Habitability of exoplanets orbiting flaring stars
Extracted source text · arXiv 2512.21357
\documentclass[11pt]{article}
\usepackage{authblk}
\usepackage{graphicx}
\usepackage{xcolor}
\usepackage{natbib}
\usepackage[margin=2cm]{geometry}
% \bibliographystyle{apalike}
\newcommand{\aap}{A\&A}
\newcommand{\aj}{AJ}
\newcommand{\apj}{ApJ}
\newcommand{\apjl}{ApJL}
\newcommand{\apjs}{ApJS}
\newcommand{\araa}{A\&AAR}
\newcommand{\mnras}{MNRAS}
\newcommand{\nat}{Nat.}
\newcommand{\pasp}{PASP}
\newcommand{\ssr}{Sp.Sci.Rev.}
\newcommand{\sovast}{Sov.Astro.}
\title{\bf ESO Expanding Horizons White Paper:\\
Habitability of exoplanets orbiting flaring stars\footnote{This is
a white paper submitted in response to the ESO Expanding Horizons
initiative.}}
\author[1]{Rebecca Szab\'o}
\author[2]{Valentin D. Ivanov}
\author[1]{Michal \v{S}vanda}
\affil[1]{Astronomick\'y \'ustav Univerzity Karlovy, Czech Republic}
\affil[2]{European Southern Observatory (ESO), Germany}
\date{December 2025}
\begin{document}
\maketitle
\begin{abstract}
As of late 2025 there are about 70 exoplanets that meet the formal
criterion of having equilibrium temperatures allowing the presence of
liquid water and about 50 of them orbit M-stars, known for their strong
chromospheric activity. Most of these stars are close to the Sun and
the planet-to-star mass and luminosity ratios are advantageous, allowing
for a more detailed follow-up than of planets orbiting hotter and more
massive stars. Many more planets orbiting late-type stars are expected
to be discovered by {\it Gaia} and {\it Plato} in the following years.
However, the lingering question remains whether the UV and X-ray emission,
associated with the stellar activity, allows for complex life. A
comprehensive study focused on properties of flaring exoplanet hosts and
their activity, on a much larger scale than these few tens (soon to
become hundreds) of stars with habitable planets is called for, to answer
the question if such stars can harbor habitable planets. The proposed
Wide Field Survey telescope is well suited for this study.
\end{abstract}
\section{Exoplanet Habitability}
The issue of exoplanet habitability
became much more tangible after the discovery of the first exoplanet
orbiting a solar-type star \citep{1995Natur.378..355M}. The habitable
zone (HZ) is defined as the range of orbital radii where the planet's
equilibrium temperature allows liquid water to exist on the surface.
This is a loose definition: planet masses, presence of the greenhouse
effect, geology, orbital eccentricities, and possibly other factors
are expected to play a role in determining the HZ borders. The most
reliable catalog of HZ rocky exoplanets today lists 67 objects
\citep[typical radii $\sim$1.5\,R$_{\mathrm{Earth}}$,
masses 1--3\,M$_{\mathrm{Earth}}$ -- ][]{2025arXiv250114054B}.
This list is expected to grow with the next {\it Gaia} data release
and future transit missions like {\it Plato}.
Finding true Earth-Sun analogs requires multi-year monitoring. The
HZ is closer in and orbital periods are shorter ($<$100\,days) for
lower mass stars, making the discovery of such planets easier. M-dwarfs
make up over 60\% of stars within 10\,pc \citep{2021A&A...650A.201R}.
Their evolution is slower than for earlier-type stars, allowing a more
stable HZ \citep{2025ApJS..281...13L}. These considerations
attracted attention to stars cooler than the Sun, but it was
quickly realized that their activity is a habitability risk --
close-in exoplanets are more exposed to intense flares and coronal
mass ejections
\citep{2024ApJ...960...62E,2024ApJ...966...69L} that can photoevaporate
their atmospheres \citep{2023MNRAS.525.5168M}.
\citet{2010AsBio..10..751S} argued that the flares can affect the
exo-atmosphere chemistry, e.g., causing years-long ozone depletion.
Fortuitously, the UV environment of quiet M-stars may be even lower
than the Sun's \citep[see for a review][]{2013Sci...340..577S}, but
not all of them are quiet; furthermore, stellar activity declines
with age \citep{2024ApJ...960...62E}.
\section{Stellar Flares}
Stellar flares
represent a complex of phenomena during which a rapid release of
energy occurs due to the reconnection of the magnetic field. The
first flare was observed visually on the Sun \citep[][the mightiest
in modern history]{1859MNRAS..20...13C}. The advance of
observational techniques in the 20$^{\mathrm{th}}$ century showed
that flares can be captured quite often. The energy release during
a typical flare is always accompanied with an emission of EUV and X-ray
electromagnetic radiation, typically also accompanied by the
eruption of hot solar plasma confined in a magnetic field -- the
coronal mass ejection. Soon it was realized that the Sun is not
unique in this regard, and superflares -- much more powerful
equivalents of what has ever been seen on the Sun -- may be
observed on other stars.
Until the seminal paper by \citet{2012Natur.485..478M} it was
believed that superflares occur either on stars of different spectral
type or evolutionary stage, or on stars in interacting systems.
This work showed that even single solar-like stars exhibits superflares,
prompting questions like how these solar-like stars differ from our Sun
so that we do not observe superflares on our Sun, if it is possible
that the Sun exhibits a superflare occasionally and what the effects
of such events on life on Earth would be.
Almost in parallel, \citet{2012Natur.486..240M} reported on finding
indications of much stronger than Carrington-event occurring in the
historical era. Until today, several such Miyake-events were reported
in the literature \citep[see for a review][]{2023SSRv..219...73U},
raising the question about the interaction of flares and planetary
biospheres once again.
\section{Planetary Environments and the Potential for Life}
Impact of stellar activity
on planetary environments and the potential for life require
accurate estimates of flare energies. Radiation and particle outputs
profoundly influence planetary atmospheres. \citet{2019AsBio..19...64T}
showed that high-energy flares at $\sim$$10^{34}$\,erg occurring at a
frequency of at least once per month can deplete over 99.99\% of a
planet’s ozone layer, exposing the surface to potentially sterilizing
levels of UV. They estimated that about 8.3\% of such flares from
M-dwarfs would directly impact a planet located in the HZ, posing
serious risks to atmospheric retention and surface habitability.
\citet{2019ApJ...873...97L} estimated that flares with energies
$>$10$^{34}$~\,erg occur about once every 6.5\,yr. Even under more
conservative assumptions, flares could prevent the long-term survival
of Earth-like ozone layers. Beyond atmospheric erosion, flare energy
may play an important role in prebiotic chemistry.
\citet{2018SciA....4.3302R} defined {\bf abiogenesis zones} as regions
around stars where UV-driven chemical pathways crucial for life’s
origin can occur. These zones are constrained by the competition
between productive photochemical reactions (e.g., those forming
ribonucleotides essential for RNA synthesis) and side reactions that
lead to inert by-products. The key factor in sustaining these
productive reactions is the cumulative UV energy delivered e.g., by
stellar flares, particularly in the 200--280\,nm band. The authors
calculated the required UV flux accumulated over the lifetime of
intermediate compounds, demonstrating that only planets receiving
sufficient UV flare output can support this form of prebiotic
chemistry. Flare energies and flare occurrence rates together with
their spectral energy distribution are the key to estimating the
possibility of the abiogenesis zone to be present around a particular
star. This idea was further processed by \citet{2020AJ....159...60G}.
On the other hand, proton events often associated with flares may
have adverse effects on life on the surface of the nearby planet.
Even though \citet{2017MNRAS.465L..34A} estimated that a complete planetary
surface sterilization is unlikely by stellar proton events,
severe effects on possible planetary biospheres can still be
expected, possibly even in the form of large-scale extinction events.
\section{Solar Flares}
The study of Solar
flares has advanced significantly over the recent years. Their
near-continuous monitoring is traditionally performed in
chromospheric lines (e.g., H$\alpha$, but not exclusively in
those), with simultaneous soft X-ray space-based monitoring from
the GOES satellite, and in the last decades also in UV, with e.g.,
EIT/SOHO or AIA/SDO. Radio observations from Earth have also
been very useful in continuous monitoring. The X-ray and radio
observations are mostly integrated over the entire solar disk.
Spectroscopic observations of solar flares have been obtained
primarily in the course of spectroscopic monitoring campaigns.
The available material is surprisingly abundant \citep{2024ARA&A..62..437F}.
Therefore, the spectroscopic properties of solar flares seem to be
reasonably well understood.
On the other hand, spectroscopic information about flares on stars
other than the Sun (see Fig.\,\ref{fig1}) is sparse. Several
flare stars
are continuously being monitored within amateur networks, where the
spectroscopic information is reduced to photometry in several
broad-band filters. Some ``color'' information is also available
from large-scale surveys such as LAMOST \citep{2012RAA....12..723Z}.
Quite a few studies have already been published that discuss the
multi-wavelength results of stellar flares
\citep[see a review by][]{2024LRSP...21....1K}.
To summarize, chromospheric lines are indicators of solar-like
activity, not just of flares. There is a correlation between these
activity indices and the occurrence of flares for active stars. The
presence of a flare is indicated by the appearance of emission
in these lines.
\begin{figure}
\centering
\includegraphics[width=1.0\textwidth]{aa620437.f8.png}
\caption{Temporal evolution of H$\alpha$ and Ca\,8542 in a solar flare
spectrum \protect{\citep{2015ApJ...813..125K}}. The duration of this
flare is of the order of minutes. Some flares may continue for tens of
minutes to hours.}\label{fig1}
\end{figure}
\section{Questions and a Path Forward}
Despite continuing efforts
\citep[e.g.,][]{2025MNRAS.537..537O,2025arXiv251107036L}, many open
questions remain about the spectrum of flare radiation, its origin,
time evolution and frequency. Summarizing them:
{\bf (I)} Statistics of flares (power distribution, frequency) as a
function of spectral type and stellar age requires spectroscopic (or
simultaneous multi-band UV-to-IR) monitoring of thousands of flare
stars to characterize the SED of the flares; the total number and
duration depends on the frequency of flares and the sensitivity of the
future facility -- to ensure a statistically significant number of
flares ($\sim$100s per T$_{eff}$/[Fe/H]/age category of stars to obtain
reliable trends).
{\bf(II)} How dangerous are the flares to complex life and in
particular -- to Earth's life? This study will benefit
from a collaboration with biologists working on extremophiles; at this
time we cannot be more specific about the state of radiation biology
and what specific questions will be relevant in the 2040s, but clearly
this project will benefit from an interdisciplinary cooperation.
\section{Future Milestones, Synergies, Requirements, and Strategy}
The following considerations are based on the assumption that a
facility similar to the WST
\citep[Wide Field Survey telescope;][]{2024arXiv240305398M} will
become available at ESO in the 2040s. It is foreseen to have 30,000
fibers and 9\,arcmin$^2$ integral field unit.
The ensemble studies of flares depend on assembling a large sample
of (mostly late-type) stars, and on spectroscopic high-cadence
monitoring. Stars with known habitable planets -- tens or hundreds --
are too few to provide ensemble information. They orbit bright stars
and can be followed-up with relatively small telescopes, on an
individual basis. Instead, for the statistical study the large ensemble
will have to include fainter stars with $V$$>$9\,mag, observe regions
near the Milky Way plane or inner regions, and take advantage of a
high-multiplexity facility.
Sources for the sample, e.g. for M-stars, are: {\it Gaia} (DR4 expected
in 2026), the ongoing surveys like SDSS (2000--) and planned like 4MOST
(2026--). Multiband variability, including flare activity, will be
assessed with ZTF (2018--) and the Rubin observatory (2025--). The
{\it Euclid} mission (2023--) will provide precise space-based infrared
photometry, that will allow to look into color excesses and redder
companions.
This facility landscape of the 2040s implies a {\bf strategy} that combines
two options: a continuous high-cadence monitoring of carefully selected
late-type stars spanning the parameter space of interest and triggered
follow-up observations for stars that exhibit a flare during
the observations. The second option requires that the integration time
is always split in at least two sub-integrations, and unlike the usual
practice of template-completion-driven data reduction, in this case the
data reduction is performed immediately upon completion and transfer of
each sub-integration. Next, the reduction should not be longer than the
time for the second sub-integration and its readout. If indications of
a flare are found in the product spectrum, then the telescope should
continue observing (if allowed by airmass and sky conditions) in the
same configuration, until the flare is over. Therefore, the vast majority
of the time WST will carry out its regular survey where different projects
share fibers in each configuration, and only in those rare occasions
when a flare is detected during the observations, the regular short-term
scheduling will be affected, albeit at the price of creating a flexible,
fast and robust data flow system.
\section{Summary}
The flare characterization places the following
{\bf requirements} considering a WST-like project:
{\bf (I)} A telescope larger than 4-m class is needed to obtain comparable
statistics for fainter late-type stars and to measure the narrow
chromospheric lines with short -- up to a minutes -- integrations to
avoid ``smearing'' the short-lived flares.
{\bf (II)} Extreme multiplexity of $\sim$10$^4$ or higher.
{\bf (III)} A wide field of view of $\sim$1--3\,deg is needed for
efficient observations.
{\bf (IV)} For reliable line profile fitting a resolving power of
$\sim$65,000 is needed \citep{2015ApJ...813..125K}.
{\bf (V)} Finally, it is crucial to adopt flexible observing and reduction
tools that allow implementation of the described observing strategy.
{\small
\bibliographystyle{apalike}
\setlength{\bibsep}{-2.0pt}
\bibliography{biblio_01}
}
\end{document}