VR.
Spatial and realistic displays in VR could amplify the impact and subtlety of deceptive designs~\cite{hadan2024deceived,krauss2024what}, impairing users' ability to critically evaluate content~\cite{cummings2022all}. As commercial game development shifts to VR platforms, understanding how deceptive practices adapt to immersive technology is paramount.
%problem - currently there's a lack of investigation in VR deceptive design. Although a few attemps were made, mostly were based on hypothestical scenarios. We look into problems in VR games and investigate real world examples on how these patterns could influence players
Although recent studies have explored how deceptive design could work in immersive environments, these explorations have mainly focused on hypothetical scenarios from literature, experts predictions, and controlled laboratory experiments (e.g.,~\cite{hadan2024deceived,krauss2024what,su2022perception}). These studies focused broadly on XR technology and neglected the specific contextual factors of VR games.
%on real-world VR game implementations
%There is a critical gap
The impact of deceptive design on players within immersive VR environments remains largely unexplored. Our research addresses this gap by investigating deceptive design patterns in commercially available VR games, and comparing them to traditional game implementations. We analyze how these patterns evolve across modalities, with a focus on their potential impact in VR and on player experience. Our overarching Research Questions (RQs) are:
\begin{enumerate}[label=\textbf{RQ\arabic*:}]
\item What deceptive design patterns are currently implemented in commercial VR games?
\item How do deceptive game designs vary in their manifestations in VR games and PC games?
\end{enumerate}
%our method and selection of games, and why we chose this method and these games.
To address these RQs, we are conducting a series of analyses, including a literature synthesis to construct a \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} (referred to as the \guide) that comprehensively captures deceptive design patterns in VR games. We are also conducting autoethnography research to identify these patterns in various VR games and to compare new manifestations in VR to those in recent PC games.
%a comparative analysis of deceptive game design manifestations between PC and VR games.}
%followed by a broader scope examination of player perception and experience from online communities to explore the VR deceptive game design impacts, and interviews with game designers to explore the reasons (if any) these designs were implemented in the first place.
In this work-in-progress (\wip), we report the first stage of our research, which includes an initial version of the \guide synthesized from the literature, a preliminary seven-week autoethnography study, and a comparative analysis of deceptive design patterns identified in two commercial VR games (see~\autoref{fig:screenshots}, left and center): \textit{Moss: Book II} (\Moss), a VR puzzle adventure game;
%where players guide a tiny mouse character through a fantastical world;
and \BS, a VR rhythm game. These games are selected because of their critical acclaim in the VR player community and significant player bases\footnote{As of May 10, 2024, \BS has about 862,000 active players; \textit{Moss Book: II} has been played by 33,000 players. See~\url{https://playtracker.net/insight/game/5}.}. We chose a third cross-platform computer game, \textit{Overwatch2} (\OW), a first-person team-based shooter (see~\autoref{fig:screenshots}, right) as an exemplar PC game to compare to VR games because our previous research~\cite{hhadan2024ow2} had identified various deceptive game design mechanisms in \OW
%where players slash colorful blocks to the beat of music.
%\OW was selected as an exemplar for the PC platform due its wide coverage of game mechanics associated with deceptive design
%related to deceptive design from the literature~\cite{petrovskaya2021predatory,neely2021come,king20233d,fitton2019F2P}
and critical player reviews\footnote{As of May 4, 2024, \OW holds the sixth position on the list of worst games on Steam with 82\% of negative reviews, resulted in an overall rating of ``overwhelmingly negative''. Currently, \OW See:~\url{https://store.steampowered.com/app/2357570/Overwatch_2/} and~\url{https://steam250.com/bottom100}}. While deceptive design varies across game types, genres, and mechanics, we have focused on examining and contrasting these patterns in a select sample of exemplary games in our preliminary investigation presented in this \wip. This approach allows us to explore how these patterns uniquely manifest and impact VR players more than traditional computer games.
The lead researcher---experienced in deceptive design research and VR gaming applications---extensively played \OW (20 hours in 6 days), followed by \Moss (8 hours in 9 days) then \BS (18 hours in 9 days) to systematically document detailed diary entries that reflect on moments where game mechanics appeared to use deceptive patterns and produce manipulative experiences. The length of play between the three games is determined by the principle of saturation when no new deceptive design patterns emerged during gameplay. The autoethnographic approach allowed us to actively engage as players and experience deceptive design first-hand, capture player frustrations and excitements, and systematically document these experiences over time~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography}. %This approach is particularly valuable for analyzing deceptive designs in VR, especially those manipulating people through long-term exposure (e.g.,~\cite{hadan2024deceived,krauss2024what}).
Next, we developed an initial version of the \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} across eight themes that consist of 71 distinct deceptive designs from the literature to deductively analyze diary entries (see~\autoref{tab:initial-codebook}). This \guide was constructed by synthesizing existing classifications (e.g.,~\cite{gray2024ontology,zagal2013dark,king20233d,hadan2024deceived}) that comprehensively captured problematic design practices from the academic and regulatory space~\cite{gray2024ontology}, as well as from games~\cite{zagal2013dark}, immersive environments~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, and player perspectives~\cite{king20233d}.
%our contribution statement and next steps.
Our preliminary research outcomes make three \textbf{contributions}: \textit{First}, we present a \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} that builds on established classifications to serve as a foundation for analyzing deceptive design in VR games, and informing future researchers, VR designers, and policymakers by providing a standardized tool for identifying and categorizing deceptive tactics in VR games.
\textit{Second}, our research uses an autoethnography method to provide valuable insights into players' lived experiences from a first-person perspective. \textit{Third}, our preliminary investigation revealed various manifestations of deceptive designs across modalities. Our findings suggest that, although the limitations of VR device battery life clashed with tactics driving extensive playtime, VR's unique features amplified the impact of emotional and sensory manipulations and presented a potential for more sophisticated manipulation in future VR games.
%In this section, we review deceptive game design literature and emphasize the need to understand player experience when studying this topic. Finally, we discuss autoethnography as a suitable approach for studying deceptive design in games.
\subsection{Deceptive Design in Games and Immersive Environment and The Role of Player Perception}
Deceptive design that impairs users' ability to make informed decisions~\cite{mathur2021makes,gray2023towards,EUDSA2022,Brignull2023book}, is widely used on websites~\cite{mathur2019dark,gray2018dark,gunawan2021comparative}, mobile apps~\cite{lewis2014irresistible,fitton2019F2P,gunawan2021comparative}, and social networks~\cite{mildner2023defending,mildner2023engaging}. %, and have compared its manifestations across modalities~\citet{gunawan2021comparative}.
In games, deceptive designs can benefit game developers but negatively impact player experiences~\cite{zagal2013dark}. The literature has classified deceptive designs for psychological manipulation~\cite{zagal2013dark}, attention capture~\cite{roffarello2023defining}, and extended playtime and money spending~\cite{dillon2020digital,geronimo2020UI,karlsen2019exploited,zagal2013dark}. Studies on 3D interaction~\cite{Greenberg2014proxemic,king20233d} and Extended Reality (XR)\footnote{Extended Reality (XR) describes immersive technologies such as Virtual Reality (VR), Augmented Reality (AR), and Mixed Reality (MR).} literature~\cite{hadan2024deceived} indicate that XR's unique features, such as spatial displays, multi-modality and realistic experiences, real-world sensory blocking, and sensor data, create new opportunities for deceptive design
%and users' tendency to believe in the objectivity of produced XR simulations all contribute to potentially
that amplifies user manipulation~\cite{hadan2024deceived,krauss2024what}. \citet{gray2024ontology} synthesized a comprehensive ontology of 64 deceptive designs from widely adopted regulatory and academic taxonomies.
%For 3D environments, \citet{Greenberg2014proxemic} explored deceptive design's potential in proxemic interactions to trigger unwanted interactions. ~\citet{king20233d} investigated players' perception on deceptive design in 3D gameplay context, and~\citet{hadan2024deceived} synthesized XR-specific deceptive designs in literature. Research has also identified XR features, such as spatial 3D display and interaction with digital objects, multi-modality and realistic virtual experience and sensations, the ability to obscure physical surroundings, the vast amount of data from XR sensors, and users' tendency to believe in the objectivity of first-person experience, could amplify user manipulation~\cite{hadan2024deceived,krauss2024what}.
%In 2023, ~\citet{hadan2024deceived} conducted a systematic literature review, identifying deceptive design strategies XR games and applications could use to create false memories, manipulate user empathy, and distort their perception of reality. Similarly, ~\citet{krauss2024what} explored 36 potential deceptive design scenarios through a combined researcher and designer perspectives. Both studies found that XR-specific features, such as spatial 3D display and interaction with digital objects, multi-modality and photorealistic virtual artifacts, the barriers created between users' physical and virtual world due to their wearing of headsets, and the reach amount of data from XR sensors, could amplify user manipulation~\citet{hadan2024deceived,krauss2024what}. To facilitate knowledge sharing and application in the field of deceptive design research, \citet{gray2024ontology} has synthesized 64 deceptive design types from widely adopted regulatory and academic taxonomies into a domain-agnostic ontology of deceptive design.
Deceptive designs exploit internal \textit{human rationality and cognitive limitations} and external \textit{social influence} to manipulate human decision-making~\cite{simon1997models,waldman2020cognitive,thaler2009nudge}. The effectiveness of deceptive design varies based on users' literacy~\cite{zagal2013dark,geronimo2020UI,luguri2021shining}, encounter frequency, perceived trustworthiness, level of frustration, misleading behaviour and UI appearance~\cite{m2020towards}. Player perceptions also play a role, with some feeling ``interrupted'' or questioning game fairness, while others might appreciate the guidance~\cite{zagal2013dark,frommel2022daily,fitton2019F2P,freeman2022pay} or accept it due to service dependency~\cite{maier2019dark}. Given this complexity, literature suggests that user-centred approaches are necessary for identifying design practices that are not straightly unethical~\cite{gray2021enduser,gray2023mapping,hhadan2024ow2}. %Our autoethnography methodology follows these recommendations by incorporate player experiences and perceptions from a first-person perspective.
In our preliminary investigation, we built upon~\citet{gray2024ontology}'s comprehensive ontology which was grounded in foundational literature and taxonomies in the field (e.g.,~\cite{Brignull2010deceptive,gray2018dark,mathur2021makes}). We further incorporated insights from~\citet{zagal2013dark} on game-specific and~\citet{hadan2024deceived} on XR-specific deceptive designs, and~\citet{king20233d} on player perception in 3D interfaces. While~\citet{zagal2013dark}'s framework lacked empirical data, it remains a ``fruitful'' starting point for game-focused deceptive design research~\cite[p.~2]{deterding2020against}. Our autoethnography methodology addresses this gap and follows the recommendations by incorporating player experiences and perceptions from a first-person perspective. We present how these studies informed our process of developing our \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} in~\autoref{subsec:codebook-development}.
%\hilda{a slightly shorter draft of this argument paragraph}
%In our preliminary investigation, we built upon~\citet{gray2024ontology}'s comprehensive ontology because of its grounding in foundational literature in the field (e.g.,~\citet{Brignull2010deceptive,gray2018dark,mathur2021makes}), which ensures our findings comparable to existing research. We further considered~\citet{zagal2013dark},~\citet{hadan2024deceived}, and~\citet{king20233d} due to their insights into game-specific~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d} and XR-specific deceptive designs~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, and player perception in 3D interfaces~\cite{king20233d}. While~\citet{zagal2013dark}'s framework lacked empirical data, it remains a ``fruitful'' analytical starting point for game-focused classification~\cite[p.~2]{deterding2020against}. We addressed this by grounding our research in player experiences through an autoethnography methodology. ~\autoref{subsec:codebook-development} presents how these studies informed our codebook development process.
%\hilda{original draft of this argument paragraph}
%While all above literature informed our study, we mainly adopted~\cite{gray2024ontology,hadan2024deceived,zagal2013dark,king20233d} as our foundation for deceptive game design. We used~\citet{gray2024ontology} as the backbone for our analysis as it offered the most recent and comprehensive framework were grounded in foundational literature in the field (e.g.,~\citet{Brignull2010deceptive,gray2018dark,mathur2021makes}). In addition,~\citet{hadan2024deceived} provided a solid understanding of XR-specific deceptive design practices from literature, and ~\citet{king20233d}'s exploration of player perception in 3D interfaces was closely relevant to our research goal. Despite lacking some empirical grounding~\citet{deterding2020against},~\citet{zagal2013dark} remains the most cited game-exclusive classification and can ``form fruitful analytic or empirical starting points for tracing when and why particular game design decisions can become ethically questionable''~\cite[p.~2]{deterding2020against}. We addressed the limitation of~\citet{zagal2013dark}'s classification by grounding our research in an empirical analysis of autoethnography diary entries that integrates the consideration of player experience.
%\hilda{I decided to merge this section with the one above to save space}
%\subsection{Human Factors in Understanding Deceptive Design}
%Deceptive designs exploit internal \textit{human limitations} (e.g.,bounded rationality, loss aversion, temptation, and mindlessness) and external \textit{social influence} to manipulate human decision-making~\cite{simon1997models,waldman2020cognitive,thaler2009nudge}. The effectiveness of deceptive design varies based on users' literacy~\cite{zagal2013dark,geronimo2020UI,luguri2021shining}, encounter frequency, perceived trustworthiness, level of frustration, misleading behavior, and UI appearance~\cite{m2020towards}. Player perceptions also play a role, with some feeling ``interrupted'' or questioning game fairness, while others might appreciate the guidance~\cite{zagal2013dark,frommel2022daily,fitton2019F2P,freeman2022pay} or accept it due to service dependency~\cite{maier2019dark}. Given this complexity, literature suggests that user-centered approaches are necessary in identifying deceptive design practices that are not straightly unethical~\cite{gray2021enduser,gray2023mapping,hhadan2024ow2}. Our autoethnography methodology follows these recommendations by incorporate player experiences and perceptions from a first-person perspective.
%Research suggests that users' experiences and perceptions can facilitate identifying problematic practices that may not be strictly illegal~\cite{gray2021enduser}. Incorporating explicit human-in-the-loop techniques in studies focusing on deceptive design detection can overcome the lack of detectability of many pattern types~\cite{gray2023mapping}.
\subsection{Autoethnography as a Methodology in Games Research}
Autoethnography is a common HCI methodology where designers reflect on their extended use of a system to understand its nature and refine its design directions (e.g.,~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography,neustaedter2012autobiographical,boehner2008interfaces}).
%methodology commonly used in HCI as a form of design research that draws on extensive use of a system by its creators to reflect on their own experiences, understand the system's nature, and continually refine its design directions~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography,neustaedter2012autobiographical,boehner2008interfaces}.
%A similar methodology, cognitive walkthrough~\cite{lewis1990testing}, has also been used in exploration and documentation of deceptive design on websites by~\citet{Brignull2023book}, where he started by ``capture extensive screenshots of the user journey and look closely at every step using an expert evaluation...''~\cite[p.~203]{Brignull2023book}. However, this methodology is highly task-oriented and concentrates on evaluating the usability of the system through logical user steps and action execution~\cite{lewis1990testing}, and ``the efficiency of the method decreases along with the amount of interactivity of the product evaluated: for applications of the exploratory type (virtual reality, for example), the method would appear not to be adapted at all.''~\cite[p.~211]{huart2004evaluation} \hilda{I wrote this myself but there might be a better justification from literature. I will look for it}
In the study of video games, the autoethnography method has been used to study game design elements that enhanced player motivation and engagement~\cite{rapp2017designing,rapp2017games}, shaped gendered experiences~\cite{nardi2010my}, and disrupted players in an AR game~\cite{laato2022balancing}. This method situates researchers as both the ``protagonist'' and observer and enables a first-person engagement and understanding of the game environment~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography}. Other studies have also used this method to study the cultural and social dynamics, such as in-game as well as out-of-the game love affairs~\cite{sunden2012desires}, collaborative play~\cite{nardi2006strangers}, gameplay learning with peers~\cite{nardi2007learning}, players' perception of cheating~\cite{boldi2023legit}, and the emergence of toxic in-game behaviour~\cite{kordyaka2023cycle}. However, to date, and to our knowledge, only one autoethnographic study has been conducted to investigate the impact of deceptive game design on players in computer-based games (i.e.,~\cite{karlsen2019exploited}).
Literature suggests that XR technology can employ deceptive designs that occur frequently or even constantly over extended periods, making them less noticeable to users~\cite{krauss2024what}, especially when XR devices are used constantly throughout people's daily lives~\cite{hadan2024deceived}. Therefore, we argue that autoethnography methodology can be an effective tool in analyzing such deceptive designs in VR games. This method allows researchers to actively engage with the game as players, gain first-hand experience with deceptive game designs players' frustrations and excitements, and systematically document their experiences over time~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography}.
%Therefore, we argue that analyzing user journeys over time becomes crucial for uncovering the subtle deceptive design in XR. We argue that autoethnography can be a useful tool in this aspect, as it allows researchers to actively engage with the game and systematically document their experiences over time periods. This approach enables researchers to ``precisely satisfy the need of gaining empathy with the user''~\cite[p.~33]{rapp2018autoethnography} by experiencing deceptive game design first-hand, gain a deeper understanding of players' emotions, frustrations, confusions, and excitements in a way that surveys or interviews cannot achieve.
In addition, autoethnography encourages critical self-reflection by requiring researchers to question their interpretations and challenge their assumptions~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography,adams2016handbook}. This introspective process enables nuanced examinations of deceptive game design. The unique combination of subjective player experience and critical researcher analysis makes autoethnography an ideal methodology for answering our research questions.
%our investigation of deceptive designs in VR games.
%``autoethnography requires that we observe ourselves observing, that we interrogate what we think and believe and that we challenge our own assumptions, asking over and over if we have penetrated as many layers of our own defenses, fears, and insecurities as our project requires.''~\cite[p.~10]{adams2016handbook}.
%``the ethnographer as the protagonist of the ethnographic narration, recounting the fieldwork from the fieldworker's point of view. the fieldworker exposes her intimate experiences to the reader and produces a version of reality painted from a first-person perspective, using self-observation as a starting point of reflection on the social and cultural, and then returns to the self and to the interpretations of what has been observed.''~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography}.
%\hilda{no more than half of page 4. (1.3 page length now, shouldn't be shorter)}
To investigate and contrast the manifestation of computer deceptive game design in commercially available VR games, we used an autoethnography methodology for data collection and a deductive reflexive thematic data analysis.
%\hilda{refer to the methodology of papers from CHI PLAY~\url{https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3544549.3582747}. \url{https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3544549.3585710}. \url{https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3491101.3519785}. \url{https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3491101.3503577}.\url{https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3411764.3445357}}
%\hilda{include the autoethnography study in \OW, make it a comparison between VR game deceptive design and PC game deceptive design. Talk about differences and similarities, and even same pattern in differeanalysis and produces different/same effects on players.}
%However, studying gameplay experiences unavoidably involves other players who can not meaningfully consent. In our preliminary investigation, we tackled this ethical issue by solely focusing on single player journey.
%Following the recommended privacy-preserving strategies from literature\hilda{[CITE]}, we excluded information from encountered players' profiles and any identifiable information shared in the chat (e.g., location, usernames, personal information, images, video and audio clips) in our analysis to ensure that we only analyzed information dedicated to particular design aspects of the games. While certain information and contexts may identify those in our descriptions, in the reporting of our results, we carefully reviewed and phrased the description of encounter players to avoid disclosing more information than necessary.
\subsection{Data Collection and Documentation}
\label{subsubsec:method-vr-game}
%To evaluate the problems within game design and to eliminate deception between players from our analysis, we deliberately selected the single player game \Moss, examined the single player mode of \BS, and focus on single player journey in \OW.
%for record: OW2 was 20 hours of 60 gameplay sessions for \OW over 6 days. \Moss was played at length and finished over nine days, totaling 8 hours of gameplay and 9 diary entries. \BS was played in single player mode over ten days with 18 hours of gameplay total, and generated nine diary entries.
The lead researcher with expertise in deceptive design, games, and VR played and was fully immersed in all three games. Through a game design mechanics analysis and an analysis of player experience from online communities~\cite{hhadan2024ow2},
%our prior research identified deceptive designs in \OW and their detrimental impacts on player experiences~\cite{hhadan2024ow2}. Expanding on this research in our autoethnography study,
the researcher played the games from a player's perspective and compiled six diary entries and video-recorded 20 hours of gameplay for \OW over six days until no new game design mechanics were observed and no new thoughts and perceptions emerged. Similarly, \Moss was played at length and finished over nine days, totaling eight hours of gameplay and nine diary entries. \BS was played in single-player mode over 10 days with 18 hours of gameplay total, and generated nine diary entries. All VR gameplay sessions were recorded using a Meta Quest3 headset screen-recording function. The 24 systematic diary entries were maintained on Miro\footnote{Miro---the Virtual Workspace for Innovation.~\url{https://miro.com/}} to document the gameplay experience and observations of potentially deceptive designs encountered, complemented by screenshots from video-recorded gameplay sessions. The diary entries and video recordings were then uploaded to Dovetail\footnote{Dovetail---Thematic Analysis Software.\url{https://dovetail.com/}} for thematic analysis. % (6 entries from \OW, 9 from \Moss, and 9 from \BS)
%calendar overview and sample diary entry
%\input{00-Figure01}
\subsection{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide Development}
\label{subsec:codebook-development}
%\hilda{refer to methodology of (https://doi.org/10.1145/3479521)}
To ensure consistency in our process of identifying deceptive design in VR games, we developed a \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide}, inspired by~\citet{gunawan2021comparative}'s deductive codebook method for comparing deceptive design in mobile and web-based applications. We adopted~\citet{gray2024ontology}'s ontology of deceptive designs as our starting point as it is the most recent and comprehensive framework at the time of our study grounded in the foundational literature in the field (e.g.,~\citet{Brignull2010deceptive,gray2018dark,mathur2021makes}). However, the ontology was not tailored to deceptive design in the VR context. Therefore, we augmented our analysis with additional frameworks that focus on VR and games from~\citet{hadan2024deceived},~\citet{king20233d}, and~\citet{zagal2013dark} due to their coverage in VR-specific~\cite{hadan2024deceived} and game-specific~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d} deceptive designs, and considerations for player perception in 3D interfaces~\cite{king20233d}.
%that are not well-integrated in~\citet{gray2024ontology}.
To minimize complexity where appropriate, we merged variances of deceptive designs that shared similarities in their definition and characteristics.
%based on examples provided in the source literature.
Overall, our \guide contained eight synthesized themes and 71 distinct deceptive design patterns, as summarized in~\autoref{tab:initial-codebook} in the Appendix.
\subsection{Data Analysis}
Given the autoethnography nature of the study, the lead researcher analyzed data using \textit{deductive reflective thematic analysis} method~\cite{clarke2021thematic}. The method preserves the personal and reflexive nature of the research~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography,fassl2023can,turner2022hard} while enabling a ``theoretically-informed exploration of qualitative data''~\cite[p.~260--263]{clarke2021thematic}. Prior studies have extensively used this method to analyze autoethnographic data (e.g.,~\cite{laato2022balancing,turner2022hard,fassl2023can}). To offer transparency in our findings and interpretations~\cite{rapp2018autoethnography}, we provide a \textit{Reflexivity Statement} in~\autoref{sec:app-reflexivity} that
%to critically acknowledge the potential biases from the lead researcher's cultural, education, and gaming background. %,
follows the recommendations for qualitative research~\cite{may2014reflexivity,saldana2021coding}.
%In April 2023,
In the early exploratory stage of our research, we reviewed our initial \OW diary entries.
%that were mainly non-structured.
We noticed trends repeatedly centred around the manifestations of deceptive game design and contexts in which they presented and the potential impacts on the game experience. To systematically organize the information hence forward, we subsequently segmented the diary entries into (1) descriptions of the lead researcher's experience, reactions, thoughts, and feelings upon encountering particular game elements, and (2) reflections on possible presence of deceptive game design and its context. An example diary entry for \Moss gameplay is included in~\autoref{sec:app-sample-diary}.
Our main analysis was conducted in
%April 2024 in
three stages. In the first stage, the lead researcher reviewed the data based on our \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} (see~\autoref{subsec:codebook-development}), with special attention to potential deceptive designs. In the second stage, the diary entries and screenshots from video gameplay recordings were deductively coded based on the \guide. We used an iterative coding process in which the analysis was constantly challenged and refined on the basis of the researcher's critical thoughts and expertise in deceptive design to interpret gameplay experiences. In the third stage, our research team collectively discussed the results to identify any potentially overlooked aspects of the data.
%We limited analysis to our initial codebook for this preliminary investigation, as our subjective autoethnography data may not be sufficient to justify entirely new design patterns without a larger player study (which we address in our next steps in~\autoref{subsec:future-work}).
In this WIP, we discuss the 15 patterns identified in \BS, and five patterns identified in \Moss, and contrast them with the 17 deceptive game design patterns identified in \OW (see~\autoref{tab:brief-codebook}). %These final codebooks reflect the deceptive game designs we identified from the selected games.
%\hilda{another reason we don't focus on multi-players modes in VR games is because the technology isn't there yet (check if this is true) for ``meaningful'' between player interactions in game. Although there's multi-player social applications, mostly are chaotic, and there's currently no games for this/analyzable state.}
%brief summary
\input{Table-briefCodeBook}
\subsection{Ethical Considerations and Limitations}
Our research followed the research ethics guidelines throughout our processes~\cite{tpcs2022}. Prior to conducting the autoethnographic diary data collection, we have consulted our institution's ethical review board (REB) and ensure that it is not subject to the ethical review process. While we decided to study single-player mode in \BS to avoid involving others without consent, for \OW that unavoidably needs the involvement of other players, we concentrated on the single-player journey and excluded information about other players in our analysis to maintain their privacy.
Our preliminary analysis did not examine deceptive game designs that rely on social relationships due to privacy and ethical considerations regarding other players.
%As an autoethnographic study, our findings are inherently subjective.
Although we transparently provided the lead researcher's background and its potential influence on our findings in our autoethnographic study through a reflexivity statement (see~\autoref{sec:app-reflexivity}), we acknowledge that our findings may not represent a broader player population with varied deceptive design literacy and perceptions~\cite{zagal2013dark,geronimo2020UI,luguri2021shining,frommel2022daily}. Our WIP results examined two VR games and a PC game, which may not cover all the deceptive design patterns across the modalities. However, we are confident that the autoethnographic approach allowed us to experience a wide variety of deceptive tactics present in VR games.
%he games we studied might have changed and deceptive game designs may no longer present. However, the negative player experiences were real and worth noting and avoiding in future game design. Overall, our preliminary investigation serves as a good starting point. In the next section, we discuss how we address these limitations in our next research steps.
%\hilda{no more than page 5 (1.5 pages) \textbf{}}
\begin{table*}[!t]
\caption{This table presents deceptive design patterns we identified in \textit{Overwatch2} (\OW)~\cite{hhadan2024ow2}, \BS (BS), and \textit{Moss Book: II} (\Moss). See~\autoref{sec:app-final-codebooks} for specific game mechanics associated with each deceptive pattern and corresponding synthesized diary entries.}
\label{tab:brief-codebook}
\resizebox{2\columnwidth}{!}{%
\begin{tabular}{@{}lllccc@{}}
\toprule
\textbf{\textit{Theme}/Subtheme} & \textbf{Code} & \textbf{Description} & \textbf{OW2} & \textbf{BS} & \textbf{Moss2} \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 1: Sneaking}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Hiding Information & Reference Pricing~\faGamepad & Include a price-inflated item or a poorer-quality item with same price, make a current price seem ideal. & \faCheckSquareO & - & -\\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 2: Obstruction}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Creating Barriers & Price Comparison Prevention & Hide information or block copying/pasting, make it difficult to compare prices across vendors. & - &\faCheckSquareO & -\\
& Intermediate Currencies~\faGamepad & Hide the real price behind a virtual currency, make informed purchase decisions difficult. & \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\ \midrule
%==========
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 3: Social Engineering}}} &\cellcolor{lightgray!50} &\cellcolor{lightgray!50} &\cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Social Proof & Parasocial Pressure & Exploit users’ trust in celebrities or other entities with inauthentic endorsements to influence decisions. & - & \faCheckSquareO& -\\
Urgency & Countdown Timers~\faGamepad & Create urgency with fake countdown timers. & \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\
& Limited Time Message~\faGamepad & Create urgency with fake limited-time offers. & - & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
& Fear of Missing Out (FOMO) & Exploit anxiety about missing exciting or valuable experiences. & \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\
Personalization & Social Obligation~\faGamepad & Create a sense of obligation to avoid letting down friends in the game or to return a favor. & \faCheckSquareO& - & - \\
& Competition~\faGamepad & Foster envy and competitions between players. &\faCheckSquareO &\faCheckSquareO & - \\ \midrule
%==========
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 4: Interface Interference}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Manipulating Choice Architecture & False Hierarchy~\faGamepad & Prioritize certain options, make it difficult to compare choices. & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
& Visual Prominence~\faGamepad & Highlight distracting elements, causing users to forget or lose focus on their initial intent. & - & \faCheckSquareO & -\\
& Bundling~\faGamepad & Group products at a ``special'' price and hide individual costs. & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
Emotional or Sensory Manipulation & Adorable Design~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop & Exploit user preference for adorable and appealing design, foster trust in NPCs* and obscure risks. & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO \\
& NPC/Narrative Manipulation~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop & Exploit self-satisfaction, sympathy, or reverse psychology to cause unintended actions. & - & - & \faCheckSquareO \\
& Trick Questions & Use confusing wording or double negatives to manipulate users' choices. & - & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
& Hidden Information & Obscure crucial details or disguising them as unimportant. & - & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO \\ \midrule
%==========
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 5: Distortion}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
& & & - & - & - \\ \midrule
%==========
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 6: Forced Action}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Forced Communication or Disclosure & Privacy Zuckering & Trick users into thinking it's essential for the service, lead to overshare personal data. & - & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
Gamification & Pay-to-play~\faGamepad & Restricts core functionalities or progress unless players pay to bypass limitations. & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
& Power Creep~\faGamepad & Diminish obtained item values over time to drive new purchase. & - & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
& Grinding~\faGamepad & Force users into repetitive tasks to access features. & \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\
& Can't Pause or Save~\faGamepad & Force users to continue playing before they can save progress. & - & - & \faCheckSquareO \\
& Playing by Appointment~\faGamepad & Force players to adhere to the game’s schedule. & \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\
Sunk Cost Fallacy & Endowed Value~\faGamepad & Trap users with their previous investment (time, money, effort). & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO & - \\
& Endowed Progress~\faGamepad & Exploit users' aversion to incompleted progression. & \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\
& Waste Aversion~\faGamepad & Set small differences between in-game currency and item costs, lead to additional currency purchases.& \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\ \midrule
%==========
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 7: Facilitation}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Infinite Treadmill~\faGamepad & & Continually expand the game (e.g., new levels, new content) so it never ends. & \faCheckSquareO & - & - \\ \midrule
%==========
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 8: Other}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Complete the Collection~\faGamepad & & Exploit users' desires of completing game item collections. & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO & \faCheckSquareO \\
\bottomrule
\multicolumn{6}{l}{*NPC = Non-Player Character. ~\faGamepad~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in the game-related literature~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d}.
~\faConnectdevelop~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in VR-related literature~\cite{hadan2024deceived}.}\\
\end{tabular}%
}
\end{table*}
This section presents our preliminary findings of deceptive designs in \Moss and \BS, and contrasts their manifestations in VR with the PC game \OW. For clarity, in the following sections, we denote game mechanics in monospace font (e.g.,~\mechanics{Song Gallery}), use \textit{italics} text for deceptive design (e.g.,~\codestyle{Bundling}) and use quoted italics text for the in-game descriptions. We present patterns identified from three games in~\autoref{tab:brief-codebook} and provide descriptions of specific game mechanics from VR games in~\autoref{tab:VR-finalcodebook} and \OW in~\autoref{tab:OW2-finalcodebook} in Appendix with synthesized diary entries.
%=========
%Moss game screenshots for emotional and sensory manipulation
\input{01-Figure02}
\subsection{RQ1: What deceptive design patterns are currently implemented in commercial VR games?}
%=========
%\subsubsection{similar deceptive design}
We found that \Moss and \BS shared similarities in deceptive design patterns (see~\autoref{tab:brief-codebook}). Both games used emotional and sensory manipulation (e.g., \codestyle{Adorable Design}) with lovable character designs, eye-catching visuals, and vibrant map environments to create a strong emotional attachment to the game world, potentially leading to longer play sessions and in-game purchases that players may not have otherwise considered. Both games also used \codestyle{Hidden Information} tactics through the fully immersive nature of VR and intense and deeply engaging gameplay. In \BS, the absence of a progress bar could be frustrating for players, as they have to replay the entire song after failing and cannot locate specific parts they fail. The intensity of gameplay could lead to players lose track of time and unintentionally extend the duration of play. In \Moss a progress indicator (\mechanics{Stained Glass Windows}) is subtly integrated into the background map environment. This could cause players to completely miss its existence. As a result, players can feel lost in the engaging storyline and interactive gameplay, and continuously play without a sense of progress. Moreover, \BS and \Moss use \codestyle{Complete the Collection} to fuel players' desire for completion. For instance, in \BS, acquiring all songs in the player's favourite music packs could lead to unintentional overspending of money. Similarly, \Moss has collectible scrolls and character-enhancing armors. While the process of discovering these items
%behind tall grass and breakable jars
by repeatedly revisiting completed maps can produce a sense of achievement and a thorough game experience, it could also lead to extensive playtime beyond what is necessary to enjoy the core game.
%=========
%\subsubsection{different deceptive design}
Beyond game-specific deceptive designs, we found that \BS's \mechanics{Song Purchase System} incorporated \codestyle{Price Comparison Prevention} that inhibits players from comparing the prices of songs and music packs, \codestyle{Limited Time Message} and \codestyle{Bundling} that encourage impulse purchases, \codestyle{Visual Prominence} that attracts players' attention to \textit{``buy music pack''} entirely instead of buying an individual song, and \codestyle{Privacy Zuckering} that requires players' payment information before displaying songs' and music packs' prices. On the other hand, \Moss has largely used deceptive game design patterns that encourage extended playtime and emotional investment from players, including \codestyle{NPC/Narrative Manipulation} that attracts players with its VR-unique interactive elements, such as allowing players to \textit{``pet,''} \textit{``hug,''} \textit{``high-five''} with main characters (see~\autoref{fig:screenshots}) and protect them in battles. While VR technology's limitations prevent a truly tactile experience, the animation of \textit{``hugging''} the player's controller pointers effectively conveys the warmth and gratitude. The main character's sign language communication added another layer of emotional bond and make players feel like they are a part of the adventure and not just outside observers.
%During boss fights, players can support the character by pulling enemy insects away from her, making them feel even more involved.
Interestingly, while \Moss incorporated \codestyle{Can't Pause or Save} tactic to keep players continuously play until designated save points, this tactic clashed with the limited VR headset battery life and can frustrate players with significant loss of progress due to a dead battery.
%Overall, our preliminary results show that VR's full immersive and interactive nature can foster a strong emotional attachment and lead to extended playtime and unplanned purchases. \hilda{I didn't say "more effective manipulation" because that's the conclusion of next subsection.}
We include the detailed descriptions of patterns identified from VR games, with synthesized diary entries, in Appendix~\autoref{tab:VR-finalcodebook}.
%=========
\subsection{RQ2: How do deceptive game designs vary in their manifestations in VR games and PC games?}
\label{subsec:RQ2}
%=========
%A key difference between traditional computer games and games in VR is the player's interaction with the game world. In computer-based games, players are restricted to interacting through an intermediary device (e.g., keyboard, mouse, controller) and remain physically separate from the game environment. On the other hand, VR games create a fully immersive experience. In VR, players wear a headset that covers them in a computer-generated world which replaces the sights and sounds of their physical surroundings. They can explore and interact with this virtual world using their own physical movements and body language, which fosters a deeper sense of presence and connection. These differences between VR and computer games has influenced the manifestation of deceptive game designs.
%==========
%varied across modality
As demonstrated in~\autoref{tab:brief-codebook}, while \OW, \BS, and \Moss all incorporated \codestyle{Adorable Design} and \codestyle{Complete the Collection}, these deceptive design patterns in \OW (e.g., skins with special visual effects, cute weapon decorations) are restricted to the 2D screen. Players interact with them using a mouse, keyboard, or controller, resulting in a clear separation between the player and the game world. On the other hand, \BS and \Moss enable a more dynamic and immersive interaction with VR-unique features. For instance, in \Moss, the VR controllers provide haptic feedback which, coupled with spatial 3D visuals, creates a deeper sense of engagement. The VR environment also allows players to physically lean forward and peer around corners or behind walls to search for strategic paths for the characters. The game also offers a more engaging way of discovering collectibles compared to collecting badges and achievement messages on \OW's 2D interfaces. While \BS places the player in a first-person perspective similar to \OW, unlike the static screen of \OW, players in \BS have a full 360-degree game environment. Players need to not only slash the target blocks but also physically move their body, arms, and legs to avoid virtual obstacles and turn around to reach blocks from different directions (see~\autoref{fig:screenshots}). This full body involvement, combined with the first-person perspective, creates a deeper sense of presence and engaging experience that traditional 2D games cannot easily replicate.
%===========
%no variation across modality
However, many deceptive design patterns embedded in the game mechanics also have no difference between VR and traditional PC games. For example, both \OW and \BS used \codestyle{Limited Time Message}, \codestyle{Countdown Timer}, \codestyle{Bundling}, and \codestyle{Pay-to-play}, and \codestyle{Competition}. The commonalities are because many deceptive design patterns remain heavily reliant on 2D interfaces even within VR's 3D environments, and therefore, have no significant variations across modalities.
Lastly, while \BS and \Moss used \codestyle{NPC/Narrative Manipulation}, \codestyle{Trick Questions}, and \codestyle{Power Creep} and \codestyle{Can't Pause or Save} that did not exist in \OW, we believe it is due to differences in game genre rather than the game platform. We include a detailed descriptions of patterns identified from \OW, with synthesized diary entries, in~\autoref{tab:OW2-finalcodebook} in~\autoref{sec:app-final-codebooks}.
%=========
%\subsubsection{Modality-unique deceptive game designs}
%\hilda{moved to future research}
%We also found many VR-unique deceptive game designs in \Moss, and \BS that relies on the uniqueness of immersion and 3D interactions. For example,
%We further identified many deceptive game designs have lost their impact on players after being implemented in VR. For example,
%\hilda{no more than page 7 (2 pages)}
\begin{figure*}[!t]
\centering
%\begin{minipage}{0.33\textwidth}
%\centering
% left figure itself
%\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{Moss-Screenshot01.pdf}
%\end{minipage}\hfill
\begin{minipage}{0.33\textwidth}
\centering
% middle figure itself
\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{Moss-Screenshot02-labelled.pdf}
\end{minipage} \hfill
\begin{minipage}{0.33\textwidth}
\centering
% right figure itself
\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{BS-Screenshot01-labelled.pdf}
\end{minipage} \hfill
\begin{minipage}{0.33\textwidth}
\centering
% right figure itself
\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{OW2-Screenshot02.pdf}
\end{minipage}
\caption{%(1) the gameplay moment in \Moss when Quill (main character) cries while holding the lifeless body of her beloved uncle Argus. Her hand outreaches directly towards the player for help;
Left: sample gameplay moment in \Moss, a VR puzzle adventure game where players guide a tiny mouse character through a fantastical world. Quill, the main character, gives the player a full-body hug, with her tiny arms wrapped tightly around the controller pointers. Center: sample gameplay moment in \BS, a VR rhythm-based block-slashing game, when players are required to physically move left, right or squat down to avoid oncoming obstacles (semi-transparent walls). Right: sample gameplay moment in \OW, a first-person team-based shooter game, when players is using ability to heal (restore) the health of allies at the front by holding down the right-click on mouse.}
\Description{Left: sample gameplay moment in \Moss, a VR puzzle adventure game where players guide a tiny mouse character through a fantastical world. Quill, the main character, gives the player a full-body hug, with her tiny arms wrapped tightly around the controller pointers. Center: sample gameplay moment in \BS, a VR rhythm-based block-slashing game, when players are required to physically move left, right or squat down to avoid oncoming obstacles (semi-transparent walls). Right: sample gameplay moment in \OW, a first-person team-based shooter game, when players is using ability to heal (restore) the health of allies at the front by holding down the right-click on mouse.}
\label{fig:screenshots}
\end{figure*}
%Implications for deceptive game design and VR researchers, VR game designers, and policymakers.
%=============
% implication of our comprehensive codebook
Although our research is ongoing, we made significant progress in developing a \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} tailored to evaluating deceptive design in VR games by synthesizing previous work~\cite{gray2024ontology,king20233d,zagal2013dark,hadan2024deceived}. Our preliminary \guide can serve as a structured foundation for future research and VR design to identify new deceptive practices, analyze player impact, and develop ethical VR game design guidelines. Specifically, researchers can use this \guide to identify new deceptive practices, analyze their impact on players, and develop ethical design guidelines for VR games. VR developers can better understand the different categories of deceptive design and impacts on VR players, create more ethical and player-centric VR experiences, and avoid those causing player frustration, confusion, and pressure in their design. The \guide can also inform regulations or guidelines that promote responsible VR design practices to ensure VR player protection from potentially manipulative tactics in games.
%implication of our diary analysis
Our results highlight that the negative effects of some VR deceptive game design patterns like \codestyle{Can't Pause or Save} that force players to engage continuously have only been limited due to hardware constraints of the technology like battery life. VR intensifies player engagement and immersion, and therefore, have the potential to amplify the impacts of deceptive game designs that capitalize on players' emotional and sensory desires (e.g., \codestyle{Adorable Design}, \codestyle{Competition}, and \codestyle{Complete the Collection}). Their existence cautions against the potential for more sophisticated player manipulations in future games. For instance, we can easily foresee that future VR games with \codestyle{Adorable Design} and \codestyle{NPC/Narrative Manipulation} could be extended to NPC conversations that are framed with NPC's inveterate longing~\cite{bogost2010persuasive} to pressure players into in-game purchases (like in~\cite{king20233d}), longer playtime, or guilt-trip players. Such emotional and sensory manipulations can cause greater harm to players compared to those in PC games. Similarly, games like \BS could use \codestyle{Perception Hacking} to trick players restart repetitively by causing unintentional slash on the wrong blocks, or secretly inflating the price of songs in-game with \codestyle{Price Comparison Prevention} by taking advantage that players may not bother to take off headset to look up the price on the website (barrier between virtual and reality~\cite{krauss2024what}). While we found that many deceptive design patterns, such as \codestyle{Pay-to-play} and \codestyle{Countdown Timer}, remain heavily reliant on 2D interfaces, they have the potential to evolve into 3D formats. For instance, \codestyle{Pay-to-play} in VR games could appear as virtual tollbooths at level entrances, while \codestyle{Countdown Timer} might be represented through NPCs' increasingly agitated or aggressive conversations as time runs out. These problems will arise in the near future with more games emerge in VR. Our preliminary findings in this WIP highlight the critical need for ongoing research in deceptive game design in VR to keep up with the rapid evolution of VR technology. %Our early findings in this WIP aim to spark crucial discussions and inform the ongoing development of ethical VR design guidelines.
%\hilda{the highlight is to re review: the Discussion section may benefit from some reflection on whether some of 2D patterns have potential to evolve to 3D (for example, pay-to-play taking the form of a virtual tollbooth at the entrance to a level).}
%\subsection{Next Steps}
%\label{subsec:future-work}
%=================
% for codebook
%\hilda{the first highlight is to re review: \textit{As a suggestion, I believe comparing VR and PC games from similar genres and similar monetization strategies may better isolate VR manifestations of deceptive designs. If possible, I think the authors may consider comparing the same game's PC and VR versions, and investigate whether the game developed enhanced the same deceptive design with VR features.}}
\textbf{Next Steps:} Building upon our preliminary findings, our first and the immediate next step is to refine and improve the comprehensiveness of the \guide by incorporating a broader scope of literature (e.g.,~\cite{krauss2024what,petrovskaya2021predatory}) and clearer considerations of VR-specific properties (e.g., spatiality, perception, and barriers~\cite{krauss2024what}) that directly influence player deception in VR. Second, our research on deceptive VR game design is still ongoing. As we write this paper, we are expanding our analysis of VR games from diverse genres, which allows us to analyze the VR manifestations of deceptive designs that were not present in our \wip (e.g., \codestyle{Wait To Play}, \codestyle{Grinding}). This will also enable us to contrast and isolate the manifestations of different types of deceptive designs in games from similar genres, or even the same game, across PC and VR, which will result in more meaningful comparisons. Lastly, to complement our autoethnographic methodology, we plan to study VR players' perspectives by analyzing player reviews in online communities and conducting in-depth interviews. We will contrast these player experiences with the findings from our autoethnographic investigation to achieve a comprehensive understanding of how deceptive designs are perceived and experienced. For example, we will closely examine the influence of VR-specific features~\cite{krauss2024what,hadan2024deceived} on player experiences, the perceived severity of various deceptive designs, and how different manifestations shape player perceptions. We hypothesize that certain VR deceptive designs, when combined with other game elements or with different manifestations, may be perceived positively in one game while being viewed as manipulative in another.
%\hilda{the second highlight is to re review: \textit{I think it is worth discussing the severity of different deceptive game design types. For example, although "adorable design" may contribute to excessive gaming time, good aesthetics also have positive mental effects.} Also review: \textit{it is recommended that this be clarified to assert whether that research will continue the autoethnographic approach or instead take the form of user studies with volunteer participants.}}
In summary, our findings highlighted the critical need for future research in deceptive game designs in VR. Combining findings from our preliminary study and next research steps, our research will enable an understanding of deceptive design manifestations between VR and traditional games, identify how VR's unique features influence the effectiveness of these tactics, and reveal VR-specific deceptions not present in traditional games.
%In the following sections, we will detail limitations in this preliminary investigation and how they are addressed in our plan for these next steps, and outline how we will expand our analysis of VR games and explore player and developer perspectives.
%Combining findings from our preliminary autoethnographic study and next research steps, our ultimate goal is to build a comprehensive list of deceptive VR game designs with consideration of VR players and the game designers' perspectives. This comprehensive list will allow us to thoroughly understand and compare deceptive design manifestations between VR and traditional games, identify how VR's unique features influence the effectiveness of these tactics, and reveal VR-specific deceptions not present in traditional games.
%- we will identify potential player manipulation from the VR platform, not necessarily related to the games but could present in other VR applications. For example,
%- some games have their own website, which consists of deceptive design. For example, on beat saber website, music pack are arranged on top of list and if you prefer to buy individual songs you will have to click through a few packages.
%https://www.meta.com/experiences/pcvr/beat-saber/1304877726278670/?utm_source=beatsaber.com&utm_medium=oculusredirect
%This is a false hierarchy to encourage purchase of more music packs. However, we do not discuss those in our current study. We only focus on those in the game. Another example is that both VR games we selected were top-rated on VR Gaming Reddit, potentially serving as ``Endorsements and Testimonials'' outside of the game itself.
%As with any methodological choice, autoethnography come with limitations. The primary one is a lack of generality. Since all results stem from one person’s experience, it is difficult to claim that they generalize. However, as~\citet{clarke2013successful} explain, strict generalizability is usually not a meaningful goal in qualitative research. Instead, they advocate for a more flexible 'transferability' approach that leaves it to the readers to identify how the results apply to similar kinds of situations and people. To improve the transferability of this work, we provided a detailed description of the lead researcher’s background in Appendix and the circumstances and context of each interaction in as much detail as possible without compromising others’ identities. Depending on the context, identified issues transfer to non-experts, albeit in a more severe manner. Put simply, when deceptive game design pose a problem to experts we can not expect laypeople to do much better, regardless of user education and motivation. The lack of generality seems acceptable in order to surface issues that may affect users who are attentive to the need for authentication. The second limitation is how the research affects the described behavior and experience. In an autoethnography, the researcher and participant are the same, making it hard to delineate naturally occurring behavior from research-influenced behavior. However, to some extent, this is a common issue with many research approaches, e.g., the artificial scenarios in lab studies affect participant behavior and certain interview questions or environments will influence responses to some degree. To mitigate the effects of this issue, this work transparently communicates the ways in which the research approach may have influenced the reported results.
%First, we acknowledge that people's experience may vary depending on their literacy regarding manipulation, familiarity and attachment towards the game, (and other factors). Thus our findings should not be directly construed as deceptive design because the effectiveness and impact of these patterns vary based on players' perceptions. However, our study laid the foundation that uncovers the potential problems that could influence the players and thus should be taken into account in the future.
%Second, our data in the three games were collected in 2023 and early 2024, we note that the game design can change frequently, deceptive patterns may be removed, replaced, and even evolved over time. Thus, what existed during the period of our data analysis might not exist right now. However, we note that players suffer and their being being manipulated and any associated consequences (e.g., time spent, monetary lost, and cognitive burden) was true and therefore worth noting and avoid in future game design.
%\hilda{no more than page 8 (1 page)}
This project has been funded by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC); the views expressed herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of the OPC.
L. Nacke also acknowledge support from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC) INSIGHT Grant (\#435-2022-0476), Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) Discovery Grant (\#RGPIN-2023-03705), and Canada Foundation for Innovation (CFI) John R. Evans Leaders Fund (\#41844) and L. Zhang-Kennedy also acknowledge support from the NSERC Discovery Grant (\#RGPIN-2022-03353)
We also thank the chairs and reviewers for their insightful feedback, which helped us to improve the quality of this manuscript. Thank you to graduate researcher Derrick Wang for his support in resolving technical issues during our paper formatting. Screenshots in this manuscript were from the games and fall under fair use.
%The research was supported by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) Discovery Grant (\#RGPIN-2022-03353 and \#RGPIN-2023-03705), the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC) Insight Grant (\#435-2022-0476), the Canada Foundation for Innovation (CFI) JELF Grant (\#41844). Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the NSERC, SSHRC, the CFI, nor the University of Waterloo.
%========
\onecolumn
\newpage
%\section{Framework That Informed Our Classification of Deceptive Designs}
%\label{sec:app-reference-frameworks}
%initial codebook from gray (barely touched on games) and zagal's (game dedicated) frameworks
\input{Table-InitialCodebook-part1}
\input{Table-InitialCodebook-part2}
\input{Table-InitialCodebook-part3}
%=====
%\input{Table-Backups/Table-InitialCodebook-backup} %full table, in the "table-backups" folder
%========
\clearpage % do not touch or section sequence will be messed up
\newpage
\section{Sample Diary Entry Structure}
\label{sec:app-sample-diary}
%\begin{figure}[!h]
% \centering
%\includegraphics[angle=90,origin=c,width=0.85\textwidth]{SampleArtefact.pdf}
%\caption{A sample diary entry of a \Moss gameplay session dated February 1, 2024. The diary was documented on Miro given its feasibility of linking videos and screenshots and diary texts. From left to right: (1) description of the lead researcher's experience, reactions, thoughts, and feelings complemented by corresponding screenshots of game design elements, and (2) post-gameplay reflection on possible presence of deceptive game design and its context. }
%\label{fig:diary}
%\end{figure}
%either the figure version above, or the table version here.
\input{Table-DiaryMockup}
%========
\twocolumn
\clearpage
\newpage
\section{Reflexivity Statement}
\label{sec:app-reflexivity}
%\hilda{I looked at a CHI privacy and security paper used autoethnography diary approach (10.1145/3544548.3581508) that had a detailed reflexivity statement so I wanted to follow their structure.}
To ensure the rigour of our qualitative research, we follow the recommendations by~\citet{may2014reflexivity} and~\citet{saldana2021coding} by providing a \textit{Reflexivity Statement}. In this statement, we acknowledge the potential biases that may arise during the data coding and theme development process due to the lead researcher's cultural, education, and gaming background. The reflexive thematic analysis was performed by the lead researcher, who has a strong research background in deceptive design and has previously published on the topic in both Extended Reality (including VR) and traditional PC-based games~\cite{hadan2024deceived,hhadan2024ow2,hadan2024pop}. The lead researcher also has several years of experience researching privacy and security issues from the user's perspective. This interdisciplinary background and experience align well with this reflexive method, as it identifying deceptive game designs and potential concerns from players' perspectives. In addition, our research team also offers diverse expertise such as interaction design, user experience, privacy and cybersecurity, and games user research. This collective expertise strengthens the comprehensiveness and quality of our research.
%While games are social in nature, since our study only focused on single player journey, we believe the lead researcher's social demeanor is thus not directly relevant to the analysis in this study. Thus, we do not describe it here.
Our autoethnography methodology puts the lead researcher into a player perspective. While the lead researcher's expertise and extensive experience in deceptive design ensured a rich identification of these patterns in the game, we still note that her personality might have influenced the focus and the interpretation of autoethnographic data. The lead researcher, as a player, identified herself as empathetic and sensitive and tend to be caring and compassionate. This personality allowed for picking up on subtle emotional manipulation and patterns that exploit players' attachment to in-game characters. In addition, the lead researcher has a strong focus on observable facts and more straightforward outcomes based on concrete evidence. While this personality might have limited the lead researcher's interpretation of hypothetical future consequences of deceptive design, her expertise enabled a thorough understanding of player manipulation currently in the games.
We also note that the lead researcher's personal experience with video games has influenced this research. The lead researcher was introduced to video games at a young age. This early experience includes a wide range of North American and Asian titles across different genres, played on both computer and PlayStation platforms. In 2017, the lead researcher was introduced to \textit{Overwatch}, which enabled a reunion between her family members during the COVID-19 pandemic, until Blizzard shut down the server in China in 2023~\cite{ign_2024}. To date, the lead researcher has played \textit{Overwatch} (both \textit{OW1} and \textit{OW2}) for about 7 years, more than 3,000 hours of gameplay in different game modes and characters. This experience, combined with the lead researcher's extensive exposure and experience with other games, fosters a deep understanding of player perspectives and various game design patterns.
In summary, the lead researcher's background presents a valuable resource to our autoethnographic research, as it allows us to have a nuanced documentation and analysis of potential deceptive game elements. While we acknowledge that the lead researcher's personality and personal connection to \OW could influence our research findings, we see this as a strength. This deep familiarity with the game equips the lead researcher with a nuanced understanding of its strengths and weaknesses, which enabled a more comprehensive analysis.
%========
\onecolumn
\newpage
\section{Deceptive Game Design Patterns Identified from Overwatch2 and VR Games}
\label{sec:app-final-codebooks}
\input{Table-OW2-FinalCodebook}
\input{Table-VR-FinalCodebook}
\clearpage
\begin{table}[!ht]
\centering
\caption{This table presents our \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} and the source literature of themes and codes~\cite{gray2024ontology,zagal2013dark,king20233d,hadan2024deceived}. This \guide served as the foundation of our identification of deceptive designs in the selected VR-based and computer-based games.}
\label{tab:initial-codebook}
\resizebox{0.73\textheight}{!}{%
\begin{sideways}
\begin{tabular}{@{}llll@{}}
\toprule
\textbf{\textit{Theme}/Subtheme} & \textbf{Code} & \textbf{Definition} & \textbf{Correspondence to Taxonomies from Literature} \\ \midrule
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 1: Sneaking}}} & &\\
Bait and Switch& Disguised Ads & ~\deficon~Disguise ads as genuine content, trick users into clicking on it. & ~\coricon~Disguised Ads~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\ \midrule
Hiding Information & Sneak into Basket & ~\deficon~Sneak items into a user's cart, lead to unintended purchases. & ~\coricon~Sneak into Basket~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& Drip Pricing, Hidden Costs, or Partitioned Pricing & ~\deficon~Gradually reveal additional costs, delaying the full price until & ~\coricon~Drip Pricing, Hidden Costs, or Partitioned \\
& & after effort is invested in the purchase process.& Pricing~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& Reference Pricing~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Include a price-inflated item or a poorer-quality item with same & ~\coricon~Reference Pricing~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Cheap Item Placed Next to \\
& & price, making a current price seem like a better deal. & Expensive Item~\cite{king20233d}, Physical Placement of Items~\cite{king20233d}, \\
& & & Anchoring Tricks (Anchoring, Decoy Effect)~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\ \midrule
Perception Hacking~\faConnectdevelop &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Alter visuals or display out-of-sight ads, causing unwanted & ~\coricon~Perception Hacking~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Obscuring Reality~\cite{hadan2024deceived}\\
& & and unintentional interaction with objects (e.g., ads) & \\ \midrule
(De)contextualizing Cues & Conflicting Information & ~\deficon~Confuse users by presenting contradictory details, making & ~\coricon~Conflicting Information~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & them unsure and likely to accept potentially unfavorable defaults. & \\
& Information without context & ~\deficon~Hide relevant information or controls, making it difficult for & ~\coricon~Information without context~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & users to find what they need. & \\ \midrule
%=======
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 2: Obstruction}}} & &\\
Roach Motel& Immortal Accounts & ~\deficon~Trap users by making account deletion difficult or impossible. & ~\coricon~Immortal Accounts~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& Dead Ends & ~\deficon~Frustrate users by hiding information behind broken links or & ~\coricon~Dead Ends~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & redirects, preventing them from finding desired information. & \\ \midrule
Creating Barriers & Price Comparison Prevention & ~\deficon~Hide information or block copying/pasting, making it difficult & ~\coricon~Price Comparison Prevention~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & to compare prices across vendors. & \\
& Intermediate Currencies~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Hide the real price behind a virtual currency, making informed & ~\coricon~Intermediate Currencies~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Use of Multiple \\
& & purchase decisions difficult. & Currencies~\cite{king20233d}, Premium Currency~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\ \midrule
Adding Steps & Privacy Mazes & ~\deficon~Bury privacy controls under layers of confusing menus, & ~\coricon~Privacy Mazes~\cite{gray2024ontology}\\
& & hindering users from making informed choices. & \\ \midrule
Reality Distortion~\faConnectdevelop &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Conceal parts of reality with digital objects, through & ~\coricon~Reality Distortion~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Obscuring Reality~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, \\
& & daily wear and photorealistic graphics, leading to false perception & Persistent Exposure to Manipulation~\cite{hadan2024deceived}\\
& & and change of behaviours. & \\ \midrule
%=======
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 3: Social Engineering}}} & &\\
Scarcity or Popularity Claims & High Demand~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Create a false sense of urgency by exaggerating product & ~\coricon~Anchoring Tricks (item popularity)~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& & popularity, tricking users into rushed purchases. & ~\coricon~High Demand~\cite{gray2024ontology}\\ \midrule
Social Proof & Low Stock~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Pressure users into impulsive purchases by falsely indicating & ~\coricon~Low Stock~\cite{gray2024ontology},Artificial Scarcity (only a certain \\
& & limited product availability. & number of items available)~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Endorsements and Testimonials & ~\deficon~Portray biased or fabricated testimonials as genuine to & ~\coricon~Endorsements and Testimonials~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Friend Spam /\\
& & influence users' purchase decisions. & Impersonation (friends follow your endorsement)~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& Parasocial Pressure~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop & ~\deficon~Exploit users' trust in celebrities or other entities with & ~\coricon~Parasocial Pressure~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Anchoring Tricks (friends' \\
& & inauthentic endorsements to influence users' decisions. & purchase activities)~\cite{zagal2013dark}, NPC Asks or Suggests a \\
& & & Purchase~\cite{king20233d}, Hyperpersonalization (recreations of \\
& & & their trusted people)~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Instructed/Told \\
& & & to Do~\cite{king20233d} \\ \midrule
Urgency & Activity Messages & ~\deficon~Create urgency with fake activity notifications of others. & ~\coricon~Activity Messages~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& Countdown Timers~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~create urgency with fake countdown timers. & ~\coricon~Countdown Timers~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Artificial Scarcity~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& Limited Time Messages~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Create urgency with fake limited-time offers. & ~\coricon~Limited Time Messages~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Artificial Scarcity~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Exploit anxiety about missing exciting or valuable experiences. & ~\coricon~Fear of Missing Out~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d}\\ \midrule
Personalization &Confirmshaming & ~\deficon~Guilt-trip users with manipulative language.& ~\coricon~Confirmshaming~\cite{gray2024ontology}\\
& Social Obligation~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Create a sense of obligation to avoid letting down friends in the & ~\coricon~Aesthetic Manipulations (feel bad for not helping \\
& & game or to return a favor. & team)~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Social Obligation / Guilds~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Players \\
& & & Feels Ashamed/Guilty~\cite{king20233d}, Reciprocity~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Competition~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Foster envy and competitions between players. & ~\coricon~Competition~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\ \midrule
Encourage Anti-Social Behavior~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Incentivize users' dishonest or harmful actions to gain benefits. & ~\coricon~Encourages Anti-Social Behavior~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
\bottomrule
\multicolumn{4}{l}{\textit{Note.} ~\faGamepad~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in the game-related literature~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d}.
~\faConnectdevelop~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in VR-related literature~\cite{hadan2024deceived}.}\\
\end{tabular}%
\end{sideways}
}
\end{table}
\clearpage
\begin{table}[!ht]
\centering
\caption*{Table 2 Continued. This table presents our \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} and the source literature of themes and codes~\cite{gray2024ontology,zagal2013dark,king20233d,hadan2024deceived}. This \guide served as the foundation of our identification of deceptive designs in the selected VR-based and computer-based games.}
\label{tab:initial-codebook-part2}
\resizebox{0.73\textheight}{!}{%
\begin{sideways}
\begin{tabular}{@{}llll@{}}
\toprule
\textbf{\textit{Theme}/Subtheme} & \textbf{Code} & \textbf{Definition} & \textbf{Correspondence to Taxonomies from Literature} \\ \midrule
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 4: Interface Interference}}} & &\\
Manipulating Choice Architecture & False Hierarchy~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Prioritize certain options, making it difficult to compare choices & ~\coricon~False Hierarchy~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Anchoring Tricks (False \\
& & and potentially leading to unintended selections. & Hierarchy)~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Aesthetic Manipulations (bigger \\
& & & checkbox)~\cite{zagal2013dark}, ``Premium Value'' or ``Rare'' Items~\cite{king20233d} \\
& Visual Prominence~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Highlight distracting elements, causing users to forget or lose & ~\coricon~Visual Prominence~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Exciting Sound Effect~\cite{king20233d}, \\
& & focus on their initial intent. & Aesthetic Manipulations (red ``yes'' button)~\cite{zagal2013dark},\\
& & & UI Colours/Animation~\cite{king20233d} \\
& Bundling~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Group products at a ``special'' price, potentially hiding individual & ~\coricon~Anchoring Tricks (Discount Bundles)~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& & costs and leading to uninformed purchases. & Bundling~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Bulk-buy Discount~\cite{king20233d} \\
& Pressured Selling & ~\deficon~Highlight or pre-select expensive options, potentially leading & ~\coricon~Pressured Selling~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & users to overlook more affordable choices.&\\ \midrule
Bad Defaults~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Set default options that benefit the company, forcing users to & ~\coricon~Bad Defaults~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Accidental Purchase (expensive \\
& & manually change settings to avoid privacy risks. & ones selected by default)~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Aesthetic Manipulations \\
& & & (checkbox opt-in by default)~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\ \midrule
Misclick~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Exploit strategic button placement and absence of confirmation & ~\coricon~Obscuring Reality~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Perception Hacking (offset\\
& & screen, leading to accidental actions. & visual cue in cursor-jacking)~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Accidental Purchase \\
& & & (accidental stray tap of the screen)~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\ \midrule
Emotional or Sensory Manipulation & Adorable design~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop & ~\deficon~Exploit user preference for adorable design to make the game & ~\coricon~Cuteness~\cite{gray2024ontology}, NPC is cute or very likeable~\cite{king20233d}, \\
& & appealing, fostering trust in characters, and obscuring risks. & Hyperpersonalization (content tailored to preference\\
& & & of an individual)~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Aesthetic Manipulations\\
& & & (Subconscious Associations)~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& Positive or Negative Framing~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Hide or downplaying crucial information through visual cues, & ~\coricon~Positive or Negative Framing~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Users Images\\
& & leading to biased or distracted decisions. & Associated with Wealth~\cite{king20233d}, Aesthetic Manipulations \\
& & & (Toy with Emotions)~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& NPC/Narrative Manipulation*~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop & ~\deficon~Exploit self-satisfaction, sympathy, or reverse psychology to & ~\coricon~Players Feel Good for Helping NPC~\cite{king20233d}, Sympathy/\\
& & cause unintended actions. & pity for NPC~\cite{king20233d}, Want to Prove NPC Wrong (to \\
& & & counter NPC's taunt)~\cite{king20233d}, Hyperpersonalization \\
& & & (idealized interaction partners)~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Artificial \\
& & & Prosthetic Memory/Empathy-Based Manipulation~\cite{hadan2024deceived}\\
& General Emotional Manipulation~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Non-specific descriptions of emotional manipulation. & ~\coricon~General Emotional Manipulation~\cite{king20233d}\\ \midrule
Trick Questions &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Use confusing wording or double negatives to manipulate users' & ~\coricon~Trick Questions~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & choices. & \\ \midrule
Choice Overload &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Overwhelm users with too many options, hindering comparison & ~\coricon~Choice Overload~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & and potentially causing them to miss important information. & \\
Hidden Information &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Obscure crucial details or disguising them as unimportant. & ~\coricon~Hidden Information~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\ \midrule
Language Inaccessibility & Wrong Language & ~\deficon~Display crucial information in a foreign language, making it & ~\coricon~Wrong Language~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & inaccessible to users. & \\
& Complex Language & ~\deficon~Use hard-to-understand words and sentence structures, & ~\coricon~Complex Language~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & hindering users' informed decisions. & \\ \midrule
Feedforward Ambiguity &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Create a gap between users' predicted result from the available & ~\coricon~Feedforward Ambiguity~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & information and the actual outcome of their actions. & \\ \midrule
%=====
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 5: Distortion}}} & &\\
Cognitive Bias & Illusion of Mastery~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Deceive players about their skill level, making them feel better & ~\coricon~Illusion of Control (e.g., manipulated matchups,\\
& & than they actually are and encouraging more gameplay. & undisclosed random win chance)~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Optimism and Frequency Biases~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Exploit optimism bias, frequency bias, and clustering illusion to &~\coricon~Optimism and Frequency Biases~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& & make players feel luckier and skilled, encouraging continued play. & \\
& False Memory Implantation~\faConnectdevelop & ~\deficon~Exploit users' memory flaw and source confusing to induce false & ~\coricon~False Memory Implantation~\cite{hadan2024deceived} \\
& & memory and influence their behaviour. & \\
& The illusion of objectivity~\faConnectdevelop & ~\deficon~First-person experiences inherently biased by creator influence, & ~\coricon~The illusion of objectivity in XR experience~\cite{hadan2024deceived}\\
& & creating a false sense of objectivity. &\\
\bottomrule
\multicolumn{4}{l}{\textit{Note}. *NPC = Non-Player Character. ~\faGamepad~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in the game-related literature~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d}.
~\faConnectdevelop~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in VR-related literature~\cite{hadan2024deceived}.}\\
\end{tabular}%
\end{sideways}
}
\end{table}
\clearpage
\begin{table}[!ht]
\centering
\caption*{Table 2 Continued. This table presents our \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} and the source literature of themes and codes~\cite{gray2024ontology,zagal2013dark,king20233d,hadan2024deceived}. This \guide served as the foundation of our identification of deceptive designs in the selected VR-based and computer-based games.}
\label{tab:initial-codebook-part3}
\resizebox{0.73\textheight}{!}{%
\begin{sideways}
\begin{tabular}{@{}llll@{}}
\toprule
\textbf{\textit{Theme}/Subtheme} & \textbf{Code} & \textbf{Definition} & \textbf{Correspondence to Taxonomies from Literature} \\ \midrule
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 6: Forced Action}}} & &\\
Nagging~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Disrupt user focus with repeatedly unwanted interruptions to & ~\coricon~Nagging~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Badges / Endowed Progress (red dot \\
& & push actions they would rather avoid. & reminder of left off progress)~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Prompted to Buy \\
& & & Robux~\cite{king20233d}, Aesthetic Manipulations (Over-the-top \\
& & & Feedback)~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\ \midrule
Forced Continuity &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Continuity traps users in unwanted subscriptions by making & ~\coricon~Forced Continuity~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & cancellation difficult and auto-renewal opaque. &\\ \midrule
Forced Registration &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Require account creation for tasks that shouldn't need it, & ~\coricon~Forced Registration~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & potentially extracting unnecessary personal data. & \\ \midrule
Forced Communication or Disclosure & Privacy Zuckering & ~\deficon~Trick users into thinking it's essential for the service, & ~\coricon~Privacy Zuckering~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& & leading to overshare personal data. & \\
& Friend Spam~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop & ~\deficon~Exploit social connections by sending spam to users' contact & ~\coricon~Friend Spam~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Friend Spam/Impersonation~\cite{zagal2013dark}, \\
& & lists and resulting in unwanted contact to other users. & Hyperpersonalization (recreate trusted people)~\cite{hadan2024deceived} \\
& Address Book Leeching & ~\deficon~Steal users' contact information under their false impression &Address Book Leeching~\cite{gray2024ontology}\\
& & that only vital information will be collected. & \\
& Social Pyramid~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Push users into recruiting others by tying it to desired features. & ~\coricon~Social Pyramid~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Social Pyramid Scheme~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\ \midrule
Gamification & Pay-to-Play~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Initially advertised as free, later restricts core functionalities or & ~\coricon~Pay-to-Play~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Pay Wall~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Pay to Skip~\cite{zagal2013dark}, \\
& & progress unless players pay to bypass limitations (limited actions, & Recurring Fee~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Real Money Spend Expected~\cite{king20233d}, \\
& & timers, ads). & Purchase Feels Part of Narrative~\cite{king20233d}\\
& Pay to Win~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Real-money purchases grant significant in-game advantages. & ~\coricon~Pay to Win~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Power Creep~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Diminish obtained item values over time to drive new purchase. & ~\coricon~Power Creep~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Grinding~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Force users into repetitive tasks to access features. & ~\coricon~Grinding~\cite{gray2024ontology}, Grinding~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& Random Rewards~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Encourage users to spend money on chance-based rewards. & ~\coricon~Variable Rewards~\cite{zagal2013dark}, Gambling/LootBoxes~\cite{zagal2013dark}, \\
& & & Gacha/lootbox/random~\cite{king20233d}, ``Gambling''~\cite{king20233d}\\
& Can't Pause or Save~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Force users to continue playing before they can save progress. & ~\coricon~Can't Pause or Save~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Daily Challenges~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Encourage players to revisit the game daily.& ~\coricon~Daily Challenges~\cite{zagal2013dark} \\
& Playing by Appointment~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Force players to adhere to the game's schedule.& ~\coricon~Playing by Appointment~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Wait To Play~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Impose arbitrary wait times on players through in-game timers. & ~\coricon~Wait To Play~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\ \midrule
Sunk Cost Fallacy & Endowed Value ~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Trap users with their previous investment (time, money, effort). & ~\coricon~Invested / Endowed Value~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Endowed Progress~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Exploit users' aversion to incompleted progression. & ~\coricon~Badges / Endowed Progress~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\
& Waste Aversion~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Set small differences between in-game currency and item costs, & ~\coricon~Must Buy More Robux (currency) Than \\
& & prompting additional currency purchases. & Needed~\cite{king20233d}, Waste Aversion~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\ \midrule
Attention Capture & Auto-Play & ~\deficon~Auto-start videos, causing excessive or unwanted views.& ~\coricon~Auto-Play~\cite{gray2024ontology} \\
& Interest Exploitation~\faConnectdevelop & ~\deficon~Leverage users' interests to capture their attention. & ~\coricon~Hyperpersonalization (idealized partners)~\cite{hadan2024deceived}\\ \midrule
%=====
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 7: Facilitation}}} & &\\
Low Barrier & Low Barrier Purchase~\faGamepad & ~\deficon~Minimize steps, and complexity during spending actions, & ~\coricon~Purchasing Is Too Easy~\cite{king20233d}, \\
& & encouraging impulsive purchases. & ~\coricon~Purchase Prompt is Immediate~\cite{king20233d}\\ \midrule
Infinite Treadmill~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Continually expanding the game (e.g., new levels, new content). & ~\coricon~Infinite Treadmill~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\ \midrule
%=====
\rowcolor{lightgray!50}\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textit{\textbf{Theme 8: Other}}} & &\\
Complete the Collection~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Exploit users' desires of completing game item collections. & ~\coricon~Complete the Collection~\cite{zagal2013dark}\\ \midrule
Data Fueled Manipulation~\faConnectdevelop &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Capture extensive user data (movement, behavior, surroundings) & ~\coricon~Data Fuels Privacy Risks and Manipulation~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, \\
& & enabling potential deanonymization and tailored manipulation.& Undesired Access and Data Use~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Insecurity \\
& & & Worsen Manipulation~\cite{hadan2024deceived}\\ \midrule
Blurry Boundary~\faConnectdevelop &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& ~\deficon~Photorealistic visual designs blur the lines between reality and & ~\coricon~Extreme Realism blurs the boundary between \\
& & ads, potentially misleading users about product quality.& virtual and reality~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, Obscuring Reality~\cite{hadan2024deceived}, \\
& & & Persistent Exposure to Manipulation~\cite{hadan2024deceived}\\
\bottomrule
\multicolumn{4}{l}{\textit{Note}. ~\faGamepad~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in the game-related literature~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d}.
~\faConnectdevelop~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in VR-related literature~\cite{hadan2024deceived}.}\\
\end{tabular}%
\end{sideways}
}
\end{table}
% Please add the following required packages to your document preamble:
% \usepackage{graphicx}
\begin{table}[!ht]
\centering
\caption{Structural outline of a sample diary entry from a \Moss gameplay session on February 1, 2024. The diary was documented in Miro given its feasibility in linking videos, screenshots, and diary texts. From left to right: (1) description of the lead researcher's experience, reactions, thoughts, and feelings complemented by corresponding screenshots of game design elements, and (2) post-gameplay reflection on possible presence of deceptive game design and its context.}
\label{tab:diary-mockup}
\resizebox{0.9\textwidth}{!}{%
\begin{tabular}{@{}p{0.5\columnwidth}|p{0.5\columnwidth}@{}}
\toprule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textbf{Date:} February 1, 2024} \\
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textbf{Estimated Time:} $\sim$3.5 hours including diary writing} \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\textbf{{[}Imported Video Gameplay Recording{]}} } \\ \midrule
\textbf{{[}\textit{Diary}{]}} & \textbf{{[}Reflection Note:{]}}\\
\textit{Today's session with Moss Book II produced a strong emotional moment that further made me more emotionally invested in Quill, the brave mouse protagonist. She had to fight a scary owl (a winged tyrant) that threw her and her uncle off a cliff. I was on the edge of my seat as Quill went after her uncle. The game then showed a really touching scene where Quill found her uncle Argus died. The moment that she holds Argus' body and looks at my direction for help made me feel like I was right there with Quill on her suffering.}& I really love how Quill interacts with me directly - it makes the game so much more engaging. Her reactions to my moves are spot on and she reacts to my every move and gives me a high-five when I do something right. Even when I mess up, she's still there showing she cares about me and bears with me while I try to solve the puzzles. It's like she's a real character to me, not just some avatar. This feeling motivates me to keep going and solve all the puzzles and guide her through the story.\\
\multicolumn{1}{r|}{ \textbf{{[}Screenshots{]}} }& \\
\textit{As I and Sahima found Quill under the cliff, she surprised me with a hug. While the limitations of VR technology prevented a fully tactile experience, the animation of ``hugging'' my controller pointers with her whole body effectively conveyed the warmth and gratitude in her embrace. This simple gesture touched deeply and reminded me of the bond we had built throughout our shared adventure. It was no longer just about guiding Quill through puzzles anymore; it was about protecting a close friend.} & The emotional weight of the hug was further amplified when we found what happened to Quill's uncle. His death made the story of Moss even more meaningful and gave me a stronger sense of purpose. I became even more determined to keep Quill safe and avenge her uncle's loss because I knew she was counting only on me now.\\
\multicolumn{1}{r|}{ \textbf{{[}Screenshots{]}} } & \textbf{{[}Next Session:{]}}\\
\textit{The way the game implemented it for Quill's hug was cool, but imagine if we could feel every detail – like the warmth of her fur or the gentle squeeze of her tiny paws. That would be so immersive and emotional. I bet it would change the way we feel about the characters we're playing with.}& In my next session, I'll be looking for other methods that the game uses to enhance player immersion and emotional connection. It will be interesting to see how Moss Book II continues to use storytelling and VR technology to create a truly impactful experience.\\
\bottomrule
\end{tabular}%
}
\end{table}
\begin{table*}[!ht]
\centering
\vspace{-3mm}
\caption{Using our \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} in~\autoref{tab:initial-codebook}, this table presents deceptive design patterns we identified within Overwatch 2 (OW2) based on our previous research on this game~\cite{hhadan2024ow2}.}
\vspace{-2mm}
\label{tab:OW2-finalcodebook}
\resizebox{0.95\textwidth}{!}{%
\begin{tabular}{@{}llll@{}}
\toprule
\textbf{\textit{Theme}/Subtheme} & \textbf{Code} & \textbf{OW2 Game Mechanics} & \textbf{Synthesized Diary Entries$^a$} \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 1: Sneaking}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Hiding Information & Reference Pricing~\faGamepad & In-Game Shop &~\deficon~I feel discounted/cheaper items are better deals compared to \\
& & & full-priced/expensive ones displayed alongside. \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 2: Obstruction}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Creating Barriers & Intermediate Currencies~\faGamepad & OW Coins &~\deficon~ I feel overwhelmed by five distinct currencies (OW Coins,\\
& & & Legacy Credits, Competitive Coins, Overwatch League Tokens, \\
& & & Mythic Prisms), each has different exchange rates to real money \\
& & & and restricted to specific item purchases.\\ \midrule
%two types are purchasable with real-money (OW Coins, Overwatch League Tokens, Mythic Prisms) and three rely on grinding (Legacy Credits, Competitive Coins, Mythic Prisms)
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 3: Social Engineering}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Urgency & Countdown Timers~\faGamepad & Battle Pass & ~\deficon~ I feel pressured to complete the Battle Pass due to a countdown\\
& & & timer indicating its end at each season's close. \\
& & Daily/Weekly/Seasonal Challenges & ~\deficon~ I feel pressured to complete challenges as they refresh daily, \\
& & & weekly, and seasonally, indicated by a countdown timer.\\
& & In-Game Shop & ~\deficon~ I feel pressured to buy bundles and discounted items as they\\
& & & refresh weekly, indicated by a countdown timer.\\
& Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)~\faGamepad & Battle Pass&~\deficon~ I fear not completing the Battle Pass before the season ends, as \\
& & & it means losing the chance to earn its rewards and potentially\\
& & & wasting the premium fee. \\
& & Daily/Weekly/Seasonal Challenges & ~\deficon~ I fear not completing the challenges within the time limit, as it \\
& & & means losing the chance to earn the XPs and currencies.\\
& & New Character & ~\deficon~ I fear not unlocking the new character from the Battle Pass this\\
& & & season, as it means missing the easiest path and quick access.\\
Personalization & Social Obligation~\faGamepad & New Character & ~\deficon~ I feel obligated to quickly unlock the new character to help\\
& & & my team in games.\\
& Competition~\faGamepad & Competitive Ranks &~\deficon~I feel jealous of higher-ranked players, which drives me to play \\
& & & competitive games repeatedly to practice and improve my rank. \\\midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{Theme 4: Interface Interference}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Manipulating Choice Architecture & False Hierarchy~\faGamepad & Battle Pass & ~\deficon~I feel buying premium is worthwhile, as nearly all rewards are\\
& & & premium-only.\\
& & Character Item Gallery &~\deficon~ I feel more easily find and click on legendary and epic items, as \\
& & & they are always at the top of the gallery. \\
& Bundling~\faGamepad & Battle Pass & ~\deficon~ I feel buying a Battle Pass with 80+ rewards cheaper than \\
& & & buying them individually, even they are items I don't want.\\
& & In-Game Shop & ~\deficon~ I feel buying bundled items at a discounted price is cheaper \\
& & & than buying them individually, even there are items I don't want.\\
Emotional or Sensory Manipulation & Adorable design~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop & Battle Pass &~\deficon~ I feel tempted to buy the unique mythic skin at the last level, as \\
& & & it has custom sound and visual effects. \\
& & In-Game Shop& ~\deficon~ I feel tempted to buy cute items. Being able to use them make \\
& & & gameplay more attractive. \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{Theme 6: Forced Action}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Gamification & Pay-to-Play~\faGamepad & Battle Pass &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to pay a premium fee every season for rewards.\\
& & & ~\deficon~I feel pressured to purchase levels to unlock reward instantly\\
& & & when I lack time for XP grinding.\\
& & New character & ~\deficon~ I feel pressured to buy the premium Battle Pass as I want to\\
& & & unlock new character immediately.\\
& Grinding~\faGamepad & Daily/Weekly/Seasonal Challenges &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to play the game everyday to grind the 3 (daily),\\
& & & 11 (weekly), and 40+ (seasonal) repetitive tasks like ``earn 10 \\
& & & eliminations/assists without dying.'' \\
& & Battle Pass &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to grind for XPs to complete levels (10,000 XP) \\
& & & each from gameplay and completing daily/weekly challenges. \\
& & New Character &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to grind for unlocking the new character\\
& & & to avoid grinding character-specific challenges in future seasons.\\
& Playing by Appointment~\faGamepad & Double XP Weekend &~\deficon~I feel an urgency to participate in this weekend event from \\
& & & March 10 to 12, 2023 to grind XPs faster.\\
Sunk Cost Fallacy & Endowed Progress~\faGamepad & Battle Pass & ~\deficon~Once I have made progress, it is hard for me to abandon an\\
& & & incomplete level and an incomplete Battle Pass.\\
& & Daily/Weekly/Seasonal Challenges & ~\deficon~ Once I have made progress, it is hard for me to abandon an \\
& & &incomplete challenge or stop before completing all daily, weekly,\\
& & & and seasonal challenges. \\
& Endowed Value~\faGamepad & Competitive Ranks &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to play daily to maintain my gained skills\\
& && and character mastery.\\
& Waste Aversion~\faGamepad & In-Game Shop &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to buy additional currency packs to use up my \\
& & & remaining coins from previous items and bundles purchases. \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{Theme 7: Facilitation}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Infinite Treadmill~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& Battle Pass &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to complete a new Battle Pass each season. \\
& & Daily/Weekly/Seasonal Challenges &~\deficon~ I feel pressured to complete new challenges daily, weekly, and\\
& & & seasonally.\\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{Theme 8: Other}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Complete the Collection~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}& Character Item Gallery &~\deficon~ I feel the urge to complete character item collections due to a\\
& & & progress bar indicating the proportion of missing items. \\
\bottomrule
\multicolumn{4}{l}{\begin{tabular}[c]{@{}l@{}}\textit{Note}. $a$. Contents in quotes are descriptions directly from the game. \\
~\faGamepad~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in the game-related literature~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d}. ~\faConnectdevelop~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in VR-related literature~\cite{hadan2024deceived}.\\ \end{tabular}}\\
\end{tabular}%
}
\vspace{-15mm}
\end{table*}
\begin{table*}[!ht]
\centering
\vspace{-4mm}
\caption{Based on our \textit{VR Deceptive Game Design Assessment Guide} in~\autoref{tab:initial-codebook}, this table presents deceptive design patterns we identified within \Moss and \BS.}
\vspace{-4mm}
\label{tab:VR-finalcodebook}
\resizebox{0.95\textwidth}{!}{%
\begin{tabular}{@{}llll@{}}
\toprule
\textbf{\textit{Theme}/Subtheme} & \textbf{Code} & \textbf{VR Game Mechanics$^a$} & \textbf{Synthesized Diary Entries$^b$} \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 2: Obstruction}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Creating Barriers & Price Comparison Prevention &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Purchase System &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel frustrated because comparing individual song and\\
& &\cellcolor{paleblue!20} & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}song pack prices in-game is impossible, as no clear prices\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}provided in game.\\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 3: Social Engineering}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Social Proof & Parasocial Pressure &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Gallery & ~\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}I feel attracted to songs and music packs from my favorite\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}singers, games, or anime.\\
Urgency & Limited Time Messages~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Purchase System & ~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel tempted to buy songs and music packs during the\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}time-limited sale.\\
Personalization & Competition~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Leaderboard &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ While my skills may not compete with global or local\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}players and my friends, I feel pressured to perform better to\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}beat my old scores to avoid losing gained skills.\\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 4: Interface Interference}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Manipulating Choice Architecture & False Hierarchy~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Main Menu &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel tempted to tap on the music pack beside game\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}mode options on the main menu because it seems special \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}compared to those within each game mode.\\
& Visual Prominence~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Purchase System &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I feel distracted by the notification that purchasing the \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}entire music pack is cheaper, and the visually prominent \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}``buy music pack'' option on top of the ``buy level (song)'' \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}option that I intend to select. \\
& Bundling~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Purchase System &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I feel buying whole music packs because an in-game\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}notification claims they are cheaper, despite no clear prices \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}listed for individual songs or packs. \\
Emotional/Sensory Manipulation & Adorable design~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Gallery & ~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel attracted to play the game repeatedly because of its \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}beautiful and visually striking block and lightsaber designs.\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& ~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I feel attracted to the BTS music pack$^c$ because each song\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}has the singers' avatars dancing with me in the game. \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& ~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I feel attracted to songs and music packs with cute covers.\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& ~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I feel attracted to songs with strong beats as they help\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}me catch the rhythm and perform better in the game.\\
& &\cellcolor{palered!20}Moss: Book II: Character Design &~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~ I feel attracted to play the game by the cute character\\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}designs, and colorful and vibrant map environments.\\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}&~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~ I feel attracted to interact with the characters because\\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}she actively ``talk'' to me using sign language.\\
& NPC/Narrative Manipulation~\faGamepad~\faConnectdevelop &\cellcolor{palered!20}Moss: Book II: Game Narrative &~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~ I lose track of time spent in game due to deep connection\\
& &\cellcolor{palered!20} & \cellcolor{palered!20}to the story and characters from the unexpected twists in\\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}the storyline.\\
& &\cellcolor{palered!20}Moss: Book II: 3D Interaction and Immersion & ~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~I lose track of time spent in game as I feel being part\\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}of the story because of the interactive 3D feedback that \\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}allow me to flip pages of the story book, move objects in \\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}the environment, and ``pet,'' ``hug,'' and ``high-five'' with the \\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}characters.\\
Trick Questions &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}&\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Purchase System &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}~\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I feel confused by the option for purchasing individual \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}songs (`` buy level'') as it might refer to purchasing a difficulty \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}level rather than a song. Whereas the ``buy music pack''\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}option is more straightforward. \\
Hidden Information &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}&\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: 3D Interaction and Immersion &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I lose track of time due to deep engagement of gameplay \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}and the absence of an in-game clock.\\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}Moss: Book II: 3D Interaction and Immersion&~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~ I lose track of time due to deep engagement of gameplay \\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}and the absence of an in-game clock.\\
& &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Gameplay&~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel frustrated by the lack of an option or progress bar \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}to mark specific parts of a song where I struggle. As a result, \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}when I fail a game, I must repeatedly practice the entire \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}song. \\
& &\cellcolor{palered!20}Moss: Book II: Progress Indicator &~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~I feel confused about my storyline progress because the \\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}progress indicator is too subtle and blends into the library \\
& &\cellcolor{palered!20} & \cellcolor{palered!20}environment seamlessly. \\ \midrule
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 6: Forced Action}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Forced Communication/Disclosure & Privacy Zuckering &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Purchase System &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel vulnerable because purchasing songs or music \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}packs requires entering payment information before seeing \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}clear prices. \\
Gamification & Pay-to-Play~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Purchase System &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel annoyed by the fact that even though I bought the \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}game I have to consistently buy new songs and music packs.\\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& ~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I lose track of money spent on songs and music packs \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}since each costs only around \$2 to \$4 USD.\\
& Power Creep~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Gameplay &~\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ \cellcolor{paleblue!20}Over time, I feel bored by playing the same songs \\
& &\cellcolor{paleblue!20} & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}repeatedly, which drives me to buy new ones. \\
& Can't Pause or Save~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{palered!20}Moss: Book II: Saving Options &~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~ I feel pressured to play continuously and stop less, as the \\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}game solely on automatic saves. I cannot save my progress \\
& & \cellcolor{palered!20}& \cellcolor{palered!20}manually even when my battery is dying. \\
Sunk Cost Fallacy & Endowed Value ~\faGamepad &\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Gameplay &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~I feel pressured to play daily to maintain my gained skills \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}and song mastery. \\
\multicolumn{2}{l}{\cellcolor{lightgray!50}\textit{\textbf{Theme 8: Other}}} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} & \cellcolor{lightgray!50} \\
Complete the Collection~\faGamepad &\multicolumn{1}{c}{-}&\cellcolor{paleblue!20}Beat Saber: Song Gallery &~\cellcolor{paleblue!20}\textcolor{paleblue}{\deficon}~ I feel the urge to own all songs in a music pack due to \\
& & \cellcolor{paleblue!20}& \cellcolor{paleblue!20}my positive experiences with some songs.\\
& &\cellcolor{palered!20}Moss: Book II: Scrolls and Armors &~\cellcolor{palered!20}\textcolor{palered}{\deficon}~ I feel the urge to collect all scrolls and armors, even \\
& &\cellcolor{palered!20} & \cellcolor{palered!20}revisiting maps, though they don't affect the storyline.\\
\bottomrule
\multicolumn{4}{l}{\begin{tabular}[c]{@{}l@{}}\textit{Note}. $a$. Mechanics from a same game are grouped by color. We used pink for game mechanics from \Moss and blue for those from \BS. \\
$b$. Contents in quotes are descriptions directly from the game. $c$. BTS Music Pack. Beat Saber Wiki. ~\url{https://beatsaber.fandom.com/wiki/BTS_Music_Pack}. Last accessed on May 4, 2024.\\
~\faGamepad~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in the game-related literature~\cite{zagal2013dark,king20233d}. ~\faConnectdevelop~denotes deceptive designs mentioned in VR-related literature~\cite{hadan2024deceived}.\\ \end{tabular}}\\
\end{tabular}%
}
\vspace{-15mm}
\end{table*}
%%% -*-BibTeX-*-
%%% Do NOT edit. File created by BibTeX with style
%%% ACM-Reference-Format-Journals [18-Jan-2012].
\begin{thebibliography}{59}
%%% ====================================================================
%%% NOTE TO THE USER: you can override these defaults by providing
%%% customized versions of any of these macros before the \bibliography
%%% command. Each of them MUST provide its own final punctuation,
%%% except for \shownote{}, \showDOI{}, and \showURL{}. The latter two
%%% do not use final punctuation, in order to avoid confusing it with
%%% the Web address.
%%%
%%% To suppress output of a particular field, define its macro to expand
%%% to an empty string, or better, \unskip, like this:
%%%
%%% \newcommand{\showDOI}[1]{\unskip} % LaTeX syntax
%%%
%%% \def \showDOI #1{\unskip} % plain TeX syntax
%%%
%%% ====================================================================
\ifx \showCODEN \undefined \def \showCODEN #1{\unskip} \fi
\ifx \showDOI \undefined \def \showDOI #1{#1}\fi
\ifx \showISBNx \undefined \def \showISBNx #1{\unskip} \fi
\ifx \showISBNxiii \undefined \def \showISBNxiii #1{\unskip} \fi
\ifx \showISSN \undefined \def \showISSN #1{\unskip} \fi
\ifx \showLCCN \undefined \def \showLCCN #1{\unskip} \fi
\ifx \shownote \undefined \def \shownote #1{#1} \fi
\ifx \showarticletitle \undefined \def \showarticletitle #1{#1} \fi
\ifx \showURL \undefined \def \showURL {\relax} \fi
% The following commands are used for tagged output and should be
% invisible to TeX
\providecommand\bibfield[2]{#2}
\providecommand\bibinfo[2]{#2}
\providecommand\natexlab[1]{#1}
\providecommand\showeprint[2][]{arXiv:#2}
\bibitem[Adams et~al\mbox{.}(2016)]%
{adams2016handbook}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Tony~E Adams}, \bibinfo{person}{Stacy~Holman Jones}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Carolyn Ellis}.} \bibinfo{year}{2016}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Handbook of autoethnography}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{Routledge}, \bibinfo{address}{London, UK}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Boehner et~al\mbox{.}(2008)]%
{boehner2008interfaces}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Kirsten Boehner}, \bibinfo{person}{Phoebe Sengers}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Simeon Warner}.} \bibinfo{year}{2008}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Interfaces with the ineffable: Meeting aesthetic experience on its own terms}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction (TOCHI)}} \bibinfo{volume}{15}, \bibinfo{number}{3} (\bibinfo{year}{2008}), \bibinfo{pages}{1--29}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Bogost(2010)]%
{bogost2010persuasive}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{I. Bogost}.} \bibinfo{year}{2010}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Persuasive Games: The Expressive Power of Videogames}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{MIT Press}, \bibinfo{address}{Massachusetts, United States}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9780262261944}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://books.google.ca/books?id=GC7MD17YvJEC}
\showURL{%
\tempurl}
\bibitem[Boldi and Rapp(2023)]%
{boldi2023legit}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Arianna Boldi} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Amon Rapp}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{“Is It Legit, To You?”. An Exploration of Players’ Perceptions of Cheating in a Multiplayer Video Game: Making Sense of Uncertainty}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction}} \bibinfo{volume}{0}, \bibinfo{number}{0} (\bibinfo{year}{2023}), \bibinfo{pages}{1--21}.
\newblock
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1080/10447318.2023.2204276}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Brignull(2010)]%
{Brignull2010deceptive}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Harry Brignull}.} \bibinfo{year}{2010}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{title}{Deceptive patterns - user interfaces crafted to trick you}.
\newblock \bibinfo{howpublished}{\url{https://www.deceptive.design/}}.
\newblock
\newblock
\shownote{Last accessed on July 24, 2023}.
\bibitem[Brignull(2023)]%
{Brignull2023book}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Harry Brignull}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{{Deceptive patterns – exposing the tricks that tech companies use to control you}}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{Testimonium Ltd}, \bibinfo{address}{UK}.
\newblock
\bibitem[{Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada, Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council}(2024)]%
{tpcs2022}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{{Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada, Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council}}.} \bibinfo{year}{2024}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{title}{Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans – TCPS 2 (2022)}.
\newblock \bibinfo{howpublished}{\url{https://ethics.gc.ca/eng/policy-politique_tcps2-eptc2_2022.html}}.
\newblock
\newblock
\shownote{Last accessed on April 24, 2024}.
\bibitem[Clarke and Braun(2021)]%
{clarke2021thematic}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Victoria Clarke} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Virginia Braun}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Thematic analysis: a practical guide}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{SAGE Publications Ltd}, \bibinfo{address}{California, United States}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Cummings and Shore(2022)]%
{cummings2022all}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{James~J Cummings} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Alexis Shore}.} \bibinfo{year}{2022}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{All too real: A typology of user vulnerabilities in extended reality}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 1st Workshop on Novel Challenges of Safety, Security and Privacy in Extended Reality}}, Vol.~\bibinfo{volume}{29}. \bibinfo{publisher}{ACM}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, USA}, \bibinfo{numpages}{3}~pages.
\newblock
\bibitem[Deterding et~al\mbox{.}(2020)]%
{deterding2020against}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Christoph~Sebastian Deterding}, \bibinfo{person}{Jaakko Stenros}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Markus Montola}.} \bibinfo{year}{2020}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Against ``Dark Game Design Patterns''}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{DiGRA'20-Abstract Proceedings of the 2020 DiGRA International Conference}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{DiGRA}, \bibinfo{address}{Finland}, \bibinfo{numpages}{3}~pages.
\newblock
\bibitem[Di~Geronimo et~al\mbox{.}(2020)]%
{geronimo2020UI}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Linda Di~Geronimo}, \bibinfo{person}{Larissa Braz}, \bibinfo{person}{Enrico Fregnan}, \bibinfo{person}{Fabio Palomba}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Alberto Bacchelli}.} \bibinfo{year}{2020}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{UI Dark Patterns and Where to Find Them: A Study on Mobile Applications and User Perception}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2020 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems}} (Honolulu, HI, USA) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CHI '20})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{1–14}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450367080}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3313831.3376600}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Dillon(2020)]%
{dillon2020digital}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Roberto Dillon}.} \bibinfo{year}{2020}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{{The digital gaming handbook}}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{CRC Press}, \bibinfo{address}{Florida, USA}.
\newblock
\bibitem[{European Parliament, Council of the European Union}(2022)]%
{EUDSA2022}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{{European Parliament, Council of the European Union}}.} \bibinfo{year}{2022}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{title}{{Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 October 2022 on a Single Market For Digital Services and amending Directive 2000/31/EC (Digital Services Act) (Text with EEA relevance)}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{howpublished}{\url{https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=celex:32022R2065}}.
\newblock
\newblock
\shownote{Last accessed on December 7, 2023.}.
\bibitem[Fassl and Krombholz(2023)]%
{fassl2023can}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Matthias Fassl} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Katharina Krombholz}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Why I Can’t Authenticate — Understanding the Low Adoption of Authentication Ceremonies with Autoethnography}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2023 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems}} (Hamburg, Germany) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CHI '23})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{72}, \bibinfo{numpages}{15}~pages.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450394215}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3544548.3581508}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Fitton and Read(2019)]%
{fitton2019F2P}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Dan Fitton} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Janet~C. Read}.} \bibinfo{year}{2019}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Creating a Framework to Support the Critical Consideration of Dark Design Aspects in Free-to-Play Apps}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 18th ACM International Conference on Interaction Design and Children}} (Boise, ID, USA) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{IDC '19})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{407–418}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450366908}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3311927.3323136}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Freeman et~al\mbox{.}(2022)]%
{freeman2022pay}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Guo Freeman}, \bibinfo{person}{Karen Wu}, \bibinfo{person}{Nicholas Nower}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Donghee~Yvette Wohn}.} \bibinfo{year}{2022}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Pay to Win or Pay to Cheat: How Players of Competitive Online Games Perceive Fairness of In-Game Purchases}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction}} \bibinfo{volume}{6}, \bibinfo{number}{CHI PLAY} (\bibinfo{year}{2022}), \bibinfo{pages}{1--24}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Frommel and Mandryk(2022)]%
{frommel2022daily}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Julian Frommel} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Regan~L Mandryk}.} \bibinfo{year}{2022}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Daily Quests or Daily Pests? The Benefits and Pitfalls of Engagement Rewards in Games}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction}} \bibinfo{volume}{6}, \bibinfo{number}{CHI PLAY} (\bibinfo{year}{2022}), \bibinfo{pages}{1--23}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Gray et~al\mbox{.}(2021)]%
{gray2021enduser}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Colin~M. Gray}, \bibinfo{person}{Jingle Chen}, \bibinfo{person}{Shruthi~Sai Chivukula}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Liyang Qu}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{End User Accounts of Dark Patterns as Felt Manipulation}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact.}} \bibinfo{volume}{5}, \bibinfo{number}{CSCW2}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{372} (\bibinfo{date}{oct} \bibinfo{year}{2021}), \bibinfo{numpages}{25}~pages.
\newblock
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3479516}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Gray et~al\mbox{.}(2018)]%
{gray2018dark}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Colin~M Gray}, \bibinfo{person}{Yubo Kou}, \bibinfo{person}{Bryan Battles}, \bibinfo{person}{Joseph Hoggatt}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Austin~L Toombs}.} \bibinfo{year}{2018}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{{The dark (patterns) side of UX design}}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2018 CHI conference on human factors in computing systems}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{ACM}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{1--14}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Gray et~al\mbox{.}(2023a)]%
{gray2023mapping}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Colin~M Gray}, \bibinfo{person}{Lorena Sanchez~Chamorro}, \bibinfo{person}{Ike Obi}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Ja-Nae Duane}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{a}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Mapping the Landscape of Dark Patterns Scholarship: A Systematic Literature Review}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Companion Publication of the 2023 ACM Designing Interactive Systems Conference}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{ACM}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{188--193}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Gray et~al\mbox{.}(2023b)]%
{gray2023towards}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Colin~M. Gray}, \bibinfo{person}{Cristiana Santos}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Nataliia Bielova}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{b}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Towards a Preliminary Ontology of Dark Patterns Knowledge}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Extended Abstracts of the 2023 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems}} (Hamburg, Germany) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CHI EA '23})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{286}, \bibinfo{numpages}{9}~pages.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450394222}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3544549.3585676}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Gray et~al\mbox{.}(2024)]%
{gray2024ontology}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Colin~M. Gray}, \bibinfo{person}{Cristiana~Teixeira Santos}, \bibinfo{person}{Nataliia Bielova}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Thomas Mildner}.} \bibinfo{year}{2024}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{An Ontology of Dark Patterns Knowledge: Foundations, Definitions, and a Pathway for Shared Knowledge-Building}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems}} (Honolulu, HI, USA) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CHI '24})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{289}, \bibinfo{numpages}{22}~pages.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9798400703300}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3613904.3642436}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Greenberg et~al\mbox{.}(2014)]%
{Greenberg2014proxemic}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Saul Greenberg}, \bibinfo{person}{Sebastian Boring}, \bibinfo{person}{Jo Vermeulen}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Jakub Dostal}.} \bibinfo{year}{2014}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Dark Patterns in Proxemic Interactions: A Critical Perspective}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2014 Conference on Designing Interactive Systems}} (Vancouver, BC, Canada) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{DIS '14})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{523–532}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450329026}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/2598510.2598541}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Gunawan et~al\mbox{.}(2021)]%
{gunawan2021comparative}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Johanna Gunawan}, \bibinfo{person}{Amogh Pradeep}, \bibinfo{person}{David Choffnes}, \bibinfo{person}{Woodrow Hartzog}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Christo Wilson}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{A Comparative Study of Dark Patterns Across Web and Mobile Modalities}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact.}} \bibinfo{volume}{5}, \bibinfo{number}{CSCW2}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{377} (\bibinfo{date}{oct} \bibinfo{year}{2021}), \bibinfo{numpages}{29}~pages.
\newblock
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3479521}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Hadan et~al\mbox{.}(2024a)]%
{hadan2024deceived}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Hilda Hadan}, \bibinfo{person}{Lydia Choong}, \bibinfo{person}{Leah Zhang-Kennedy}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Lennart~E. Nacke}.} \bibinfo{year}{2024}\natexlab{a}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Deceived by Immersion: A Systematic Analysis of Deceptive Design in Extended Reality}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{ACM Comput. Surv.}} \bibinfo{volume}{56}, \bibinfo{number}{10}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{250} (\bibinfo{date}{may} \bibinfo{year}{2024}), \bibinfo{numpages}{25}~pages.
\newblock
\showISSN{0360-0300}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3659945}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Hadan et~al\mbox{.}(2024b)]%
{hadan2024pop}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Hilda Hadan}, \bibinfo{person}{Sabrina~A. Sgandurra}, \bibinfo{person}{Leah Zhang-Kennedy}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Lennart~E. Nacke}.} \bibinfo{year}{2024}\natexlab{b}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{{Culture Clash: When Deceptive Design Meets Diverse Player Expectations}}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Companion Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play}} (Tampere, Finland) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CHI PLAY Companion '24})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{numpages}{4}~pages.
\newblock
\showISBNx{979-8-4007-0692-9/24/10}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3665463.3678866}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Hadan et~al\mbox{.}(2024c)]%
{hhadan2024ow2}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Hilda Hadan}, \bibinfo{person}{Sabrina~A. Sgandurra}, \bibinfo{person}{Leah Zhang-Kennedy}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Lennart~E. Nacke}.} \bibinfo{year}{2024}\natexlab{c}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{From Motivating to Manipulative: The Use of Deceptive Design in a Game's Free-to-Play Transition}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact.}} \bibinfo{volume}{8}, \bibinfo{number}{CHI PLAY}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{309} (\bibinfo{date}{oct} \bibinfo{year}{2024}), \bibinfo{numpages}{31}~pages.
\newblock
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3677074}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[{IGN Southeast Asia}(2024)]%
{ign_2024}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{{IGN Southeast Asia}}.} \bibinfo{year}{2024}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{title}{Overwatch 2, World of Warcraft, and Hearthstone Shut Down in China}.
\newblock \bibinfo{howpublished}{https://sea.ign.com/activision-blizzard/194620/news/overwatch-2-world-of-warcraft-and-hearthstone-shut-down-in-china}.
\newblock
\newblock
\shownote{Last accessed on May 4, 2024.}.
\bibitem[Karlsen(2019)]%
{karlsen2019exploited}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Faltin Karlsen}.} \bibinfo{year}{2019}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{{Exploited or Engaged? Dark Game Design Patterns in Clicker Heroes, FarmVille 2, and World of Warcraft}}.
\newblock In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{{Transgression in Games and Play}}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{The MIT Press}, \bibinfo{address}{MA, USA}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9780262348706}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/11550.003.0019}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\showeprint{https://direct.mit.edu/book/chapter-pdf/2104393/9780262348706\_ceb.pdf}
\bibitem[King et~al\mbox{.}(2023)]%
{king20233d}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{John King}, \bibinfo{person}{Dan Fitton}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Brendan Cassidy}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Investigating Players’ Perceptions of Deceptive Design Practices within a 3D Gameplay Context}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact.}} \bibinfo{volume}{7}, \bibinfo{number}{CHI PLAY}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{407} (\bibinfo{date}{oct} \bibinfo{year}{2023}), \bibinfo{numpages}{17}~pages.
\newblock
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3611053}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Kordyaka et~al\mbox{.}(2023)]%
{kordyaka2023cycle}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Bastian Kordyaka}, \bibinfo{person}{Samuli Laato}, \bibinfo{person}{Katharina Jahn}, \bibinfo{person}{Juho Hamari}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Bjoern Niehaves}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{The Cycle of Toxicity: Exploring Relationships between Personality and Player Roles in Toxic Behavior in Multiplayer Online Battle Arena Games}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction}} \bibinfo{volume}{7}, \bibinfo{number}{CHI PLAY} (\bibinfo{year}{2023}), \bibinfo{pages}{611--641}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Krauss et~al\mbox{.}(2024)]%
{krauss2024what}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Veronika Krauss}, \bibinfo{person}{Pejman Saeghe}, \bibinfo{person}{Alexander Boden}, \bibinfo{person}{Mohamed Khamis}, \bibinfo{person}{Mark McGill}, \bibinfo{person}{Jan Gugenheimer}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Michael Nebeling}.} \bibinfo{year}{2024}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{What Makes XR Dark? Examining Emerging Dark Patterns in Augmented and Virtual Reality through Expert Co-Design}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{ACM Trans. Comput.-Hum. Interact.}} \bibinfo{volume}{0}, \bibinfo{number}{0} (\bibinfo{date}{apr} \bibinfo{year}{2024}), \bibinfo{numpages}{37}~pages.
\newblock
\showISSN{1073-0516}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3660340}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\newblock
\shownote{Just Accepted}.
\bibitem[Laato et~al\mbox{.}(2022)]%
{laato2022balancing}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Samuli Laato}, \bibinfo{person}{Daniel Fern{\'a}ndez~Galeote}, \bibinfo{person}{Ferran Altarriba~Bertran}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Juho Hamari}.} \bibinfo{year}{2022}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Balancing the augmented experience: design tensions in the location-based game Pikmin Bloom}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems Extended Abstracts}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{1--7}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Lewis(2014)]%
{lewis2014irresistible}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Chris Lewis}.} \bibinfo{year}{2014}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{{Irresistible Apps: Motivational design patterns for apps, games, and web-based communities}}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{Springer}, \bibinfo{address}{Berlin, Germany}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Luguri and Strahilevitz(2021)]%
{luguri2021shining}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Jamie Luguri} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Lior~Jacob Strahilevitz}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Shining a light on dark patterns}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Journal of Legal Analysis}} \bibinfo{volume}{13}, \bibinfo{number}{1} (\bibinfo{year}{2021}), \bibinfo{pages}{43--109}.
\newblock
\bibitem[M.~Bhoot et~al\mbox{.}(2021)]%
{m2020towards}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Aditi M.~Bhoot}, \bibinfo{person}{Mayuri A.~Shinde}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Wricha P.~Mishra}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Towards the Identification of Dark Patterns: An Analysis Based on End-User Reactions}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 11th Indian Conference on Human-Computer Interaction}} (Online, India) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{IndiaHCI '20})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{24–33}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450389440}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3429290.3429293}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Maier(2019)]%
{maier2019dark}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Maximilian Maier}.} \bibinfo{year}{2019}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{title}{Dark patterns--An end user perspective}.
\newblock
\newblock
\bibitem[Mathur et~al\mbox{.}(2019)]%
{mathur2019dark}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Arunesh Mathur}, \bibinfo{person}{Gunes Acar}, \bibinfo{person}{Michael~J Friedman}, \bibinfo{person}{Eli Lucherini}, \bibinfo{person}{Jonathan Mayer}, \bibinfo{person}{Marshini Chetty}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Arvind Narayanan}.} \bibinfo{year}{2019}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Dark patterns at scale: Findings from a crawl of 11K shopping websites}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction}} \bibinfo{volume}{3}, \bibinfo{number}{CSCW} (\bibinfo{year}{2019}), \bibinfo{pages}{1--32}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Mathur et~al\mbox{.}(2021)]%
{mathur2021makes}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Arunesh Mathur}, \bibinfo{person}{Mihir Kshirsagar}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Jonathan Mayer}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{What makes a dark pattern... dark? Design attributes, normative considerations, and measurement methods}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2021 CHI conference on human factors in computing systems}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{ACM}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{1--18}.
\newblock
\bibitem[May et~al\mbox{.}(2014)]%
{may2014reflexivity}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Tim May}, \bibinfo{person}{Beth Perry}, {et~al\mbox{.}}} \bibinfo{year}{2014}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Reflexivity and the practice of qualitative research}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{The SAGE handbook of qualitative data analysis}} \bibinfo{volume}{109} (\bibinfo{year}{2014}), \bibinfo{pages}{109--122}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Mildner et~al\mbox{.}(2023a)]%
{mildner2023defending}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Thomas Mildner}, \bibinfo{person}{Merle Freye}, \bibinfo{person}{Gian-Luca Savino}, \bibinfo{person}{Philip~R. Doyle}, \bibinfo{person}{Benjamin~R. Cowan}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Rainer Malaka}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{a}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Defending Against the Dark Arts: Recognising Dark Patterns in Social Media}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2023 ACM Designing Interactive Systems Conference}} (Pittsburgh, PA, USA) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{DIS '23})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{2362–2374}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450398930}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3563657.3595964}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Mildner et~al\mbox{.}(2023b)]%
{mildner2023engaging}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Thomas Mildner}, \bibinfo{person}{Gian-Luca Savino}, \bibinfo{person}{Philip~R. Doyle}, \bibinfo{person}{Benjamin~R. Cowan}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Rainer Malaka}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{b}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{About Engaging and Governing Strategies: A Thematic Analysis of Dark Patterns in Social Networking Services}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2023 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems}} (<conf-loc>, <city>Hamburg</city>, <country>Germany</country>, </conf-loc>) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CHI '23})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{192}, \bibinfo{numpages}{15}~pages.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450394215}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3544548.3580695}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Monge~Roffarello et~al\mbox{.}(2023)]%
{roffarello2023defining}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Alberto Monge~Roffarello}, \bibinfo{person}{Kai Lukoff}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Luigi De~Russis}.} \bibinfo{year}{2023}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Defining and Identifying Attention Capture Deceptive Designs in Digital Interfaces}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2023 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems}} (<conf-loc>, <city>Hamburg</city>, <country>Germany</country>, </conf-loc>) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CHI '23})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, Article \bibinfo{articleno}{194}, \bibinfo{numpages}{19}~pages.
\newblock
\showISBNx{9781450394215}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/3544548.3580729}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Nardi(2010)]%
{nardi2010my}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Bonnie Nardi}.} \bibinfo{year}{2010}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{My life as a night elf priest: An anthropological account of World of Warcraft}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{University of Michigan Press}, \bibinfo{address}{MI, USA}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Nardi and Harris(2006)]%
{nardi2006strangers}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Bonnie Nardi} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Justin Harris}.} \bibinfo{year}{2006}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Strangers and friends: collaborative play in world of warcraft}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 2006 20th Anniversary Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work}} (Banff, Alberta, Canada) \emph{(\bibinfo{series}{CSCW '06})}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{149–158}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{1595932496}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1145/1180875.1180898}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Nardi et~al\mbox{.}(2007)]%
{nardi2007learning}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Bonnie~A Nardi}, \bibinfo{person}{Stella Ly}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Justin Harris}.} \bibinfo{year}{2007}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Learning conversations in World of Warcraft}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{2007 40th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS'07)}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{IEEE}, \bibinfo{address}{New Jersey, United States}, \bibinfo{pages}{79--79}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Neustaedter and Sengers(2012)]%
{neustaedter2012autobiographical}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Carman Neustaedter} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Phoebe Sengers}.} \bibinfo{year}{2012}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Autobiographical design: what you can learn from designing for yourself}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{interactions}} \bibinfo{volume}{19}, \bibinfo{number}{6} (\bibinfo{year}{2012}), \bibinfo{pages}{28--33}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Petrovskaya and Zendle(2021)]%
{petrovskaya2021predatory}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Elena Petrovskaya} {and} \bibinfo{person}{David Zendle}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Predatory monetisation? A categorisation of unfair, misleading and aggressive monetisation techniques in digital games from the player perspective}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Journal of Business Ethics}} \bibinfo{volume}{181} (\bibinfo{year}{2021}), \bibinfo{pages}{1065–--1081}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Rapp(2017a)]%
{rapp2017designing}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Amon Rapp}.} \bibinfo{year}{2017}\natexlab{a}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Designing interactive systems through a game lens: An ethnographic approach}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Computers in human behavior}} \bibinfo{volume}{71} (\bibinfo{year}{2017}), \bibinfo{pages}{455--468}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Rapp(2017b)]%
{rapp2017games}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Amon Rapp}.} \bibinfo{year}{2017}\natexlab{b}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{From games to gamification: A classification of rewards in World of Warcraft for the design of gamified systems}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Simulation \& Gaming}} \bibinfo{volume}{48}, \bibinfo{number}{3} (\bibinfo{year}{2017}), \bibinfo{pages}{381--401}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Rapp(2018)]%
{rapp2018autoethnography}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Amon Rapp}.} \bibinfo{year}{2018}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Autoethnography in Human-Computer Interaction: Theory and Practice}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{Springer International Publishing}, \bibinfo{address}{Cham}, \bibinfo{pages}{25--42}.
\newblock
\showISBNx{978-3-319-73374-6}
\urldef\tempurl%
\url{https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-73374-6_3}
\showDOI{\tempurl}
\bibitem[Salda{\~n}a(2021)]%
{saldana2021coding}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Johnny Salda{\~n}a}.} \bibinfo{year}{2021}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{The coding manual for qualitative researchers}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{sage}, \bibinfo{address}{Thousand Oaks, CA, USA}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Simon(1997)]%
{simon1997models}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Herbert~Alexander Simon}.} \bibinfo{year}{1997}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Models of bounded rationality: Empirically grounded economic reason}}. Vol.~\bibinfo{volume}{3}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{MIT press}, \bibinfo{address}{MA, USA}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Su et~al\mbox{.}(2022)]%
{su2022perception}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Zihao Su}, \bibinfo{person}{Faysal~Hossain Shezan}, \bibinfo{person}{Yuan Tian}, \bibinfo{person}{David Evans}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Seongkook Heo}.} \bibinfo{year}{2022}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{{Perception Hacking for 2D Cursorjacking in Virtual Reality}}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Proceedings of the 1st Workshop on Novel Challenges of Safety, Security and Privacy in Extended Reality}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{Association for Computing Machinery}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{numpages}{5}~pages.
\newblock
\bibitem[Sund{\'e}n(2012)]%
{sunden2012desires}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Jenny Sund{\'e}n}.} \bibinfo{year}{2012}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Desires at play: On closeness and epistemological uncertainty}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Games and Culture}} \bibinfo{volume}{7}, \bibinfo{number}{2} (\bibinfo{year}{2012}), \bibinfo{pages}{164--184}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Thaler and Sunstein(2009)]%
{thaler2009nudge}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Richard~H Thaler} {and} \bibinfo{person}{Cass~R Sunstein}.} \bibinfo{year}{2009}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Nudge: Improving decisions about health, wealth, and happiness}}.
\newblock \bibinfo{publisher}{Penguin}, \bibinfo{address}{London, United Kingdom}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Turner et~al\mbox{.}(2022)]%
{turner2022hard}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Sarah Turner}, \bibinfo{person}{Jason~RC Nurse}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Shujun Li}.} \bibinfo{year}{2022}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{``It was hard to find the words'': Using an Autoethnographic Diary Study to Understand the Difficulties of Smart Home Cyber Security Practices}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems Extended Abstracts}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{ACM}, \bibinfo{address}{New York, NY, USA}, \bibinfo{pages}{1--8}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Waldman(2020)]%
{waldman2020cognitive}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Ari~Ezra Waldman}.} \bibinfo{year}{2020}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Cognitive biases, dark patterns, and the ‘privacy paradox’}.
\newblock \bibinfo{journal}{\emph{Current opinion in psychology}} \bibinfo{volume}{31} (\bibinfo{year}{2020}), \bibinfo{pages}{105--109}.
\newblock
\bibitem[Zagal et~al\mbox{.}(2013)]%
{zagal2013dark}
\bibfield{author}{\bibinfo{person}{Jos{\'e}~P Zagal}, \bibinfo{person}{Staffan Bj{\"o}rk}, {and} \bibinfo{person}{Chris Lewis}.} \bibinfo{year}{2013}\natexlab{}.
\newblock \showarticletitle{Dark patterns in the design of games}. In \bibinfo{booktitle}{\emph{Foundations of Digital Games 2013}}. \bibinfo{publisher}{ACM}, \bibinfo{address}{Crete, Greece}, \bibinfo{numpages}{8}~pages.
\newblock
\end{thebibliography}