The Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment. UBVI Photometry of Stars in Baade's Window
Extracted source text ยท arXiv astro-ph/9908043
\nofiles
\documentstyle[11pt,psfig,twoside]{article}
\thinmuskip = 2mu plus 0mu minus 2mu
\medmuskip = 2.3mu plus 1mu minus 2.3mu
\thickmuskip = 2.6mu plus 2mu minus 2.6mu
\begin{document}
\newcommand{\dd}{\,{\rm d}}
\newcommand{\ie}{{\it i.e.},\,}
\newcommand{\etal}{{\it et al.\ }}
\newcommand{\eg}{{\it e.g.},\,}
\newcommand{\cf}{{\it cf.\ }}
\newcommand{\vs}{{\it vs.\ }}
\newcommand{\zdot}{\makebox[0pt][l]{.}}
\newcommand{\up}[1]{\ifmmode^{\rm #1}\else$^{\rm #1}$\fi}
\newcommand{\dn}[1]{\ifmmode_{\rm #1}\else$_{\rm #1}$\fi}
\newcommand{\upd}{\up{d}}
\newcommand{\uph}{\up{h}}
\newcommand{\upm}{\up{m}}
\newcommand{\ups}{\up{s}}
\newcommand{\arcd}{\ifmmode^{\circ}\else$^{\circ}$\fi}
\newcommand{\arcm}{\ifmmode{'}\else$'$\fi}
\newcommand{\arcs}{\ifmmode{''}\else$''$\fi}
\newcommand{\MS}{{\rm M}\ifmmode_{\odot}\else$_{\odot}$\fi}
\newcommand{\RS}{{\rm R}\ifmmode_{\odot}\else$_{\odot}$\fi}
\newcommand{\LS}{{\rm L}\ifmmode_{\odot}\else$_{\odot}$\fi}
\newcommand{\Abstract}[2]{{\footnotesize\begin{center}ABSTRACT\end{center}
\vspace{1mm}\par#1\par
\noindent
{~}{\it #2}}}
\newcommand{\TabCap}[2]{\begin{center}\parbox[t]{#1}{\begin{center}
\small {\spaceskip 2pt plus 1pt minus 1pt T a b l e}
\refstepcounter{table}\thetable \\[2mm]
\footnotesize #2 \end{center}}\end{center}}
\newcommand{\TableSep}[2]{\begin{table}[p]\vspace{#1}
\TabCap{#2}\end{table}}
\newcommand{\FigCap}[1]{\footnotesize\par\noindent Fig.\ %
\refstepcounter{figure}\thefigure. #1\par}
\newcommand{\TableFont}{\footnotesize}
%\newcommand{\TableFont}{\scriptsize}
\newcommand{\TableFontIt}{\ttit}
\newcommand{\SetTableFont}[1]{\renewcommand{\TableFont}{#1}}
\newcommand{\MakeTable}[4]{\begin{table}[htb]\TabCap{#2}{#3}
\begin{center} \TableFont \begin{tabular}{#1} #4
\end{tabular}\end{center}\end{table}}
\newcommand{\MakeTableSep}[4]{\begin{table}[p]\TabCap{#2}{#3}
\begin{center} \TableFont \begin{tabular}{#1} #4
\end{tabular}\end{center}\end{table}}
\newenvironment{references}%
{
\footnotesize \frenchspacing
\renewcommand{\thesection}{}
\renewcommand{\in}{{\rm in }}
\renewcommand{\AA}{Astron.\ Astrophys.}
\newcommand{\AAS}{Astron.~Astrophys.~Suppl.~Ser.}
\newcommand{\ApJ}{Astrophys.\ J.}
\newcommand{\ApJS}{Astrophys.\ J.~Suppl.~Ser.}
\newcommand{\ApJL}{Astrophys.\ J.~Letters}
\newcommand{\AJ}{Astron.\ J.}
\newcommand{\IBVS}{IBVS}
\newcommand{\PASP}{P.A.S.P.}
\newcommand{\Acta}{Acta Astron.}
\newcommand{\MNRAS}{MNRAS}
\renewcommand{\and}{{\rm and }}
\section{{\rm REFERENCES}}
\sloppy \hyphenpenalty10000
\begin{list}{}{\leftmargin1cm\listparindent-1cm
\itemindent\listparindent\parsep0pt\itemsep0pt}}%
{\end{list}\vspace{2mm}}
\def\TYLDA{~}
\newlength{\DW}
\settowidth{\DW}{0}
\newcommand{\dw}{\hspace{\DW}}
\newcommand{\refitem}[5]{\item[]{#1} #2%
\def\REFARG{#3}\ifx\REFARG\TYLDA\else, {\it#3}\fi
\def\REFARG{#4}\ifx\REFARG\TYLDA\else, {\bf#4}\fi
\def\REFARG{#5}\ifx\REFARG\TYLDA\else, {#5}\fi.}
\newcommand{\Section}[1]{\section{#1}}
\newcommand{\Subsection}[1]{\subsection{#1}}
\newcommand{\Acknow}[1]{\par\vspace{5mm}{\bf Acknowledgments.} #1}
\pagestyle{myheadings}
\def\thefootnote{\fnsymbol{footnote}}
\begin{center}
{\Large\bf The Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment.\\
\vskip3pt
{\Large\bf {\it UBVI} Photometry of Stars\\}
\vskip3pt
{\Large\bf in Baade's Window}\footnote{Based on observations obtained
with the 1.3~m Warsaw telescope at the Las Campanas Observatory of the
Carnegie Institution of Washington.}}
\vskip1cm
{\bf
B.~~P~a~c~z~y~{\'n}~s~k~i$^1$,~~A.~~U~d~a~l~s~k~i$^2$,
~~M.~~S~z~y~m~a~{\'n}~s~k~i$^2$,~~M.~~K~u~b~i~a~k$^2$,
~~G.~~P~i~e~t~r~z~y~\'n~s~k~i$^2$,~~I.~~S~o~s~z~y~{\'n}~s~k~i$^2$,
~~P.~~W~o~\'z~n~i~a~k$^1$,~~ and~~K.~~\.Z~e~b~r~u~\'n$^2$}
\vskip3mm
{$^1$ Princeton University Observatory, Princeton, NJ 08544-1001, USA\\
e-mail: (bp,wozniak)@astro.princeton.edu\\
$^2$Warsaw University Observatory, Al.~Ujazdowskie~4, 00-478~Warszawa, Poland\\
e-mail: (udalski,msz,mk,pietrzyn,soszynsk,zebrun)@sirius.astrouw.edu.pl}
\end{center}
\Abstract{We present {\it UBVI} photometry for 8530 stars in Baade's
Window obtained during the OGLE-II microlensing survey. Among these are
over one thousand red clump giants. 1391 of them have photometry with
errors smaller than 0.04, 0.06, 0.12, and 0.20~mag in the {\it I, V, B,}
and {\it U}-band, respectively. We constructed a map of interstellar
reddening. The corrected colors of the red clump giants: ${(U-B)_0}$,
${(B-V)_0}$, and ${(V-I)_0}$ are very well correlated, indicating that
a single parameter determines the observed spread of their values,
reaching almost 2~mag in the ${(U-B)_0}$. It seems most likely that
heavy element content is the dominant parameter, but it is possible
that another parameter: the age (or mass) of a star moves it along the
same trajectory in the color--color diagram as the metallicity. The
current ambiguity can be resolved with spectral analysis, and our
catalog may be useful as a finding list of red clump giants. We point
out that these K giants are more suitable for a fair determination of
the distribution of metallicity than brighter M giants.
We also present a compilation of {\it UBVI} data for 308 red clump
giants near the Sun, for which Hipparcos parallaxes are more accurate
than 10\%. Spectral analysis of their metallicity may provide
information about the local metallicity distribution as well as the
extent to which mass (age) of these stars affects their colors.
It is remarkable that in spite of a number of problems, stellar models
agree with observations at the 0.1--0.2~mag level, making red clump
giants not only the best calibrated but also the best understood
standard candle.}{~}
\Section{Introduction}
Red clump giants appear to be among the best standard candles
available. Not a single RR~Lyr star or a Cepheid has its parallax
measured by Hipparcos (Perryman \etal 1997) with a 10\% accuracy
(Horner \etal 1999), but there are about $10^3$ red clump giants with
parallaxes at least as good as 10\% (Paczy\'nski and Stanek 1998). The
absolute {\it I}-band magnitude of these stars appears to be almost
independent of their ${(V-I)}$ color (Paczy\'nski and Stanek 1998). The
weak dependence on metallicity was empirically calibrated by Udalski
(1998a), who also demonstrated that there is no detectable dependence
on age, as long as it is between $2\times10^9$ and $10\times10^9$~years
(Udalski 1998b). While this calibration is not perfect, it is superior
to the calibration of either RR~Lyr or Cepheid variables, or any other
standard candle ever proposed. Unfortunately, there is some confusion
about the color--metallicity dependence (Paczy\'nski 1998).
The main purpose of this paper is to present a catalog of {\it UBVI}
photometry for 8530 stars in Baade's Window obtained during the second
phase of the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment (OGLE-II)
microlensing project (\cf Udalski, Kubiak and Szyma\'nski 1997). The
important part of the catalog is the list of 1391 red clump giants in
the galactic bulge/bar, covering a very broad range of colors, and
presumably metallicities. We also present a compilation of {\it UBVI}
photometry (Mermilliod and Mermilliod 1994) for 308 nearby red clump
giants, for which Hipparcos parallaxes are more accurate than 10\%. Our
expectation is that these two data sets provide a convenient list of
objects for which metallicity can be obtained spectroscopically in order
to determine the range of [Fe/H] and [O/H] for nearby stars as well as
for those near the Galactic center. Such spectroscopic study could
resolve the current ambiguity about the distribution of metallicities
and the relation between the metallicity and colors of red clump
giants.
We also present, following Kiraga, Paczy\'nski and Stanek (1997), a
description of the procedure which appears to be fairly accurate in
mapping interstellar extinction. The variation, with the line of sight,
of average colors of the bulge red clump stars, red sub-giants, and the
stars near the main sequence turn off point are very well correlated
with each other, as all are affected by the same variations in the
interstellar reddening. The map of color variations provides
information about angular scale over which the extinction varies.
\Section{Observations}
Observations presented in this paper were collected during the second
phase of the OGLE microlensing search with the 1.3-m Warsaw telescope
at the Las Campanas Observatory, Chile, which is operated by the
Carnegie Institution of Washington. The telescope was equipped with the
"first generation" camera with a SITe ${2048\times2048}$ CCD detector.
The pixel size was 24~$\mu$m giving the 0.417~arcsec/pixel scale.
Observations were performed in the "medium" speed reading mode of CCD
detector with the gain 7.1~e$^-$/ADU and readout noise of about
6.3~e$^-$. Details of the instrumentation setup can be found in
Udalski, Kubiak and Szyma{\'n}ski (1997).
The {\it BVI} photometry comes from observations of the OGLE-II field
covering large part of Baade's Window: BUL$\_$SC45. Observations of
this field were obtained in the drift-scan mode of CCD detector and
the field covers approximately ${14.2\times57}$~arcmin in the sky.
Coordinates of its center are: ${\rm
RA(J2000)=18\uph03\upm37}$, ${\rm
DEC(J2000)=-30\arcd05\arcm00\arcs}$. The effective exposure time was 87,
124 and 162 seconds for the {\it I, V} and {\it B}-band, respectively.
BUL$\_$SC45 field is observed in somewhat different way than the
remaining 47 bulge fields -- it is not a subject of microlensing
search. Observations of this field are collected mainly for maintaining
the phasing of variable stars discovered in its part during the first
stage of the OGLE project (\cf Udalski \etal 1995). Therefore only
about 30 {\it I}-band, 15 {\it V}-band and 10 {\it B}-band epochs were
collected during the period August~5, 1997 through October~21, 1998.
The {\it U}-band photometry was obtained in the standard, still frame
mode of the CCD detector. One field, covering ${14.2\times14.2}$~arcmin
in the sky and centered approximately at the field BWC of OGLE-I: ${\rm
RA(J2000)=18\uph03\upm24\ups}$, ${\rm
DEC(J2000)=-30\arcd02\arcm00\arcs}$; (\cf Udalski \etal 1993, and also
Stanek 1996) was observed on four nights between September~20 and
September~25, 1998. The field overlaps in large part with BUL$\_$SC45
field. The exposure time was 1800 seconds.
Observations collected in the drift-scan mode were reduced with the
standard OGLE data pipeline and transformed to the {\it BVI} system
based on observations of standard stars from Landolt (1992) fields
collected during 5--7 photometric nights (\cf Udalski \etal 1998b).
{\it U}-band photometry collected in the still-frame mode was reduced
in similar manner as described in Udalski (1998b) with the difference
that the full ${2048\times2048}$ pixel image was divided into 16
${512\times512}$ pixel sub-frames and each of them was reduced
separately to ensure constant PSF. In this case transformation to the
standard system was based on photometry of standard stars collected
during three photometric nights.
The systematic error of the {\it BVI}-band transformation should be
smaller than 0.02--0.03~mag. For {\it U}-band the systematic error
might be larger and we conservatively assume it to be equal to
0.05~mag. This is caused by somewhat different spectral response of the
OGLE instrumental ultraviolet filter because of somewhat steeper cut of
the short wavelength (${\lambda<3500}$~\AA) side of the {\it U}-band by
the telescope field corrector made from BK7 Schott glass. Nevertheless,
the standard stars transform well to the standard system and the color
term coefficient for the {\it U}-band is equal to 0.127 (0.000 means
the standard system) which compares to $-0.041$, $+0.004$ and $+0.032$
for {\it B, V} and {\it I}-band, respectively.
The final list of Baade's Window stars with {\it UBVI} photometry was
constructed by cross-identification of all stars found in the {\it
U}-band images with the stars from the drift-scan field BUL$\_$SC45
using second order transformation between pixel coordinates.
Astrometric positions of stars were determined with the standard OGLE
procedure as described in Udalski \etal (1998b). About 10270 stars from
the BUL$\_$SC45 field were used to derive transformation between image pixel
coordinates and the Digitized Sky Survey (DSS) coordinate system.
Internal accuracy of determined equatorial coordinates is about
0.15~arcsec with possible systematic errors of the DSS system up to
0.7~arcsec.
\Section{{\it UBVI} Photometry of Baade's Window Stars}
Table~1 contains {\it UBVI} photometric data for 8530 stars in Baade's
Window. We provide there star ID number (in BUL$\_$SC45 field),
equatorial coordinates (J2000) and observed and extinction-free (see
below) {\it UBVI} magnitudes of each star. Table~1 is too large to be
conveniently printed, therefore only a few sample lines are shown. Full
versions of Tables presented in this paper are available in electronic
form from the OGLE Internet data archive: {\it
http://www.astrouw.edu.pl/\~{}ftp/ogle} or its mirror\newline
{\it http://www.astro.princeton.edu/\~{}ogle}.
\begin{figure}[htb]
\vspace*{-5mm}
\psfig{figure=fig1.ps,bbllx=0pt,bblly=0pt,bburx=590pt,bbury=750pt,width=12cm,clip=,angle=-90}
\FigCap{Color--magnitude diagrams for 50\% of the 8530 stars in Baade's Window
for which {\it UBVI} photometry was obtained by the OGLE-II. Photometric
errors in all bands are smaller than 0.1 mag. Notice the increase of color
range of red clump giants progressing from $(V-I)$, through $(B-V)$ to $(U-
B)$.}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}[p]
\vspace*{2cm}
\centerline{\hglue8.3cm\psfig{figure=tab1.ps,height=23cm,angle=90}}
\end{figure}
The ${I-(V-I)}$, ${I-(B-V)}$, and ${I-(U-B)}$ color--magnitude diagrams
(CMDs) of Baade's Window stars are shown in Fig.~1 for 50\% of the
total of 8530 stars for which {\it UBVI} band photometry was more
accurate than 0.1~mag. The red clump is clearly visible in all three
diagrams, and its width increases dramatically toward the blue and
ultraviolet. For these diagrams to be useful we have to correct them
for interstellar reddening.
\Section{Reddening Map}
We followed Kiraga, Paczy\'nski and Stanek (1997) in the determination
of interstellar reddening variation over our field. We selected 38,249
stars for which {\it V} and {\it I}-band photometry was more accurate
than 0.1~mag. The corresponding CMD for 25\% of those stars is shown in
Fig.~2. Four regions were selected: one near the red clump (RC), one
below it, at the red giant branch (RG), and two near the main sequence
turn off point, one brighter, and the other one fainter (TOPb, TOPf),
as indicated in Fig.~2. The six parallel lines are described with the
equations: ${I-1.5\times(V-I)=C}$, where ${C=12.00}$, 13.25, 14.50,
15.50, 16.00, 16.50, respectively. The slope of these lines was chosen
so that they are parallel to the reddening vector (Stanek 1996).
\begin{figure}[htb]
\hglue1.3cm\psfig{figure=fig2.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=150pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=10cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Color--magnitude diagram for 25\% of the 38,249 stars in Baade's
Window for which {\it V} and {\it I}-band photometry was obtained by the
OGLE-II. Photometric errors in both bands are smaller than 0.1~mag. The stars
in the four marked regions were used for reddening determination.}
\end{figure}
We divided our field into squares of ${200\times200}$ pixels. In every
square we calculated average color of the stars in each of the four
groups separately, and also the average of the stars in all four
groups. It is safe to assume that there was no significant variation in
stellar populations within our field, which had the total area of only
$(0\zdot\arcd23)^2$. The variation of average colors was due to
variation in the interstellar reddening as well as the statistical
fluctuations caused by a small number of stars.
The colors of all four stellar groups are very well correlated, as shown
in Fig.~3. To bring the colors of the four groups to the same average
value the corrections were added to the ${(V-I)}$ color of each star,
with ${\Delta(V- I)_{\rm TOPf}=+0.200}$~mag, ${\Delta(V-I)_{\rm
TOPb}=+0.138}$~mag, $\Delta(V-I)_{\rm RG}=-0.120$~mag and
$\Delta(V-I)_{\rm RC}=-0.217$~mag. The shift between colors of each
group in Fig.~3 has been increased for the clarity of presentation.
\begin{figure}[htb]
\hglue1.5cm\psfig{figure=fig3.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=145pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=9cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Relation between the average ${(V-I)}$ colors of the stars in four
areas indicated in Fig.~2 are shown as a function of the average $(V-I)_{\rm
av}$ for stars in all four areas. Each dot corresponds to a different square
in the CCD field, $200\times 200$ pixels, \ie ${83\zdot\arcs4\times
83\zdot\arcs4}$ each.}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}[htb]
\hglue1.5cm\psfig{figure=fig4.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=145pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=9cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Correlation function $\sigma^2$ of the variation in ${(V-
I)}$ is shown as a function of separation~$d$. The upper sequence of points
corresponds to the resolution ${50\times50}$ pixels, while the lower sequence
corresponds to the resolution ${100\times100}$ pixels.}
\end{figure}
As there was such a good correlation between the colors of the four
groups we combined all stars, adding the suitable corrections as given
above. We calculated average colors for the stars in squares
${50\times50}$ pixels, \ie ${20\zdot\arcs8\times20\zdot\arcs8}$ in the
sky. The total number of such squares in our field was
${39\times42=1638}$. These became our resolution elements for the
reddening map, or the elementary squares. The number of stars in the
four groups was: ${N_{\rm TOPf}=6422}$, ${N_{\rm TOPb}=7776}$, ${N_{\rm
RG}=4185}$, ${N_{\rm RC}=4546}$. The total number of all stars used for
the reddening determination was ${N=22,929}$, the average number of
stars per elementary square was ${n=14.0}$, and the variance of the
average color was ${\langle\sigma^2_{V-I}\rangle=(0.034~{\rm mag})^2}$.
The {\it rms} variation of the ${(V-I)}$ color per star was
approximately 0.13~mag.
Given the values of the average ${(V-I)}$ colors in 1638 elementary
squares we calculated the correlation function defined as
$$\sigma^2(d)=\langle\Delta(V- I)^2\rangle,\eqno(1)$$ averaged over all
pairs of squares within each range of separations~$d$. $\sigma^2$ is
shown in Fig.~4 as a function of the separation between the elementary
squares (the upper sequence of points). The point corresponding to the
separation ${d=0}$ is twice the variance of the ${(V-I)}$ color per
elementary square. Fig.~4 shows that the value of the correlation
function doubles at a separation ${d\approx500}$ pixels, which is 10
times larger than the elementary square size. We repeated the exercise
by combining 4 adjacent elementary squares into one composite square of
${100\times100}$ pixels, thereby increasing the average number of stars
to 56.0, and reducing the variance of the average ${(V-I)}$ color to
$(0.017~{\rm mag})^2$. The corresponding correlation points are shown
as the lower sequence in Fig.~4. This time the correlation function
doubles its value at a separation ${d\approx 100}$ pixels.
While the zero point depends on the choice of the square size, the rest
of the correlation function is the same in both cases, except for the
zero point shift. The contribution of interstellar reddening to the
correlation function may be approximated as
$$\langle\Delta E_{V-I}^2\rangle\approx\left(0.027~{\rm mag}\right)^2\times
{d\over1'},\qquad 0<d<7'.\eqno(2)$$
How to chose the right square size? If the squares are small then the
resolution is high, and the variations of interstellar reddening from
square to square are small. However, there are few stars per square and
the statistical error in the estimate of the average stellar color is
large. When the squares are large the opposite is true: the average
color is calculated accurately, but the resolution is poor and the
variations of the interstellar reddening within the square become
substantial. Without attempting a rigorous analysis it seems that a
sensible square size is such, that the two contributions: the random
noise due to a finite number of stars within the square, and the
variations of the interstellar reddening within the square are
comparable. Fig.~4 suggests that a sensible choice is a square size
${100\times 100}$~pixels, \ie ${41\zdot\arcs7\times41\zdot\arcs7}$ in
the sky.
\begin{figure}[htb]
\hglue1.5cm\psfig{figure=fig5.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=145pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=9cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Correlation of the average color ${(V-I)_{\rm av}}$ of the OGLE
stars on the reddening ${E_{V-I}}$ calculated with Stanek's (1996) map. The
diagonal line is the relation: ${(V-I)_{\rm av}=E_{V-I}+0.931}$.}
\end{figure}
We calculated average ${(V-I)_{\rm av}}$ color for the stars in a grid
of ${100\times100}$ pixel squares. We shifted the grid by 50 pixels in
both directions, so as to have average color calculated at 50 pixel
intervals. A comparison between the ${(V-I)_{\rm av}}$ color from our
data and the color excess ${E_{V-I}}$ calculated with the Stanek's
(1996) extinction map is shown in Fig.~5. The agreement is good, and we
adopt the relation:
$$E_{V-I}=(V-I)_{\rm av}-0.931,\qquad\langle E_{V-I}\rangle=0.59.\eqno(3)$$
Obviously, our method, as well as Stanek's, provides only a differential
reddening map. The zero point adopted by Stanek, and therefore also by
us, is based on the determination by Gould \etal (1998) and Alcock
\etal (1998).
We calculate reddening within our $(0\zdot\arcd23)^2$ field by linear
interpolation in the grid with the spacing of 50 pixels. The values of
$E_{V-I}$ are based on the average ${(V-I)_{\rm av}}$ calculated in
${100\times100}$ pixel squares. Therefore, the resolution of our
extinction map is 100~pixels, \ie 41\zdot\arcs7 in the sky. We estimate
the statistical accuracy of our reddening map to be
${\approx0.02}$~mag. Of course, the uncertainty in the zero point of
our extinction is substantially larger. The {\sc FORTRAN} code {\sc
red.f}, calculating reddening within our field is available from the
OGLE Internet archive.
\Section{Color--Color Diagrams}
The extinction in the four bands was calculated according to the formulae:
$$A_I=1.500\cdot E_{V-I},\qquad\langle A_I\rangle=0.88,\eqno{\rm (4a)}$$
$$A_V=2.500\cdot E_{V-I},\qquad\langle A_V\rangle=1.48,\eqno{\rm (4b)}$$
$$A_B=3.333\cdot E_{V-I},\qquad\langle A_B\rangle=1.97,\eqno{\rm (4c)}$$
$$A_U=3.958\cdot E_{V-I},\qquad\langle A_U\rangle=2.34,\eqno{\rm (4d)}$$
and the colors were corrected for the reddening accordingly. The coefficients
in the Eqs.~(4a)--(4d) are more or less standard, but the reader may adopt
different values as we provide the original as well as the dereddened
photometry. The reddening varied relatively little over our small field of
view, with 90\% of stars in the range ${0.51<E_{V-I}<0.65}$. Therefore, the
CMDs corrected for extinction were similar to those shown in Fig.~1, except
for a shift in color and magnitude.
\begin{figure}[p]
\vspace*{2cm}
\centerline{\hglue8.3cm\psfig{figure=tab2.ps,height=23cm,angle=90}}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}[p]
\vspace*{2cm}
\centerline{\hglue8.3cm\psfig{figure=tab3.ps,height=23cm,angle=90}}
\end{figure}
Median errors of the OGLE-II photometry of the red clump giants are
0.016, 0.02, 0.04 and 0.06~mag for {\it I, V, B} and {\it U}-band,
respectively. The {\it I}-band errors are color independent, but the
errors in {\it V, B} and mostly in {\it U}-band increase with the
${(V-I)}$ color, because the redder stars are fainter. In the {\it
U}-band the reddest red clump stars are near our detection limit, as it
is apparent in Fig.~1. We rejected stars with the errors larger than
0.04, 0.06, 0.12, and 0.20~mag in the {\it I, V, B} and {\it U}-band,
respectively; these were about 5\% of the total. 1391 stars had smaller
photometric errors and satisfied the inequalities:
$$14.0<I_0<14.5,\qquad0.8<(V-I)_0<1.6,\eqno(5)$$
and these are listed in Table~2 (full version is available from the OGLE
Internet archive). Note, that some stars in Table~2 are not present in
Table~1, because the criteria used for the error discrimination were
different for the two sets.
We also selected red clump giants from the Hipparcos catalog according
to the following criteria: genuine {\it I}-band photometry was available
in the catalog, the absolute magnitude $M_I$, the color ${(V-I)}$, and the
parallax $\pi$ satisfied the criteria:
$$-0.5<M_I<0.2,\qquad0.8<(V-I)<1.6,\qquad\pi~{\rm error<10\%},\eqno(6)$$
J-C. Mermilliod kindly provided us with the {\it UBV} photometry for the
selected stars in a computer readable form (\cf Mermilliod and
Mermilliod 1994, and {\it http://obswww.unige.ch/gcpd/} ). The list of
308 stars which satisfied the criteria given above, had {\it UBVI}
photometry and had the differences in {\it V} and {\it B} magnitudes as
given by the Hipparcos/Tycho catalogs and by Mermilliod not larger than
0.03~mag, are listed in Table~3 (full version is available from the
OGLE Internet archive). As all Hipparcos stars with accurate parallaxes
are within about 100~pc, their reddening is very small (Stanek and Garnavich
1998, Sekiguchi and Fukugita 1999).
The number of red clump giants for which Hipparcos provides accurate
parallaxes is several times larger than 308, and they all have accurate
{\it V} and {\it B} photometry, but a large fraction does not have
either {\it I} or {\it U} data. The calibration of red clump giants
could be improved considerably if standard {\it I} and {\it U}
photometry were made for these bright stars.
Figs.~6 and 7 show ${(V-I)_0-(B-V)_0}$ and ${(B-V)_0-(U-B)_0}$
color--color diagrams constructed for 1391 Baade's Window red clump
giants. Figs.~8 and 9 show similar diagrams for the Hipparcos sample of
red clump stars. The arrow pointing the direction of interstellar
reddening is shown in Figs.~6 and 7, with the filled circles indicating
the average reddening, and the open circles indicating the full range
of reddening within our field.
\begin{figure}[p]
\hglue2cm\psfig{figure=fig6.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=145pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=8cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Color--color diagram: ${(V-I)_0-(B-V)_0}$ for 1391 red clump
giants in Baade's Window corrected for interstellar reddening. The two
thin lines that cross are for reference; they are the same as in
Fig.~8.}
\vspace*{10pt}
\hglue2cm\psfig{figure=fig7.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=145pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=8cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Color--color diagram: ${(B-V)_0-(U-B)_0}$ for 1391 red clump
giants in Baade's Window corrected for interstellar reddening. The two
thin lines that cross are for reference; they are the same as in
Fig.~9.} \end{figure}
\begin{figure}[p]
\hglue2cm\psfig{figure=fig8.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=145pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=8cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Color--color diagram: ${(V-I)-(B-V)}$ for 308 red clump giants for
which Hipparcos measured parallaxes with the accuracy better than 10\%. The
two thin lines that cross are the regression lines of one color with respect
to another.}
\vspace*{10pt}
\hglue2cm\psfig{figure=fig9.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=145pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=8cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Color--color diagram: ${(B-V)-(U-B)}$ for 308 red clump giants for
which Hipparcos measured parallaxes with the accuracy better than 10\%. The
two thin lines that cross are the regression lines of one color with respect
to another.}
\end{figure}
\Section{Discussion}
\Subsection{{\it UBVI} Observations}
A comparison of several hundred red clump giants for which OGLE-I
photometry (Szyma{\'n}ski \etal 1996) and the current OGLE-II
photometry are available allowed us to determine a small offset between
the two. The OGLE-I $V$-band is 0.021~mag fainter, the $I$-band is
0.035~mag brighter, and the ${(V-I)}$ color is 0.056~mag redder than
the corresponding quantities determined with the OGLE-II, which we
consider to be more accurate.
The average colors for the red clump giants presented in Table~2, and
the {\it rms} deviations of the stars from the average are: (1.114,
0.117), (1.081, 0.191), and (1.148, 0.510) for ${(V-I)_0}$,
${(B-V)_0}$, and ${(U-B)_0}$, respectively. The corresponding numbers
for the Hipparcos red clump giants listed in Table~3 are: (1.021,
0.091), (1.050, 0.102), and (0.916, 0.239) for these colors. Notice
that the range of colors for Baade's Window stars is larger than for
Hipparcos stars, and the difference increases strongly toward short
wavelengths, being the largest in ${(U-B)_0}$, as expected for a
population with a larger range of metallicities.
We may compare our mean ${(V-I)_0}$ colors and their range with the
corresponding numbers given by Paczy{\'n}ski and Stanek (1998): (1.16,
0.14) for Baade's Window (based on OGLE-I data but corrected to the
OGLE-II photometric system) and (1.01, 0.08) for the Hipparcos stars.
Our new Hipparcos numbers are practically the same as those of
Paczy{\'n}ski and Stanek (1998), but there is some difference for
Baade's Window stars. There may be several reasons: Paczy{\'n}ski and
Stanek (1998) used a much larger area in their study, with a larger
range of interstellar extinction. OGLE-I photometric errors were larger
which may be responsible for the apparent larger range of colors, in
addition to the systematic offset between OGLE-I and OGLE-II, which has
been allowed for.
The data we present in this paper cannot by itself resolve the current
ambiguity about the relation between the colors and the metallicity of
red clump giants (Paczy\'nski 1998). However, the catalogs of these
stars in Baade's Window (Table~2) and near the Sun (Table~3) can be
used to select stars over the full range of colors for spectroscopic
studies.
Tight color--color relations apparent for the Hipparcos stars (Figs.~8
and 9) clearly indicate that either there is a single parameter that
determines the red clump colors, or there is a degeneracy between
several parameters, which conspire to change stellar colors in the same
direction in the three dimensional space of ${(V-I)-(B-V)-(U-B)}$. The
same appears to be true for the red clump giants in Baade's Window
(Figs.~6 and 7). The scatter is larger in Baade's Window for at least
two reasons: photometric errors are larger than for the bright
Hipparcos stars, and reddening corrections are not perfect. It is
somewhat disturbing that the slope of the ${(B-V)_0-(V-I)_0}$ relation
is somewhat different for the stars in Baade's Window than those near
the Sun. In principle there is a possibility that the reddening vector
varies significantly with the stellar color, but we did not make an
estimate of this effect.
If future spectroscopic determinations of the metallicity establish only
a weak correlation with colors of red clump giants, then it will be
clear that another parameter, most likely the mass (\ie age) of a star
affects its colors too. This would imply that red clump giants make
large loops in the CMD during their core helium burning phase. However,
if it turns out that the spectroscopic metallicity is very well
correlated with colors, then the implication will be that the
dependence on mass (age) is weak, and the evolutionary loops are small.
Note, that our samples of the red clump giants are not likely to be
biased by their colors, as they are all well above the detection limit,
except for the reddest stars, for which {\it U}-band magnitude was close
to the detection limit (\cf Fig.~1).
Following the approach of Paczy\'nski and Stanek (1998) we determined that the
number density of red clump stars peaks at ${I_0=14.37\pm0.02}$. Of course,
the true error may be as large as 0.1 mag because the zero point of the
interstellar extinction is uncertain (Alcock \etal 1998, Gould \etal 1998).
For comparison, Paczy{\'n}ski and Stanek (1998) obtained ${I_0=14.36}$ for the
peak of the red clump stars, allowing for the systematic offset between OGLE-I
and OGLE-II.
Stanek \etal (1999) have presented {\it UBVI} photometry in a nearby
field BW8 in Baade's Window. Their results are in substantial agreement
with ours, although there appear to be some systematic differences of
order of 0.05~mag in zero points of photometry. They also discuss the
effect of metallicity on colors of the red clump stars.
\Subsection{Stellar Models}
It is remarkable how well the models of red clump giants agree with the
observations. Recently, evolutionary tracks for a broad range of
metallicities and masses were calculated by Bertelli \etal (1994),
Jimenez, Flynn and Kotoneva (1998), and by Girardi \etal (1998). The
results are best summarized by Fig.~1 of Girardi \etal (1998), which
clearly shows that the absolute {\it I}-band magnitude changes very
little with stellar mass (\ie age), but it decreases by 0.2--0.3~mag
when the metallicity decreases from ${Z=0.03}$ to ${Z=0.001}$, in a
fairly good agreement with the Udalski's (1998b) empirical calibration.
Models demonstrate that while the metallicity is the dominant factor
affecting the colors, the stellar mass (age) makes a non-negligible
contribution, especially at high metallicities, where red clump giants
make fairly large horizontal loops in the CMD. This suggests that there
is some degeneracy, in the sense that metallicity and stellar mass
(age) move a star along nearly the same, approximately horizontal
vector in the CMD, and along approximately the same vector in a
color--color diagram.
Things are different at very low metallicities, like those found in
Leo~I (Caputo \etal 1999), where ${Z=0.0004}$ or even 0.0001. Under
these extreme conditions the red clump appears like a small arc, with
the top and bottom relatively blue, and the middle relatively red. The
range of luminosities of the red clump giants in Leo~I is larger than
the range observed in the Galaxy (\eg Paczy\'nski and Stanek
1998), Magellanic Clouds (\eg Udalski \etal 1998a, Stanek, Zaritsky and
Harris 1998), or in M31 (Stanek and Garnavich 1998). This is in
excellent agreement with the prediction of stellar evolutionary models
(Bertelli \etal 1994), and indicates a very large spread in masses
(ages) of the extremely metal poor population observed in Leo I (Caputo
\etal 1999).
Things are also different for very young red clump giants, as it is
apparent in the data (Udalski \etal 1998a) and in the models (\cf
Fig.~1 of Girardi \etal 1998): the stars younger than 2~Gyr are
brighter than those in the age group of 2--10~Gyr. However, it is
remarkable, that in all objects with a large number of red clump giants
that were studied so far: Hipparcos stars and the Galactic bulge
(Paczy\'nski and Stanek 1998), LMC, SMC, Carina dwarf galaxy (Udalski
\etal 1998a, Udalski 1998a), M31 (Stanek and Garnavich 1998), the red
clump shows very little spread in the {\it I}-band magnitude,
indicating that the stellar population is dominated by stars which are
2--10~Gyr old.
While one may argue about 0.1~mag or even 0.2~mag discrepancy between
the models and observations (\eg Girardi 1999), the situation is
comparable to, or better than, the situation with the RR~Lyr stars or
with Cepheids, except those stars do not have empirical calibration as
good as the red clump giants. A thorough comparison between the models
and the data for the red clump giants can be found in Stanek \etal
(1999).
While the evolutionary models are in a reasonable agreement with
observations, one should be aware of several problems with the models
which cannot be readily resolved and which make a perfect agreement
with the data almost impossible.
It is well known that theory cannot predict what should be the value of
the mixing length parameter which is used to describe non-adiabatic
convection below stellar photosphere. Moreover, the model effective
temperature and radius are very sensitive to this parameter, and in
practice the calibration is empirical. There is no reason for the
mixing length parameter to be a universal constant, and today's theory
cannot make a firm prediction of the effective temperature of any cool
star, including red clump giants.
In order to be compared with observations, the effective temperature
of a stellar model is converted to a color, like ${(V-I)}$, which
introduces next theoretical step: model atmosphere. While these are
ever more sophisticated and presumably accurate, ultimately the
accuracy of the $T_{\rm eff}$ \vs color transformation has to be
empirically verified. The same is true for the bolometric corrections.
Note that the bolometric luminosity provided by stellar models is not
sensitive to the value of mixing length parameter. However, the
bolometric correction rests on model atmospheres and their empirical
calibration.
Stochastic mass loss from red giant stars is believed to be responsible
for the morphology of the horizontal branch (Rood 1973, Chiosi,
Bertelli, and Bressan 1992). In other words, the amount of matter lost
affects stellar radius and effective temperature, affecting the size of
a loop the star makes in the CMD. Red clump giants have identical
interior structure as classical horizontal branch stars and therefore
their loops are also affected by the amount of mass loss. As the reason
for the stochastic nature of mass loss is not known, the size of those
loops cannot be firmly predicted by the theory.
There is yet another major uncertainty of the models, which is not very
well known, or not very well remembered. Several decades ago it was
established that low mass stars develop large semiconvective zones just
outside of their convective helium burning cores (Schwarzschild 1970,
Iben 1974, and references therein). The question: "what is the proper
criterion for a marginally stable gradient of chemical composition" was
debated. There has been no discussion of this subject lately, and there
is no reference to the semiconvection in recent papers on models of
horizontal branch or red clump stars. It is not clear whether the
problem has been solved or forgotten.
Another very delicate issue is the extent to which chemical composition
profile affects the size of the loops that stars make in the CMD while
burning helium in their cores. Robertson (1971), and Lauterborn,
Refsdal, and Weigert (1971) demonstrated that even very small changes
in the stellar interior had a huge effect on the loop size. This is not
important when the red clump models are very close to the red giant
branch, \ie when the loop is very small, and the range of colors is
very small. However, high metallicity clump models appear to have
fairly extended loops (\cf Fig.~1 of Girardi \etal 1998), and the size
of these may be very sensitive to many details of stellar structure.
The issue of the loop size can be most reliably resolved with the
spectral observations, which may establish how tight (or not tight) is
the correlation between the colors and metallicity of the red clump
giants. The tighter the correlation, the smaller the loops have to be,
and {\it vice versa}.
Considering the many difficulties with the stellar models it is not
likely that they can provide quantities like $M_I$ and ${(V-I)_0}$ with
a precision better than 0.1--0.2~mag, unless empirically calibrated.
This is roughly the level at which the models and the observations
appear to agree or disagree with each other.
\begin{figure}[htb]
\hglue2cm\psfig{figure=fig10.ps,bbllx=20pt,bblly=150pt,bburx=550pt,bbury=680pt,width=9cm,clip=}
\vspace*{3pt}
\FigCap{Color--magnitude diagram for 30\% of stars in the SMC field SMC$\_$SC1
(Udalski \etal 1998b). Note how narrow is the red giant branch and how compact
is the red clump in this field with low and uniform reddening.}
\end{figure}
\Subsection{Red Clump in the SMC}
Although the Small Magellanic Cloud is not the topic of this paper, we
present in Fig.~10 a color magnitude diagram for the red clump for a
region near the south-west end of the SMC bar. We took the data from
the SMC Photometric Maps published by the OGLE team (Udalski \etal
1998b), which have been accessible from the OGLE archive for over a
year. The main reason for presenting Fig.~10 is to show how compact the
red clump is when the reddening is not a problem, the range of
distances is small, and the range of metallicities is low too. The data
from the SMC maps may be useful to test and/or calibrate theoretical
models. In particular, it is striking that the red clump in the SMC has
no apparent structure, except for a cloud of stars above the main body
of the clump; these are likely the younger and more massive stars as
shown in Fig.~1 of Girardi \etal (1998).
\Acknow{It is a great pleasure to acknowledge numerous discussions with
Dr.\ K.Z.~Stanek. We are very indebted to Dr.\ J.-C.\ Mermilliod for
providing us with the {\it UBV} data for the Hipparcos stars in a
computer readable form. We are very grateful to Dr.\ P.\ Popowski for
pointing out some important omissions in the original version of this
paper. We are also grateful to Dr.\ J.\ Cohen for pointing out mistakes
in the original Table~3. This work was supported with the NSF grants
AST--9530478 and AST--9820314 to B.\ Paczy{\'n}ski and the Polish KBN
grant 2P03D00814 to A.\ Udalski.}
\begin{references}
\refitem{Alcock, C. \etal}{1998}{\ApJ}{494}{396}
\refitem{Bertelli, G. \etal}{1994}{\AAS}{106}{275}
\refitem{Caputo, F. \etal}{1999}{\AJ}{117}{2199}
\refitem{Chiosi, C., Bertelli, G., and Bressan, A.}{1992}{Ann.~Rev.~Astron.
Astrophys.}{30}{235}
\refitem{Girardi, L., Groenewegen, M.A.T, Weiss, A., and Salaris, M.}{1998}
{\MNRAS}{301}{149}
\refitem{Girardi, L.}{1999}{~}{~}{astro-ph/9807086}
\refitem{Gould, A., Popowski, P., and Terndrup, D.M.}{1998}{\ApJ}{492}{778}
\refitem{Horner, D. \etal}{1999}{~}{~}{astro-ph/9907213}
\refitem{Iben, I.Jr.}{1974}{Ann.~Rev.~Astron.~Astrophys.}{12}{215}
\refitem{Jimenez, R., Flynn, C., and Kotoneva, E.}{1998}{\MNRAS}{299}{515}
\refitem{Kiraga, M., Paczy\'nski, B., and Stanek, K.Z.}{1997}{\ApJ}{485}{611}
\refitem{Landolt, A.U.}{1992}{\AJ}{104}{372}
\refitem{Lauterborn, D., Refsdal, S., and Weigert, A.}{1971}{\AA}{10}{97}
\refitem{Mermilliod, J.-C., and Mermilliod, M.}{1994}{~}{~}{"Catalogue of Mean
{\it UBV} Data on Stars", Springer-Verlag}
\refitem{Paczy\'nski, B.}{1998}{\Acta}{48}{405}
\refitem{Paczy\'nski, B., and Stanek, K.Z.}{1998}{\ApJL}{494}{L219}
\refitem{Perryman, M.A.C. \etal}{1997}{\AA}{323}{L49}
\refitem{Robertson, J.W.}{1971}{\ApJL}{164}{L105}
\refitem{Rood, R.T.}{1973}{\ApJ}{184}{815}
\refitem{Schwarzschild, M.}{1970}{Quart.~J.~RAS}{11}{12}
\refitem{Sekiguchi, M., and Fukugita, M.}{1999}{~}{~}{astro-ph/9904299}
\refitem{Stanek, K.Z.}{1996}{\ApJ}{460}{L37}
\refitem{Stanek, K.Z. and Garnavich, P. M.}{1998}{\ApJ}{503}{131}
\refitem{Stanek, K.Z., Zaritsky, D., and Harris, J.}{1998}{\ApJ}{500}{141}
\refitem{Stanek, K.Z., Kaluzny, J., Wysocka, A., and Thompson, I.}{1999}{~}{~}
{astro-ph/9908041}
\refitem{Szyma{\'n}ski, M., Udalski, A., Kubiak, M., Kaluzny, J., Mateo, M.,
and Krzemi{\'n}ski, W.}{1996}{\Acta}{46}{1}
\refitem{Udalski, A., Szyma\'nski, M., Kaluzny, J., Kubiak, M, and
Mateo, M.}{1993}{\Acta}{43}{69}
\refitem{Udalski, A., Olech, A., Szyma\'nski, M., Kaluzny, J., Kubiak, M,
Mateo, M. and Krzemi{\'n}ski, W.}{1995}{\Acta}{45}{433}
\refitem{Udalski, A., Kubiak, M., and Szyma\'nski, M.}{1997}{\Acta}{47}{319}
\refitem{Udalski, A.}{1998a}{\Acta}{48}{113}
\refitem{Udalski, A.}{1998b}{\Acta}{48}{383}
\refitem{Udalski, A., Szyma\'nski, M., Kubiak, M., Pietrzy\'nski, G.,
Wo\'zniak, P., and {\.Z}ebru\'n, K.}{1998a}{\Acta}{48}{1}
\refitem{Udalski, A., Szyma\'nski, M., Kubiak, M.,Pietrzy\'nski, G., Wo\'zniak,
P., and {\.Z}ebru\'n, K.}{1998b}{\Acta}{48}{147}
\end{references}
\end{document}