Long-term infrared variation of 3C 279 and 4C 29.45
Extracted source text ยท arXiv astro-ph/9908080
\documentstyle{l-aa}
\begin{document}
\title{Long-term infrared variation of 3C279 and 4C29.45}
\author{J.H. Fan \inst{1,2} }
\institute{ CCAST (World Laboratory), P.O. Box 8730, Beijing
100080, China \and Center for
Astrophysics, Guangzhou Normal University,
Guangzhou 510400, China, e-mail:
jhfan@guangztc.edu.cn}
\date{Received <date>;accepted<date>}
\maketitle
\begin{abstract}
In this paper, the historical infrared (JHK) data compiled from 22
publications are presented for 3C279 and 4C29.45.
Relations between color index and magnitude and between color-color
indices are discussed. (J-K) is found closely
correlated with (J-H) while (J-H) is almost not correlated with (H-K),
which is perhaps due to two facts of (1) (J-K) shows wider distribution
than (J-H) and (H-K) and (2) the spectrum deviates from the power law.
For color-magnitude relation, there is a correlation of color index
increasing with the magnitude for 3C279 suggesting that the spectrum flattens
when the source brightens. But an opposite tendency is also noted between
(H-K) and J when J is fainter than 14 magnitude, which suggests that
the near-IR spectrum of 3C 279 consists of, at least, two
components. No similar result is found for 4C29.45. The largest
amplitude infrared variation is smaller than but comparable with the
largest amplitude variation for the two objects.
\keywords{Variability--Infrared--Blazars-Individual (3C279, 4C29.45)}
\end{abstract}
\section{Introduction}
Blazars are AGNs characterized by compact radio core, high and variable
radio and optical polarization, superluminal radio components. The
continuum emissions are rapidly variable at all frequencies with
amplitude of variability increasing with frequency (see Kollgaard 1994,
Urry \& Padovani 1995 and Scarp \& Falomo 1997). Blazars include BL
Lac objects, optically violently variable quasars (OVVs), highly
polarized quasars(HPQs), flat spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs), and core
dominated quasars (CDQ). All those objects are basically the same
thing (Fugmann 1989; Impey et al. 1991; Valtaoja et al. 1992;
Will et al. 1992; Scarpa \& Falomo 1997).
3C279 ( PKS 1253-055, 4C-05.55) and 4C29.45 (QSO 1156+295, Ton 599)
are members of blazars. These two objects have some interesting
observation properties. They are QSOs showing properties similar to those
of a BL Lacertae object: Large amplitude variation and high and variable
polarization. 4C29.45 is classified as a BL Lac object (see
Fan et al. 1993 and references therein), but its line spectrum
looks like that of a normal QSOs when the continuum is faint
( B $\sim$ 18) (Wills et al. 1983). 3C279 and 3C 345 occupy the same
place as radio selected BL Lacertae objects (RBLs) in the
polarization-Doppler factor diagram and are more like RBLs than QSOs
(Fan 1998).
Before $\gamma$-ray observations were available, Impey \& Neugebauer
(1988) found that the infrared emission (1-100 $\mu m$) dominate the
bolometric luminosities of blazars. The infrared emissions are also an
important component for the luminosity even the $\gamma$-ray emissions
are included ( von Montigny 1995). The high energetic $\gamma$-ray
emission mechanism is still an open problem (see Fan et al. 1998a, and
references therein). Recently, Xie et al. (1997)
found that the high energetic $\gamma$-rays are correlated with the
near-IR emissions suggesting that the soft photons scattered to the
$\gamma$-rays region are from the dust. So, study of the infrared will
throw some lights on the understanding of the emission mechanisms in
AGNs.
Blazars have been observed in infrared region for more than 20 years.
But there are no available long-term infrared variations in the literature
for all these objects. In this paper, we mainly present the long-term
infrared (J,H, and K bands ) light curves for 3C279 and 4C29.45 and
discuss the variation properties because there are more continuous
observations in their J, H, and K bands. The paper has been arranged as
follows:
In section 2, we present the literature for the data and the light curves;
in section 3, we discuss them and give a brief conclusion.
\section{Near-infrared Light Curves}
\subsection{Data}
Infrared observations are available since the 1960s. Here we compiled
the data from 22 publications listed in table 1, which gives the
observers in Col. 1. and the telescope(s) used in Col.2.
\begin{table}
\caption[]{Literature and telescopes for the data}
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|}
\hline\noalign{\smallskip}
Observer(s) & Telescope(s)\\
\hline\noalign{\smallskip}
Brown et al (1989b) & UKIRT 3.8m \\ \hline
Garcia-Lario et a l(1989) & TCS 1.5m \\ \hline
Gear et al (1985,1986a) & UKIRT 3.8m \\ \hline
Glassgold et al(1983) & UKIRT 3.8m \\
& Palomer Mt. 5m \\ \hline
Holmes et al (1984) & UKIRT 3.8m \\ \hline
Impey et al (1984) & UKIRT 3.8m \\ \hline
Kidger \& Casares (1989) & TCS 1.5m \\ \hline
Kidger et al(1992) & TCS 1.5m \\ \hline
Landau et al (1986) & UKIRT 3.8m; Hale 5m \&\\
& Mount Lemnon 1.5m \\ \hline
Lepine et al(1985) & ESO 3.6m \\ \hline
Litchfield et al (1994) & ESO 2.2m \\ \hline
Maraschi et al(1994) & Sutherland 1.9m \\ \hline
Mead et al (1990) & UKIRT 3.8m\\ \hline
Neugebauer et al(1979) & Hale 5.0m \\ \hline
O'Dell et al (1978) & UM/UCSD 1.5m \\ \hline
Rieke et al (1977) & UOA 90inch \& 61 inch \\ \hline
Roelling et al (1986) & UKIRT 3.8m \\ \hline
Sitko et al (1982) & UM/UCSD 1.5m \\ \hline
Sitko \& Sitko (1991) & KPNO 1.3m \& 1.5m \\ \hline
Smith et al (1987) & KPNO 2.1m \\ \hline
Takalo et al(1992) & TCS 1.5m\\ \hline
\end{tabular}
\end{table}
\subsection{Light Curves}
The flux density in the literature has been convected back to
magnitude using the original conversion. No dereddening correction
was done for the two high Galactic latitude ( $b^{II} = 57^{\circ}.1$ for
3C279, $b^{II} = 80^{\circ}$ for 4C29.45) objects. The measurements were
not always made in three bands, generally, there are more measurements in H
and K than in J.
The light curves are shown in Fig. 1a-c, and Fig. 2a-c for 3C279
and 4C29.45, respectively. In the literature, some
measurements from 3C279 have relatively large uncertainties( one point
from Neugebauer
et al. (1979), one from Lepine et al. (1985), and one from Impey et al.
(1984) for instance). Fig 1(a)-(c) show that there is good overall
agreement in the flux variation. The largest amplitude variations are
$\Delta J$ = 4.57, $\Delta H$ = 4.26, and $\Delta K$ = 4.45 for 3C279
and $\Delta J$ = 3.47, $\Delta H$ = 3.82, and $\Delta K$ = 3.97 for
4C29.45. Now, we will analyse the correlations between
color index and color index and magnitude as well.
\subsection{Correlation}
Because of the uncertainties in the considered data, straight-line
fitting with the uncertainties in both coordinates considered is
used to deal with the data.
$$y(x) = a + bx$$
In principle, $a$ and $b$ can be determined by
minimizing the $\chi^{2}$ merit function, i.e. equation (15.3.2)
in the book by Press et al. (1992)
$$\chi^{2}(a,b)= {\sum\limits_{i=1}^{n} {(y_{i}-a-bx_{i})^{2}w_{i} }} $$
where $\sigma_{y_{i}}$ and $\sigma_{x_{i}}$ are the $x$ and $y$
uncertainties for the $i$th point and
${\frac{1}{w_{i}}}=\sigma^{2}_{y_{i}}+b^{2}\sigma^{2}_{x_{i}}$.
Unfortunately, the occurrence of $b$ in the denominator of above
$\chi^{2}$ merit function resulting in equation for
${\frac{\partial \chi^{2}}{\partial b}}=0$ nonlinear makes the task
of fitting very complex although we can get a formula for $a$ from
${\frac{\partial \chi^{2}}{\partial a}}=0$,
$$a={\frac{\sum\limits_{i}w_{i}(y_{i}-bx_{i})}{\sum\limits_{i}w_{i}}}$$
By minimizing the $\chi^{2}$ merit function with respect to $b$
and using the equation for $a$ at each stage to ensure that the minimum
with respect to $b$ is also minimized with respect to $a$, we can get $a$ and $b$,
but finding the uncertainties, $\sigma_{a}$ and $\sigma_{b}$, in $a$ and $b$
is more complicated (see Press et al. 1992). So, in the present paper, we
only estimated the regression parameters $a$ and $b$ without
considering the corresponding uncertainties in $a$ and $b$.
\subsubsection{Color-color relation}
The data discussed here and in the following section are given simultaneously in the original literature
except for a few several-day-averaged points of 3C279.
From the simultaneous observations, we can get that the averaged color
indices are:
(J-H) = 0.93$\pm$0.12, (J-K) = 1.89$\pm$0.14, and (H-K) = 0.95$\pm$0.09
for 3C279;
(J-H) = 0.84$\pm$0.09, (J-K) = 1.74$\pm$0.13, and (H-K) = 0.91$\pm$0.09
for 4C29.45. When the straight-line fitting is used to the color indices,
(J-K) is found associated with both (J-H) and (H-K) while there is
almost no correlation between (J-H) and (H-K) as found in RBLs ( Fan \&
Lin
1998).
(J-K) = 1.6(J-H) + 0.41 with the correlation coefficient $r = 0.876$ and the
probability of the relation happening by chance $p $ is almost 0,
(J-K) = 2.14(H-K) - 0.17 with $r = 0.72$ and $p$ is almost 0
for 3C279;
(J-K) = 1.52(H-K) + 0.45 with $r = 0.62$ and $p = 4.2 \times 10^{-4}$,
(J-K) = 1.4(H-K) + 0.48 with $r = 0.705$ and $p = 3. \times 10^{-5}$
for 4C29.45.
They are shown in Fig. 1d-f and Fig. 2d-f.
\subsubsection{Color-magnitude relation}
In AGNs, it is found common for the continuous spectrum to change
with the brightness of the source, generally, the spectrum flattens
when the source brightens but an opposite behaviour is found in
some RBLs (see Fan \& Lin 1998, and references therein). But for the
spectral index versus flux density correlation, there is a
statistic bias (e.g. Massaro \& Trevese 1996). To avoid this bias,
we discuss the relation between the magnitude in one band and the
color index obtained in other two bands. Used the straight-line-fittin,
following relations are found for 3C279:
(H-K) = 0.04J + 0.44 with $r = 0.53$ and $p = 5.0 \times 10^{-7}$,
(J-K) = 0.08H + 0.92 with $r = 0.72$ and $p$ is near 0.0,
(J-H) = 0.06K + 0.26 with $r = 0.72$ and $p = 2.0 \times 10^{-10}$.
No similar result is found for 4C29.45 (see Fig. 1g-i, Fig. 2g-i).
\section{Discussion}
Blazars are variable at all wavelengths, variation in optical band
show some periodicities for those objects with some hundred years optical
observations (see Fan et al. 1998b ).
Infrared observations have been done more than 20 years, but no
long-term variation is available for AGNs except for the works of Neugebeuer
et al. (1979) and Litchfield et al. (1994), in which they presented infrared observations of about 8-year for some selected objects. Recently, we found that
variations in the optical and infrared
closely associated for PKS 0735+178 (Lin \& Fan 1998)
and OJ287 (Fan et al. 1998c) indicating these two bands coming
from the same mechanism. But, it is reasonable that other nonvariable or
slowly varying near-IR component, such as the stars in the parent galaxy,
is present in the spectrum of AGNs. In this sense, when the source is
bright, the spectrum is observed to steepen when the source dims, as
expected from a synchrotron component which experiencing radiative energy
losses, but when the source dims further, because of the presence of
the underlying near-IR emission, the spectrum will flattens with the
source getting faint. Because the underlying near-IR emission affects J
more
serious than other two bands, we would expect that there is a clear
tendency of spectral flattening with J when J is fainter than a certain
magnitude.
3C279 is a well known member of OVVs, a large optical variation
of $\Delta B\geq6.70$ mag (Eachus \& Liller 1975) and a highly
optical polarization of $P_{opt}=43.3\pm1.3\%$ ( see Scarpa \&
Falomo 1997) are reported. It shows a violently optical brightness increase
of 2.0 mag during an interval of 24 hours (Webb et al. 1990). The largest
amplitude optical variation is greater than the largest amplitude infrared
one. The straight-line fitting gives a very significant linear
correlation between (H-K) and J, but Fig.1g indicates that (H-K)
decreases with J when J is fainter
than 14 mag indicating the spectrum flattens when the source dims, but his
tendency does not show up obviously in Fig. 1h or Fig. 1i. The difference
between the fitting and the plot is from the faint J points with large
error bars, which play a less important role on the fitting. If we
remove the two points with large error bar at the bottom right corner,
the tendency is not very clear. Nevertheless, it is worth of noticing
and being discussed with more data. If this tendency is real, it is
perhaps from the affection of the underlying galaxy as discussed above,
and the near-IR spectrum of 3C279 consists of, at least, two components.
The underlying galaxy affects J more serious than H or K, so the tendency
appeared in Fig. 1g does not show up clearly in Fig. 1h or 1i.
4C29.45 also shows large amplitude variation ($\Delta m=5.0$,
Branly et al. 1996), high and variable polarizations
($P_{IR}=28.06\% $, $P_{opt}$=28\%, Holmes et al. 1984; Mead et al.
1990). The largest amplitude variations
in the infrared are smaller than, but comparable with, that in the
optical band. The infrared light curves show two
one-year-separating-double-peaked outbursts
with an interval of 3.2 years. During the simultaneous infrared observations,
4C29.45 showed no significant spectral changing when the source was relative
bright ($\alpha = -0.98\pm0.18$
when the source dimmed by $\sim$ 0.9 mag from K = 9.87 faints to
10.76) during April 5-8, 1981. But the spectral index obtained
at the end of April ($\alpha = -1.39\pm0.08$) showed spectral
steepening when the source was about 2.5 magnitude fainter
than it was on April 5 ( Glassgold et al. 1983). There are no continuous
observations between them. From the compiled
long-term data, this association is complex and some data (Smith et al. 1987)
have relatively large uncertainties, $\sigma = 0^{m}.1$, (see Fig. 2g-i).
From the data, we found that the largest variation in J is
smaller than
that in K. The reason is that there are fewer points in J than H and K
in the literature. Besides, a weak correlation of (J-K) increasing with H ($p \sim 0.5 \%$) can be
obtained. For this object, the data are sparse, its variability
properties should be discussed with more observations.
For the color indices, there are correlations between (J-K) and (H-K) and
(J-H) as well, but there is almost no correlation between (J-H) and
(H-K). We think the reasons are perhaps due to the facts that (1)
(J-K) has wider distribution than (J-H) and (H-K) so that (J-H) and (H-K)
concentrate in a narrow region diluting the correlation, and (2)
the spectrum deviates from the power law (Fan et al. 1998d).
We have compiled the infrared light curves for 3C279 and 4C29.45, largest
amplitude variation, color-color relation and color-magnitude relation
are investigated. The largest variation in the infrared is smaller than
that in the optical band, (J-K) is strongly associated with (J-H) for the
two objects while color-magnitude relation is only found for 3C279,
the (H-K)-J plot suggests that the spectrum of 3C279 consists of, at
least, two components. No similar results are found for 4C29.45.
\begin{acknowledgements}{I am grateful to the anonymous referee for his/her
suggestions, I thank Dr. R.G. Lin (CfA, Guangzhou Normal University, China)
for his help with the data and Dr. Y. Copin (CRAL, Observatoire de Lyon,
France) for his help with the figures. This work is supported by the
National Natural Scientific Foundation of China and the National
Pandeng Project of China.}
\end{acknowledgements}
\cite{}
\begin{thebibliography}{}
\bibitem[]{} Branly R., Kilgard R., Sadun A., Shcherbanovsky A., Webb J. 1996, ASP Conf. Ser. Vol. 110, P170
\bibitem[]{} Brown L.M.J., Robson E.I., Gear W.K., Smith M.G.: 1989, ApJ 340, 150
\bibitem[]{} Eachus L.A., Liller W., 1975, ApJ 200, L61
\bibitem[]{} Fan J.H. 1998, BL Lac phenomena, June 22-26, Turku, Finland
\bibitem[]{} Fan J.H., Lin R.G. 1998, ApJS (accepted)
\bibitem[]{} Fan J.H., Adam G., Xie G.Z. et al. 1998a, A\&A, 338, 27
\bibitem[]{} Fan J.H., Xie G.Z., Pecontal M. et al. 1998b, ApJ 507, 173
\bibitem[]{} Fan J.H., Adam G., Xie G.Z. et al., 1998c, A\&AS 133, 163
\bibitem[]{} Fan J.H., Xie G.Z., Lin R.G., Qin, Y.P., 1998d, A\&AS 133,
217
\bibitem[]{} Fan J.H. Xie G.Z., Liu, J. et al. 1993, ApJ, 415, 113
\bibitem[]{} Fugmann W., 1989, A\&A 205, 86
\bibitem[]{} Garcia-Lario P., Kidger M.R., de Diego J. et al. 1989 IAU Cir 4789
\bibitem[]{} Gear W.K., Brown L.M.J., Robson E.I.,et al. 1986, ApJ 304, 295
\bibitem[]{} Gear W.K., Robson E.I., Brown L.M.J. et al. 1985, ApJ 291, 511
\bibitem[]{} Glassgold A.E., Bergman J.N., Huggins P.J. et al. 1983, ApJ 274, 101
\bibitem[]{} Holmes P.A., Brand P.W.J.L., Wolstencroft R.D., Williams P.M., 1984, MNRAS 210, 961
\bibitem[]{} Impey C.D., Lawrence C.R.,Tapia S., 1991, ApJ 375, 461.
\bibitem[]{} Impey C.D., Neugebauer G., 1988 , AJ 95, 307
\bibitem[]{} Impey C.D., Brand P.W.J.L., Wolstencroft R.D., Williams P.M., 1984 MNRAS 209, 245
\bibitem[]{} Kidger M.R., Garcia-Lario P., de Diego J.A., 1992, A\&AS 93, 391
\bibitem[]{} Kidger M.R., Casares J., 1989 IAU Cir. 4739
\bibitem[]{} Kollgaard R.J., 1994, Vista Astron. 38, 29
\bibitem[]{} Landau R., Golish B., Jones T.J., et al. 1986, ApJ 308, 78
\bibitem[]{} Lepine J.R.D., Braz M.A., Epchtein N., 1985, A\&A 149, 351
\bibitem[]{} Lin R.G., Fan J.H., 1998, ApSS (in press)
\bibitem[]{} Litchfield S.L., Robson E.I., Stevens J.A., 1994, MNRAS 270, 341
\bibitem[]{} Maraschi L., Grandi P., Urry C.M., et al. 1994, ApJ 435, L91
\bibitem[]{} Massaro E., Treves D. 1996, A\&A 312, 810
\bibitem[]{} Mead A.R.G., Ballard K.R., Brand P.W.J.L.,et al. 1990, A\&AS 83, 183
\bibitem[]{} Neugebauer G., Oke J.B., Becklin E.E., Matthews K., 1979 ApJ 230, 79
\bibitem[]{} O'Dell S.L., Pushell J.J., Stein W.A., Warner J.W., 1978, ApJS 38, 267
\bibitem[]{} Press W.H., Teukoisky S.A., Vetterling W.T., Flannery B.P. 1992, in Numerical Recipes in C, The Art of Scientific
Computing (2nd Edition), Cambridge Uni. Press.
\bibitem[]{} Rieke G.H., Lebofsky M.L., Kemp J.C., et al., 1977, ApJ 218, L37
\bibitem[]{} Roelling T.L., Beckin, E.E., Impey C.D., Werner M.W., 1986, ApJ 304, 646
\bibitem[]{} Scarpa R., Falomo R., 1997, A\&A 325, 109
\bibitem[]{} Sitko M.L., Sitko A.K. 1991, PASP 103, 160
\bibitem[]{} Sitko M.L., Stein W.A., Zhang Y.X., Wisniewski W.Z., 1982 ApJ 259, 486
\bibitem[]{} Smith P.S., Balonek T., Elston R., Heckert P.A; 1987, ApJS 64, 459
\bibitem[]{} Takalo L.O., Kidger M.R., de Diego J. et al. 1992, AJ 104, 40
\bibitem[]{} Urry C.M., Padovani P., 1995, PASP 107, 803
\bibitem[]{} Valtaoja E., Terasranta H., Uppo S., et al. 1992, A\&A 254, 80
\bibitem[]{} von Montigny C., Bertsch D.L., Chiang J., et al. 1995, ApJ 440, 525
\bibitem[]{} Webb J.R., Carini M.T., Clements S., et al. 1990, AJ 100, 1452
\bibitem[]{} Wills B.J., Wills D., Breger M., et al. 1992, ApJ 398, 454
\bibitem[]{} Wills B.J., Polloock J.T., Aller H.D., et al. 1983, ApJ 274, 62
\bibitem[]{} Xie G.Z., Zhang Y.H., Fan J.H. 1997, ApJ, 477, 177
\end{thebibliography}
\end{document}