APOGEE chemical abundances of stars in the MW satellites Fornax, Sextans, Draco and Carina
Extracted source text · arXiv 2511.06820
% aa.dem
% AA vers. 9.1, LaTeX class for Astronomy & Astrophysics
% demonstration file
% (c) EDP Sciences
%-----------------------------------------------------------------------
%
%\documentclass[referee]{aa} % for a referee version
%\documentclass[onecolumn]{aa} % for a paper on 1 column
%\documentclass[longauth]{aa} % for the long lists of affiliations
%\documentclass[letter]{aa} % for the letters
%\documentclass[bibyear]{aa} % if the references are not structured
% according to the author-year natbib style
%
\documentclass{aa}
\newcommand{\mmax}{m_{\mathrm{max}}}
\newcommand{\mob}{M_{\mathrm{OB}}}
\newcommand{\nob}{N_{\mathrm{OB}}}
\newcommand{\rtid}{R_{\mathrm{tid}}}
\newcommand{\rh}{R_{\mathrm{h}}}
\newcommand{\mrh}{M_{\mathrm{rh}}}
\newcommand{\rc}{R_{\mathrm{c}}}
\newcommand{\mtid}{M_{\mathrm{tid}}}
\newcommand{\ftid}{f_{\mathrm{tid}}}
\newcommand{\mbh}{M_{\mathrm{BH}}}
\newcommand{\nrh}{N_{\mathrm{rh}}}
\newcommand{\abbh}{a_{\mathrm{BBH}}}
\newcommand{\mave}{\langle m_{\mathrm{s}} \rangle}
\newcommand{\ns}{N_{\mathrm{s}}}
\newcommand{\ntid}{N_{\mathrm{tid}}}
\newcommand{\mout}{M_{\mathrm{out}}}
\newcommand{\nout}{N_{\mathrm{out}}}
\newcommand{\trh}{T_{\mathrm{rh}}}
\newcommand\red[1]{\color{red}#1}
%
\usepackage{float}
\usepackage{graphicx}
\usepackage{longtable}
\usepackage{threeparttable}
\usepackage{natbib}
\usepackage{txfonts}
\usepackage{color}
\usepackage{enumerate}
\usepackage{listings}
\usepackage{bm}
\usepackage{hyperref}
\usepackage{comment}
%\usepackage[section]{placeins}
\defcitealias{2020A&A...641A.127R}{R20}
\defcitealias{2023A&A...669A.125T}{T23}
%\defcitealias{Reichert2020}{R20}
\usepackage{enumitem}
\setlist[enumerate]{label=\textbullet}
\hypersetup{
colorlinks=true,
pdfborder=2 2 0.,
linkcolor=blue,
anchorcolor=black,
citecolor=blue,
urlcolor=black,
}
%\usepackage{refcheck}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%\usepackage[options]{hyperref}
%\hypersetup{colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue,citecolor=blue,filecolor=magenta,urlcolor=blue}
% To add links in your PDF file, use the package "hyperref"
% with options according to your LaTeX or PDFLaTeX drivers.
%
\begin{document}
\title{APOGEE Chemical Abundances of Stars in the MW Satellites Fornax, Sextans, Draco and Carina}
\titlerunning{MW satellites}
\authorrunning{Xu et~al.}
%\subtitle{}
\author{Cheng Xu\inst{1,2}, Yi Qiao\inst{1,2}, Baitian Tang\inst{1,2}, Jos\'e G. Fern\'andez-Trincado\inst{3}, Zhiqiang Yan \inst{4,5}, and Doug Geisler \inst{6,7}}
\institute{Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Sun Yat-sen University, Zhuhai, Guangdong Province, China \\
\email{tangbt@sysu.edu.cn}
\and{CSST Science Center for the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macau Greater Bay Area, Zhuhai 519082, China}
\and{Instituto de Astronom\'ia, Universidad Cat\'olica del Norte, Av. Angamos 0610, Antofagasta, Chile}
\and{School of Astronomy and Space Science, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, PR China}
\and{Key Laboratory of Modern Astronomy and Astrophysics (Nanjing University), Ministry of Education, Nanjing 210093, PR China}
\and{Departamento de Astronom\'{i}a, Casilla 160-C, Universidad de Concepci\'{o}n, Concepci\'{o}n, Chile}
%\and{Instituto de Investigaci\'on Multidisciplinario en Ciencia y Tecnolog\'ia, Universidad de La Serena. Avenida Ra\'ul Bitr\'an S/N, La Serena, Chile}
\and{Departamento de Astronom\'ia, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de La Serena. Av. Ra\'ul Bitr\'an 1305, La Serena, Chile}
}
\date{Received --, --; accepted --, --}
%\abstract{}{}{}{}{}
%5 {} token are mandatory
\abstract
%\begin{abstract}
% don't write them separately.
\abstract{During its evolution, the Milky Way (MW) incorporated numerous dwarf galaxies, particularly low-mass systems. The surviving dwarf galaxies orbiting the MW serve as exceptional laboratories for studying the unique properties of these systems. Their metal-poor environments and shallow gravitational potentials likely drive significant differences in star formation and star cluster properties compared to those in the MW. Using high-quality near-infrared spectra from the APOGEE survey, we determined abundances of Fe, C, N, O, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, Cr, Mn, Ni, and Ce for 74 stars in four MW satellite dwarf galaxies: Fornax, Sextans, Draco, and Carina.
Our analysis reveals that the distribution of $\alpha$ elements (e.g., [Si/Fe]) strongly correlates with galaxy luminosity (and hence mass), underscoring the critical role of galaxy mass in shaping chemical evolution. These dwarf galaxies exhibit [Al/Fe$]\sim -0.5$, which is comparable to those of the metal-poor stars in the MW. Additionally, we identified nitrogen-rich field stars in the Fornax dwarf galaxy, which display distinct metallicities compared to its known globular clusters (GCs). If these stars originated in GCs and subsequently escaped, their presence suggests we are observing relics of destroyed GCs, offering possible evidence of cluster disruption.
}
\keywords{dwarf galaxies --
chemical abundances --
globular clusters
}
\maketitle
%
%-------------------------------------------------------------------
\section{Introduction}
Galaxies represent the fundamental building blocks of the universe. Their observed scaling relations, e.g., the mass-luminosity relation \citep[e.g.,][]{2003ApJS..149..289B}, and the mass-metallicity relation \citep[e.g.,][]{1979A&A....80..155L, 2012A&A...547A..79F}, play a pivotal role in deciphering galaxy formation and evolution across diverse cosmic environments characterized by variations in age, metallicity, and redshift. Nevertheless, the underlying physical mechanisms driving these processes remain subjects of ongoing scientific debate. In this context, the ability to resolve galaxies into their constituent stars provides the most direct observational approach for probing their assembly histories.
The hierarchical galaxy formation paradigm suggests that dwarf galaxies originate within dark matter subhalos, subsequently merging to assemble larger galactic systems like the Milky Way (MW). This framework is observationally supported by the numerous dwarf satellites identified in the MW’s vicinity \citep{1971ARA&A...9...35H,1989ARA&A..27..139H, 2003AJ....125.1926G, 2009ARA&A..47..371T, 2012AJ....144....4M,2013ApJ...765L..15I, 2014ApJ...789..147W,2019ARA&A..57..375S}. Recent discoveries have further revealed both tidally disrupting systems, such as the Sagittarius (Sgr) stream \citep[][]{2003ApJ...599.1082M,2010ApJ...718.1128L}, and fully disrupted remnants including the Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus \citep[GSE;][]{2018MNRAS.478..611B,2018Natur.563...85H}, and the Sequoia \citep[e.g.,][]{2019MNRAS.488.1235M} substructures.
These systems display remarkable diversity in mass distribution, morphological configuration, and stellar population properties. Through comparative analysis with numerical simulations, they offer critical insights into halo assembly processes, the environmental regulation of galaxy formation, and their dynamical interactions throughout cosmic history.
%Due to the low stellar densities and surface brightness, dwarf galaxies are challenging to observe. However, the release of Gaia data has enabled the tracing of some early mergers through their clustering in orbital and kinematical parameter space, exemplified by the discoveries of Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus \citep[GSE;][]{2018MNRAS.478..611B,2018Natur.563...85H} and Sequoia \citep[e.g.,][]{2019MNRAS.488.1235M}. More recent minor mergers between dwarf galaxies and the Milky Way (MW) have produced spectacular observable stellar streams, such as the Sagittarius (Sgr) stream \citep[e.g.,][]{2003ApJ...599.1082M,2010ApJ...718.1128L}. Therefore, stars formed in these dissolved and dissolving dwarf galaxies constitute important building blocks of the MW, providing strong evidence for the hierarchical galaxy formation theory.
The stellar chemical abundance patterns of galaxies serve as a fossil record of their evolutionary history. For example, stars in dwarf galaxies show systematically lower metallities than those of MW stars. Furthermore, the characteristic ``knee'' in the [$\alpha$/Fe]-[Fe/H] trend provides a diagnostic tool for estimating the star formation history in dwarf galaxies \citep[e.g.,][]{1979ApJ...229.1046T,2003AJ....125..684S,2006ApJ...653.1145K,2014ApJ...796...38N,2020AJ....159...46K,2020ApJ...895...88N}. Building on this framework, \citet{2021ApJ...923..172H} proposed the potential occurrence of a second starburst episode in several nearby MW satellite galaxies, inferred from chemical evolution modeling of their [$\alpha$/Fe]–[Fe/H] distributions.
High-precision abundance measurements also enable investigations into variations in the stellar initial mass function (IMF) across galactic environments \citep[e.g.,][]{2013ApJ...778..149M,2017ApJ...845..162H,2018ApJ...859L..10C}. These chemical signatures collectively offer critical insights into the diverse physical processes governing galaxy assembly and evolution.
% or the degree of chemical pollution from asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars \citep[e.g.,][]{2000A&A...359..663B,2004AJ....128.1177V,2007A&A...465..815S,2018ApJ...855...83H,2019A&A...631A.171S,2020A&A...641A.127R,2020ApJ...903L..17F}. (\textcolor{red} {why only mention AGB, what about SNe II \& Ia?})
%Fortunately, the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment \citep[APOGEE;][]{2017AJ....154...94M} has obtained high-resolution spectra not only of stars in the MW but also in several of its nearby satellite galaxies. These include the most massive systems such as the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), Sagittarius (Sgr) dwarf galaxy, Fornax (Fnx) dwarf galaxy, and GSE. Additionally, APOGEE spectra also cover stars from smaller and less massive dwarf galaxies, such as Sculptor (Scl), Sextans (Sex), Carina (Car), Draco (Dra), and Ursa Minor (UMi). Using the APOGEE pipeline results, \citet{2021ApJ...923..172H} systematically investigated the chemical abundances of multiple elements (C, N, O, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Fe, Ni, and Ce) in LMC, SMC, Sgr, Fnx, and GSE. Their chemical modeling in the [$\alpha$/Fe]–[Fe/H] space revealed detailed star formation epochs and suggested the possible occurrence of a second starburst.
Clustered star formation is ubiquitously observed across cosmic time, manifesting in both the low-redshift (low-z) Universe \citep{2024arXiv241107424P} and the high-z Universe \citep[e.g.,][]{2024Natur.632..513A}.
Surviving star clusters serve as crucial tracers of galactic star formation histories. These stellar systems are typically classified into open clusters and globular clusters (GCs), with the latter exhibiting distinctive chemical abundance patterns characterized by N, Na, and Al enhancements alongside C, O, and Mg depletion \citep{2010A&A...516A..55C,2015ApJ...808...51M,2015AJ....149..153M,2018ARA&A..56...83B,2017MNRAS.465...19T,2018ApJ...855...38T,2021ApJ...908..220T,2021ApJ...906..133L} --- a phenomenon recognized as multiple populations (MPs). Our ongoing research initiative, ``Scrutinizing {\bf GA}laxy-{\bf ST}a{\bf R} cluster coevoluti{\bf ON} with chem{\bf O}dyna{\bf MI}cs ({\bf GASTRONOMI})'', employs multi-wavelength photometric and spectroscopic data to unravel the coevolutionary relationships between the MW, its satellite dwarf galaxies, and their stellar clusters. Recent analysis of MP detections in ancient star clusters by \citet{HT2024} reveals two critical parameters governing MP formation: cluster compactness and metallicity. Intriguingly, this study found an absence of MPs in younger Sgr-associated clusters (<8 Gyr), contrasting sharply with their older counterparts. This disparity may reflect the metallicity evolution of the galactic environment, suggesting suboptimal conditions for MP formation in metal-rich settings.
Extending this investigation to the Sculptor dwarf galaxy (Scl), \citet[][hereafter T23]{2023A&A...669A.125T} reported no detectable GCs or chemically peculiar stars indicative of GC dissolution. Our modeling analysis of APOGEE chemical abundance data yields a top-light IMF for Scl, characterized by a high-mass slope of $-2.7$. This paucity of massive stars aligns with the observed dearth of compact star clusters, which typically serve as nurseries for high-mass star formation.
%Although Fnx has been extensively studied over the past few years \citep[e.g.,][]{2006yCat..34590423B,2011ApJ...742...20W,2012ApJ...756L...2A,2015MNRAS.454.3996D,2017MNRAS.465.3708D,2023MNRAS.519.3611F}, there remain intriguing questions about its stellar populations and their origins. Notably, Fnx is the least massive dwarf galaxy known to host globular clusters (GCs) apart from Sagittarius (Sgr).
As GCs orbit their host galaxies, they gradually lose stars to the field population through dynamical processes, with some clusters eventually dissolving entirely. Identifying these GC escapees is important for modeling galaxy-star cluster interactions, yet their kinematic resemblance to halo stars makes them challenging to detect. Recent studies have uncovered a substantial population of nitrogen-rich (N-rich) field stars in the MW \citep[e.g.,][]{2015A&A...575L..12L,2016ApJ...825..146M,2017MNRAS.465..501S,2016ApJ...833..132F,2017ApJ...846L...2F,2019MNRAS.488.2864F,2019ApJ...871...58T,
%2019ApJ...886L...8F,2020A&A...644A..83F,2020A&A...643L...4F,2020MNRAS.495.4113F,2021ApJ...918L..37F,
2021ApJ...913...23Y,2022A&A...663A.126F}, which shared the most significant feature of MPs in GCs $-$ N-enhancement. These stars are widely regarded as the strongest candidates for escaped GC members. Moreover, N-rich field stars have been detected in the Magellanic clouds (MCs) and Sgr \citep{2020ApJ...903L..17F, 2021A&A...648A..70F}, extending the evidence for GC dissolution to diverse galactic environments. By combining observations of extant GCs with their dispersed stellar remnants, we can construct a more complete picture of GC evolution, dissolution histories, and their role in shaping galactic stellar populations.
%This raises the question of whether Fnx, as a GC-hosting dwarf galaxy, also harbors N-rich stars in its field. Detecting and characterizing such stars could provide critical insights into the contribution of GCs to the stellar population of Fnx, as well as the interactions between GCs and their host galaxies. Future investigations into the presence of N-rich stars in the Fnx field, especially using high-resolution spectroscopic data, could help clarify the evolutionary history of Fnx. By identifying and tracing the origins of these stars, we may better understand the role of GCs in enriching and shaping the stellar populations of dwarf galaxies, as well as the mechanisms behind GC disruption and mass loss in these systems.
%What about lower-mass MW satellites? Can we identify N-rich field stars there? What is the connection between star cluster properties and galaxy chemical evolution in these systems?
How do lower-mass Milky Way satellites contribute to our understanding of galactic chemical evolution? Can N-rich field stars be identified in these systems, and what do they reveal about the interplay between star cluster dynamics and galaxy evolution?
In this study, we present detailed chemical abundance measurements for up to 13 elements across four dwarf spheroidal galaxies: Fornax (Fnx), Draco (Dra), Carina (Car), and Sextans (Sex). Section~\ref{sec:Data} outlines the data acquisition and reduction. In Section~\ref{sec: result}, we systematically compare abundance patterns for $\alpha$-elements (O, Mg, Si), iron-peak species (Cr, Mn, Ni), and neutron-capture elements (e.g., Ce), highlighting both commonalities and divergences across these satellite systems. We further examine radial abundance gradients and investigate the presence of N-rich field stars, discussing their potential origins and implications in Section~\ref{sec:discussion}. Finally, our conclusions and a summary of key findings are outlined in Section~\ref{sec: summary}.
%星系是宇宙中最常见的结构，并且无处不在。尽管到目前为止，我们对于星系的理解和研究（比如质量光度关系，质量金属丰度关系，星系颜色亮度关系等方面）取得了很大的进展，但是对于星系形成演化的细节却所知甚少。因为仅有少数星系可以被分辨单颗恒星，而大量的精确的单个恒星的研究对于分析星系的恒星形成历史非常关键。经典的分层理论认为，矮星系首先在暗物质子晕中形成，之后通过合并形成更大的星系，例如我们的银河系，所以对银河系以及近邻矮星系的研究将对我们揭示星系的形成演化和相互作用至关重要，幸运的是，在银河系附近存在大量的矮星系，而矮椭球星系可以说是宇宙中最常见的星系类型，它们在质量，结构，形态，恒星环境等各个方面都具有很大范围的变化（Hodge 1971, 1989；Mateo 1998；Grebel 等（2003）；Tolstoy等人，2009；McConnachie 2012；Ibata等人，2013；Weisz等人，2014；Simon）。理论上，如果可以通过光度乃至光谱观测足够多的样本，就可以帮助我们理解星系晕结构的形成，不同星系的形成环境，以及星系之间的相互作用历史等。
%由于矮星系一般具有较低的恒星密度，较低的表面亮度，所以不容易被观测到。由于Gaia数据的发布，一些早期的合并可以通过其在轨道和动力学参数空间中的聚类被追溯，例如Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus（GSE，Belokurov等，2018；Helmi等，2018）和Sequoia（如Myeong等，2019）的发现。一些最近的矮星系与银河系的小规模合并形成了壮观的可观测星流，例如人马座（Sgr）星流（如Majewski等，2003；Law & Majewski，2010）。因此，在这些已经解体和正在解体的矮星系中形成的恒星是我们银河系的重要组成部分，这也是星系分层理论的强有力的证据。尽管动力学的研究可以帮助我们一定程度上理解星系间的相互作用，但是光谱研究可以揭示更多的细节，例如矮星系的一个重要特征是在相同的【Fe/H】下，其【alpha/Fe]丰度要对于银河系，并且α元素丰度趋势中的“拐点”可以帮助我们估计矮星系早期的恒星形成效率（SFEs）（例如，Tinsley 1979；Shetrone等人，2003；Kobayashi等人，2006；Nidever等人，2014；Kirby等人，2020，Nidever等人，2020， Hasselquist等人，2021）。通过详细的丰度模式研究，还可以探究星系初始质量函数（IMF）变化（例如，McWilliam等人，2013；Hasselquist等人，2017；Carlin等人，2018， Tang等人，2023）或来自渐近巨星分支（AGB）恒星的污染量（例如，Bonifacio等人，2000；Venn等人，2004；Sbordone等人，2007；Hansen等人，2018；Skúladóttir等人，2019；Reichert等人，2020；Fernández-Trincado等人，2020）。
%幸运的是，阿帕奇点天文台银河系演化实验（APOGEE，Majewski等，2017）获取的高分辨率光谱，不止包含银河系的恒星光谱，还包含了一些近邻的卫星星系：例如最具质量的LMC，SMC，Sgr，Fnx以及GSE，同时其光谱中也包含了一些Sculptor，Sextans，Carina，Draco，Ursa Minor等几个低质量矮星系的恒星光谱。而Hasselquist等（2021）利用APOGEE pipeline给出的结果系统探讨了大麦哲伦星云（LMC）和小麦哲伦星云（SMC）、人马座矮星系（Sgr）、长蛇座矮星系（Fornax）以及GSE的多种元素（CNO、Mg、Al、Si、Ca、Fe、Ni和Ce）的化学丰度。[α/Fe]–[Fe/H]空间的化学建模揭示了详细的恒星形成时期，并可能存在第二次恒星爆发。Tang等人2023使用BACCHUS对Sculptor的APOGEE光谱求出多种化学元素丰度，并且建立了化学演化模型，发现Scl应该具有一个 top-light initial mass function (IMF), with a high-mass IMF power index of ∼−2.7, and a minimum Type Ia supernovae delay time of ∼100 Myr，同时alpha元素的径向丰度梯度也证实了Scl具有outside-in formation scenario。对于APOGEE的光谱上述提到的矮星系都有不少的研究，为了扩充矮星系的样本，我们也期待对于Sex，Dra，Car等几个小质量矮星系的APOGEE光谱进行处理，
%###我们希望通过APOGEE光谱获取这些矮星系的化学元素丰度，这里是分别介绍每个矮星系的相关研究吗，还是整体说对矮星系的相关工作，这几个矮星系我找了相关研究，发现如果都介绍都说的话，好像会特别多内容，从运动学动力学还有测光部分光谱研究都有相关的文献。
%尽管Fnx在过去十几年间，已经存在大量的研究（e.g. Battaglia et al. 2006， Matthew G. Walker2011， Amorisco & Evans 2012; del Pino et al. 2015, 2017）。。。此外，Fnx是已知除Sgr外具有球状星团质量最小的矮星系，在此前对于银河系球状星团的研究中，我们在场中发现大量的N-rich场星，并且其中部分恒星表明了其球状星团的来源（e.g. Tang etal 2017,2019，Yu，Jose，Xu），那么对于Fnx，我们也期待是否能在场中发现N-rich的恒星，证认这些N-rich的恒星是否可以帮助我们认识了解Fnx的GC对于Fnx的恒星贡献以及相互作用等。
%在这项工作中，我们从APOGEE光谱中获取了化学元素丰度，我们展示了Fnx,Dra,Car,Sex这四个矮星系中至多13种元素的详细化学丰度模式。In Section~\ref{sec:sample}, we describe our data and reduction processes. 并且我们也将我们的结果与APOGEE Pipeline以及文献中的数据进行对比. We compare chemical abundances of O, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, Cr, Mn, Ni, Ce with those of the MW and other dwarf galaxies in Section~\ref{sec:result}. We further discuss radial chemical gradients and N-rich field stars (Section \ref{sec:discussion}). Our final conclusions are outlined in Section~\ref{sec:conclusion}.-------------------------------------------------------------------
\section{Data Reduction}
\label{sec:Data}
\subsection{Observational data}
\label{sec:Obv}
The near-infrared (H-band, $\lambda$ = 1.51 -- 1.69 $\mu$m), high-resolution (R $\sim$ 22,500) spectra are provided by the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE, \citealt{2017AJ....154...94M}), which was part of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey III (SDSS-III, \citealt{2011AJ....142...72E}) and SDSS-IV \citep{2017AJ....154...28B}.
The APOGEE survey were carried out with two telescopes: the 2.5 m telescope at the Apache Point Observatory \citep{2017AJ....154...28B} and the 2.5 m du Pont telescope at the Las Campanas Observatory \citep{1973ApOpt..12.1430B}. The APOGEE survey sample primarily consists of red giant stars (RGB) across the MW \citep{2017AJ....154...94M,2021AJ....162..303S,2021AJ....162..302B}. To date, APOGEE has observed nearly a million stars, covering the MW and neighboring galaxies. Furthermore, APOGEE data reduction software is used to simplify multiple 3D raw data cubes into well-sampled, calibrated combined 1D spectra \citep{2015AJ....150..173N}. Stellar parameters are derived using the FERRE code \citep{2006ApJ...636..804A}, which finds the best solution by comparing the observed spectra with the libraries of theoretical spectra \citep{2015AJ....149..181Z}.
With 17 data releases of SDSS (DR 17, \citealt{2022ApJS..259...35A}) to date, dwarf galaxies in the vicinity of the MW have been observed multiple times, and the signal-to-noise ratios (S/N) have reached a level sufficient for chemical analysis. In this work, we cross-matched the catalogs of \citet{2018A&A...616A..12G} and APOGEE DR17 to select potential member stars of Fnx, Dra, Car, and Sex dwarf galaxies. To reduce the uncertainties of derived chemical abundances, we excluded spectra with $S/N< 70$. Furthermore, we examined the radial velocities (RVs) of these candidates (Table \ref{Tabel:Dwarf members stellar parameters}), finding that the RVs of all member stars fall within $3\sigma$ range. Therefore, the reliability of these member stars is confirmed by their spatial positions, proper motions, and RVs. There are 32 members in Fnx, 14 members in Dra, 19 members in Car, and 8 members in Sex. The locations of our Fnx sample stars and their positions in the color–magnitude diagram are plotted in Fig. \ref{fig:FornaxCMD}.
%First, we derive T$_{eff}$ and log $g$ using photometric measurements. Next, to deal with the weak lines of metal-poor stars in these dwarf galaxies, we derive chemical abundances using a Turbospectrum wrapper --- Bacchus \citep{2016ascl.soft05004M}. We follow exactly the same routine as outlined in \citetalias{2023A&A...669A.125T}. Readers are referred to that paper for detailed data reduction procedures. The derived results are shown in Tables \ref{Tabel:Dwarf members stellar parameters} \& \ref{tab:abundances}.
\begin{figure*}[htbp]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=0.85\textwidth]{FORNAX_SDF_CMD_snr70.pdf}
\caption{Target information. (a): Spatial distribution of target stars in Fnx dwarf galaxy. The black ellipse indicates the tidal radius of Fnx and its center is labelled with black cross. Target stars from \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R} and this work are marked as blue triangles and red dots, respectively. The N-rich stars are further marked with red circles. The black stars represent GC Fnx 1-5 while the purple star represents GC Fnx 6. (b): Color--magnitude diagram of Fnx stars based on $Gaia\ DR3$ (grey dots).}
\label{fig:FornaxCMD}%
\end{figure*}
\begin{table*}
\caption{Basic information of our sample stars} % title of Table
\label{Tabel:Dwarf members stellar parameters} % is used to refer this table in the text
\centering % used for centering table
\setlength{\tabcolsep}{5pt}
\begin{tabular}{cccccccccccc} % centered columns
\hline\hline%\cline{2-9}
\\[-3pt]
\# & APOGEE ID & RA & DEC & $T_{eff}$ & log $g$ & $RV$ & S/N & Gmag & BP-RP & Dwarf Galaxy\\
& & [deg] & [deg] & [K] & & [km s$^{-1}$] & & [mag] & [mag]\\
\hline\\[-5pt]
1 & 2M02403081-3422028 & 40.12842 & $-34.36745$ & 3626 & 0.35 & 81 & 83 & 17.61 & 1.77 & Fnx\\
2 & 2M02372118-3437451 & 39.33825 & $-34.62923$ & 3845 & 0.74 & 63 & 112 & 17.59 & 1.93 & Fnx\\
3 & 2M02392578-3442220 & 39.85744 & $-34.70617$ & 3586 & 0.27 & 59 & 130 & 17.40 & 2.19 & Fnx\\
4 & 2M02402354-3415204 & 40.09813 & $-34.25565$ & 3552 & 0.24 & 36 & 96 & 17.70 & 2.06 & Fnx\\
5 & 2M02413913-3405505 & 40.41308 & $-34.09736$ & 3684 & 0.56 & 59 & 79 & 17.84 & 1.82 & Fnx\\
6 & 2M02381712-3425482 & 39.57135 & $-34.43009$ & 3696 & 0.56 & 54 & 114 & 17.51 & 2.18 & Fnx\\
7 & 2M02410066-3415551 & 40.25277 & $-34.26532$ & 3796 & 0.72 & 57 & 80 & 17.78 & 1.86 & Fnx\\
8 & 2M02380004-3444219 & 39.50015 & $-34.73947$ & 3806 & 0.75 & 40 & 85 & 17.80 & 1.88 & Fnx\\
9 & 2M02372718-3430033 & 39.36329 & $-34.50095$ & 4012 & 0.97 & 50 & 72 & 17.86 & 1.79 & Fnx\\
10 & 2M02390557-3432503 & 39.77323 & $-34.54732$ & 4054 & 1.01 & 57 & 76 & 17.85 & 1.83 & Fnx\\
... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
\hline %inserts single line
\end{tabular}
\tablefoot{Full table at the CDS.}
%see Table \ref{Table: Full Dwarf members stellar parameters}\textcolor{red}{Full table at the CDS. You don't need to show it in the appendix anymore. Same for table 2. Why there are two columns for logg???}}
\end{table*}
%\begin{comment}
%\textcolor{red}{I don't think Section 2.2 \& 2.3 is necessary if you copy most of them from the Scl paper.}
\subsection{Stellar parameters and chemical abundances}
%\begin{figure*}[htbp]
% \centering
% \includegraphics[width=0.875\textwidth]{dwarf_chemical/lines_example.pdf}
% \caption{\textcolor{red}{Key lines utilized to calculate chemical abundances in BACCHUS (take Mg, Al, N, Si as example). }}
% \label{fig:lines}%
%\end{figure*}
In this work, we determined the photometric effective temperature ($T_{\rm eff}$) using 2MASS photometry, following the method outlined by \citet{2009A&A...497..497G}. The final $T_{\rm eff}$ values were derived from the dereddened color indices ($J-K$), using the extinction map from \citet{1998ApJ...500..525S}. The surface gravity (log $g$) values were estimated from the canonical equation:
\begin{equation}
\log(\frac{g}{g_{\odot}})=\log(\frac{M}{M_{\odot}})+4\log(\frac{T}{T_{\odot}})-\log(\frac{L}{L_{\odot}})
\end{equation}
where the stellar mass is assumed to be 0.8 solar mass. To estimate the bolometric luminosities, we apply the bolometric correction procedure described by \citet{1999A&AS..140..261A}. The derived values of $T_{\rm eff}$ and $\log g$ are presented in Table \ref{Tabel:Dwarf members stellar parameters}. The uncertainties of $T_{\rm eff}$ are dominated by those of the $T_{\rm eff}$-($J-K$) relation, which is 94 K. The $T_{\rm eff}$ uncertainties are propagated to the estimation of $\log g$ uncertainties.
Chemical abundances under the assumption of local thermal equilibrium (LTE), were analyzed using the Brussels Automatic Stellar Parameter (BACCHUS) code \citep{2016ascl.soft05004M}. Built upon the radiative transfer code, Turbospectrum \citep{1998A&A...330.1109A, 2012ascl.soft05004P}, BACCHUS interpolates model atmospheres from the MARCS model grids \citep{2008A&A...486..951G}. The code's meticulous line selection and inspection capabilities were essential for analyzing the weak spectral lines characteristic of the metal-poor stars in our sample.
For each absorption line, the abundance derivation began with a sigma-clipping selection of continuum regions, followed by a linear fit. This step identifies and rejects poor fits caused by features like bad pixels or abrupt spectral drops. The abundance is then estimated by comparing the observed and synthetic spectra using four independent methods: (1) $\chi^2$ minimization of the overall fit; (2) comparison of the line core intensity; (3) equivalent width analysis; and (4) spectral synthesis (see Fig. 12 of \citealt{2021ApJ...913...23Y}). Each method is assigned a quality flag. To ensure robustness, we only accepted an abundance measurement if all four methods yielded a satisfactory fit; otherwise, the line was rejected.
Given the prevalence of CO, CN, and OH molecular lines in the APOGEE spectral range, we determined the abundances of C, N, O, and Fe in a self-consistent, iterative procedure to account for their interdependencies, following \citet{2013ApJ...765...16S}. We first derived the oxygen abundance from $^{16}$OH lines, then carbon from $^{12}$C$^{16}$O, and nitrogen from $^{12}$C$^{14}$N, before determining the iron abundance from Fe I lines.
With these key elements established, we performed a line-by-line analysis of atomic lines for Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, Cr, Mn, Ni, and Ce. While strong lines for Mg, Al, and Si allowed for a comprehensive analysis, many lines for Cr, Mn, Ni, and Ce, as well as some molecular $^{12}$C$^{16}$O and $^{12}$C$^{14}$N lines, were too weak for reliable measurement. These were carefully inspected and excluded from the final abundance set. The resulting chemical abundances are presented in Table \ref{tab:abundances}, with solar abundances adopted from \citet{2005ASPC..336...25A} as our reference. Other elements, such as sodium (Na), were not analyzed due to their weak and unreliable absorption lines in our data.
%In the wavelength range covered by APOGEE spectra, molecular lines of CO, CN, and OH are significant features that may impact line-by-line abundance analysis. To account for this, we estimated the abundances of carbon (C), nitrogen (N), oxygen (O), and iron (Fe) in a self-consistent manner. We began by determining the $^{16}$O abundance using $^{16}$OH lines. Subsequently, we derived the $^{12}$C abundance from $^{12}$C$^{16}$O lines, and $^{14}$N abundance from $^{12}$C$^{14}$N. Iron abundances were then determined using Fe I lines. This process was iteratively repeated to minimize the interdependence of the molecular lines and Fe I lines, following the methodology outlined by \citet{2013ApJ...765...16S}. Following the derivation of these key elements, we performed a line-by-line analysis of atomic lines \textcolor{red}{(see \textbf{Fig.\ref{fig:lines}})} for magnesium (Mg), aluminum (Al), silicon (Si), calcium (Ca), titanium (Ti), chromium (Cr), manganese (Mn), nickel (Ni), and cerium (Ce). Strong atomic lines for Mg, Al, and Si were present within the observed wavelength range, enabling a comprehensive abundance analysis for these elements across our sample stars. However, a number of the atomic lines for Cr, Mn, Ni, and Ce, as well as the molecular lines for $^{12}$C$^{16}$O and $^{12}$C$^{14}$O, were too weak to yield reliable measurements. These lines were, therefore, visually inspected and excluded to avoid inaccurate detections. The chemical abundances derived from our analysis are presented in Table \ref{tab:abundances}. For this study, we adopted the solar abundances from \citet{2005ASPC..336...25A} as a reference. Some other elements (e.g. Na), due to the week atomic absorption line, were not discussed here.
We first estimated the uncertainties of chemical abundances caused by individual stellar parameter error: $\sigma_{\Delta T_{\rm eff}}, \sigma_{\Delta \log g}$, and $\sigma_{\Delta {\rm [Fe/H]}}$, where their typical errors were set as: $\Delta T_{\rm eff} = 100\,{\rm K}$, $\Delta \log g = 0.25\,{\rm dex}$.
Subsequently, the total estimated error is : $\sigma_{\rm tot} = [ (\sigma_{\Delta T_{\rm eff}})^2 + (\sigma_{\Delta \log g})^2 + (\sigma_{\Delta {\rm [Fe/H]}})^2 ]^{1/2}$. The errors for Star \#10 are shown in Table \ref{Table: abu_err} as an example.
\begin{table*}
\caption{Errors of chemical abundances propagated from atmospheric parameters for star \#10. }
%{(The errors of C\&N\&Ti are greater than 0.5 dex???)} Star 5 or Star 10??
\label{Table: abu_err}
\centering % used for centering table
\setlength{\tabcolsep}{5pt}
\begin{tabular}{c c c c c}
\hline
\hline\\[-3pt]
Element & $\Delta T_{\rm eff}=100 {\rm \,(K)}$ & $\Delta \log (g) = 0.25$\,(dex) & $\Delta {\rm [Fe/H]} = 0.1$\,(dex) & $\sigma_{\rm tot}$ \\
%Element & abundance & \tabincell{c}{$\Delta T_{\rm eff}=50$\\(K)} & \tabincell{c}{$\Delta \log (g) = 0.1$\\(dex)} & \tabincell{c}{$\Delta {\rm [Fe/H]} = 0.05$\\(dex)} & $\sigma{\rm tot}$ \\
\hline\\[-5pt]
%{\rm [Fe/H]} & 0.034 & 0.211 & 0.020 & 0.215 \\
{\rm [C/Fe]} & 0.251 & 0.357 & 0.292 & 0.525 \\
{\rm [N/Fe]} & 0.282 & 0.385 & 0.279 & 0.553 \\
{\rm [O/Fe]} & 0.189 & 0.092 & 0.012 & 0.211 \\
{\rm [Mg/Fe]} & 0.154 & 0.173 & 0.129 & 0.265 \\
{\rm [Al/Fe]} & 0.102 & 0.074 & 0.015 & 0.127 \\
{\rm [Si/Fe]} & 0.008 & 0.025 & 0.009 & 0.028 \\
{\rm [Ca/Fe]} & 0.064 & 0.164 & 0.021 & 0.177 \\
{\rm [Ti/Fe]} & 0.865 & 0.142 & 0.798 & 1.185 \\
{\rm [Cr/Fe]} & 0.134 & 0.226 & 0.025 & 0.264 \\
{\rm [Mn/Fe]} & 0.015 & 0.138 & 0.042 & 0.145 \\
{\rm [Ni/Fe]} & 0.010 & 0.023 & 0.054 & 0.060 \\
{\rm [Ce/Fe]} & 0.051 & 0.032 & 0.047 & 0.076 \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\end{table*}
%\end{comment}
\begin{figure*}[htbp]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=0.85\textwidth]{Alpha-FeH.pdf}
\caption{[$\alpha$/Fe] vs. [Fe/H]. Fnx, Dra, Car and Sex stars from this work are labeled as red, cyan, blue and green stars respectively. The error bar in each panel indicates the median uncertainty of available measurements. Black dots correspond to MW stars from the halo \citep{2000AJ....120.1841F,2004A&A...416.1117C,2005A&A...439..129B,2013ApJ...762...27Y,2014AJ....147..136R}, and MW stars from the disc \citep{2003MNRAS.340..304R,2006MNRAS.367.1329R,2014A&A...562A..71B}. Orange dots represent Sgr stars from \citet{2021ApJ...923..172H}. Purple squares represent GCs in Fnx from \citet{2022A&A...660A..88L}}
\label{fig: alpha}%
\end{figure*}
\begin{figure*}[htbp]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=14cm,height=8.5cm]{Al-FeH.pdf}
\caption{[Al/Fe] vs. [Fe/H] relations. Symbols are the same as in Fig.~\ref{fig: alpha}. }
\label{fig: Al-Fe}
\end{figure*}
%---------------------------------------------------
%are generally small. For instance, high-resolution studies have shown that NLTE effects on Mg can often be neglected \citep[e.g.,][]{2017ApJ...835...90Z,2020A&A...637A..80O,2022A&A...665A..33L}. However, at lower resolutions, these effects can impact Mg abundance derivations from APOGEE spectra \citep{2020A&A...637A..80O,2021A&A...647A..24M}. Such discrepancies in Mg abundances between APOGEE and optical data are particularly common in metal-poor giant stars \citepalias[e.g.,][]{2023A&A...669A.125T}.
\section{Results}
\label{sec: result}
\subsection{$\alpha$--elements}
\label{sec: result-alpha}
According to nucleosynthetic models \citep{2020ApJ...900..179K}, $\alpha$-elements are primarily synthesized in exploding massive stars (Type II supernovae, SNe II), while iron is produced by both Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) and SNe II. Since the timescale of SNe II ($\sim$ Myr) is much shorter than that of SNe Ia ($\sim 100$ Myr), the interstellar medium (ISM) is contaminated by $\alpha$-rich materials at earliest time. Therefore, high $\alpha$ abundances are generally observed in low metallicity stars. After the onset of SNe Ia, so-called `SNe Ia delay time', the ejection of large amounts of iron continues to increase the [Fe/H], but decreases the [Mg/Fe] of the ISM and thus the later formed stars. This point of decline, termed the ``knee'' in the $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ versus ${\rm [Fe/H]}$ trend, is influenced by the galaxy's star formation rate (SFR) and mass: generally the $\alpha$ knee appears at a lower metallicity in lower mass galaxies since they have a lower SFR \citep{2009ARA&A..47..371T}. %\textcolor{red}{For APOGEE targets, NLTE corrections for magnesium (Mg) abundance measurements are generally small (< 0.1 dex) in H-band, making LTE a reasonably good approximation for Mg itself \citep{nlte_mg_2020A&A...637A..80O}. }
%and post-turnover $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ levels are also lower than that in more massive galaxies. (I don't think this commonly accepted, you need citation for this!!!!!)
The relationship between $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ and ${\rm [Fe/H]}$ is illustrated in Fig. \ref{fig: alpha}, where background data include stars from the Galactic halo, disk, and dwarf galaxies. For each galaxy, we generally see a relatively constant $[\alpha/Fe]$ at low metallicity, which begins to decline above a certain metallicity, commonly referred as the $\alpha$ knee. However, the data are more complex than expected due to the uncertainties and systematics.
%Our sample stars exhibit a general trend of declining $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ with increasing metallicity. %Notably, this study represents the first precise measurements of near-infrared chemical abundances, particularly for Si, in Fnx, Car, Dra and Sex. \textcolor{red}{Caution!!!, the ASPCAP results of these galaxies have been published before this work.}
The Ti abundance measurements show larger dispersion due to the relatively weak absorption lines. Meanwhile, the O abundances also present a fairly large scattered distribution, particularly for metal-poor stars, which could be attributed to their iterated derivation procedures between C, N, O related molecular lines needed to achieve molecular equilibrium \citepalias{2023A&A...669A.125T}. Note that a few metal-rich Fnx stars ([Fe/H$]>-0.75$) show relatively high [O/Fe], probably due to their AGB nature with enhanced [Ce/Fe] (See Section \ref{sec: result-Neu}).
%Interestingly, some stars display O abundances comparable to those in MW stars. \textcolor{red}{This larger scatter compared to Mg, Si, and Ca, one of the reason could be they are derived from $^{16}$OH molecular lines. }
Our measured Mg abundances are systematically lower ($\sim 0.2$ dex) than those derived from the optical spectra, as we pointed out before.
%while using the common stars of \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}. This is probably due to the NLTE effect for Mg triplet ($\lambda \sim 15741, 15749, 15766$ \AA) in the APOGEE spectra \citep{2020A&A...637A..80O,2021A&A...647A..24M}.
Interestingly, a large portion of stars in Sex show low [Mg/Fe] ($\sim -0.6$), which may be related to the second knee implied by \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}.
We will further discuss the correlation between galaxy mass and $\alpha$-element distribution in Section \ref{sec:alphaknee}.
%We also compared our sample with optical data, where Mg and Ti are the common elements between optical and near-infrared observations. Their abundance trends are largely consistent, though we observed slightly lower Mg abundances overall, which is also found in previous studies \citep{2020A&A...641A.127R,2021ApJ...923..172H,2023A&A...669A.125T}.
%
%α元素主要通过II型超新星（SNe II）在大质量恒星中生成，然后喷射到星系介质中去，而铁主要通过Ia型超新星（SNe Ia）产生，因此alpha元素在星际介质中富集的时间远小于铁，显然，[α/Fe]丰度在最初会增强，但是在SNe Ia延迟时间之后，随着[Fe/H]的增加开始下降（Matteucci & Greggio 1986）。这种下降点，或称为[α/Fe]与[Fe/H]趋势中的“膝状”特征，与星系中恒星形成率和星系质量有关：一般来说，星系质量越小，[α/Fe]转折点越贫金属，并且在转折点之后的[α/Fe]也会相对大质量的星系更低。
%[α/Fe]与[Fe/H]的关系图见图3，背景中包含了银河系晕星，盘星以及矮星系的恒星。我们发现样本中的恒星的[α/Fe]都大体上呈现随着金属丰度增加而下降的趋势。并且我们留意到首先这是我们对Fornax等四个矮星系首次得到精确的近红外化学元素丰度的信息（尤其是Si）,其次对于Ti元素丰度，由于其光谱对应的吸收线相对较弱，所以呈现出一个较大的弥散，最后值得注意的是，我们的O元素丰度显示出一个比较弥散的分布，有部分恒星的O丰度与银河系恒星相近。（原因：光谱无误，吸收线明显，所以确实是O-rich？）
%我们还将得到的数据与光学数据进行对比，由于光学近红外共同的观测元素只有Mg，Ti。其分布趋势也较为一致，不过我们注意到我们得到的Mg元素丰度呈现出整体偏低的现象，这一结果与之前的工作都符合（R2020，H2021，T2023）
%另外，对于越大质量的星系，其[α/Fe]相应应该更高，在我们的结果中，银河系的质量远大于Sgr，Fnx，Sex，Car以及Dra，我们证实了银河系具有最高的[α/Fe]丰度，我们将得到的结果与Sgr系统对比发现，Fnx等四个矮星系的[α/Fe]系统性低于Sgr，这一结果与越小质量的星系产生越低的[α/Fe]丰度的结论相符。
\begin{table*}
\caption{Chemical abundances}
\label{tab:abundances}
\centering %\input{abundances.tex}
\setlength{\tabcolsep}{3pt}
\begin{tabular}{c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c}
\hline
\hline
\hline
\# & [Fe/H] & [C/Fe] & [N/Fe] & [O/Fe] & [Mg/Fe] & [Al/Fe] & [Si/Fe] & [Ca/Fe] & [Ti/Fe] & [Cr/Fe] & [Mn/Fe] & [Ni/Fe] & [Ce/Fe] & Dwarf Galaxy \\
\hline
\hline
1 & -1.65 & ... & ... & -0.13 & 0.11 & -0.47 & 0.28 & 0.15 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & Fornax \\
2 & -1.32 & ... & ... & ... & ... & -0.89 & -0.08 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & -0.07 & Fornax \\
3 & -1.21 & 0.45 & 0.56 & 0.35 & 0.29 & -0.42 & 0.39 & 0.14 & 0.04 & ... & ... & 0.11 & 0.19 & Fornax \\
4 & -1.12 & ... & ... & 0.05 & -0.09 & -0.81 & 0.07 & -0.09 & -0.51 & ... & -0.16 & ... & 0.14 & Fornax \\
5 & -1.1 & ... & ... & -0.31 & -0.05 & -0.43 & 0.18 & 0.04 & 0.22 & -0.27 & -0.04 & ... & 0.26 & Fornax \\
6 & -1.07 & 0.05 & -0.13 & 0.27 & -0.07 & -0.5 & 0.11 & 0.09 & -0.24 & -0.33 & -0.15 & -0.01 & 0.18 & Fornax \\
7 & -1.04 & -0.47 & 0.36 & -0.06 & ... & -0.46 & 0.03 & -0.01 & 0.15 & 0.03 & -0.25 & ... & 0.32 & Fornax \\
8 & -1.01 & -0.13 & 0.07 & 0.21 & ... & -0.8 & 0.12 & -0.03 & -0.29 & -0.15 & -0.17 & 0.09 & 0.32 & Fornax \\
9 & -0.99 & ... & ... & 0.47 & -0.13 & -0.32 & 0.15 & 0.24 & 0.14 & 0.14 & -0.09 & -0.37 & 0.46 & Fornax \\
10 & -0.98 & -0.52 & 1.23 & 0.46 & -0.19 & -0.38 & -0.05 & ... & 0.0 & -0.14 & -0.32 & ... & 0.07 & Fornax \\
... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\tablefoot{Full table at the CDS.}
\end{table*}
\subsection{Odd-Z element: Al}
\label{sec: result-Al}
Al is primarily synthesized in massive stars \citep{1971ApJ...166..153A, 1995ApJS..101..181W} and is released into the ISM via SNe II. Its yield may depend on the metallicity of the progenitor stars \citep[e.g.,][]{2019ApJ...874..102W}. Al also can be generated via high temperature hydrogen burning through the Mg-Al cycle \citep{arnould1999}, which can be found in stellar objects like Wolf-Rayet stellar winds \citep{2006ApJ...647..483L} and AGB stars.
%In this study, we have, for the first time, determined relatively precise Al abundances for a large number of member stars using Bacchus, whereas previous studies have mostly focused on larger sample sets with slightly lower precision (e.g., by directly applying ASPCAP results, as in \citealt{2021ApJ...923..172H}). Although our sample size is limited, we ensured high reliability in elemental abundances for most stars. \textcolor{red}{Try to avoid saying others are not good...}
As shown in Fig. \ref{fig: Al-Fe}, the Al abundances of our studied dwarf galaxies are systematically lower than those from the MW disk ([Fe/H$]>-1.5$). However, they are comparable to some MW halo stars ([Fe/H$]<-1.5$). It is speculated that the early evolution of [Al/Fe] is similar between a MW-like galaxy and a GSE-like galaxy \citep{Horta2021}.
No clear trend is seen in Car, Dra, and Sex, given that the sample size of each dwarf galaxy is small. We do find a vague trend that [Al/Fe] of Fnx stars decreases with increasing metallicity in the more metal-poor regime ([Fe/H$]<-0.75$), but start flattening in the more metal-rich regime. This possible flattening feature is also vaguely found in [Mg/Fe] and [Si/Fe]. \citet{2021ApJ...923..172H} suggests such a feature is caused by a secondary burst of star formation.
%铝元素，尽管与镁元素类似，但是铝主要通过大质量恒星合成Arnett 1971；Woosley & Weaver 1995），并通过II型超新星爆发释放到星系介质中，并且其丰度与前身恒星的金属丰度有关例如，Weinberg等人，2019）。同时铝元素还有其他核合成途径，例如铝可以通过CNO，NeNa以及MgAl循环的氢燃烧阶段形成Samland 1998；Guelin等人，1995，也有少量的观测表明铝在白矮双星Nofar等人，1991；Weiss & Truran，1990），沃尔夫-拉叶星风（Limongi & Chieffi，2006），以及渐近巨星分支恒星。
%在本工作中，我们首次通过Bacchus确定了大量成员星的较为精确的Al丰度，在此之前的研究大多针对大批量的样本数据（直接应用ASCAP的结果，e.g. H2021），这可能在精度上会稍有欠缺。尽管我们的样本数量有限，但可以确保绝大多数恒星元素丰度的可靠性。我们发现所有矮星系的Al/Fe的分布以及趋势与Sgr矮星系类似，并且系统低于银河系。但是我们也要声明我们的样本数目较少，且同一矮星系的恒星其金属丰度覆盖范围较小，相对于之前的一些工作来说，Al/Fe随金属丰度增加而降低的趋势并不明显，这可能是由于样本数目少以及测量误差所导致的。同时我们并没有发现Al-rich恒星（Al/Fe > 0），尽管有几颗星的Al/Fe已经接近0。这也是预料之中的，因为Al-rich恒星的形成通常需要很高密度的环境，一般会在大质量恒星中产生，而且此前的研究也并没有在质量低于Sgr的矮星系中发现。但是对于恒星质量与Sgr差不多的Fnx而言，我们同样没发现Al-rich的恒星，我们认为这是因为Sgr与银河系发生相互作用，正在被银河系所吸积，而最初Sgr的质量可能远远大于Fnx，所以在银河系周围的矮星系中，只有Sgr发现Al-rich的恒星。
%\begin{figure}
% \centering \includegraphics[width=\linewidth,angle=0]{Al-FeH.pdf}
% \caption{ [Al/Fe] vs. [Fe/H]. Symbols are the same as in Figure.~\ref{fig: alpha}.}
% \label{fig: Al}
%\end{figure}
\subsection{Iron-peak elements}
\label{sec: result-Iron}
Analyses of solar elemental abundances reveal that iron-peak elements are actually contributed by both SNe Ia and core-collapse SNe II \citep{1995ApJS..101..181W}. Due to differences in star formation timescales and histories between the MW and dwarf galaxies, the iron-peak element abundances also vary accordingly.
The atomic lines for Cr, Mn, and Ni are relatively weak in the APOGEE spectra, making it impossible to obtain abundances for all sample stars. %Fig \ref{fig: Iron-Fe} displays the trends in Cr, Mn, and Ni abundances as a function of metallicity. For non-Fnx stars, only one has measurable abundances of [Cr/Fe].
%We compare our measurements with those obtained using optical spectra \citepalias[][]{2020A&A...641A.127R}, and the agreements are generally satisfactory for common stars.
[Cr/Fe] generally shows a flat trend as a function of metallicity for MW, Sgr, and Fnx (Fig. \ref{fig: Iron-Fe}). The Sgr and Fnx stars show greater dispersion in Cr, especially for more metal-poor stars, probably due to their weaker lines and lower SNR in the NIR spectra.
For MW and Sgr, [Mn/Fe] are almost constant ($\sim -0.3$) in the range of [Fe/H$]<-1.0$, and increase in the more metal-rich regime. Based on the limited measurements, Car stars show a similar flat trend ($\sim -0.2$) as a function of metallicity for [Fe/H$]<-1.0$; Fnx stars show similar [Mn/Fe] values as Sgr stars between $-1.0<[$Fe/H$]<-0.6$. However, it is difficult to tell its trend with metallicity given the limited metallicity range and large scatter.
%Interestingly, for Mn in Fnx, we observe an initial decline followed by an increase with metallicity ([Fe/H] \~ -0.8). This slight upward trend at high metallicity is also observed in the MW and Sgr, possibly suggesting differences in the star formation environments, stellar density, or star formation histories between Fnx, Sgr, and other dwarf galaxies. %Comparison with \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R} optical data shows a relatively steady trend for Mn abundance in Fnx, albeit with greater dispersion than in our sample. More precise samples are needed for a more complete interpretation.
No obvious [Ni/Fe] trend is found in the metal-poor regime ([Fe/H$]<-1.3$) for any aforementioned galaxies, due to their large abundance scatter. However, in the metal-rich regime ([Fe/H$]>-1.3$), Sgr stars show lower [Ni/Fe] compared to MW stars, and Fnx stars seem to show even lower values. In this regime, [Ni/Fe] decreases as the metallicity increases. Similar results are found in the optical counterpart \citepalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}. Theoretical studies suggest a significant contribution of sub-Chandrasekhar mass channels to SNe Ia in Fnx, possibly with additional progenitor mass variation related to star formation history \citep{Sanders2021,Nissen2024}.
%Such decreasing trend is also seen in Scl \citep[e.g.,][]{2019A&A...626A..15H}, which may be attributed to a lower contribution of SNe Ia to Ni \citep{2011A&A...530A..15N}. Wrong!!!!
%For Ni, Fnx shows a relatively stable trend with metallicity, consistent with the distribution in Sgr, which is also reflected in the \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R} comparison. While a few Car stars exhibit significant dispersion, the distribution appears largely flat, and there is minimal available abundance data for Sex and Dra. Notably, in other dwarf galaxies, such as Scl, \citepalias{2023A&A...669A.125T} and \citet{2019A&A...626A..15H} report a declining trend in Ni with increasing metallicity, which the authors attribute to the relatively lower contribution of SNe Ia to Ni \citep{2011A&A...530A..15N}.
%Following this, these variations in abundance distributions across different dwarf galaxies indicate that SNe contributions to iron-peak elements vary across galactic environments and metallicities \citep[e.g.,][]{}.
%根据对太阳元素丰度的分析和研究发现，铁锋元素实际上是由SNaI以及核塌缩型超新星SNa II共同贡献的（Woosley & Weaver 1995），同时由于银河系以及矮星系的恒星形成时标，历史不同，铁锋元素也会相应有所不同。
%由于本工作中铁锋元素的原子线相对较弱，所以并不是所有样本恒星的丰度都可用，图5展示的是Cr,Mn,Ni丰度随金属丰度的趋势，只有一颗非Fnx的恒星元素丰度可用，对于Fnx而言，其分布趋势与Sgr相似，但其弥散相对较大，而对于其他三个矮星系，仅有少量的丰度被测量。有趣的事，我们注意到对于Mn元素，Fnx似乎呈现出随着金属丰度增加，先下降，随后上升的趋势（大约在FeH在-0.8处），在高金属丰度下轻微上升的趋势也在MW以及Sgr中被发现，这是否也能说明着Fnx，Sgr矮星系与其他矮星系的恒星形成环境，恒星密度或者恒星形成历史不同。我们同时也对比R2020光学波段的数据，Fnx的Mn元素丰度展现一个较为恒定的趋势，但是其弥散要大于我们的样本，我们认为需要更多精确的样本才能做出更完善的解释。
%对于Cr以及Ni，Fnx整体都表现出随金属丰度变化相对稳定的趋势，这与Sgr的分布基本吻合，并且对比R2020，也展现了同样的趋势，少量的Car恒星尽管有一个较大的弥散，但似乎仍然可以认为是平坦的分布，而Sex以及Dra几乎没有可用的丰度。我们留意到对于其他矮星系，例如Scl，T2023，H2019都展现出随着金属丰度上升而下降的趋势，作者认为这可能是由于SNa Ia对于Ni的贡献较低导致的（Cite Nissen2011）。不同矮星系间展现出不尽相同的分布，也表明在不同星系环境中，SNa对于Iron-Peak元素的贡献存在差异。
\begin{figure}[htbp]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=9.3cm,height=5.8cm]{SiFe_v2.pdf}
\caption{Derived LTE abundances of [Si/Fe] over metallicities for individual dwarf galaxies. MW stars (black dots) are described in Fig. \ref{fig: alpha}. The best polynomial fits to the data of Sgr, Fnx, Dra, Car, Sex and Scl member stars are labeled as orange, red, cyan, blue, green, and yellow lines.}
\label{fig: Si_trend}%
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}[htbp]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=1.1\linewidth]{Iron-FeH.pdf}
\caption{Abundances of iron peak elements vs. [Fe/H]. Symbols are the same as in Fig. \ref{fig: alpha}.}
\label{fig: Iron-Fe}%
\end{figure}
\subsection{Neutron-capture elements: Ce}
\label{sec: result-Neu}
Elements heavier than iron are generally formed through neutron-capture processes, which are classified into rapid ({\it r}-) and slow ({\it s}-) neutron-capture processes depending on the relative rates of neutron capture and $\beta$-decay. For several decades, the astrophysical sites of these processes have been the subject of ongoing research and debate. For the {\it r}-process, current mainstream models include core-collapse SNe \citep[e.g.,][]{1994ApJ...433..229W} and neutron star mergers \citep[e.g.,][]{2018ApJ...855...99C,2019Natur.574..497W}. The s-process, on the other hand, primarily occurs in AGB stars during thermal pulsation phases \citep{2001ApJ...557..802B,2014PASA...31...30K}. %In AGB stars, two key nuclear reactions serve as primary sources of neutron excess: $\rm {^{13}C(\alpha,n) ^{16}O}$ and $\rm {^{22}Ne(\alpha,n) ^{25}Mg}$. The $\rm {^{13}C(\alpha,n) ^{16}O}$ reaction predominantly occurs in low-mass AGB stars, whereas $\rm {^{22}Ne(\alpha,n) ^{25}Mg}$ is more characteristic of massive AGB stars \citep{2015ApJS..219...40C}. As the availability of free neutrons per iron seed increases, the {\it s}-process pathway initially produces elements at the light {\it s}-process peak (Sr$−$Y$−$Zr), extending up to $\rm ^{136}Ba$, and subsequently reaches elements at the heavy {\it s}-process peak (Ba$−$La$−$Ce$−$Pr$−$Nd), continuing to $\rm ^{204}Pb-^{207}Pb$ \citep{2014ApJ...787...10B}.
%Nucleosynthetic models suggest that Ce is primarily synthesized through the {\it s}-process within AGB stars \citep{2020ApJ...900..179K}.
According to \citet{2014ApJ...787...10B}, approximately 83\% of the Ce in our Sun originates from the {\it s}-process, which is similar to another frequently measured {\it s}-process-dominated element, Ba (85\%).
Six stars show exceptionally large [Ce/Fe], including four from Fnx, one from Car, and one from Dra (Fig. \ref{fig: Ce-Fe}). The usually large [Ce/Fe] indicate that they are possible AGB stars. This is further confirmed by their higher values of [N/Fe] and [O/Fe] when available (see \citetalias{2023A&A...669A.125T} for further discussion). These AGB candidate stars do not seem to show abnormal values in other investigated elements of this work. % \textcolor{red}{What about these AGB star candidates in other elements?}
%more interestingly, three of this four Ce-rich stars from Fnx also have large [N/Fe]，we further discuss these in Sect \ref{sec: discussion-nrich}.
%After excluding the stars with the strongest [Ce/Fe], a decreasing trend as a function of metallicity seems to exist in Car and Dra stars. However, this trend is rather uncertain because of the low number statistics and the weakness of Ce lines. On the other hand, another typical {\it s}-process element, Ba, shows an increasing trend as [Fe/H] increases for Scl stars \citep{2019A&A...626A..15H}; Ce in other dwarf galaxies with larger galaxy mass than Scl also shows an increasing trend as a function of metallicity \citep{2021ApJ...923..172H}. Further high S/N spectra with measurable Ce lines are needed to confirm this trend.
After excluding the AGB candidates, we do not find significant [Ce/Fe] trend as a function of metallicity for all four dwarf galaxies, partially due to the large scatter in measured abundances. Notably, Ba, an element with similar {\it s}-process contribution as Ce, are measured in these four dwarf galaxies by \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}. [Ba/Fe] generally show a flat trend as a function of metallicity for these dwarf galaxies between $-2.3<[$Fe/H$]<-0.5$, which is consistent with the null [Ce/Fe] trend in this work.
%Ce abundances in Fnx tend to stabilize with increasing metallicity, whereas in Car and Dra, there appears to be a decreasing trend with metallicity, similar to what has been observed in Scl stars \citep{2023A&A...669A.125T}. However, this trend remains uncertain due to the limited sample size and the weak Ce lines. Notably, another typical s-process element, Ba, shows an increasing trend with [Fe/H] in Scl stars \citep{2019A&A...626A..15H,2020A&A...641A.127R}. This trend for Ba is also observed in Sex and Umi, with Fnx showing an upward trend at the metal-poor end \citep{2020A&A...641A.127R}. In larger dwarf galaxies, such as LMC, SMC, and Sgr, Ce abundance also appears to increase with metallicity \citep{2021ApJ...923..172H}. To confirm these trends, additional high-S/N spectra with detectable Ce lines are needed.
\section{Discussion}
\label{sec:discussion}
\subsection{Comparison with literature and NLTE effects}
In this section, we try to verify our derived abundances and look for possible systematics by comparing with abundances derived from the optical counterparts. Here we pick the work of (\citealt{2020A&A...641A.127R}, hereafter \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}), which derived abundances of 380 stars in 13 dwarf galaxies with archival optical high-resolution spectra. There are twelve common stars between our and their works.
%In this study, we utilized near-infrared (NIR) APOGEE spectra to investigate Fnx, Dra, Car, and Sex, deriving accurate chemical abundances using the BACCHUS pipeline. We compared our results with optical spectroscopy data (\citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}), though we found overlap with only a small portion of optical datasets (e.g., R20).
The top panels of Fig. \ref{fig: compare_li} indicate that the stellar parameters generally agree with each other between two studies, although our derived log $g$ values are slightly larger ($\sim 0.3$ dex) than those reported by \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}. %Overall, our results align well with the 1:1 distribution when compared to the optical data. However, \citep[][; Here after R20]{2020A&A...641A.127R}, and our [Fe/H] measurements show a mild metal-rich offset relative to \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}, likely due to our adoption of larger log $g$ values.
The middle and bottom panels of Fig. \ref{fig: compare_li} show the comparisons of element abundances derived by two studies. Some stars may not have Cr, Mn, or Ni measurements, as they have weaker lines in the NIR wavelength range. Though with significant scatters ($\sim 0.3-0.4$ dex), the derived element abundances agree with each other, except for Mg.
%We also compared elemental abundances with \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}, as illustrated in subsequent panels of Figure \ref{fig: compare_li}. For elements such as Mg, Ti, and Ni, the results generally follow a 1:1 distribution, although with a limited sample size. For example, while we measured the abundances of O and Si in our sample, these elements were not observed in \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}. This discrepancy arises because OH molecular lines and Si atomic lines are stronger in the NIR, enhancing their detectability. In contrast, Ni measurements are more robust in optical spectra. The scatter in Ti abundances likely results from the relatively weak atomic lines in APOGEE spectra, leading to larger uncertainties in derived abundances (see Table \ref{Table: abu_err}).
\begin{figure*}[htbp]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=0.85\textwidth]{compare_All_X_H_ASCAP_our.pdf}
\caption{Comparison of stellar parameters and chemical abundances of this work with those from the \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}. Our results are denoted “our” and shown in the x-axis. The black solid line is the 1:1 relation.}
\label{fig: compare_li}%
\end{figure*}
Our Mg abundances are systematically lower (approximately 0.2 dex) compared to those in \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}. A similar trend is also found in \citetalias{2023A&A...669A.125T}, who suggests non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) corrections for the adopted NIR Mg lines ($\lambda \sim 15741, 15749, 15766$ \AA) at the resolution of APOGEE spectra \citep{2020A&A...637A..80O,2021A&A...647A..24M}.
\textbf{The NLTE corrections for aluminum abundances measured by APOGEE are generally negative, ranging from about –0.1 to –0.2 dex for RGB stars. These corrections vary depending on the specific spectral lines used and the stellar parameters, but they do not significantly alter the separation between different stellar populations \citep{nlte_al_2023ApJ...953..143F}. Thus, while individual stellar abundances may be affected, the overall chemical trends found in this work remain robust. }
\textbf{The Mn I lines in H band originate from high-excitation levels and are relatively sensitive to departures from LTE especially in the metal-poor giants \citep{nlte2020A&A...642A..62A}. The primary direction of the NLTE correction is positive. For metal-poor stars with [Fe/H] < -1.0, these corrections can reach between +0.2 dex and +0.5 dex (in extreme cases). Applying these NLTE corrections may raise the [Mn/Fe] ratios at low metallicities, possibly resulting in a flatter and potentially plateau-like trend in the [Mn/Fe] vs. [Fe/H] plane. }
\subsection{Galaxy mass and $\alpha$-element}
\label{sec:alphaknee}
%Use [Si/Fe] as proxy to estimate the relation between $\alpha$ knee metallicity and galaxy absolute magnitude or estimated mass. Include Scl, too. Draw illustrated lines.
%Additionally, in more massive galaxies, $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ is expected to be correspondingly higher. In our results, the MW, which is far more massive than Sgr, Fnx, Sex, Car, and Dra, shows the highest $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ abundances. Comparisons with the Sgr system confirm that this four dwarf galaxies exhibit systematically lower $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ abundances than Sgr, supporting the conclusion that smaller galaxies tend to produce lower $[\alpha/{\rm Fe}]$ abundances.
It is suggested that the more massive galaxy is more metal-rich with faster star formation enrichment \citep[e.g.,][]{1979ApJ...229.1046T,2009ARA&A..47..371T}. This relation may be complicated by the lost mass in tidally disrupted galaxies \citep{2009ARA&A..47..371T}. However, it generally reflects that more mass galaxies have longer star formation history (SFH) due to their strong potential well, and thus forming more metal-rich stars with low [$\alpha$/Fe]. In this work, we collect the data of MW, Sgr, Scl, Fnx, Car, Dra, and Sex to find the rough correlation between the trend of $\alpha$-element and luminosity which is a proxy for galaxy mass. Given that O, Ca, Ti show larger scatters, and Mg may be systematically lower than those from the optical, we use Si as the tracer of $\alpha$-element (Fig. \ref{fig: Si_trend}). Limited by the sample sizes and metallicity coverage of each galaxy, accurate estimation of the $\alpha$-knee, if any, could be tricky. Instead, we perform a polynomial fit to the distribution of [Si/Fe] vs. [Fe/H] for each dwarf galaxy (Fig. \ref{fig: Si_trend}), and find out their intersection with [Si/Fe$]=0$ (Table \ref{Tabel:Si_trend}). Clearly, the more luminous, and thus more mass galaxies (Table \ref{Tabel:Si_trend}) show more metal-rich metallicities at the intersection, underscoring the critical role of galaxy mass in shaping chemical evolution. Interestingly, we find that the brightest galaxies, i.e., Sagittarius and Fornax, show similar metallicities at the intersection, suggesting they may have comparable masses in the past, and thus similar chemical evolution.
%Moreover, as the luminosity of dwarf galaxies decreases sequentially, the metallicity at the [Si/Fe]=0 intersection also decreases. This implies that the combined effects of SFH, SNe II, SNe Ia yields strongly depend on the absolute magnitude (and hence stellar mass) of the galaxy. %Yet, we caution this correlation is a rough one, as the $\alpha$-element may have large uncertainty, and some galaxies may have lost a significant amount of mass (e.g., Sgr).
%We fit the [Si/Fe] vs. [Fe/H] distribution with two segments: a flat plateau and a declining slope. These two segments meet in the $\alpha$ knee. After deriving the metallcities of the $\alpha$ knee ([Fe/H]$_{Si,knee}$) with $\chi^2$ minimization (Table \ref{Tabel:Si knee}), we fit [Fe/H]$_{Si,knee}$ as a function of absolute magnitude with orthogonal-distance regression (Figure \ref{fig: Si_knee_mag}). The fitted result is:
%\begin{equation}
% [Fe/H]_{Si,knee}= (-0.098 \pm0.02) \times M_V + (-2.97\pm0.28)
%\end{equation}
%Our slope is consistent with those from \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}, which is based on Mg, Sc, and Ti abundances derived from the optical spectra. This implies that the combined effects of SFH, SNe II, SNe Ia yields strongly depend on the absolute magnitude (and hence stellar mass) of the galaxy. Yet, we caution this correlation is a rough one, as the $\alpha$ knee position may have large uncertainty, and some galaxies may have lost a significant amount of mass (e.g., Sgr).
\begin{table*}
\caption{The metallicities at [Si/Fe] = 0 and absolute magnitudes for dwarf galaxies.} % title of Table
\label{Tabel:Si_trend} % is used to refer this table in the text
\centering % used for centering table
\setlength{\tabcolsep}{5pt}
\begin{tabular}{ccc} % centered columns
\hline\hline%\cline{2-9}
\\[-3pt]
Galaxy & [Fe/H]$_{[Si/Fe]=0}$ & M$_V$ [mag]$^a$ \\
\hline\\
Sgr & $-0.55 \pm \ 0.16$ & $-13.5 \pm \ 0.30$\\
Fnx & $-0.62 \pm \ 0.15$ & $-13.46 \pm \ 0.14$\\
Scl & $-1.08 \pm \ 0.11$ & $-10.82 \pm \ 0.14$\\
Car & $-1.35 \pm \ 0.23$ & $-9.43 \pm \ 0.05$\\
Sex & $-1.71 \pm \ 0.27$ & $-8.72 \pm \ 0.06$\\
Dra & $-1.72 \pm \ 0.25$ & $-8.71 \pm \ 0.05$\\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\tablefoot{ $^a$: From \citet{2012AJ....144....4M} and \citet{2018ApJ...860...66M}.}
\end{table*}
\subsection{Radial chemical gradients}
\label{sec: discussion-mg}
%\citet{2022A&A...659A.119K}
\begin{table*}
\caption{Results of linear least squares regression for Fnx}
\label{tab:XFe_a_linearFitting_coefficient}
\begin{center}
%\input{XFe_a_linearFitting.tex}
%\scriptsize
\begin{tabular}{c c c c}
\hline
\hline
\hline
element & k & k error & p-value \\
& (dex/degree) &(dex/degree) & \\
\hline
\hline
{\rm [Fe/H]} & $-0.7814$ & 0.217 & 0.0004\\
{\rm [O/Fe]} & $-0.2480$ & 0.488 & 0.615\\
{\rm [Mg/Fe]} & $-0.1475$ & 0.221 & 0.510\\
{\rm [Al/Fe]} & $-0.2178$ & 0.229 & 0.351\\
{\rm [Si/Fe]} & 0.0687 & 0.149 & 0.647\\
{\rm [Ca/Fe]} & $-0.1202$ & 0.215 & 0.581\\
{\rm [Ti/Fe]} & 0.2733 & 0.390 & 0.489\\
\hline
\hline
\end{tabular}
\end{center}
\tablefoot{ k: best-fit slope. p-value: two-sided p-value for a hypothesis test in which the null hypothesis is that the slope is zero.}
\end{table*}
Radial chemical gradients are important observational constraints to reconstruct galaxy formation history \citep{2017A&A...603A...2M}. The sample sizes of Dra, Car, and Sex are not large enough for meaningful discussions, and we focus on Fnx in this section. Being one of the first dwarf spheroidals discovered by Harlow Shapley in 1938, Fnx has been investigated for a long time. Fnx shows a prolonged star formation history, with at least three distinct stellar populations: a young population (few 100 Myr old), an intermediate age population (2-8 Gyr old), and an ancient population ($>10$ Gyr, \citealt{2006A&A...459..423B}). The stellar populations in Fnx can be separated into two/three components considering their spatial, kinematics and metallicity distributions: the metal-rich component is more centrally concentrated with colder kinematics, and vice versa \citep{2006A&A...459..423B,2011ApJ...742...20W,2012ApJ...756L...2A}. These components show misalignment between their angular momentum vectors and different anisotropy parameters \citep{2012ApJ...756L...2A, 2022A&A...659A.119K}, indicating a ``core'' dark matter density profile \citep{2011ApJ...742...20W}, and a late merger history \citep{2012ApJ...756L...2A}.
%In recent years, research on the structure and evolution of the Fnx dwarf elliptical galaxy has become increasingly detailed and sophisticated. Utilizing the ESO 2.2-meter wide-field imager and the VLT/FLAMES GIRAFFE spectrograph, \citet{2006A&A...459..423B} studied the stellar populations of Fnx, covering and exceeding its tidal radius, and discovered complex evolutionary processes, indicating that Fnx contains a significant number of stars ranging from young to old. The authors found that stars with higher metallicity have a smaller and more concentrated spatial distribution, exhibiting cooler dynamical characteristics, while those with lower metallicity show the opposite trend. This may suggest that recent external material accretion, such as mergers with other galaxies, has occurred in Fnx. And \citet{2012ApJ...756L...2A} classified the red giant stars in Fnx into three different stellar subpopulations and investigated their kinematics and metallicity relationships, discovering a clear ordering among these three subpopulations in terms of velocity dispersion, spatial distribution, and metallicity. Additionally, the authors constructed an evolutionary history for the Fnx dwarf elliptical galaxy corresponding to late merger events. Furthermore, \citet{2022A&A...659A.119K} simulated the separation of Fnx into two categories of stars based on different metallicities, finding that the anisotropy parameter slightly increases. These studies reveal that the various parameters of stars with different ages and metallicities in Fnx show differences, and further research is anticipated on whether the metallicities of these stars exhibit a certain trend.
Chemical abundance investigation is more challenging, since it demands spectra with higher SNR (\citealt{2003AJ....125..684S}; \citetalias{2020A&A...641A.127R}). \citet{2021ApJ...923..172H} suggests a second, weaker ``burst'' star formation in Fnx based on chemical modelling the [$\alpha$/Fe]-[Fe/H] patterns, in agreement with results from the color-magnitude diagram. As chemical abundances are strongly affected by galaxy star formation history, here we explore the possible radial chemical gradient in Fnx for the first time.
We used linear least-squares regression fitting to find the correlations between chemical abundances and elliptical galactic radius. We list the results in Table \ref{tab:XFe_a_linearFitting_coefficient}, including their slopes (k), slope errors, and p-value\footnote{A hypothesis test is performed to assess whether the slope equals zero, using the Wald Test with a t-distribution for the test statistic.}. Our results suggest a nondetectable radial gradient for [O/Fe], [Mg/Fe], [Al/Fe], [Si/Fe], [Ca/Fe] and [Ti/Fe], given their two-sided p-values are too large ($>0.05$). However, we confirmed the metallicity gradient (p-value$= 0.0004$ and $k=-0.7814$, Fig. \ref{fig:metal_bin}) suggested in literature \citep{2006A&A...459..423B,2012ApJ...756L...2A}, where we further include stars with $40<$ SNR (per pixel) $<70$. If we divide them with [Fe/H$]=-1$ according to \citet{2022A&A...659A.119K}, we find the average radius of the metal-rich stars is 0.1-0.2 degree, while it is 0.3-0.4 degree for their counterparts. This agrees with \citet[][Fig. 15]{2006A&A...459..423B}.
%Due to the limited number of stars with S/N greater than 70, we selected all stars with S/N greater than 40 for meaningful statistical distributions. As shown in Fig \ref{fig:metal_bin}, the correlation between the metallicity of the sample stars and their angular distance from the center of Fnx is presented, illustrating that the overall metallicity of stars in Fnx increases with distance from the center. This trend is similar to findings from previous studies.
%revealing that [Fe/H] showed a noticeable linear correlation: the p-value$= 0.0004$ and $k=-0.7814$,
The lack of detectable radial chemical gradients could be attributed to the following reasons: 1. Not large enough sample size (32 Fnx stars); 2. Measurement uncertainties and offsets ($\sim 0.1-0.2$ dex); 3. Three star-formation epochs and possible merger history may form more complicated radial chemical gradients. When a new large-scale SF event occurs, one would expect the [$\alpha$/Fe] to increase after the first new SNe II and for the first 0.1-1 Gyrs until SNe Ia kick in, complicating any abundance gradient using $\alpha$-elements. We speculate the last one may be the driving factor: radial gradients of [Mg/Fe] and [Ca/Fe] were identified in Scl \citepalias{2023A&A...669A.125T}, which formed most of the stars early with a single peak \citep{2022ApJ...925...66D}.
\begin{figure}
\centering
\includegraphics[width=9cm,height = 5.8cm]{Ce-FeH.pdf}
\caption{[Ce/Fe] vs. [Fe/H]. Symbols are the same as in Fig.~\ref{fig: alpha}. Notably, the stars marked with star symbols are those with [Ce/Fe] greater than 0.5, which are likely AGB stars.}
\label{fig: Ce-Fe}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure*}
\centering \includegraphics[width=15.4cm,height=8.3cm,angle=0]{FORNAX_metal_bin.pdf}
\caption{Metallicity distribution of stars in Fnx. Left panel: {\rm [Fe/H]} as a function of elliptical radius in degrees. The green dashed line represents the best least-squared fit. They are divided into a metal-rich population ([Fe/H$]>-1$, blue dots) and a metal-poor population ([Fe/H$]<-1$, red dots).
Right panel: the radial distribution of the metal-rich population (blue histogram) and the metal-poor population (red histogram).
}
\label{fig:metal_bin}
\end{figure*}
% 近些年来关于Fnx恒星群体的结构以及演化研究愈发成熟和精细， xxx利用使用了ESO 2.2米宽场成像仪和VLT/FLAMES GIRAFFE光谱仪，研究了Fornax矮椭球星系的分辨恒星群体的详细性质，覆盖范围达到并超出了其潮汐半径，发现Fnx经历了复杂的演化，并且包含大量从年轻到年老的恒星。作者发现金属丰度较高的恒星具有更小且更集中的空间分布，并表现出较冷的动力学特征，金属丰度较低的恒星则相反。这可能说明近期Fnx可能存在外部物质吸积的过程，例如其他星系的并合等。 xxx等人对Fnx的红巨星分成三个不同的恒星子群体，并研究他们的运动学与金属丰度的关系，作者发现这三个子群体在速度弥散、空间分布以及金属丰度方面表现出明确的排序。并且作者构建一个Fnx矮椭球星系演化历史，对应晚期合并事件 。此外xxx通过模拟也将Fnx分为金属丰度不同的两类恒星，find the anisotropy parameter to be slightly increasing。这些工作都发现了Fnx中不同年龄不同金属丰度的恒星其各种参数都会有差异，我们也期待对这些恒星的金属丰度是否呈现出一定的趋势，由于对于S/N大于70的恒星数目有限，为了得到具有统计意义的分布，并且对于Fe/H而言,S/N大于40的恒星依然可用（例如H2021），所以在此我们选取了所有s/N大于40的金属丰度，如图8所示，我们绘制了Fnx恒星样本金属丰度随离Fnx中心的角距离的关系，左图中Fnx的恒星随着离中心距离的增加，其整体的金属丰度也在增加，类似xxx2022，我们将数据也分为贫金属和富金属的恒星(以-1.0为界限)，如右图所示，金属丰度较高的恒星更加密集且集中于内部，而贫金属的恒星更分散并会相对分散在外围。这一结果与2006,2022,2018的结果都符合。我们也尝试对【Fe/H】以及部分化学元素丰度随角距离的分布做了线性最小二次回归拟合，结果如表xx所示，我们发现仅有【Fe/H】的线性相关性明显，其余的O，Mg,Al,Ca,Si，Ti等元素均无明显线性分布。
\subsection{N-rich field stars}
\label{sec: discussion-nrich}
As part of our on-going project ``{\bf GASTRONOMI}'', we aim to investigate the connection between star cluster properties and galaxy chemical evolution in these lower mass MW satellites. A substantial number of the existing MW GCs were born ex-situ, and later joined other in-situ GCs by mergers \citep[e.g.,][]{massari2019}. GCs are also found in large MW satellite galaxies (e.g., LMC and SMC) and smaller dwarf galaxies \citep{2021MNRAS.500..986H}. Many GCs are dissolved after birth \citep{2019MNRAS.486.4030L}, while member stars of surviving GC may escape its potential well through two-body relaxation. Therefore, GC escapees are expected to be found in the field. Using the chemical anomaly found in GCs, astronomers identified N-rich field stars as possible candidates for GC escapees. These stars can be found in dissolved dwarf galaxies (e.g., GSE, \citealt{2021ApJ...913...23Y}), dissolving dwarf galaxies (e.g., Sgr, \citealt{2021A&A...648A..70F}), and existing dwarf galaxies (e.g, LMC \& SMC, \citealt{2020ApJ...903L..17F}).
%The distinct chemical signature of GCs is known as multiple populations . This phenomenon pertains to the variations in the abundances of light elements among GC members. Stars in GCs that exhibit enhanced levels of N and Na (and occasionally He and Al) alongside depleted levels of C and O (and sometimes Mg) are typically classified as the second population (2P), whereas those without these anomalies are referred to as the primordial population (1P). It is widely recognized that these chemical peculiarities primarily develop in dense environments like GCs \citep{2012A&ARv..20...50G,2018ARA&A..56...83B}. So searching for 2P-like stars is a feasible way to find the association between GC escapees and the ejecting and/or dissolving GCs \citep[e.g.,][]{2024A&A...684A.205X}. According to chemo-dynamical analysis of N-rich field stars, a substantial portion of them may have an extragalactic origin \citep{2020ApJ...891...28T,2021ApJ...913...23Y,2022A&A...663A.126F}. \citet{2020ApJ...903L..17F,2021A&A...648A..70F} reported the discovery of a large group of N-rich field stars in Sgr and Magellanic Clouds.
%Moreover, we found that galaxies hosting N-rich stars are typically those containing GCs. In contrast, no evidence of N-rich field stars has been reported in dwarf galaxies without GCs \citep[e.g., Scl,][]{2023A&A...669A.125T}. Regarding whether dwarf galaxies host GCs, apart from the largest satellite galaxies (LMC and SMC), smaller satellite galaxies have also been observed to host ancient GCs \citep{2021MNRAS.500..986H}.
%\begin{figure}
% \centering \includegraphics[width=8.8cm,height=7.5cm]{dwarf_chemical/nf.pdf}
% \caption{\textcolor{red}{[N/Fe] vs. [Fe/H] panel of 4 identified N-rich stars (gold diamonds). Violet diamonds stand for stars in NGC6752 \citep{ngc6752-carretta}. Grey dots correspond to MW stars from the halo \citep{halo-cayrel-2004A&A...416.1117C,halo-barklem-2005A&A...439..129B,halo-yong-2013ApJ...762...26Y} and blue dots for the disk \citep{disk-reddy-2006MNRAS.367.1329R,disk-bensby-2014A&A...562A..71B}. }}
% \label{fig:nfe}
%\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\centering
\includegraphics[width=8.3cm,height=6.2cm]{n-teff_m-1.pdf}
\includegraphics[width=8.3cm,height=6.2cm]{c-teff_m-1.pdf}
\caption{\textbf{Abundance comparison between our identified N-rich stars (gold diamonds) and Lagarde2012 model predictions. Blue and orange lines represent model predictions for the stellar mass of 1.0 $M_{\odot}$ in the primordial and mixing-enriched stellar populations, while solid and dashed lines represent those for [Fe/H] = $-0.86$ and $-0.56$, respectively. }}
\label{fig:model}
\end{figure}
Next, we try to identify N-rich field stars in Fnx, Dra, Car, Sex dwarf galaxies with the following criteria: [N/Fe$]>0.65$, [C/Fe$]<0.15$, and [Ce/Fe$]<0.5$. Here we exclude stars with high C and Ce abundances to avoid AGB star contamination \citep{2017MNRAS.465..501S, 2019MNRAS.488.2864F}. We identify 4 N-rich field stars out of 32 sample stars (4/32) in Fnx, 0/14 in Dra, 0/19 in Car, and 0/8 in Sex. %\textcolor{red}{(their [N/Fe] vs. [Fe/H] are shown in \textbf{Fig.\ref{fig:nfe}} comparing with MW and GC stars).
\textbf{ Considering that the effects of internal mixing in giant stars could also cause high N surface abundances, we compared the C\&N abundances of these N-rich stars with the stellar models mentioned in \cite{lagarde_2012A&A...543A.108L} (see Fig.\ref{fig:model}). Models including thermohaline convection and rotation-induced mixing are considered here. The systematically higher N and lower C abundances in our stars (particularly the two stars with [N/Fe$]>+0.94$) compared to the mixing models cannot be fully explained by internal processes like rotational or thermohaline mixing. Instead, such stars are more likely to be formed from gas previously enriched by the CNO-processed ejecta of massive first-generation stars, imprinting high N and low C abundances at birth. }
Additionally, N-rich field stars may show abnormal abundances in other elements, e.g., Al \citep{2021ApJ...913...23Y, 2021A&A...648A..70F}. However, we do not find such peculiarity in the four N-rich field stars of Fnx. Specifically, none of them show Al enrichment, which does not contradict the hypothesis that they are escaped from GCs ---- more metal-rich GCs usually do not show Al enrichment \citep{Pancino2017}.
The lack of N-rich field stars in Dra, Car, and Sex is not surprising, as similar situation is found in Scl \citepalias{2023A&A...669A.125T}. It is probable that the low-mass, diffuse galactic environment is not suitable for the formation of GCs \citep{HT2024}, and therefore should not have any N-rich field stars if they were formed in GCs.
%which results in less massive stars \citepalias{2023A&A...669A.125T} and lower [$\alpha$/Fe] (Section \ref{sec:alphaknee}).
%\textcolor{red}{what about Na? They have [Fe/H]>-1.0}
%Eight stars show significantly high nitrogen abundances across the Fnx (seven stars) and Dra (one star) samples. However, among these, star #3 in Fnx and star $\#$33 in Draco exhibit high carbon abundances, disqualifying them as nitrogen-enhanced field stars ([C/Fe] < 0.15; see \citealt{2017MNRAS.465..501S,2019MNRAS.488.2864F}). Additionally, star $\#$25, $\#$30, and $\#$33 display elevated Ce abundances. As noted by \citet{2023A&A...669A.125T}, such stars with high neutron-capture element abundances are likely asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars, based on AGB models. Thus, they do not meet the criteria for N-rich field stars. Ultimately, only stars $\#$10, $\#$18, $\#$20, and $\#$21 in Fnx are confirmed as N-rich field stars, marking the first evidence of such stars in Fnx.
%Furthermore, we did not detect any Al-rich stars ([Al/Fe] > 0), although several stars had [Al/Fe] close to zero. This is expected, as the formation of Al-rich stars typically requires high-density environments, usually associated with massive stars, and previous studies have not identified such stars in dwarf galaxies with masses lower than that of Sgr. Interestingly, we also did not find any Al-rich stars in Fnx, despite its stellar mass being similar to Sgr. We propose this may due to Sgr, which is currently being accreted by the Milky Way, originally had a significantly larger mass than Fnx. Consequently, among dwarf galaxies surrounding the MW, only Sgr exhibits Al-rich stars.
Fnx shows not only a special chemodynamical structure (Section \ref{sec: discussion-mg}), but also remarkably high GC specific frequency\footnote{The number of GCs per unit galaxy luminosity, i.e., $S_N= N_{GC} \times 10^{(M_V+15)}$.}, $S_N=26$. This value is exceptionally high among local galaxies, but it is comparable to those found in dwarf galaxies of the Coma cluster \citep{2020MNRAS.492.4874F}.
Currently, six GCs are suggested to be associated with Fnx (e.g., see \citealt{2019ApJ...875L..13W,2021ApJ...923...77P} and references therein), where three of them, Fnx 1 ([Fe/H$]=-2.5 \pm 0.1$), Fnx 2 ([Fe/H$]=-2.1 \pm 0.1$), Fnx 3 ([Fe/H$]=-2.4 \pm 0.1$), show MPs, i.e., star-to-star variations in O, Na, and Mg \citep{2006A&A...453..547L}. Moreover, Fnx 3 ([Fe/H$]=-2.28 \pm 0.02$), Fnx 4 ([Fe/H$]=-1.24 \pm 0.02$), and Fnx 5 ([Fe/H$]=-2.06 \pm 0.03$) were investigated by integrated-light spectra \citep{2022A&A...660A..88L}. Fnx 6 is the most metal-rich one with [Fe/H$]=-0.71 \pm 0.05$ \citep{2021ApJ...923...77P}.
%Specifically, the Fnx dwarf spheroidal galaxy (dSph) is known to host at least six GCs (e.g., see \citealt{2019ApJ...875L..13W,2021ApJ...923...77P} and references therein), which is a remarkably high number compared to other MW satellite galaxies. A distinctive feature of Fnx is its high GC specific frequency (defined as the number of GCs per unit galaxy luminosity, normalized to a galaxy with an absolute V-magnitude of −15; see, e.g., \citealt{1999Ap&SS.269..469E}), with a $S_N$ value of approximately 26\footnote{Local spiral galaxies typically have $S_N$ $\leq$ 1, whereas ellipticals, dwarf ellipticals and $S_0$ galaxies show GC specific frequencies in the range 2 $\leq$ $S_N$ $\leq$ 6.}. This value is exceptionally high for a satellite galaxy and is comparable to those found in central cD galaxies in galaxy clusters, which typically have $S_N$ values greater than 10. Similar to most GCs, Fnx's GCs also exhibit multiple stellar populations \citep{2006A&A...453..547L}. The reason for Fnx's unusually high GC fraction remains debated (e.g., \citealt{2015MNRAS.454.2401B,2016MNRAS.457.4248W,2024A&A...690A..61D}). Furthermore, as observed in MW GCs, evidence of “anomalous” stars has also been found in Fnx's GCs, characterized by enhanced helium, nitrogen, and sodium abundances compared to field stars with standard abundance patterns \citep{2006A&A...453..547L,2018A&A...613A..56L}. Therefore, we anticipate discovering N-rich stars within Fnx's sample.
Given the metallicity range of our measured Fnx stars, we plot the abundances of Fnx 3, Fnx 4, and Fnx 5 \citep{2022A&A...660A..88L} in Fig. \ref{fig: alpha} and \ref{fig: Iron-Fe} to visualize the abundance trend at lower metallicities. With similar metallicity, Fnx 4 perfectly matches with our Fnx field stars in all measured abundances. Fnx 3 and Fnx 5 also match with other Fnx field stars in elements heavier than Ca, but lower [Mg/Fe] and higher [Si/Fe] are spotted when compared with field stars of other galaxies (e.g., MW). These peculiar features are in fact related to their GC nature: 1. The star-to-star Mg variation with depleted values is found in Fnx 3 \citep{2006A&A...453..547L}, where a similar situation may also be true in Fnx 5; 2. Enhanced Si abundances are commonly found in metal-poor Galactic GCs \citep[e.g.,][]{2018ApJ...855...38T}. Therefore, the enhanced Si integrated-light abundances indicate the existence of star-to-star Si variation with elevated values in Fnx 3 and Fnx 5. Our identified N-rich field stars show metallicity between $-0.8$ and $-1.0$ (Table \ref{Table: chemi_abu}) with measurement uncertainties of $\sim 0.1$ dex. They do not overlap with any existing Fnx GCs either in metallicity or in spatial location (Fig. \ref{fig:FornaxCMD}). %Given that their internal metallicity difference is not too large ($\sim 0.2$ dex), we suggest there are at least one more dissolved GC in Fnx.
Assuming that N-rich field stars are escaped from GCs \citep{2020ApJ...891...28T,2021ApJ...913...23Y}, this may indicate GC destruction in Fnx. %The fact that most N-rich field stars are located near the center supports the GC destruction scenario, as GC destruction rate is higher in denser core region.
In fact, \citet{2023MNRAS.522.5638C} predicted the number of GCs drops by a factor of $\sim 5-8$ compared to the peak value based on modeling massive satellites with similar properties as Fnx. Therefore, the existence of GC escapees is expected by theoretical models. To further verify the destruction rate, a complete census of Fnx stars with high accurate abundances is needed.
%This finding suggests that Fnx hosts dense star-forming environments and may have experienced interactions with its surroundings that ejected stars into the galaxy during its evolution. Such interactions might resemble those between the MW and its GCs. Additionally, recent work by \citet{2022A&A...660A..88L} provided detailed chemical abundance data for up to a dozen elements in Local Group GCs. We aim to establish chemical links between the nitrogen-enhanced field stars we identified and the GCs in Fnx. We plotted the chemical abundances of Fnx’s GCs using purple squares as provided by \citet{2022A&A...660A..88L} in Figure \ref{fig: alpha}. Unfortunately, we did not find any stars with alpha-element abundances matching Fnx’s GCs. We propose the following reasons for this discrepancy: 1): Our sample size is small and does not adequately cover the metal-poor end of the metallicity range. Most of Fnx’s GCs are metal-poor, with [Fe/H] < −2. Furthermore, detailed chemical abundance information is available only for three of Fnx’s six GCs (Fnx 3, 4, and 5); 2): These N-rich field stars might originate from GCs that have completely dissolved, preventing us from establishing chemical links to existing Fnx GCs.
\section{Summary}
\label{sec: summary}
Although dwarf galaxies outnumber bright galaxies, their low surface brightness makes them challenging to observe in the distant Universe. The satellite dwarf galaxies orbiting the MW serve as ideal laboratories for studying the detailed evolution of galaxy systems. Specifically, we can model their evolution using resolved stellar populations in color-magnitude diagrams and their chemical abundances. Additionally, we can investigate the coevolution of galaxies and star clusters, as these systems mutually influence one another \citep{HT2024}. Following our initial study of the Scl dwarf galaxy, this paper represents our second investigation into low-mass MW satellites using high-resolution spectra.
We derived chemical abundances for Fe, C, N, O, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, Cr, Mn, Ni, and Ce in 74 member stars across the Fnx, Dra, Car, and Sex dwarf galaxies. To address the weak spectral lines in these metal-poor stars, we determined abundances line-by-line using the Turbospectrum wrapper --- Bacchus.
\begin{enumerate}
\item The $\alpha$ elements (O, Mg, Si, Ca, Ti) exhibit a characteristic ``flat then decreasing'' trend with increasing metallicity. Given the smaller uncertainties and negligible systemic offset display by Si, the distribution of [Si/Fe] shows a strong correlation with the absolute magnitudes of galaxies (including Sgr, Scl and four dwarf galaxies in this work), confirming the critical role of galaxy mass in shaping chemical evolution.
\item Al abundances in the studied dwarf galaxies cluster around [Al/Fe]$\sim -0.5$, consistent with values observed in the Sgr dwarf galaxy or MW metal-poor stars. While Car, Dra, and Sex show no discernible metallicity-dependent trends, Fornax displays a tentative flattening of [Al/Fe] near [Fe/H]$\sim-0.75$ after an initial decline with increasing metallicity.
\item Leveraging Fnx’s larger stellar sample, we investigated radial chemical abundance gradients. While confirming the previously reported metallicity gradient, we detected no significant radial trends for O, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, or Ti. This may reflect Fnx's complex star-formation history and potential merger events.
\item N-rich field stars --- potential escapees from globular clusters (GCs) formed in dense environments --- are absent in Dra, Car or Sex, consistent with their lack of GC as low-mass dwarfs. However, N-rich field stars were identified in Fnx. These stars exhibit no anomalous abundances in other measured elements and show metallicities distinct from known Fnx GCs, suggesting they may represent remnants of one or more dissolved GCs.
\end{enumerate}
In the coming years, next-generation astronomical facilities --- such as the Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) and multi-fiber spectroscopic surveys (e.g., 4MOST, WEAVE, DESI) --- will deliver increasingly detailed chemical profiles of member stars within dwarf galaxies. These advancements will enable tighter constraints on abundance patterns at the metal-poor end, a critical input for modeling the early evolutionary stages of these systems. By conducting comprehensive studies of dwarf galaxies across a range of mass scales, we will gain transformative insights into their formation histories and dynamical interactions, significantly advancing our understanding of galaxy evolution and the cosmic processes shaping these faint stellar systems.
\begin{acknowledgements}
C.X. and B.T. gratefully acknowledge support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China through grants NOs. 12233013 and 12473035, China Manned Space Project under grant NO. CMS-CSST-2025-A13 and CMS-CSST-2021-A08, the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities, Sun Yat-sen University (24qnpy121). J.G.F.-T. gratefully acknowledges the grant support provided by ANID Fondecyt Iniciaci\'on No. 11220340, ANID Fondecyt Postdoc No. 3230001, and from the Joint Committee ESO-Government of Chile under the agreement 2023 ORP 062/2023. Z.Y. acknowledges the support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grant numbers 12203021.
D.G. gratefully acknowledges the support provided by Fondecyt regular no. 1220264.
D.G. also acknowledges financial support from the Direcci\'on de Investigaci\'on y Desarrollo de
la Universidad de La Serena through the Programa de Incentivo a la Investigaci\'on de
Acad\'emicos (PIA-DIDULS).
\end{acknowledgements}
% WARNING
%-------------------------------------------------------------------
% Please note that we have included the references to the file aa.dem in
% order to compile it, but we ask you to:
%
% - use BibTeX with the regular commands:
% \bibliographystyle{aa} % style aa.bst
% \bibliography{Yourfile} % your references Yourfile.bib
%
% - join the .bib files when you upload your source files
\bibliographystyle{aa}
\bibliography{MW_satellite.bib}
%\begin{comment}
\begin{appendix} %First appendix
\appendix
\onecolumn
\centering
\section{Information on all sample stars}
\label{app:sample}
\begin{longtable}{ccccccccccc}
\caption{Basic information on all sample stars}
\label{Table: Full Dwarf members stellar parameters}
\\
\hline\hline%\cline{2-9}
\\[-3pt]
\# & APOGEE ID & RA & DEC & $\mathrm{T_{eff}}$ & log $g$ & $RV$ & S/N & Gmag & BP-RP & Dwarf Galaxy\\
& & [deg] & [deg] & [K] & & [km s$^{-1}$] & & [mag] & [mag]\\
\hline
\\[-3pt]
\endfirsthead
\hline\hline%\cline{2-9}
\\[-3pt]
\# & APOGEE ID & RA & DEC & $\mathrm{T_{eff}}$ & log $g$ & $RV$ & S/N & Gmag & BP-RP & Dwarf Galaxy\\
& & [deg] & [deg] & [K] & & [km s$^{-1}$] & & [mag] & [mag]\\
\hline
\\[-3pt]
\endhead
\hline
\endfoot
\hline
\endlastfoot
1 & 2M02403081-3422028 & 40.12842 & $-34.36745$ & 3626 & 0.35 & 81 & 82 & 17.61 & 1.77 & Fnx\\
2 & 2M02372118-3437451 & 39.33825 & $-34.62923$ & 3845 & 0.74 & 63 & 112 & 17.59 & 1.93 & Fnx\\
3 & 2M02392578-3442220 & 39.85744 & $-34.70617$ & 3586 & 0.27 & 59 & 130 & 17.40 & 2.19 & Fnx\\
4 & 2M02402354-3415204 & 40.09813 & $-34.25565$ & 3552 & 0.24 & 36 & 96 & 17.70 & 2.06 & Fnx\\
5 & 2M02413913-3405505 & 40.41308 & $-34.09736$ & 3684 & 0.56 & 59 & 78 & 17.84 & 1.82 & Fnx\\
6 & 2M02381712-3425482 & 39.57135 & $-34.43009$ & 3696 & 0.56 & 54 & 114 & 17.51 & 2.18 & Fnx\\
7 & 2M02410066-3415551 & 40.25277 & $-34.26532$ & 3796 & 0.72 & 57 & 80 & 17.78 & 1.86 & Fnx\\
8 & 2M02380004-3444219 & 39.50015 & $-34.73947$ & 3806 & 0.75 & 40 & 84 & 17.80 & 1.88 & Fnx\\
9 & 2M02372718-3430033 & 39.36329 & $-34.50095$ & 4012 & 0.97 & 50 & 72 & 17.86 & 1.79 & Fnx\\
10 & 2M02390557-3432503 & 39.77323 & $-34.54732$ & 4054 & 1.01 & 57 & 76 & 17.85 & 1.83 & Fnx\\
11 & 2M02373820-3424530 & 39.40918 & $-34.41473$ & 3668 & 0.48 & 65 & 84 & 17.64 & 1.92 & Fnx\\
12 & 2M02393333-3438302 & 39.88889 & $-34.64173$ & 3800 & 0.69 & 53 & 96 & 17.56 & 2.00 & Fnx\\
13 & 2M02384789-3439397 & 39.69955 & $-34.66104$ & 4037 & 1.00 & 42 & 70 & 17.89 & 1.77 & Fnx\\
14 & 2M02385954-3445362 & 39.74808 & $-34.76010$ & 3779 & 0.72 & 53 & 70 & 17.85 & 1.83 & Fnx\\
15 & 2M02375588-3447160 & 39.48286 & $-34.78779$ & 4019 & 0.98 & 31 & 71 & 17.88 & 1.77 & Fnx\\
16 & 2M02384113-3444205 & 39.67132 & $-34.73905$ & 4031 & 0.85 & 50 & 70 & 17.61 & 1.64 & Fnx\\
17 & 2M02385365-3433048 & 39.72355 & $-34.55134$ & 3812 & 0.77 & 39 & 77 & 17.85 & 1.87 & Fnx\\
18 & 2M02392438-3432530 & 39.85161 & $-34.54810$ & 3918 & 0.79 & 41 & 106 & 17.49 & 1.99 & Fnx\\
19 & 2M02383024-3445030 & 39.62601 & $-34.75087$ & 3565 & 0.24 & 56 & 86 & 17.66 & 1.95 & Fnx\\
20 & 2M02372807-3431053 & 39.36702 & $-34.51817$ & 3922 & 0.89 & 55 & 101 & 17.63 & 2.13 & Fnx\\
21 & 2M02393076-3451354 & 39.87812 & $-34.85985$ & 3972 & 0.96 & 54 & 71 & 17.87 & 1.86 & Fnx\\
22 & 2M02394140-3422511 & 39.92243 & $-34.38085$ & 3715 & 0.64 & 59 & 72 & 17.87 & 1.86 & Fnx\\
23 & 2M02370583-3432342 & 39.27432 & $-34.54286$ & 3733 & 0.61 & 46 & 85 & 17.69 & 1.91 & Fnx\\
24 & 2M02393198-3419234 & 39.88329 & $-34.32318$ & 3495 & 0.65 & 54 & 71 & 17.83 & 1.82 & Fnx\\
25 & 2M02393285-3417028 & 39.88670 & $-34.28409$ & 4126 & 1.70 & 56 & 101 & 17.57 & 2.21 & Fnx\\
26 & 2M02392221-3412133 & 39.84261 & $-34.20371$ & 3747 & 0.63 & 45 & 82 & 17.70 & 1.89 & Fnx\\
27 & 2M02384018-3439121 & 39.66743 & $-34.65336$ & 3657 & 0.48 & 40 & 84 & 17.77 & 1.82 & Fnx\\
28 & 2M02412486-3422044 & 40.35363 & $-34.36794$ & 3705 & 0.57 & 63 & 73 & 17.79 & 1.78 & Fnx\\
29 & 2M02395861-3425279 & 39.99427 & $-34.42443$ & 3620 & 0.32 & 57 & 140 & 17.24 & 2.30 & Fnx\\
30 & 2M02402780-3412351 & 40.11589 & $-34.20972$ & 4215 & 1.11 & 45 & 75 & 17.82 & 1.76 & Fnx\\
31 & 2M02394049-3419391 & 39.91870 & $-34.32756$ & 4182 & 1.13 & 51 & 75 & 17.84 & 1.87 & Fnx\\
32 & 2M02393365-3424419 & 39.89019 & $-34.41165$ & 4519 & 1.37 & 42 & 70 & 17.86 & 1.89 & Fnx\\
33 & 2M17210223+5815384 & 260.25928 & 58.26062 & 4961 & 1.06 & $-274$ & 107 & 16.71 & 1.54 & Dra \\
34 & 2M17193600+5756289 & 259.90003 & 57.94136 & 4810 & 1.14 & $-289$ & 73 & 17.13 & 1.48 & Dra \\
35 & 2M17184224+5759099 & 259.67599 & 57.98609 & 4883 & 1.03 & $-288$ & 103 & 16.74 & 1.53 & Dra \\
36 & 2M17185211+5804130 & 259.71709 & 58.07026 & 4888 & 1.06 & $-292$ & 107 & 16.79 & 1.56 & Dra \\
37 & 2M17191225+5802577 & 259.80107 & 58.04937 & 4503 & 0.90 & $-281$ & 85 & 16.97 & 1.45 & Dra \\
38 & 2M17200396+5759082 & 260.01655 & 57.98564 & 4209 & 0.66 & $-289$ & 110 & 16.80 & 1.59 & Dra \\
39 & 2M17193545+5758465 & 259.89772 & 57.97959 & 4295 & 0.80 & $-279$ & 85 & 17.03 & 1.50 & Dra \\
40 & 2M17191342+5752334 & 259.80604 & 57.87592 & 4437 & 0.89 & $-281$ & 78 & 17.04 & 1.47 & Dra \\
41 & 2M17195181+5759177 & 259.96588 & 57.98826 & 4305 & 0.85 & $-300$ & 71 & 17.16 & 1.45 & Dra \\
42 & 2M17180807+5801468 & 259.53360 & 58.02968 & 4862 & 1.02 & $-309$ & 103 & 16.77 & 1.50 & Dra \\
43 & 2M17205204+5759477 & 260.21692 & 57.99659 & 4399 & 0.89 & $-293$ & 72 & 17.10 & 1.47 & Dra \\
44 & 2M17215819+5756042 & 260.49254 & 57.93446 & 4453 & 0.84 & $-302$ & 78 & 16.91 & 1.44 & Dra \\
45 & 2M17221363+5753065 & 260.55683 & 57.88510 & 4150 & 0.64 & $-302$ & 80 & 16.89 & 1.49 & Dra \\
46 & 2M17162365+5752345 & 259.09860 & 57.87624 & 4660 & 0.99 & $-282$ & 76 & 16.99 & 1.44 & Dra \\
47 & 2M17194767+5748365 & 259.94869 & 57.81015 & 4465 & 0.81 & $-280$ & 88 & 16.76 & 1.53 & Dra \\
48 & 2M06415460-5057007 & 100.47748 & $-50.95019$ & 4309 & 0.87 & 232 & 78 & 17.09 & 1.65 & Car \\
49 & 2M06414823-5055016 & 100.45096 & $-50.91713$ & 4587 & 1.05 & 224 & 88 & 17.15 & 1.60 & Car \\
50 & 2M06412612-5055439 & 100.35881 & $-50.92886$ & 4466 & 0.98 & 215 & 86 & 17.16 & 1.57 & Car \\
51 & 2M06422826-5100038 & 100.61778 & $-51.00108$ & 4660 & 1.14 & 214 & 82 & 17.28 & 1.58 & Car \\
52 & 2M06420106-5103442 & 100.50446 & $-51.06228$ & 4319 & 0.96 & 225 & 71 & 17.38 & 1.50 & Car \\
53 & 2M06415985-5101533 & 100.49940 & $-51.03147$ & 4801 & 1.16 & 217 & 93 & 17.11 & 1.62 & Car \\
54 & 2M06412718-5100182 & 100.36326 & $-51.00510$ & 4507 & 1.05 & 233 & 78 & 17.29 & 1.53 & Car \\
55 & 2M06411470-5051099 & 100.31128 & $-50.85277$ & 4056 & 0.70 & 220 & 73 & 17.23 & 1.49 & Car \\
56 & 2M06415969-5051133 & 100.49872 & $-50.85368$ & 3714 & 0.35 & 211 & 73 & 17.30 & 1.56 & Car \\
57 & 2M06413963-5049587 & 100.41515 & $-50.83298$ & 4652 & 1.09 & 230 & 84 & 17.14 & 1.58 & Car \\
58 & 2M06403111-5055246 & 100.12971 & $-50.92348$ & 5029 & 1.34 & 213 & 74 & 17.33 & 1.51 & Car \\
59 & 2M06410537-5105257 & 100.27240 & $-51.09047$ & 4243 & 0.81 & 227 & 96 & 17.10 & 1.57 & Car \\
60 & 2M06411566-5059480 & 100.31527 & $-50.99668$ & 4074 & 0.77 & 227 & 78 & 17.37 & 1.53 & Car \\
61 & 2M06405789-5102276 & 100.24127 & $-51.04100$ & 4447 & 1.00 & 226 & 70 & 17.30 & 1.44 & Car \\
62 & 2M06403082-5059153 & 100.12848 & $-50.98756$ & 3777 & 0.44 & 217 & 74 & 17.32 & 1.52 & Car \\
63 & 2M06404635-5101392 & 100.19319 & $-51.02753$ & 4975 & 1.27 & 230 & 79 & 17.22 & 1.53 & Car \\
64 & 2M06410501-5101359 & 100.27090 & $-51.02663$ & 4532 & 1.02 & 221 & 94 & 17.15 & 1.58 & Car \\
65 & 2M06404775-5106033 & 100.19901 & $-51.10094$ & 4335 & 0.88 & 236 & 89 & 17.11 & 1.59 & Car \\
66 & 2M06411676-5100540 & 100.31984 & $-51.01501$ & 4048 & 0.74 & 221 & 70 & 17.35 & 1.48 & Car \\
67 & 2M10143985-0110527 & 153.66609 & $-1.18129$ & 4506 & 1.19 & 239 & 54 & 17.32 & 1.50 & Sex \\
68 & 2M10133675-0108018 & 153.40315 & $-1.13382$ & 4699 & 0.72 & 235 & 74 & 16.75 & 1.53 & Sex \\
69 & 2M10143342-0135549 & 153.63932 & $-1.59858$ & 4631 & 1.19 & 216 & 42 & 17.42 & 1.46 & Sex \\
70 & 2M10111188-0148488 & 152.79948 & $-1.81351$ & 5001 & 1.48 & 228 & 65 & 17.14 & 1.48 & Sex \\
71 & 2M10135723-0144452 & 153.48848 & $-1.74586$ & 4711 & 1.03 & 218 & 57 & 17.48 & 1.44 & Sex \\
72 & 2M10121613-0145482 & 153.06727 & $-1.76341$ & 3990 & 1.16 & 221 & 71 & 17.25 & 1.49 & Sex \\
73 & 2M10133529-0117548 & 153.39708 & $-1.29854$ & 4308 & 1.03 & 227 & 50 & 17.32 & 1.47 & Sex \\
74 & 2M10122523-0122257 & 153.10512 & $-1.37386$ & 4316 & 0.63 & 220 & 88 & 16.79 & 1.64 & Sex \\
\hline
\end{longtable}
%\twocolumn
\begin{longtable}{cccccccccccccc}
\caption{Chemical abundance of all sample stars}
\label{Table: chemi_abu}
\\
\hline\hline%\cline{2-9}
\\[-0.5pt]
\# & [Fe/H] & [C/Fe] & [N/Fe] & [O/Fe] & [Mg/Fe] & [Al/Fe] & [Si/Fe] & [Ca/Fe] & [Ti/Fe] & [Cr/Fe] & [Mn/Fe] & [Ni/Fe] & [Ce/Fe]\\
\hline
\\[-0.5pt]
\endfirsthead
\hline\hline%\cline{2-9}
\\[-0.5pt]
\# & [Fe/H] & [C/Fe] & [N/Fe] & [O/Fe] & [Mg/Fe] & [Al/Fe] & [Si/Fe] & [Ca/Fe] & [Ti/Fe] & [Cr/Fe] & [Mn/Fe] & [Ni/Fe] & [Ce/Fe]\\
\hline
\\[-0.5pt]
\endhead
\hline
\endfoot
\hline
\endlastfoot
1 & -1.65 & ... & ... & -0.13 & 0.11 & -0.47 & 0.28 & 0.15 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
2 & -1.32 & ... & ... & ... & ... & -0.89 & -0.08 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & -0.07 \\
3 & -1.21 & 0.45 & 0.56 & 0.35 & 0.29 & -0.42 & 0.39 & 0.14 & 0.04 & ... & ... & 0.11 & 0.19 \\
4 & -1.12 & ... & ... & 0.05 & -0.09 & -0.81 & 0.07 & -0.09 & -0.51 & ... & -0.16 & ... & 0.14 \\
5 & -1.1 & ... & ... & -0.31 & -0.05 & -0.43 & 0.18 & 0.04 & 0.22 & -0.27 & -0.04 & ... & 0.26 \\
6 & -1.07 & 0.05 & -0.13 & 0.27 & -0.07 & -0.5 & 0.11 & 0.09 & -0.24 & -0.33 & -0.15 & -0.01 & 0.18 \\
7 & -1.04 & -0.47 & 0.36 & -0.06 & ... & -0.46 & 0.03 & -0.01 & 0.15 & 0.03 & -0.25 & ... & 0.32 \\
8 & -1.01 & -0.13 & 0.07 & 0.21 & ... & -0.8 & 0.12 & -0.03 & -0.29 & -0.15 & -0.17 & 0.09 & 0.32 \\
9 & -0.99 & ... & ... & 0.47 & -0.13 & -0.32 & 0.15 & 0.24 & 0.14 & 0.14 & -0.09 & -0.37 & 0.46 \\
10 & -0.98 & -0.52 & \textbf{1.23} & 0.46 & -0.19 & -0.38 & -0.05 & ... & 0.0 & -0.14 & -0.32 & ... & 0.07 \\
11 & -0.97 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & 0.06 & ... & 0.3 & ... & -0.19 & ... & -0.17 \\
12 & -0.96 & -0.08 & 0.22 & 0.25 & -0.27 & -0.74 & -0.04 & -0.06 & -0.27 & ... & -0.25 & ... & 0.3 \\
13 & -0.94 & ... & ... & 0.43 & -0.43 & -0.3 & -0.08 & 0.14 & 0.22 & 0.04 & -0.23 & ... & 0.37 \\
14 & -0.93 & -0.41 & 0.45 & 0.03 & -0.13 & -0.29 & 0.13 & -0.04 & -0.07 & -0.5 & -0.25 & ... & 0.36 \\
15 & -0.92 & -0.36 & 0.36 & 0.26 & -0.33 & -0.61 & -0.06 & -0.13 & -0.02 & -0.21 & -0.27 & -0.16 & 0.14 \\
16 & -0.91 & ... & ... & 0.31 & 0.01 & -0.3 & 0.12 & 0.13 & 0.26 & -0.02 & -0.18 & ... & ... \\
17 & -0.9 & -0.51 & -0.01 & 0.05 & -0.18 & -0.51 & 0.01 & -0.15 & -0.33 & -0.02 & -0.22 & ... & 0.16 \\
18 & -0.89 & -0.1 & \textbf{0.67} & 0.51 & -0.18 & -0.35 & 0.0 & -0.06 & -0.17 & -0.3 & -0.32 & -0.21 & 0.3 \\
19 & -0.85 & -0.77 & 0.27 & -0.06 & -0.15 & ... & -0.03 & -0.36 & -0.37 & -0.56 & -0.41 & -0.39 & -0.13 \\
20 & -0.81 & -0.42 & \textbf{0.94} & 0.54 & -0.35 & -0.44 & -0.05 & 0.01 & 0.22 & ... & -0.23 & -0.36 & 0.32 \\
21 & -0.8 & -0.4 & \textbf{0.68} & 0.36 & -0.17 & -0.64 & 0.03 & -0.11 & -0.12 & -0.36 & -0.18 & -0.48 & 0.31 \\
22 & -0.79 & ... & ... & -0.19 & -0.41 & -0.58 & -0.02 & -0.1 & -0.17 & ... & -0.36 & ... & 0.03 \\
23 & -0.77 & ... & ... & -0.08 & -0.27 & -0.56 & 0.11 & -0.14 & -0.27 & -0.37 & -0.41 & -0.26 & 0.11 \\
24 & -0.76 & -1.22 & 0.4 & -0.54 & 0.0 & -0.68 & 0.27 & -0.22 & -0.04 & ... & -0.48 & -0.31 & -0.12 \\
25 & -0.73 & -0.02 & 0.74 & 0.91 & -0.34 & -0.35 & 0.05 & 0.11 & 0.54 & -0.11 & -0.19 & -0.1 & 1.0 \\
26 & -0.73 & -0.65 & 0.13 & 0.0 & -0.17 & -0.48 & 0.07 & -0.15 & -0.37 & -0.34 & -0.38 & -0.17 & 0.23 \\
27 & -0.72 & ... & ... & -0.31 & -0.22 & -0.61 & 0.02 & -0.23 & -0.27 & -0.17 & -0.65 & -0.2 & 0.09 \\
28 & -0.7 & ... & ... & -0.22 & -0.29 & -0.65 & 0.07 & 0.08 & -0.52 & -0.44 & -0.54 & -0.14 & 0.0 \\
29 & -0.67 & -0.15 & 0.42 & 0.21 & -0.18 & -0.42 & -0.04 & 0.04 & -0.24 & -0.21 & -0.11 & 0.15 & 0.33 \\
30 & -0.63 & -0.29 & 0.89 & 0.71 & -0.1 & -0.4 & 0.01 & 0.21 & 0.3 & -0.04 & -0.21 & ... & 0.8 \\
31 & -0.55 & ... & ... & 0.64 & -0.05 & ... & 0.1 & 0.2 & 0.3 & -0.14 & -0.17 & -0.17 & 0.7 \\
32 & -0.37 & ... & ... & ... & -0.07 & ... & -0.15 & 0.23 & ... & -0.02 & -0.13 & -0.23 & 1.01 \\
33 & -1.59 & 0.43 & 1.17 & 1.22 & -0.23 & ... & -0.03 & ... & 0.32 & ... & ... & ... & 0.68 \\
34 & -1.25 & -0.38 & ... & 0.96 & -0.31 & -0.25 & -0.19 & 0.26 & ... & ... & -0.06 & ... & ... \\
35 & -1.67 & ... & ... & 1.24 & 0.04 & -0.55 & 0.12 & ... & 0.38 & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
36 & -1.26 & ... & ... & 1.12 & 0.04 & -0.59 & ... & ... & 0.32 & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
37 & -1.92 & ... & ... & 0.74 & -0.04 & -0.46 & 0.36 & 0.43 & 0.05 & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
38 & -1.47 & -0.41 & 0.46 & 0.31 & -0.24 & -0.28 & -0.03 & ... & ... & ... & -0.47 & ... & 0.13 \\
39 & -1.7 & 0.04 & ... & 0.41 & -0.07 & -0.53 & 0.11 & 0.41 & ... & ... & ... & -0.48 & 0.11 \\
40 & -1.67 & ... & ... & 0.6 & ... & -0.41 & 0.14 & -0.02 & 0.04 & ... & ... & ... & 0.28 \\
41 & -1.76 & ... & ... & 0.42 & 0.07 & ... & 0.02 & 0.21 & ... & ... & ... & 0.3 & ... \\
42 & -1.78 & ... & ... & 1.02 & -0.13 & -0.45 & 0.2 & ... & ... & ... & ... & 0.36 & ... \\
43 & -1.63 & ... & ... & 0.59 & 0.05 & ... & 0.05 & 0.05 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
44 & -2.25 & ... & ... & 0.65 & -0.07 & -0.25 & -0.1 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
45 & -2.17 & ... & ... & 0.37 & -0.01 & ... & 0.19 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & 0.39 \\
46 & -1.95 & -0.04 & ... & 0.97 & -0.09 & ... & 0.03 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
47 & -1.74 & -0.29 & ... & 0.72 & 0.03 & -0.55 & 0.08 & ... & -0.35 & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
48 & -1.67 & ... & ... & 0.28 & ... & ... & -0.32 & ... & -0.17 & ... & ... & -0.43 & -0.11 \\
49 & -1.18 & ... & ... & 0.73 & -0.01 & -0.38 & 0.06 & 0.08 & 0.25 & ... & -0.08 & ... & 0.07 \\
50 & -1.02 & ... & ... & 0.59 & -0.04 & -0.48 & 0.04 & 0.17 & 0.12 & ... & -0.21 & ... & 0.03 \\
51 & -1.19 & ... & ... & 0.84 & 0.23 & -0.21 & 0.01 & 0.36 & 0.5 & ... & -0.06 & -0.02 & 0.03 \\
52 & -1.51 & ... & ... & 0.39 & -0.06 & ... & 0.09 & 0.46 & 0.7 & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
53 & -1.61 & ... & ... & 1.15 & -0.14 & -0.37 & -0.03 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & 0.26 \\
54 & -1.58 & ... & ... & 0.74 & -0.02 & -0.24 & 0.28 & 0.47 & 0.28 & ... & ... & 0.12 & 0.15 \\
55 & -1.75 & -0.05 & 0.39 & 0.09 & ... & -0.33 & 0.18 & 0.52 & 0.68 & 0.28 & ... & -0.33 & 0.26 \\
56 & -1.81 & -1.06 & ... & -0.42 & 0.03 & ... & 0.39 & 0.11 & 0.19 & ... & -0.29 & -0.33 & -0.15 \\
57 & -1.21 & ... & ... & 0.92 & ... & -0.09 & 0.11 & ... & 0.32 & ... & -0.1 & -0.09 & 0.56 \\
58 & -1.16 & ... & ... & 1.15 & -0.03 & -0.65 & -0.01 & ... & 0.3 & ... & ... & ... & -0.01 \\
59 & -1.54 & -0.46 & ... & 0.44 & -0.11 & -0.51 & 0.19 & 0.25 & -0.13 & ... & -0.24 & -0.36 & 0.18 \\
60 & -1.54 & ... & ... & 0.17 & 0.05 & -0.35 & 0.34 & -0.04 & 0.73 & ... & -0.24 & -0.1 & ... \\
61 & -1.29 & -0.2 & ... & 0.47 & ... & -0.5 & 0.09 & -0.03 & -0.16 & ... & -0.03 & ... & 0.13 \\
62 & -1.92 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & 0.3 & ... & ... & ... & ... & 0.35 & -0.03 \\
63 & -1.25 & ... & ... & 1.17 & -0.02 & -0.28 & 0.09 & 0.21 & ... & ... & ... & 0.22 & ... \\
64 & -1.04 & -0.34 & 0.34 & 0.65 & -0.03 & -0.41 & 0.18 & -0.2 & 0.13 & ... & -0.11 & -0.02 & 0.06 \\
65 & -2.1 & ... & ... & 0.51 & 0.24 & -0.5 & 0.27 & 0.56 & ... & ... & ... & ... & 0.19 \\
66 & -1.96 & 0.11 & ... & 0.13 & ... & ... & 0.23 & ... & ... & ... & -0.17 & ... & 0.18 \\
67 & -1.34 & ... & ... & 0.52 & -0.55 & ... & -0.07 & ... & -0.32 & ... & ... & ... & -0.08 \\
68 & -1.99 & 0.4 & ... & ... & 0.03 & -0.39 & -0.05 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
69 & -1.67 & 0.34 & 0.2 & ... & -0.2 & ... & -0.02 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
70 & -1.62 & ... & ... & ... & -0.45 & ... & 0.03 & 0.17 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... \\
71 & -1.37 & ... & ... & ... & -0.54 & ... & -0.14 & -0.08 & ... & ... & ... & -0.05 & 0.17 \\
72 & -1.6 & -0.37 & 0.03 & -0.31 & -0.71 & -1.05 & 0.11 & ... & -0.45 & ... & ... & -0.47 & -0.08 \\
73 & -1.44 & -0.47 & ... & 0.2 & -0.6 & ... & -0.13 & ... & -0.14 & ... & ... & -0.17 & 0.25 \\
74 & -1.62 & ... & ... & 0.5 & 0.11 & -0.67 & 0.07 & ... & -0.32 & ... & ... & -0.09 & -0.07 \\
\hline
\end{longtable}
%\twocolumn
\end{appendix}
%\end{comment}
\end{document}
%
\begin{thebibliography}{116}
\expandafter\ifx\csname natexlab\endcsname\relax\def\natexlab#1{#1}\fi
\bibitem[{{Abdurro'uf} {et~al.}(2022){Abdurro'uf}, {Accetta}, {Aerts}, {Silva
Aguirre}, {Ahumada}, {Ajgaonkar}, {Filiz Ak}, {Alam}, {Allende Prieto},
{Almeida}, {Anders}, {Anderson}, {Andrews}, {Anguiano}, {Aquino-Ort{\'\i}z},
{Arag{\'o}n-Salamanca}, {Argudo-Fern{\'a}ndez}, {Ata}, {Aubert},
{Avila-Reese}, {Badenes}, {Barb{\'a}}, {Barger}, {Barrera-Ballesteros},
{Beaton}, {Beers}, {Belfiore}, {Bender}, {Bernardi}, {Bershady}, {Beutler},
{Bidin}, {Bird}, {Bizyaev}, {Blanc}, {Blanton}, {Boardman}, {Bolton},
{Boquien}, {Borissova}, {Bovy}, {Brandt}, {Brown}, {Brownstein}, {Brusa},
{Buchner}, {Bundy}, {Burchett}, {Bureau}, {Burgasser}, {Cabang}, {Campbell},
{Cappellari}, {Carlberg}, {Wanderley}, {Carrera}, {Cash}, {Chen}, {Chen},
{Cherinka}, {Chiappini}, {Choi}, {Chojnowski}, {Chung}, {Clerc}, {Cohen},
{Comerford}, {Comparat}, {da Costa}, {Covey}, {Crane}, {Cruz-Gonzalez},
{Culhane}, {Cunha}, {Dai}, {Damke}, {Darling}, {Davidson}, {Davies},
{Dawson}, {De Lee}, {Diamond-Stanic}, {Cano-D{\'\i}az}, {S{\'a}nchez},
{Donor}, {Duckworth}, {Dwelly}, {Eisenstein}, {Elsworth}, {Emsellem},
{Eracleous}, {Escoffier}, {Fan}, {Farr}, {Feng}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Feuillet}, {Filipp}, {Fillingham}, {Frinchaboy}, {Fromenteau}, {Galbany},
{Garc{\'\i}a}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Ge}, {Geisler}, {Gelfand},
{G{\'e}ron}, {Gibson}, {Goddy}, {Godoy-Rivera}, {Grabowski}, {Green},
{Greener}, {Grier}, {Griffith}, {Guo}, {Guy}, {Hadjara}, {Harding},
{Hasselquist}, {Hayes}, {Hearty}, {Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Hill}, {Hogg},
{Holtzman}, {Horta}, {Hsieh}, {Hsu}, {Hsu}, {Huber}, {Huertas-Company},
{Hutchinson}, {Hwang}, {Ibarra-Medel}, {Chitham}, {Ilha}, {Imig}, {Jaekle},
{Jayasinghe}, {Ji}, {Johnson}, {Jones}, {J{\"o}nsson}, {Katkov}, {Khalatyan},
{Kinemuchi}, {Kisku}, {Knapen}, {Kneib}, {Kollmeier}, {Kong}, {Kounkel},
{Kreckel}, {Krishnarao}, {Lacerna}, {Lane}, {Langgin}, {Lavender}, {Law},
{Lazarz}, {Leung}, {Leung}, {Lewis}, {Li}, {Li}, {Lian}, {Liang}, {Lin},
{Lin}, {Lin}, {Lintott}, {Long}, {Longa-Pe{\~n}a}, {L{\'o}pez-Cob{\'a}},
{Lu}, {Lundgren}, {Luo}, {Mackereth}, {de la Macorra}, {Mahadevan},
{Majewski}, {Manchado}, {Mandeville}, {Maraston}, {Margalef-Bentabol},
{Masseron}, {Masters}, {Mathur}, {McDermid}, {Mckay}, {Merloni},
{Merrifield}, {Meszaros}, {Miglio}, {Di Mille}, {Minniti}, {Minsley},
{Monachesi}, {Moon}, {Mosser}, {Mulchaey}, {Muna}, {Mu{\~n}oz}, {Myers},
{Myers}, {Nadathur}, {Nair}, {Nandra}, {Neumann}, {Newman}, {Nidever},
{Nikakhtar}, {Nitschelm}, {O'Connell}, {Garma-Oehmichen}, {Luan Souza de
Oliveira}, {Olney}, {Oravetz}, {Ortigoza-Urdaneta}, {Osorio}, {Otter},
{Pace}, {Padilla}, {Pan}, {Pan}, {Parikh}, {Parker}, {Peirani}, {Pe{\~n}a
Ram{\'\i}rez}, {Penny}, {Percival}, {Perez-Fournon}, {Pinsonneault},
{Poidevin}, {Poovelil}, {Price-Whelan}, {B{\'a}rbara de Andrade Queiroz},
{Raddick}, {Ray}, {Rembold}, {Riddle}, {Riffel}, {Riffel}, {Rix}, {Robin},
{Rodr{\'\i}guez-Puebla}, {Roman-Lopes}, {Rom{\'a}n-Z{\'u}{\~n}iga}, {Rose},
{Ross}, {Rossi}, {Rubin}, {Salvato}, {S{\'a}nchez}, {S{\'a}nchez-Gallego},
{Sanderson}, {Santana Rojas}, {Sarceno}, {Sarmiento}, {Sayres}, {Sazonova},
{Schaefer}, {Schiavon}, {Schlegel}, {Schneider}, {Schultheis}, {Schwope},
{Serenelli}, {Serna}, {Shao}, {Shapiro}, {Sharma}, {Shen}, {Shetrone}, {Shu},
{Simon}, {Skrutskie}, {Smethurst}, {Smith}, {Sobeck}, {Spoo}, {Sprague},
{Stark}, {Stassun}, {Steinmetz}, {Stello}, {Stone-Martinez},
{Storchi-Bergmann}, {Stringfellow}, {Stutz}, {Su}, {Taghizadeh-Popp},
{Talbot}, {Tayar}, {Telles}, {Teske}, {Thakar}, {Theissen}, {Tkachenko},
{Thomas}, {Tojeiro}, {Hernandez Toledo}, {Troup}, {Trump}, {Trussler},
{Turner}, {Tuttle}, {Unda-Sanzana}, {V{\'a}zquez-Mata}, {Valentini},
{Valenzuela}, {Vargas-Gonz{\'a}lez}, {Vargas-Maga{\~n}a}, {Alfaro},
{Villanova}, {Vincenzo}, {Wake}, {Warfield}, {Washington}, {Weaver},
{Weijmans}, {Weinberg}, {Weiss}, {Westfall}, {Wild}, {Wilde}, {Wilson},
{Wilson}, {Wilson}, {Wolf}, {Wood-Vasey}, {Yan}, {Zamora}, {Zasowski},
{Zhang}, {Zhao}, {Zheng}, {Zheng}, \& {Zhu}}]{2022ApJS..259...35A}
{Abdurro'uf}, {Accetta}, K., {Aerts}, C., {et~al.} 2022, \apjs, 259, 35
\bibitem[{{Adamo} {et~al.}(2024){Adamo}, {Bradley}, {Vanzella}, {Claeyssens},
{Welch}, {Diego}, {Mahler}, {Oguri}, {Sharon}, {Abdurro'uf}, {Hsiao}, {Xu},
{Messa}, {Lassen}, {Zackrisson}, {Brammer}, {Coe}, {Kokorev}, {Ricotti},
{Zitrin}, {Fujimoto}, {Inoue}, {Resseguier}, {Rigby}, {Jim{\'e}nez-Teja},
{Windhorst}, {Hashimoto}, \& {Tamura}}]{2024Natur.632..513A}
{Adamo}, A., {Bradley}, L.~D., {Vanzella}, E., {et~al.} 2024, \nat, 632, 513
\bibitem[{{Allende Prieto} {et~al.}(2006){Allende Prieto}, {Beers}, {Wilhelm},
{Newberg}, {Rockosi}, {Yanny}, \& {Lee}}]{2006ApJ...636..804A}
{Allende Prieto}, C., {Beers}, T.~C., {Wilhelm}, R., {et~al.} 2006, \apj, 636,
804
\bibitem[{{Alonso} {et~al.}(1999){Alonso}, {Arribas}, \&
{Mart{\'\i}nez-Roger}}]{1999A&AS..140..261A}
{Alonso}, A., {Arribas}, S., \& {Mart{\'\i}nez-Roger}, C. 1999, \aaps, 140, 261
\bibitem[{{Alvarez} \& {Plez}(1998)}]{1998A&A...330.1109A}
{Alvarez}, R. \& {Plez}, B. 1998, \aap, 330, 1109
\bibitem[{{Amarsi} {et~al.}(2020){Amarsi}, {Lind}, {Osorio}, {Nordlander},
{Bergemann}, {Reggiani}, {Wang}, {Buder}, {Asplund}, {Barklem}, {Wehrhahn},
{Sk{\'u}lad{\'o}ttir}, {Kobayashi}, {Karakas}, {Gao}, {Bland-Hawthorn}, {de
Silva}, {Kos}, {Lewis}, {Martell}, {Sharma}, {Simpson}, {Zucker},
{{\v{C}}otar}, {Horner}, \& {GALAH Collaboration}}]{nlte2020A&A...642A..62A}
{Amarsi}, A.~M., {Lind}, K., {Osorio}, Y., {et~al.} 2020, \aap, 642, A62
\bibitem[{{Amorisco} \& {Evans}(2012)}]{2012ApJ...756L...2A}
{Amorisco}, N.~C. \& {Evans}, N.~W. 2012, \apjl, 756, L2
\bibitem[{{Arnett}(1971)}]{1971ApJ...166..153A}
{Arnett}, W.~D. 1971, \apj, 166, 153
\bibitem[{{Arnould} {et~al.}(1999){Arnould}, {Goriely}, \&
{Jorissen}}]{arnould1999}
{Arnould}, M., {Goriely}, S., \& {Jorissen}, A. 1999, \aap, 347, 572
\bibitem[{{Asplund} {et~al.}(2005){Asplund}, {Grevesse}, \&
{Sauval}}]{2005ASPC..336...25A}
{Asplund}, M., {Grevesse}, N., \& {Sauval}, A.~J. 2005, in Astronomical Society
of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 336, Cosmic Abundances as Records of
Stellar Evolution and Nucleosynthesis, ed. I.~{Barnes}, Thomas~G. \& F.~N.
{Bash}, 25
\bibitem[{{Barklem} {et~al.}(2005){Barklem}, {Christlieb}, {Beers}, {Hill},
{Bessell}, {Holmberg}, {Marsteller}, {Rossi}, {Zickgraf}, \&
{Reimers}}]{2005A&A...439..129B}
{Barklem}, P.~S., {Christlieb}, N., {Beers}, T.~C., {et~al.} 2005, \aap, 439,
129
\bibitem[{{Bastian} \& {Lardo}(2018)}]{2018ARA&A..56...83B}
{Bastian}, N. \& {Lardo}, C. 2018, \araa, 56, 83
\bibitem[{{Battaglia} {et~al.}(2006){Battaglia}, {Tolstoy}, {Helmi}, {Irwin},
{Letarte}, {Jablonka}, {Hill}, {Venn}, {Shetrone}, {Arimoto}, {Primas},
{Kaufer}, {Francois}, {Szeifert}, {Abel}, \&
{Sadakane}}]{2006A&A...459..423B}
{Battaglia}, G., {Tolstoy}, E., {Helmi}, A., {et~al.} 2006, \aap, 459, 423
\bibitem[{{Beaton} {et~al.}(2021){Beaton}, {Oelkers}, {Hayes}, {Covey},
{Chojnowski}, {De Lee}, {Sobeck}, {Majewski}, {Cohen},
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Longa-Pe{\~n}a}, {O'Connell}, {Santana},
{Stringfellow}, {Zasowski}, {Aerts}, {Anguiano}, {Bender}, {Ca{\~n}as},
{Cunha}, {Donor}, {Fleming}, {Frinchaboy}, {Feuillet}, {Harding},
{Hasselquist}, {Holtzman}, {Johnson}, {Kollmeier}, {Kounkel}, {Mahadevan},
{Price-Whelan}, {Rojas-Arriagada}, {Rom{\'a}n-Z{\'u}{\~n}iga}, {Schlafly},
{Schultheis}, {Shetrone}, {Simon}, {Stassun}, {Stutz}, {Tayar}, {Teske},
{Tkachenko}, {Troup}, {Albareti}, {Bizyaev}, {Bovy}, {Burgasser}, {Comparat},
{Downes}, {Geisler}, {Inno}, {Manchado}, {Ness}, {Pinsonneault}, {Prada},
{Roman-Lopes}, {Simonian}, {Smith}, {Yan}, \& {Zamora}}]{2021AJ....162..302B}
{Beaton}, R.~L., {Oelkers}, R.~J., {Hayes}, C.~R., {et~al.} 2021, \aj, 162, 302
\bibitem[{{Bell} {et~al.}(2003){Bell}, {McIntosh}, {Katz}, \&
{Weinberg}}]{2003ApJS..149..289B}
{Bell}, E.~F., {McIntosh}, D.~H., {Katz}, N., \& {Weinberg}, M.~D. 2003, \apjs,
149, 289
\bibitem[{{Belokurov} {et~al.}(2018){Belokurov}, {Erkal}, {Evans}, {Koposov},
\& {Deason}}]{2018MNRAS.478..611B}
{Belokurov}, V., {Erkal}, D., {Evans}, N.~W., {Koposov}, S.~E., \& {Deason},
A.~J. 2018, \mnras, 478, 611
\bibitem[{{Bensby} {et~al.}(2014){Bensby}, {Feltzing}, \&
{Oey}}]{2014A&A...562A..71B}
{Bensby}, T., {Feltzing}, S., \& {Oey}, M.~S. 2014, \aap, 562, A71
\bibitem[{{Bisterzo} {et~al.}(2014){Bisterzo}, {Travaglio}, {Gallino},
{Wiescher}, \& {K{\"a}ppeler}}]{2014ApJ...787...10B}
{Bisterzo}, S., {Travaglio}, C., {Gallino}, R., {Wiescher}, M., \&
{K{\"a}ppeler}, F. 2014, \apj, 787, 10
\bibitem[{{Blanton} {et~al.}(2017){Blanton}, {Bershady}, {Abolfathi},
{Albareti}, {Allende Prieto}, {Almeida}, {Alonso-Garc{\'\i}a}, {Anders},
{Anderson}, {Andrews}, {Aquino-Ort{\'\i}z}, {Arag{\'o}n-Salamanca},
{Argudo-Fern{\'a}ndez}, {Armengaud}, {Aubourg}, {Avila-Reese}, {Badenes},
{Bailey}, {Barger}, {Barrera-Ballesteros}, {Bartosz}, {Bates}, {Baumgarten},
{Bautista}, {Beaton}, {Beers}, {Belfiore}, {Bender}, {Berlind}, {Bernardi},
{Beutler}, {Bird}, {Bizyaev}, {Blanc}, {Blomqvist}, {Bolton}, {Boquien},
{Borissova}, {van den Bosch}, {Bovy}, {Brandt}, {Brinkmann}, {Brownstein},
{Bundy}, {Burgasser}, {Burtin}, {Busca}, {Cappellari}, {Delgado Carigi},
{Carlberg}, {Carnero Rosell}, {Carrera}, {Chanover}, {Cherinka}, {Cheung},
{G{\'o}mez Maqueo Chew}, {Chiappini}, {Choi}, {Chojnowski}, {Chuang},
{Chung}, {Cirolini}, {Clerc}, {Cohen}, {Comparat}, {da Costa}, {Cousinou},
{Covey}, {Crane}, {Croft}, {Cruz-Gonzalez}, {Garrido Cuadra}, {Cunha},
{Damke}, {Darling}, {Davies}, {Dawson}, {de la Macorra}, {Dell'Agli}, {De
Lee}, {Delubac}, {Di Mille}, {Diamond-Stanic}, {Cano-D{\'\i}az}, {Donor},
{Downes}, {Drory}, {du Mas des Bourboux}, {Duckworth}, {Dwelly}, {Dyer},
{Ebelke}, {Eigenbrot}, {Eisenstein}, {Emsellem}, {Eracleous}, {Escoffier},
{Evans}, {Fan}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Alvar}, {Fernandez-Trincado}, {Feuillet},
{Finoguenov}, {Fleming}, {Font-Ribera}, {Fredrickson}, {Freischlad},
{Frinchaboy}, {Fuentes}, {Galbany}, {Garcia-Dias},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Gaulme}, {Geisler}, {Gelfand},
{Gil-Mar{\'\i}n}, {Gillespie}, {Goddard}, {Gonzalez-Perez}, {Grabowski},
{Green}, {Grier}, {Gunn}, {Guo}, {Guy}, {Hagen}, {Hahn}, {Hall}, {Harding},
{Hasselquist}, {Hawley}, {Hearty}, {Gonzalez Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Ho}, {Hogg},
{Holley-Bockelmann}, {Holtzman}, {Holzer}, {Huehnerhoff}, {Hutchinson},
{Hwang}, {Ibarra-Medel}, {da Silva Ilha}, {Ivans}, {Ivory}, {Jackson},
{Jensen}, {Johnson}, {Jones}, {J{\"o}nsson}, {Jullo}, {Kamble}, {Kinemuchi},
{Kirkby}, {Kitaura}, {Klaene}, {Knapp}, {Kneib}, {Kollmeier}, {Lacerna},
{Lane}, {Lang}, {Law}, {Lazarz}, {Lee}, {Le Goff}, {Liang}, {Li}, {Li},
{Lian}, {Lima}, {Lin}, {Lin}, {Bertran de Lis}, {Liu}, {de Icaza Lizaola},
{Long}, {Lucatello}, {Lundgren}, {MacDonald}, {Deconto Machado}, {MacLeod},
{Mahadevan}, {Geimba Maia}, {Maiolino}, {Majewski}, {Malanushenko},
{Malanushenko}, {Manchado}, {Mao}, {Maraston}, {Marques-Chaves}, {Masseron},
{Masters}, {McBride}, {McDermid}, {McGrath}, {McGreer}, {Medina Pe{\~n}a},
{Melendez}, {Merloni}, {Merrifield}, {Meszaros}, {Meza}, {Minchev},
{Minniti}, {Miyaji}, {More}, {Mulchaey}, {M{\"u}ller-S{\'a}nchez}, {Muna},
{Munoz}, {Myers}, {Nair}, {Nandra}, {Correa do Nascimento}, {Negrete},
{Ness}, {Newman}, {Nichol}, {Nidever}, {Nitschelm}, {Ntelis}, {O'Connell},
{Oelkers}, {Oravetz}, {Oravetz}, {Pace}, {Padilla}, {Palanque-Delabrouille},
{Alonso Palicio}, {Pan}, {Parejko}, {Parikh}, {P{\^a}ris}, {Park}, {Patten},
{Peirani}, {Pellejero-Ibanez}, {Penny}, {Percival}, {Perez-Fournon},
{Petitjean}, {Pieri}, {Pinsonneault}, {Pisani}, {Poleski}, {Prada},
{Prakash}, {Queiroz}, {Raddick}, {Raichoor}, {Barboza Rembold}, {Richstein},
{Riffel}, {Riffel}, {Rix}, {Robin}, {Rockosi}, {Rodr{\'\i}guez-Torres},
{Roman-Lopes}, {Rom{\'a}n-Z{\'u}{\~n}iga}, {Rosado}, {Ross}, {Rossi}, {Ruan},
{Ruggeri}, {Rykoff}, {Salazar-Albornoz}, {Salvato}, {S{\'a}nchez}, {Aguado},
{S{\'a}nchez-Gallego}, {Santana}, {Santiago}, {Sayres}, {Schiavon}, {da Silva
Schimoia}, {Schlafly}, {Schlegel}, {Schneider}, {Schultheis}, {Schuster},
{Schwope}, {Seo}, {Shao}, {Shen}, {Shetrone}, {Shull}, {Simon}, {Skinner},
{Skrutskie}, {Slosar}, {Smith}, {Sobeck}, {Sobreira}, {Somers}, {Souto},
{Stark}, {Stassun}, {Stauffer}, {Steinmetz}, {Storchi-Bergmann},
{Streblyanska}, {Stringfellow}, {Su{\'a}rez}, {Sun}, {Suzuki}, {Szigeti},
{Taghizadeh-Popp}, {Tang}, {Tao}, {Tayar}, {Tembe}, {Teske}, {Thakar},
{Thomas}, {Thompson}, {Tinker}, {Tissera}, {Tojeiro}, {Hernandez Toledo}, {de
la Torre}, {Tremonti}, {Troup}, {Valenzuela}, {Martinez Valpuesta},
{Vargas-Gonz{\'a}lez}, {Vargas-Maga{\~n}a}, {Vazquez}, {Villanova}, {Vivek},
{Vogt}, {Wake}, {Walterbos}, {Wang}, {Weaver}, {Weijmans}, {Weinberg},
{Westfall}, {Whelan}, {Wild}, {Wilson}, {Wood-Vasey}, {Wylezalek}, {Xiao},
{Yan}, {Yang}, {Ybarra}, {Y{\`e}che}, {Zakamska}, {Zamora}, {Zarrouk},
{Zasowski}, {Zhang}, {Zhao}, {Zheng}, {Zheng}, {Zhou}, {Zhou}, {Zhu},
{Zoccali}, \& {Zou}}]{2017AJ....154...28B}
{Blanton}, M.~R., {Bershady}, M.~A., {Abolfathi}, B., {et~al.} 2017, \aj, 154,
28
\bibitem[{{Bowen} \& {Vaughan}(1973)}]{1973ApOpt..12.1430B}
{Bowen}, I.~S. \& {Vaughan}, A.~H., J. 1973, \ao, 12, 1430
\bibitem[{{Busso} {et~al.}(2001){Busso}, {Gallino}, {Lambert}, {Travaglio}, \&
{Smith}}]{2001ApJ...557..802B}
{Busso}, M., {Gallino}, R., {Lambert}, D.~L., {Travaglio}, C., \& {Smith},
V.~V. 2001, \apj, 557, 802
\bibitem[{{Carlin} {et~al.}(2018){Carlin}, {Sheffield}, {Cunha}, \&
{Smith}}]{2018ApJ...859L..10C}
{Carlin}, J.~L., {Sheffield}, A.~A., {Cunha}, K., \& {Smith}, V.~V. 2018,
\apjl, 859, L10
\bibitem[{{Carretta} {et~al.}(2010){Carretta}, {Bragaglia}, {Gratton},
{Recio-Blanco}, {Lucatello}, {D'Orazi}, \& {Cassisi}}]{2010A&A...516A..55C}
{Carretta}, E., {Bragaglia}, A., {Gratton}, R.~G., {et~al.} 2010, \aap, 516,
A55
\bibitem[{{Cayrel} {et~al.}(2004){Cayrel}, {Depagne}, {Spite}, {Hill}, {Spite},
{Fran{\c{c}}ois}, {Plez}, {Beers}, {Primas}, {Andersen}, {Barbuy},
{Bonifacio}, {Molaro}, \& {Nordstr{\"o}m}}]{2004A&A...416.1117C}
{Cayrel}, R., {Depagne}, E., {Spite}, M., {et~al.} 2004, \aap, 416, 1117
\bibitem[{{Chen} \& {Gnedin}(2023)}]{2023MNRAS.522.5638C}
{Chen}, Y. \& {Gnedin}, O.~Y. 2023, \mnras, 522, 5638
\bibitem[{{C{\^o}t{\'e}} {et~al.}(2018){C{\^o}t{\'e}}, {Fryer}, {Belczynski},
{Korobkin}, {Chru{\'s}li{\'n}ska}, {Vassh}, {Mumpower}, {Lippuner},
{Sprouse}, {Surman}, \& {Wollaeger}}]{2018ApJ...855...99C}
{C{\^o}t{\'e}}, B., {Fryer}, C.~L., {Belczynski}, K., {et~al.} 2018, \apj, 855,
99
\bibitem[{{de los Reyes} {et~al.}(2022){de los Reyes}, {Kirby}, {Ji}, \&
{Nu{\~n}ez}}]{2022ApJ...925...66D}
{de los Reyes}, M. A.~C., {Kirby}, E.~N., {Ji}, A.~P., \& {Nu{\~n}ez}, E.~H.
2022, \apj, 925, 66
\bibitem[{{Eisenstein} {et~al.}(2011){Eisenstein}, {Weinberg}, {Agol},
{Aihara}, {Allende Prieto}, {Anderson}, {Arns}, {Aubourg}, {Bailey},
{Balbinot}, {Barkhouser}, {Beers}, {Berlind}, {Bickerton}, {Bizyaev},
{Blanton}, {Bochanski}, {Bolton}, {Bosman}, {Bovy}, {Brandt}, {Breslauer},
{Brewington}, {Brinkmann}, {Brown}, {Brownstein}, {Burger}, {Busca},
{Campbell}, {Cargile}, {Carithers}, {Carlberg}, {Carr}, {Chang}, {Chen},
{Chiappini}, {Comparat}, {Connolly}, {Cortes}, {Croft}, {Cunha}, {da Costa},
{Davenport}, {Dawson}, {De Lee}, {Porto de Mello}, {de Simoni}, {Dean},
{Dhital}, {Ealet}, {Ebelke}, {Edmondson}, {Eiting}, {Escoffier}, {Esposito},
{Evans}, {Fan}, {Femen{\'\i}a Castell{\'a}}, {Dutra Ferreira}, {Fitzgerald},
{Fleming}, {Font-Ribera}, {Ford}, {Frinchaboy}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez},
{Gaudi}, {Ge}, {Ghezzi}, {Gillespie}, {Gilmore}, {Girardi}, {Gott}, {Gould},
{Grebel}, {Gunn}, {Hamilton}, {Harding}, {Harris}, {Hawley}, {Hearty},
{Hennawi}, {Gonz{\'a}lez Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Ho}, {Hogg}, {Holtzman},
{Honscheid}, {Inada}, {Ivans}, {Jiang}, {Jiang}, {Johnson}, {Jordan},
{Jordan}, {Kauffmann}, {Kazin}, {Kirkby}, {Klaene}, {Knapp}, {Kneib},
{Kochanek}, {Koesterke}, {Kollmeier}, {Kron}, {Lampeitl}, {Lang}, {Lawler},
{Le Goff}, {Lee}, {Lee}, {Leisenring}, {Lin}, {Liu}, {Long}, {Loomis},
{Lucatello}, {Lundgren}, {Lupton}, {Ma}, {Ma}, {MacDonald}, {Mack},
{Mahadevan}, {Maia}, {Majewski}, {Makler}, {Malanushenko}, {Malanushenko},
{Mandelbaum}, {Maraston}, {Margala}, {Maseman}, {Masters}, {McBride},
{McDonald}, {McGreer}, {McMahon}, {Mena Requejo}, {M{\'e}nard},
{Miralda-Escud{\'e}}, {Morrison}, {Mullally}, {Muna}, {Murayama}, {Myers},
{Naugle}, {Neto}, {Nguyen}, {Nichol}, {Nidever}, {O'Connell}, {Ogando},
{Olmstead}, {Oravetz}, {Padmanabhan}, {Paegert}, {Palanque-Delabrouille},
{Pan}, {Pandey}, {Parejko}, {P{\^a}ris}, {Pellegrini}, {Pepper}, {Percival},
{Petitjean}, {Pfaffenberger}, {Pforr}, {Phleps}, {Pichon}, {Pieri}, {Prada},
{Price-Whelan}, {Raddick}, {Ramos}, {Reid}, {Reyle}, {Rich}, {Richards},
{Rieke}, {Rieke}, {Rix}, {Robin}, {Rocha-Pinto}, {Rockosi}, {Roe},
{Rollinde}, {Ross}, {Ross}, {Rossetto}, {S{\'a}nchez}, {Santiago}, {Sayres},
{Schiavon}, {Schlegel}, {Schlesinger}, {Schmidt}, {Schneider}, {Sellgren},
{Shelden}, {Sheldon}, {Shetrone}, {Shu}, {Silverman}, {Simmerer}, {Simmons},
{Sivarani}, {Skrutskie}, {Slosar}, {Smee}, {Smith}, {Snedden}, {Stassun},
{Steele}, {Steinmetz}, {Stockett}, {Stollberg}, {Strauss}, {Szalay},
{Tanaka}, {Thakar}, {Thomas}, {Tinker}, {Tofflemire}, {Tojeiro}, {Tremonti},
{Vargas Maga{\~n}a}, {Verde}, {Vogt}, {Wake}, {Wan}, {Wang}, {Weaver},
{White}, {White}, {Wilson}, {Wisniewski}, {Wood-Vasey}, {Yanny}, {Yasuda},
{Y{\`e}che}, {York}, {Young}, {Zasowski}, {Zehavi}, \&
{Zhao}}]{2011AJ....142...72E}
{Eisenstein}, D.~J., {Weinberg}, D.~H., {Agol}, E., {et~al.} 2011, \aj, 142, 72
\bibitem[{{Feltzing} \& {Feuillet}(2023)}]{nlte_al_2023ApJ...953..143F}
{Feltzing}, S. \& {Feuillet}, D. 2023, \apj, 953, 143
\bibitem[{{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado} {et~al.}(2022){Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Beers}, {Barbuy}, {Minniti}, {Chiappini}, {Garro}, {Tang}, {Alves-Brito},
{Villanova}, {Geisler}, {Lane}, \& {Diaz}}]{2022A&A...663A.126F}
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Beers}, T.~C., {Barbuy}, B., {et~al.} 2022,
\aap, 663, A126
\bibitem[{{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado} {et~al.}(2020){Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Beers}, {Minniti}, {Carigi}, {Barbuy}, {Placco}, {Moni Bidin}, {Villanova},
{Roman-Lopes}, \& {Nitschelm}}]{2020ApJ...903L..17F}
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Beers}, T.~C., {Minniti}, D., {et~al.} 2020,
\apjl, 903, L17
\bibitem[{{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado} {et~al.}(2021){Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Beers}, {Minniti}, {Moni Bidin}, {Barbuy}, {Villanova}, {Geisler}, {Lane},
{Roman-Lopes}, \& {Bizyaev}}]{2021A&A...648A..70F}
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Beers}, T.~C., {Minniti}, D., {et~al.} 2021,
\aap, 648, A70
\bibitem[{{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado} {et~al.}(2019){Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Beers}, {Tang}, {Moreno}, {P{\'e}rez-Villegas}, \&
{Ortigoza-Urdaneta}}]{2019MNRAS.488.2864F}
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Beers}, T.~C., {Tang}, B., {et~al.} 2019,
\mnras, 488, 2864
\bibitem[{{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado} {et~al.}(2016){Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Robin}, {Moreno}, {Schiavon}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez}, {Vieira}, {Cunha},
{Zamora}, {Sneden}, {Souto}, {Carrera}, {Johnson}, {Shetrone}, {Zasowski},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Majewski}, {Reyl{\'e}}, {Blanco-Cuaresma},
{Martinez-Medina}, {P{\'e}rez-Villegas}, {Valenzuela}, {Pichardo}, {Meza},
{M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Sobeck}, {Geisler}, {Anders}, {Schultheis}, {Tang},
{Roman-Lopes}, {Mennickent}, {Pan}, {Nitschelm}, \&
{Allard}}]{2016ApJ...833..132F}
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Robin}, A.~C., {Moreno}, E., {et~al.} 2016,
\apj, 833, 132
\bibitem[{{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado} {et~al.}(2017){Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Zamora}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Souto}, {Dell'Agli}, {Schiavon},
{Geisler}, {Tang}, {Villanova}, {Hasselquist}, {Mennickent}, {Cunha},
{Shetrone}, {Allende Prieto}, {Vieira}, {Zasowski}, {Sobeck}, {Hayes},
{Majewski}, {Placco}, {Beers}, {Schleicher}, {Robin}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros},
{Masseron}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez}, {Anders}, {Meza}, {Alves-Brito},
{Carrera}, {Minniti}, {Lane}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Alvar}, {Moreno}, {Pichardo},
{P{\'e}rez-Villegas}, {Schultheis}, {Roman-Lopes}, {Fuentes}, {Nitschelm},
{Harding}, {Bizyaev}, {Pan}, {Oravetz}, {Simmons}, {Ivans},
{Blanco-Cuaresma}, {Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Alonso-Garc{\'\i}a}, {Valenzuela}, \&
{Chanam{\'e}}}]{2017ApJ...846L...2F}
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Zamora}, O., {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez},
D.~A., {et~al.} 2017, \apjl, 846, L2
\bibitem[{{Forbes} {et~al.}(2020){Forbes}, {Alabi}, {Romanowsky}, {Brodie}, \&
{Arimoto}}]{2020MNRAS.492.4874F}
{Forbes}, D.~A., {Alabi}, A., {Romanowsky}, A.~J., {Brodie}, J.~P., \&
{Arimoto}, N. 2020, \mnras, 492, 4874
\bibitem[{{Foster} {et~al.}(2012){Foster}, {Hopkins}, {Gunawardhana},
{Lara-L{\'o}pez}, {Sharp}, {Steele}, {Taylor}, {Driver}, {Baldry}, {Bamford},
{Liske}, {Loveday}, {Norberg}, {Peacock}, {Alpaslan}, {Bauer},
{Bland-Hawthorn}, {Brough}, {Cameron}, {Colless}, {Conselice}, {Croom},
{Frenk}, {Hill}, {Jones}, {Kelvin}, {Kuijken}, {Nichol}, {Owers},
{Parkinson}, {Pimbblet}, {Popescu}, {Prescott}, {Robotham}, {Lopez-Sanchez},
{Sutherland}, {Thomas}, {Tuffs}, {van Kampen}, \&
{Wijesinghe}}]{2012A&A...547A..79F}
{Foster}, C., {Hopkins}, A.~M., {Gunawardhana}, M., {et~al.} 2012, \aap, 547,
A79
\bibitem[{{Fulbright}(2000)}]{2000AJ....120.1841F}
{Fulbright}, J.~P. 2000, \aj, 120, 1841
\bibitem[{{Gaia Collaboration} {et~al.}(2018){Gaia Collaboration}, {Helmi},
{van Leeuwen}, {McMillan}, {Massari}, {Antoja}, {Robin}, {Lindegren},
{Bastian}, {Arenou}, {Babusiaux}, {Biermann}, {Breddels}, {Hobbs}, {Jordi},
{Pancino}, {Reyl{\'e}}, {Veljanoski}, {Brown}, {Vallenari}, {Prusti}, {de
Bruijne}, {Bailer-Jones}, {Evans}, {Eyer}, {Jansen}, {Klioner}, {Lammers},
{Luri}, {Mignard}, {Panem}, {Pourbaix}, {Randich}, {Sartoretti}, {Siddiqui},
{Soubiran}, {Walton}, {Cropper}, {Drimmel}, {Katz}, {Lattanzi}, {Bakker},
{Cacciari}, {Casta{\~n}eda}, {Chaoul}, {Cheek}, {De Angeli}, {Fabricius},
{Guerra}, {Holl}, {Masana}, {Messineo}, {Mowlavi}, {Nienartowicz}, {Panuzzo},
{Portell}, {Riello}, {Seabroke}, {Tanga}, {Th{\'e}venin}, {Gracia-Abril},
{Comoretto}, {Garcia-Reinaldos}, {Teyssier}, {Altmann}, {Andrae}, {Audard},
{Bellas-Velidis}, {Benson}, {Berthier}, {Blomme}, {Burgess}, {Busso},
{Carry}, {Cellino}, {Clementini}, {Clotet}, {Creevey}, {Davidson}, {De
Ridder}, {Delchambre}, {Dell'Oro}, {Ducourant},
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Fouesneau}, {Fr{\'e}mat}, {Galluccio},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Torres}, {Gonz{\'a}lez-N{\'u}{\~n}ez}, {Gonz{\'a}lez-Vidal},
{Gosset}, {Guy}, {Halbwachs}, {Hambly}, {Harrison}, {Hern{\'a}ndez},
{Hestroffer}, {Hodgkin}, {Hutton}, {Jasniewicz}, {Jean-Antoine-Piccolo},
{Jordan}, {Korn}, {Krone-Martins}, {Lanzafame}, {Lebzelter}, {L{\"o}ffler},
{Manteiga}, {Marrese}, {Mart{\'\i}n-Fleitas}, {Moitinho}, {Mora}, {Muinonen},
{Osinde}, {Pauwels}, {Petit}, {Recio-Blanco}, {Richards}, {Rimoldini},
{Sarro}, {Siopis}, {Smith}, {Sozzetti}, {S{\"u}veges}, {Torra}, {van Reeven},
{Abbas}, {Abreu Aramburu}, {Accart}, {Aerts}, {Altavilla}, {{\'A}lvarez},
{Alvarez}, {Alves}, {Anderson}, {Andrei}, {Anglada Varela}, {Antiche},
{Arcay}, {Astraatmadja}, {Bach}, {Baker}, {Balaguer-N{\'u}{\~n}ez}, {Balm},
{Barache}, {Barata}, {Barbato}, {Barblan}, {Barklem}, {Barrado}, {Barros},
{Barstow}, {Bartholom{\'e} Mu{\~n}oz}, {Bassilana}, {Becciani}, {Bellazzini},
{Berihuete}, {Bertone}, {Bianchi}, {Bienaym{\'e}}, {Blanco-Cuaresma}, {Boch},
{Boeche}, {Bombrun}, {Borrachero}, {Bossini}, {Bouquillon}, {Bourda},
{Bragaglia}, {Bramante}, {Bressan}, {Brouillet}, {Br{\"u}semeister},
{Brugaletta}, {Bucciarelli}, {Burlacu}, {Busonero}, {Butkevich}, {Buzzi},
{Caffau}, {Cancelliere}, {Cannizzaro}, {Cantat-Gaudin}, {Carballo},
{Carlucci}, {Carrasco}, {Casamiquela}, {Castellani}, {Castro-Ginard},
{Charlot}, {Chemin}, {Chiavassa}, {Cocozza}, {Costigan}, {Cowell}, {Crifo},
{Crosta}, {Crowley}, {Cuypers}, {Dafonte}, {Damerdji}, {Dapergolas}, {David},
{David}, {de Laverny}, {De Luise}, {De March}, {de Martino}, {de Souza}, {de
Torres}, {Debosscher}, {del Pozo}, {Delbo}, {Delgado}, {Delgado}, {Di
Matteo}, {Diakite}, {Diener}, {Distefano}, {Dolding}, {Drazinos},
{Dur{\'a}n}, {Edvardsson}, {Enke}, {Eriksson}, {Esquej}, {Eynard Bontemps},
{Fabre}, {Fabrizio}, {Faigler}, {Falc{\~a}o}, {Farr{\`a}s Casas}, {Federici},
{Fedorets}, {Fernique}, {Figueras}, {Filippi}, {Findeisen}, {Fonti},
{Fraile}, {Fraser}, {Fr{\'e}zouls}, {Gai}, {Galleti}, {Garabato},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Sedano}, {Garofalo}, {Garralda}, {Gavel}, {Gavras}, {Gerssen},
{Geyer}, {Giacobbe}, {Gilmore}, {Girona}, {Giuffrida}, {Glass}, {Gomes},
{Granvik}, {Gueguen}, {Guerrier}, {Guiraud}, {Guti{\'e}rrez-S{\'a}nchez},
{Hofmann}, {Holland}, {Huckle}, {Hypki}, {Icardi}, {Jan{\ss}en}, {Jevardat de
Fombelle}, {Jonker}, {Juh{\'a}sz}, {Julbe}, {Karampelas}, {Kewley}, {Klar},
{Kochoska}, {Kohley}, {Kolenberg}, {Kontizas}, {Kontizas}, {Koposov},
{Kordopatis}, {Kostrzewa-Rutkowska}, {Koubsky}, {Lambert}, {Lanza}, {Lasne},
{Lavigne}, {Le Fustec}, {Le Poncin-Lafitte}, {Lebreton}, {Leccia}, {Leclerc},
{Lecoeur-Taibi}, {Lenhardt}, {Leroux}, {Liao}, {Licata}, {Lindstr{\o}m},
{Lister}, {Livanou}, {Lobel}, {L{\'o}pez}, {Managau}, {Mann}, {Mantelet},
{Marchal}, {Marchant}, {Marconi}, {Marinoni}, {Marschalk{\'o}}, {Marshall},
{Martino}, {Marton}, {Mary}, {Matijevi{\v{c}}}, {Mazeh}, {Messina},
{Michalik}, {Millar}, {Molina}, {Molinaro}, {Moln{\'a}r}, {Montegriffo},
{Mor}, {Morbidelli}, {Morel}, {Morris}, {Mulone}, {Muraveva}, {Musella},
{Nelemans}, {Nicastro}, {Noval}, {O'Mullane}, {Ord{\'e}novic},
{Ord{\'o}{\~n}ez-Blanco}, {Osborne}, {Pagani}, {Pagano}, {Pailler},
{Palacin}, {Palaversa}, {Panahi}, {Pawlak}, {Piersimoni}, {Pineau}, {Plachy},
{Plum}, {Poggio}, {Poujoulet}, {Pr{\v{s}}a}, {Pulone}, {Racero}, {Ragaini},
{Rambaux}, {Ramos-Lerate}, {Regibo}, {Riclet}, {Ripepi}, {Riva}, {Rivard},
{Rixon}, {Roegiers}, {Roelens}, {Romero-G{\'o}mez}, {Rowell}, {Royer},
{Ruiz-Dern}, {Sadowski}, {Sagrist{\`a} Sell{\'e}s}, {Sahlmann}, {Salgado},
{Salguero}, {Sanna}, {Santana-Ros}, {Sarasso}, {Savietto}, {Schultheis},
{Sciacca}, {Segol}, {Segovia}, {S{\'e}gransan}, {Shih}, {Siltala}, {Silva},
{Smart}, {Smith}, {Solano}, {Solitro}, {Sordo}, {Soria Nieto}, {Souchay},
{Spagna}, {Spoto}, {Stampa}, {Steele}, {Steidelm{\"u}ller}, {Stephenson},
{Stoev}, {Suess}, {Surdej}, {Szabados}, {Szegedi-Elek}, {Tapiador}, {Taris},
{Tauran}, {Taylor}, {Teixeira}, {Terrett}, {Teyssandier}, {Thuillot},
{Titarenko}, {Torra Clotet}, {Turon}, {Ulla}, {Utrilla}, {Uzzi}, {Vaillant},
{Valentini}, {Valette}, {van Elteren}, {Van Hemelryck}, {van Leeuwen},
{Vaschetto}, {Vecchiato}, {Viala}, {Vicente}, {Vogt}, {von Essen}, {Voss},
{Votruba}, {Voutsinas}, {Walmsley}, {Weiler}, {Wertz}, {Wevems},
{Wyrzykowski}, {Yoldas}, {{\v{Z}}erjal}, {Ziaeepour}, {Zorec}, {Zschocke},
{Zucker}, {Zurbach}, \& {Zwitter}}]{2018A&A...616A..12G}
{Gaia Collaboration}, {Helmi}, A., {van Leeuwen}, F., {et~al.} 2018, \aap, 616,
A12
\bibitem[{{Gonz{\'a}lez Hern{\'a}ndez} \&
{Bonifacio}(2009)}]{2009A&A...497..497G}
{Gonz{\'a}lez Hern{\'a}ndez}, J.~I. \& {Bonifacio}, P. 2009, \aap, 497, 497
\bibitem[{{Grebel} {et~al.}(2003){Grebel}, {Gallagher}, \&
{Harbeck}}]{2003AJ....125.1926G}
{Grebel}, E.~K., {Gallagher}, III, J.~S., \& {Harbeck}, D. 2003, \aj, 125, 1926
\bibitem[{{Gustafsson} {et~al.}(2008){Gustafsson}, {Edvardsson}, {Eriksson},
{J{\o}rgensen}, {Nordlund}, \& {Plez}}]{2008A&A...486..951G}
{Gustafsson}, B., {Edvardsson}, B., {Eriksson}, K., {et~al.} 2008, \aap, 486,
951
\bibitem[{{Hasselquist} {et~al.}(2021){Hasselquist}, {Hayes}, {Lian},
{Weinberg}, {Zasowski}, {Horta}, {Beaton}, {Feuillet}, {Garro}, {Gallart},
{Smith}, {Holtzman}, {Minniti}, {Lacerna}, {Shetrone}, {J{\"o}nsson},
{Cioni}, {Fillingham}, {Cunha}, {O'Connell}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Mu{\~n}oz}, {Schiavon}, {Almeida}, {Anguiano}, {Beers}, {Bizyaev},
{Brownstein}, {Cohen}, {Frinchaboy}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Geisler},
{Lane}, {Majewski}, {Nidever}, {Nitschelm}, {Povick}, {Price-Whelan},
{Roman-Lopes}, {Rosado}, {Sobeck}, {Stringfellow}, {Valenzuela}, {Villanova},
\& {Vincenzo}}]{2021ApJ...923..172H}
{Hasselquist}, S., {Hayes}, C.~R., {Lian}, J., {et~al.} 2021, \apj, 923, 172
\bibitem[{{Hasselquist} {et~al.}(2017){Hasselquist}, {Shetrone}, {Smith},
{Holtzman}, {McWilliam}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Beers}, {Majewski},
{Nidever}, {Tang}, {Tissera}, {Fern{\'a}ndez Alvar}, {Allende Prieto},
{Almeida}, {Anguiano}, {Battaglia}, {Carigi}, {Delgado Inglada},
{Frinchaboy}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Geisler}, {Minniti}, {Placco},
{Schultheis}, {Sobeck}, \& {Villanova}}]{2017ApJ...845..162H}
{Hasselquist}, S., {Shetrone}, M., {Smith}, V., {et~al.} 2017, \apj, 845, 162
\bibitem[{{Helmi} {et~al.}(2018){Helmi}, {Babusiaux}, {Koppelman}, {Massari},
{Veljanoski}, \& {Brown}}]{2018Natur.563...85H}
{Helmi}, A., {Babusiaux}, C., {Koppelman}, H.~H., {et~al.} 2018, \nat, 563, 85
\bibitem[{{Hodge}(1989)}]{1989ARA&A..27..139H}
{Hodge}, P. 1989, \araa, 27, 139
\bibitem[{{Hodge}(1971)}]{1971ARA&A...9...35H}
{Hodge}, P.~W. 1971, \araa, 9, 35
\bibitem[{{Horta} {et~al.}(2021){Horta}, {Schiavon}, {Mackereth}, {Pfeffer},
{Mason}, {Kisku}, {Fragkoudi}, {Allende Prieto}, {Cunha}, {Hasselquist},
{Holtzman}, {Majewski}, {Nataf}, {O'Connell}, {Schultheis}, \&
{Smith}}]{Horta2021}
{Horta}, D., {Schiavon}, R.~P., {Mackereth}, J.~T., {et~al.} 2021, \mnras, 500,
1385
\bibitem[{{Huang} \& {Koposov}(2021)}]{2021MNRAS.500..986H}
{Huang}, K.-W. \& {Koposov}, S.~E. 2021, \mnras, 500, 986
\bibitem[{{Huang} {et~al.}(2024){Huang}, {Tang}, {Li}, {Geisler}, {Mateo},
{Song}, {Baumgardt}, {Carballo-Bello}, {Wang}, {Nie}, {Dias}, \&
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}}]{HT2024}
{Huang}, R., {Tang}, B., {Li}, C., {et~al.} 2024, Science China Physics,
Mechanics, and Astronomy, 67, 259513
\bibitem[{{Ibata} {et~al.}(2013){Ibata}, {Lewis}, {Martin}, {Bellazzini}, \&
{Correnti}}]{2013ApJ...765L..15I}
{Ibata}, R., {Lewis}, G.~F., {Martin}, N.~F., {Bellazzini}, M., \& {Correnti},
M. 2013, \apjl, 765, L15
\bibitem[{{Karakas} \& {Lattanzio}(2014)}]{2014PASA...31...30K}
{Karakas}, A.~I. \& {Lattanzio}, J.~C. 2014, \pasa, 31, e030
\bibitem[{{Kirby} {et~al.}(2020){Kirby}, {Gilbert}, {Escala}, {Wojno},
{Guhathakurta}, {Majewski}, \& {Beaton}}]{2020AJ....159...46K}
{Kirby}, E.~N., {Gilbert}, K.~M., {Escala}, I., {et~al.} 2020, \aj, 159, 46
\bibitem[{{Kobayashi} {et~al.}(2020){Kobayashi}, {Karakas}, \&
{Lugaro}}]{2020ApJ...900..179K}
{Kobayashi}, C., {Karakas}, A.~I., \& {Lugaro}, M. 2020, \apj, 900, 179
\bibitem[{{Kobayashi} {et~al.}(2006){Kobayashi}, {Umeda}, {Nomoto}, {Tominaga},
\& {Ohkubo}}]{2006ApJ...653.1145K}
{Kobayashi}, C., {Umeda}, H., {Nomoto}, K., {Tominaga}, N., \& {Ohkubo}, T.
2006, \apj, 653, 1145
\bibitem[{{Kowalczyk} \& {{\L}okas}(2022)}]{2022A&A...659A.119K}
{Kowalczyk}, K. \& {{\L}okas}, E.~L. 2022, \aap, 659, A119
\bibitem[{{Lagarde} {et~al.}(2012){Lagarde}, {Decressin}, {Charbonnel},
{Eggenberger}, {Ekstr{\"o}m}, \& {Palacios}}]{lagarde_2012A&A...543A.108L}
{Lagarde}, N., {Decressin}, T., {Charbonnel}, C., {et~al.} 2012, \aap, 543,
A108
\bibitem[{{Larsen} {et~al.}(2022){Larsen}, {Eitner}, {Magg}, {Bergemann},
{Moltzer}, {Brodie}, {Romanowsky}, \& {Strader}}]{2022A&A...660A..88L}
{Larsen}, S.~S., {Eitner}, P., {Magg}, E., {et~al.} 2022, \aap, 660, A88
\bibitem[{{Law} \& {Majewski}(2010)}]{2010ApJ...718.1128L}
{Law}, D.~R. \& {Majewski}, S.~R. 2010, \apj, 718, 1128
\bibitem[{{Lequeux} {et~al.}(1979){Lequeux}, {Peimbert}, {Rayo}, {Serrano}, \&
{Torres-Peimbert}}]{1979A&A....80..155L}
{Lequeux}, J., {Peimbert}, M., {Rayo}, J.~F., {Serrano}, A., \&
{Torres-Peimbert}, S. 1979, \aap, 80, 155
\bibitem[{{Letarte} {et~al.}(2006){Letarte}, {Hill}, {Jablonka}, {Tolstoy},
{Fran{\c{c}}ois}, \& {Meylan}}]{2006A&A...453..547L}
{Letarte}, B., {Hill}, V., {Jablonka}, P., {et~al.} 2006, \aap, 453, 547
\bibitem[{{Li} {et~al.}(2021){Li}, {Tang}, {Milone}, {de Grijs}, {Hong},
{Yang}, \& {Wang}}]{2021ApJ...906..133L}
{Li}, C., {Tang}, B., {Milone}, A.~P., {et~al.} 2021, \apj, 906, 133
\bibitem[{{Li} \& {Gnedin}(2019)}]{2019MNRAS.486.4030L}
{Li}, H. \& {Gnedin}, O.~Y. 2019, \mnras, 486, 4030
\bibitem[{{Limongi} \& {Chieffi}(2006)}]{2006ApJ...647..483L}
{Limongi}, M. \& {Chieffi}, A. 2006, \apj, 647, 483
\bibitem[{{Lind} {et~al.}(2015){Lind}, {Koposov}, {Battistini}, {Marino},
{Ruchti}, {Serenelli}, {Worley}, {Alves-Brito}, {Asplund}, {Barklem},
{Bensby}, {Bergemann}, {Blanco-Cuaresma}, {Bragaglia}, {Edvardsson},
{Feltzing}, {Gruyters}, {Heiter}, {Jofre}, {Korn}, {Nordlander}, {Ryde},
{Soubiran}, {Gilmore}, {Randich}, {Ferguson}, {Jeffries}, {Vallenari},
{Allende Prieto}, {Pancino}, {Recio-Blanco}, {Romano}, {Smiljanic},
{Bellazzini}, {Damiani}, {Hill}, {de Laverny}, {Jackson}, {Lardo}, \&
{Zaggia}}]{2015A&A...575L..12L}
{Lind}, K., {Koposov}, S.~E., {Battistini}, C., {et~al.} 2015, \aap, 575, L12
\bibitem[{{Magrini} {et~al.}(2017){Magrini}, {Randich}, {Kordopatis},
{Prantzos}, {Romano}, {Chieffi}, {Limongi}, {Fran{\c{c}}ois}, {Pancino},
{Friel}, {Bragaglia}, {Tautvai{\v{s}}ien{\.{e}}}, {Spina}, {Overbeek},
{Cantat-Gaudin}, {Donati}, {Vallenari}, {Sordo}, {Jim{\'e}nez-Esteban},
{Tang}, {Drazdauskas}, {Sousa}, {Duffau}, {Jofr{\'e}}, {Gilmore}, {Feltzing},
{Alfaro}, {Bensby}, {Flaccomio}, {Koposov}, {Lanzafame}, {Smiljanic}, {Bayo},
{Carraro}, {Casey}, {Costado}, {Damiani}, {Franciosini}, {Hourihane},
{Lardo}, {Lewis}, {Monaco}, {Morbidelli}, {Sacco}, {Sbordone}, {Worley}, \&
{Zaggia}}]{2017A&A...603A...2M}
{Magrini}, L., {Randich}, S., {Kordopatis}, G., {et~al.} 2017, \aap, 603, A2
\bibitem[{{Majewski} {et~al.}(2017){Majewski}, {Schiavon}, {Frinchaboy},
{Allende Prieto}, {Barkhouser}, {Bizyaev}, {Blank}, {Brunner}, {Burton},
{Carrera}, {Chojnowski}, {Cunha}, {Epstein}, {Fitzgerald}, {Garc{\'\i}a
P{\'e}rez}, {Hearty}, {Henderson}, {Holtzman}, {Johnson}, {Lam}, {Lawler},
{Maseman}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Nelson}, {Nguyen}, {Nidever}, {Pinsonneault},
{Shetrone}, {Smee}, {Smith}, {Stolberg}, {Skrutskie}, {Walker}, {Wilson},
{Zasowski}, {Anders}, {Basu}, {Beland}, {Blanton}, {Bovy}, {Brownstein},
{Carlberg}, {Chaplin}, {Chiappini}, {Eisenstein}, {Elsworth}, {Feuillet},
{Fleming}, {Galbraith-Frew}, {Garc{\'\i}a}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez},
{Gillespie}, {Girardi}, {Gunn}, {Hasselquist}, {Hayden}, {Hekker}, {Ivans},
{Kinemuchi}, {Klaene}, {Mahadevan}, {Mathur}, {Mosser}, {Muna}, {Munn},
{Nichol}, {O'Connell}, {Parejko}, {Robin}, {Rocha-Pinto}, {Schultheis},
{Serenelli}, {Shane}, {Silva Aguirre}, {Sobeck}, {Thompson}, {Troup},
{Weinberg}, \& {Zamora}}]{2017AJ....154...94M}
{Majewski}, S.~R., {Schiavon}, R.~P., {Frinchaboy}, P.~M., {et~al.} 2017, \aj,
154, 94
\bibitem[{{Majewski} {et~al.}(2003){Majewski}, {Skrutskie}, {Weinberg}, \&
{Ostheimer}}]{2003ApJ...599.1082M}
{Majewski}, S.~R., {Skrutskie}, M.~F., {Weinberg}, M.~D., \& {Ostheimer}, J.~C.
2003, \apj, 599, 1082
\bibitem[{{Martell} {et~al.}(2016){Martell}, {Shetrone}, {Lucatello},
{Schiavon}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Allende Prieto},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Beers}, \& {Nidever}}]{2016ApJ...825..146M}
{Martell}, S.~L., {Shetrone}, M.~D., {Lucatello}, S., {et~al.} 2016, \apj, 825,
146
\bibitem[{{Massari} {et~al.}(2019){Massari}, {Koppelman}, \&
{Helmi}}]{massari2019}
{Massari}, D., {Koppelman}, H.~H., \& {Helmi}, A. 2019, \aap, 630, L4
\bibitem[{{Masseron} {et~al.}(2016){Masseron}, {Merle}, \&
{Hawkins}}]{2016ascl.soft05004M}
{Masseron}, T., {Merle}, T., \& {Hawkins}, K. 2016, {BACCHUS: Brussels
Automatic Code for Characterizing High accUracy Spectra}, Astrophysics Source
Code Library, record ascl:1605.004
\bibitem[{{Masseron} {et~al.}(2021){Masseron}, {Osorio},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Allende Prieto}, {Zamora}, \&
{M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}}]{2021A&A...647A..24M}
{Masseron}, T., {Osorio}, Y., {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, D.~A., {et~al.}
2021, \aap, 647, A24
\bibitem[{{McConnachie}(2012)}]{2012AJ....144....4M}
{McConnachie}, A.~W. 2012, \aj, 144, 4
\bibitem[{{McWilliam} {et~al.}(2013){McWilliam}, {Wallerstein}, \&
{Mottini}}]{2013ApJ...778..149M}
{McWilliam}, A., {Wallerstein}, G., \& {Mottini}, M. 2013, \apj, 778, 149
\bibitem[{{M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros} {et~al.}(2015){M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Martell},
{Shetrone}, {Lucatello}, {Troup}, {Bovy}, {Cunha},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Overbeek}, {Allende Prieto}, {Beers},
{Frinchaboy}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez}, {Hearty}, {Holtzman}, {Majewski},
{Nidever}, {Schiavon}, {Schneider}, {Sobeck}, {Smith}, {Zamora}, \&
{Zasowski}}]{2015AJ....149..153M}
{M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, S., {Martell}, S.~L., {Shetrone}, M., {et~al.} 2015, \aj,
149, 153
\bibitem[{{Milone} {et~al.}(2015){Milone}, {Marino}, {Piotto}, {Renzini},
{Bedin}, {Anderson}, {Cassisi}, {D'Antona}, {Bellini}, {Jerjen},
{Pietrinferni}, \& {Ventura}}]{2015ApJ...808...51M}
{Milone}, A.~P., {Marino}, A.~F., {Piotto}, G., {et~al.} 2015, \apj, 808, 51
\bibitem[{{Mu{\~n}oz} {et~al.}(2018){Mu{\~n}oz}, {C{\^o}t{\'e}}, {Santana},
{Geha}, {Simon}, {Oyarz{\'u}n}, {Stetson}, \&
{Djorgovski}}]{2018ApJ...860...66M}
{Mu{\~n}oz}, R.~R., {C{\^o}t{\'e}}, P., {Santana}, F.~A., {et~al.} 2018, \apj,
860, 66
\bibitem[{{Myeong} {et~al.}(2019){Myeong}, {Vasiliev}, {Iorio}, {Evans}, \&
{Belokurov}}]{2019MNRAS.488.1235M}
{Myeong}, G.~C., {Vasiliev}, E., {Iorio}, G., {Evans}, N.~W., \& {Belokurov},
V. 2019, \mnras, 488, 1235
\bibitem[{{Nidever} {et~al.}(2014){Nidever}, {Bovy}, {Bird}, {Andrews},
{Hayden}, {Holtzman}, {Majewski}, {Smith}, {Robin}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez},
{Cunha}, {Allende Prieto}, {Zasowski}, {Schiavon}, {Johnson}, {Weinberg},
{Feuillet}, {Schneider}, {Shetrone}, {Sobeck}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez},
{Zamora}, {Rix}, {Beers}, {Wilson}, {O'Connell}, {Minchev}, {Chiappini},
{Anders}, {Bizyaev}, {Brewington}, {Ebelke}, {Frinchaboy}, {Ge}, {Kinemuchi},
{Malanushenko}, {Malanushenko}, {Marchante}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Oravetz},
{Pan}, {Simmons}, \& {Skrutskie}}]{2014ApJ...796...38N}
{Nidever}, D.~L., {Bovy}, J., {Bird}, J.~C., {et~al.} 2014, \apj, 796, 38
\bibitem[{{Nidever} {et~al.}(2020){Nidever}, {Hasselquist}, {Hayes}, {Hawkins},
{Povick}, {Majewski}, {Smith}, {Anguiano}, {Stringfellow}, {Sobeck}, {Cunha},
{Beers}, {Bestenlehner}, {Cohen}, {Garcia-Hernandez}, {J{\"o}nsson},
{Nitschelm}, {Shetrone}, {Lacerna}, {Allende Prieto}, {Beaton}, {Dell'Agli},
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Feuillet}, {Gallart}, {Hearty}, {Holtzman},
{Manchado}, {Mu{\~n}oz}, {O'Connell}, \& {Rosado}}]{2020ApJ...895...88N}
{Nidever}, D.~L., {Hasselquist}, S., {Hayes}, C.~R., {et~al.} 2020, \apj, 895,
88
\bibitem[{{Nidever} {et~al.}(2015){Nidever}, {Holtzman}, {Allende Prieto},
{Beland}, {Bender}, {Bizyaev}, {Burton}, {Desphande}, {Fleming}, {Garc{\'\i}a
P{\'e}rez}, {Hearty}, {Majewski}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Muna}, {Nguyen},
{Schiavon}, {Shetrone}, {Skrutskie}, {Sobeck}, \&
{Wilson}}]{2015AJ....150..173N}
{Nidever}, D.~L., {Holtzman}, J.~A., {Allende Prieto}, C., {et~al.} 2015, \aj,
150, 173
\bibitem[{{Nissen} {et~al.}(2024){Nissen}, {Amarsi}, {Sk{\'u}lad{\'o}ttir}, \&
{Schuster}}]{Nissen2024}
{Nissen}, P.~E., {Amarsi}, A.~M., {Sk{\'u}lad{\'o}ttir}, {\'A}., \& {Schuster},
W.~J. 2024, \aap, 682, A116
\bibitem[{{Osorio} {et~al.}(2020){Osorio}, {Allende Prieto}, {Hubeny},
{M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, \& {Shetrone}}]{2020A&A...637A..80O}
{Osorio}, Y., {Allende Prieto}, C., {Hubeny}, I., {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, S., \&
{Shetrone}, M. 2020, \aap, 637, A80
\bibitem[{{Pace}(2024)}]{2024arXiv241107424P}
{Pace}, A.~B. 2024, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2411.07424
\bibitem[{{Pace} {et~al.}(2021){Pace}, {Walker}, {Koposov}, {Caldwell},
{Mateo}, {Olszewski}, {Bailey}, \& {Wang}}]{2021ApJ...923...77P}
{Pace}, A.~B., {Walker}, M.~G., {Koposov}, S.~E., {et~al.} 2021, \apj, 923, 77
\bibitem[{{Pancino} {et~al.}(2017){Pancino}, {Romano}, {Tang}, {Tautvai{\v
s}ien{\.e}}, {Casey}, {Gruyters}, {Geisler}, {San Roman}, {Randich},
{Alfaro}, {Bragaglia}, {Flaccomio}, {Korn}, {Recio-Blanco}, {Smiljanic},
{Carraro}, {Bayo}, {Costado}, {Damiani}, {Jofr{\'e}}, {Lardo}, {de Laverny},
{Monaco}, {Morbidelli}, {Sbordone}, {Sousa}, \& {Villanova}}]{Pancino2017}
{Pancino}, E., {Romano}, D., {Tang}, B., {et~al.} 2017, \aap, 601, A112
\bibitem[{{Plez}(2012)}]{2012ascl.soft05004P}
{Plez}, B. 2012, {Turbospectrum: Code for spectral synthesis}, Astrophysics
Source Code Library, record ascl:1205.004
\bibitem[{{Reddy} {et~al.}(2006){Reddy}, {Lambert}, \& {Allende
Prieto}}]{2006MNRAS.367.1329R}
{Reddy}, B.~E., {Lambert}, D.~L., \& {Allende Prieto}, C. 2006, \mnras, 367,
1329
\bibitem[{{Reddy} {et~al.}(2003){Reddy}, {Tomkin}, {Lambert}, \& {Allende
Prieto}}]{2003MNRAS.340..304R}
{Reddy}, B.~E., {Tomkin}, J., {Lambert}, D.~L., \& {Allende Prieto}, C. 2003,
\mnras, 340, 304
\bibitem[{{Reichert} {et~al.}(2020){Reichert}, {Hansen}, {Hanke},
{Sk{\'u}lad{\'o}ttir}, {Arcones}, \& {Grebel}}]{2020A&A...641A.127R}
{Reichert}, M., {Hansen}, C.~J., {Hanke}, M., {et~al.} 2020, \aap, 641, A127
\bibitem[{{Roederer} {et~al.}(2014){Roederer}, {Preston}, {Thompson},
{Shectman}, {Sneden}, {Burley}, \& {Kelson}}]{2014AJ....147..136R}
{Roederer}, I.~U., {Preston}, G.~W., {Thompson}, I.~B., {et~al.} 2014, \aj,
147, 136
\bibitem[{{Sanders} {et~al.}(2021){Sanders}, {Belokurov}, \&
{Man}}]{Sanders2021}
{Sanders}, J.~L., {Belokurov}, V., \& {Man}, K. T.~F. 2021, \mnras, 506, 4321
\bibitem[{{Santana} {et~al.}(2021){Santana}, {Beaton}, {Covey}, {O'Connell},
{Longa-Pe{\~n}a}, {Cohen}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Hayes}, {Zasowski},
{Sobeck}, {Majewski}, {Chojnowski}, {De Lee}, {Oelkers}, {Stringfellow},
{Almeida}, {Anguiano}, {Donor}, {Frinchaboy}, {Hasselquist}, {Johnson},
{Kollmeier}, {Nidever}, {Price-Whelan}, {Rojas-Arriagada}, {Schultheis},
{Shetrone}, {Simon}, {Aerts}, {Borissova}, {Drout}, {Geisler}, {Law},
{Medina}, {Minniti}, {Monachesi}, {Mu{\~n}oz}, {Poleski}, {Roman-Lopes},
{Schlaufman}, {Stutz}, {Teske}, {Tkachenko}, {Van Saders}, {Weinberger}, \&
{Zoccali}}]{2021AJ....162..303S}
{Santana}, F.~A., {Beaton}, R.~L., {Covey}, K.~R., {et~al.} 2021, \aj, 162, 303
\bibitem[{{Schiavon} {et~al.}(2017){Schiavon}, {Zamora}, {Carrera},
{Lucatello}, {Robin}, {Ness}, {Martell}, {Smith},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Manchado}, {Sch{\"o}nrich}, {Bastian},
{Chiappini}, {Shetrone}, {Mackereth}, {Williams}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros},
{Allende Prieto}, {Anders}, {Bizyaev}, {Beers}, {Chojnowski}, {Cunha},
{Epstein}, {Frinchaboy}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez}, {Hearty}, {Holtzman},
{Johnson}, {Kinemuchi}, {Majewski}, {Muna}, {Nidever}, {Nguyen}, {O'Connell},
{Oravetz}, {Pan}, {Pinsonneault}, {Schneider}, {Schultheis}, {Simmons},
{Skrutskie}, {Sobeck}, {Wilson}, \& {Zasowski}}]{2017MNRAS.465..501S}
{Schiavon}, R.~P., {Zamora}, O., {Carrera}, R., {et~al.} 2017, \mnras, 465, 501
\bibitem[{{Schlegel} {et~al.}(1998){Schlegel}, {Finkbeiner}, \&
{Davis}}]{1998ApJ...500..525S}
{Schlegel}, D.~J., {Finkbeiner}, D.~P., \& {Davis}, M. 1998, \apj, 500, 525
\bibitem[{{Shetrone} {et~al.}(2003){Shetrone}, {Venn}, {Tolstoy}, {Primas},
{Hill}, \& {Kaufer}}]{2003AJ....125..684S}
{Shetrone}, M., {Venn}, K.~A., {Tolstoy}, E., {et~al.} 2003, \aj, 125, 684
\bibitem[{{Simon}(2019)}]{2019ARA&A..57..375S}
{Simon}, J.~D. 2019, \araa, 57, 375
\bibitem[{{Smith} {et~al.}(2013){Smith}, {Cunha}, {Shetrone}, {Meszaros},
{Allende Prieto}, {Bizyaev}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez}, {Majewski}, {Schiavon},
{Holtzman}, \& {Johnson}}]{2013ApJ...765...16S}
{Smith}, V.~V., {Cunha}, K., {Shetrone}, M.~D., {et~al.} 2013, \apj, 765, 16
\bibitem[{{Tang} {et~al.}(2017){Tang}, {Cohen}, {Geisler}, {Schiavon},
{Majewski}, {Villanova}, {Carrera}, {Zamora}, {Garcia-Hernandez}, {Shetrone},
{Frinchaboy}, {Meza}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Mu{\~n}oz}, {Lin}, {Lane},
{Nitschelm}, {Pan}, {Bizyaev}, {Oravetz}, \& {Simmons}}]{2017MNRAS.465...19T}
{Tang}, B., {Cohen}, R.~E., {Geisler}, D., {et~al.} 2017, \mnras, 465, 19
\bibitem[{{Tang} {et~al.}(2018){Tang}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Geisler},
{Zamora}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Masseron}, {Cohen},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Dell'Agli}, {Beers}, {Schiavon}, {Sohn},
{Hasselquist}, {Robin}, {Shetrone}, {Majewski}, {Villanova}, {Schiappacasse
Ulloa}, {Lane}, {Minnti}, {Roman-Lopes}, {Almeida}, \&
{Moreno}}]{2018ApJ...855...38T}
{Tang}, B., {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Geisler}, D., {et~al.} 2018,
\apj, 855, 38
\bibitem[{{Tang} {et~al.}(2020){Tang}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Liu}, {Yu},
{Yan}, {Gao}, {Shi}, \& {Geisler}}]{2020ApJ...891...28T}
{Tang}, B., {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {Liu}, C., {et~al.} 2020, \apj,
891, 28
\bibitem[{{Tang} {et~al.}(2019){Tang}, {Liu}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado},
{Geisler}, {Shi}, {Zamora}, {Worthey}, \& {Moreno}}]{2019ApJ...871...58T}
{Tang}, B., {Liu}, C., {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {et~al.} 2019, \apj,
871, 58
\bibitem[{{Tang} {et~al.}(2021){Tang}, {Wang}, {Huang}, {Li}, {Yu}, {Geisler},
{Dias}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Carballo-Bello}, \&
{Cabrera-Lavers}}]{2021ApJ...908..220T}
{Tang}, B., {Wang}, Y., {Huang}, R., {et~al.} 2021, \apj, 908, 220
\bibitem[{{Tang} {et~al.}(2023){Tang}, {Zhang}, {Yan}, {Zhang}, {Carigi}, \&
{Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}}]{2023A&A...669A.125T}
{Tang}, B., {Zhang}, J., {Yan}, Z., {et~al.} 2023, \aap, 669, A125
\bibitem[{{Tinsley}(1979)}]{1979ApJ...229.1046T}
{Tinsley}, B.~M. 1979, \apj, 229, 1046
\bibitem[{{Tolstoy} {et~al.}(2009){Tolstoy}, {Hill}, \&
{Tosi}}]{2009ARA&A..47..371T}
{Tolstoy}, E., {Hill}, V., \& {Tosi}, M. 2009, \araa, 47, 371
\bibitem[{{Walker} \& {Pe{\~n}arrubia}(2011)}]{2011ApJ...742...20W}
{Walker}, M.~G. \& {Pe{\~n}arrubia}, J. 2011, \apj, 742, 20
\bibitem[{{Wang} {et~al.}(2019){Wang}, {Koposov}, {Drlica-Wagner}, {Pieres},
{Li}, {de Boer}, {Bechtol}, {Belokurov}, {Pace}, {Bacon}, {Abbott}, {Annis},
{Bertin}, {Brooks}, {Buckley-Geer}, {Burke}, {Carnero Rosell}, {Carrasco
Kind}, {Carretero}, {da Costa}, {De Vicente}, {Desai}, {Diehl}, {Doel},
{Estrada}, {Flaugher}, {Fosalba}, {Frieman}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Bellido}, {Gerdes},
{Gruen}, {Gruendl}, {Gschwend}, {Gutierrez}, {Hollowood}, {Honscheid},
{Hoyle}, {James}, {Kent}, {Kuehn}, {Kuropatkin}, {Maia}, {Marshall},
{Menanteau}, {Miquel}, {Plazas}, {Sanchez}, {Santiago}, {Scarpine},
{Schindler}, {Schubnell}, {Serrano}, {Sevilla-Noarbe}, {Smith}, {Smith},
{Sobreira}, {Suchyta}, {Swanson}, {Tarle}, {Thomas}, {Tucker}, {Walker}, \&
{DES Collaboration}}]{2019ApJ...875L..13W}
{Wang}, M.~Y., {Koposov}, S., {Drlica-Wagner}, A., {et~al.} 2019, \apjl, 875,
L13
\bibitem[{{Watson} {et~al.}(2019){Watson}, {Hansen}, {Selsing}, {Koch},
{Malesani}, {Andersen}, {Fynbo}, {Arcones}, {Bauswein}, {Covino}, {Grado},
{Heintz}, {Hunt}, {Kouveliotou}, {Leloudas}, {Levan}, {Mazzali}, \&
{Pian}}]{2019Natur.574..497W}
{Watson}, D., {Hansen}, C.~J., {Selsing}, J., {et~al.} 2019, \nat, 574, 497
\bibitem[{{Weinberg} {et~al.}(2019){Weinberg}, {Holtzman}, {Hasselquist},
{Bird}, {Johnson}, {Shetrone}, {Sobeck}, {Allende Prieto}, {Bizyaev},
{Carrera}, {Cohen}, {Cunha}, {Ebelke}, {Fernandez-Trincado},
{Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, {Hayes}, {J{\"o}nsson}, {Lane}, {Majewski},
{Malanushenko}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Nidever}, {Nitschelm}, {Pan}, {Rix},
{Rybizki}, {Schiavon}, {Schneider}, {Wilson}, \&
{Zamora}}]{2019ApJ...874..102W}
{Weinberg}, D.~H., {Holtzman}, J.~A., {Hasselquist}, S., {et~al.} 2019, \apj,
874, 102
\bibitem[{{Weisz} {et~al.}(2014){Weisz}, {Dolphin}, {Skillman}, {Holtzman},
{Gilbert}, {Dalcanton}, \& {Williams}}]{2014ApJ...789..147W}
{Weisz}, D.~R., {Dolphin}, A.~E., {Skillman}, E.~D., {et~al.} 2014, \apj, 789,
147
\bibitem[{{Woosley} \& {Weaver}(1995)}]{1995ApJS..101..181W}
{Woosley}, S.~E. \& {Weaver}, T.~A. 1995, \apjs, 101, 181
\bibitem[{{Woosley} {et~al.}(1994){Woosley}, {Wilson}, {Mathews}, {Hoffman}, \&
{Meyer}}]{1994ApJ...433..229W}
{Woosley}, S.~E., {Wilson}, J.~R., {Mathews}, G.~J., {Hoffman}, R.~D., \&
{Meyer}, B.~S. 1994, \apj, 433, 229
\bibitem[{{Yong} {et~al.}(2013){Yong}, {Norris}, {Bessell}, {Christlieb},
{Asplund}, {Beers}, {Barklem}, {Frebel}, \& {Ryan}}]{2013ApJ...762...27Y}
{Yong}, D., {Norris}, J.~E., {Bessell}, M.~S., {et~al.} 2013, \apj, 762, 27
\bibitem[{{Yu} {et~al.}(2021){Yu}, {Tang}, {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, {Geisler},
{Yan}, \& {Soto}}]{2021ApJ...913...23Y}
{Yu}, J., {Tang}, B., {Fern{\'a}ndez-Trincado}, J.~G., {et~al.} 2021, \apj,
913, 23
\bibitem[{{Zamora} {et~al.}(2015){Zamora}, {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez},
{Allende Prieto}, {Carrera}, {Koesterke}, {Edvardsson}, {Castelli}, {Plez},
{Bizyaev}, {Cunha}, {Garc{\'\i}a P{\'e}rez}, {Gustafsson}, {Holtzman},
{Lawler}, {Majewski}, {Manchado}, {M{\'e}sz{\'a}ros}, {Shane}, {Shetrone},
{Smith}, \& {Zasowski}}]{2015AJ....149..181Z}
{Zamora}, O., {Garc{\'\i}a-Hern{\'a}ndez}, D.~A., {Allende Prieto}, C.,
{et~al.} 2015, \aj, 149, 181
\end{thebibliography}