Interaction of vacancies with grain boundary in aluminum: a first-principles study
Extracted source text ยท arXiv cond-mat/0101397
%\documentstyle[prl,aps,preprint,epsf]{revtex}
\documentclass[aps,preprint,epsf,prl]{revtex4}
\begin{document}
\title{Interaction of vacancies with grain boundary in aluminum:
a first-principles study}
\author{Gang Lu and Nicholas Kioussis}
\address{Department of Physics, California State University Northridge,
Northridge, CA 91330-8268}
\begin{abstract}
We present a theoretical study of the interaction of vacancies with a tilt
grain boundary in aluminum based on the density functional theory.
The grain boundary volume expansion and vacancy induced contraction are
calculated and compared for the nearest-neighbor atoms, and the former is found
to be smaller than the latter. The formation energy of a vacancy placed at
various layers in the grain boundary has been calculated and we find that
the grain
boundary does not always act as sinks for vacancies. In fact, it costs more
energy to form a vacancy at the boundary plane than in bulk, although the rest
of the grain boundary region does attract vacancies. The microscopic mechanisms
of grain boundary sliding and migration are investigated thoroughly with and
without a vacancy. We find that although the vacancy can hinder the grain
boundary motion by tripling the energy barrier of sliding and migration, it can
not inhibit or even delay the migration process. The vacancy placed at the first
layer from the interface is found to be trapped at the layer and
not able to follow
the migrating interface.
\end{abstract}
\maketitle
\begin{center}
I. INTRODUCTION
\end{center}
Vacancies are the simplest lattice defects and play an important role for
various properties of materials, such as kinetic, thermodynamic, electrical,
optical and even mechanical properties, to name a few. Similarly, grain
boundaries as planar defects, are also responsible for the various material
properties.\cite{wolf,sutton} While there have been extensive theoretical
studies aimed at either vacancies or grain boundaries individually, much less
effort has been devoted to the understanding of the collective behavior of grain
boundaries and vacancies, especially from parameter-free {\it ab initio}
studies. For example, {\it ab initio} calculations have been used with great
success to study the vacancy formation energy and the vacancy-induced relaxation
in different metals,\cite{turner,meyer} the vacancy diffusion energy barrier
and the annihilation process in semiconductors,\cite{watanabe,pankratov,fazzio}
etc. However, all these calculations are confined to either bulk systems or
surfaces. On the other hand, grain boundaries (pure or with impurities) have
attracted a great deal of attention recently. For example, {\it ab initio}
calculations have been performed for the grain boundary energies and the atomic
structures of the pure $\Sigma$11 tilt and $\Sigma$3 twin grain boundaries in
aluminum\cite{wright}, and the effect of impurity on the grain boundary
cohesion in Ni$_3$Al.\cite{lu} However, these studies do not involve vacancies
in the grain boundaries and examine only the properties of the grain boundaries
themselves. Therefore, one of the goals in this paper is to investigate the
combined effect of grain boundaries and vacancies in aluminum using {\it ab
initio} calculations and to explore the
possible interactions between the point and planar defects.
While the equilibrium structures of grain boundaries have been extensively
studied, only very limited research has focused on the atomistic simulation of
grain boundary sliding and migration.\cite{mishin,hoagland,chandra,bishop}
The former process involves the
relative displacement of the two constituent grains in a direction parallel to
the boundary interface, while the latter involves the motion of the interface
in a direction perpendicular to the boundary plane. Grain boundary
sliding/migration is considered to be one of the principal mechanisms of plastic
deformation of polycrystalline materials at intermediate-to-high temperatures
(above 0.6T$_m$, where T$_m$ is the melting point) and it contributes to creep
deformation and intergranular fracture, which can in turn be significantly
affected by the presence of vacancies.\cite{sutton,nabarro} These two modes of
grain boundary motion can be correlated from a simple geometrical analysis.
\cite{ashby} Very recently, Molteni {\it et al.} carried out {\it ab initio}
studies of the atomic structure and the energy barriers for grain boundary
sliding in germanium and aluminum.\cite{molteni1,molteni2}
Employing molecular dynamics simulations in conjunction with the Embedded Atom
Method, Chandra and Dang have shown that the coupling between sliding and
migration depends strongly on the external conditions that initiate the grain
boundary sliding.\cite{chandra}
In this paper we have studied the interactions of vacancies with the tilt
$\Sigma$5 (210)[001] grain boundary in aluminum using state-of-the-art {\it
ab initio} total-energy calculations based on the pseudopotential plane wave
method.
First, we have calculated the vacancy formation energies and atomic structures
for a vacancy placed at various positions in the grain boundary region. These
results
reveal that the grain boundary may act as sink or source of vacancies
depending on the location of the vacancy. Second, in order to understand the
effect of vacancies on the grain boundary mobility, we have investigated the
effect of vacancies on the grain boundary sliding and migration behavior.
Aluminum is selected in this study because it is a prototypical simple metal of
importance in industrial applications and some of the conclusions we draw from
the present study may be extended to other fcc metals as well.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: Sec. II describes briefly
the computational techniques and the supercell used for the grain boundary
calculations. In Sec. III we present the results for the atomic structures and
energetics of the pure grain boundary. Sec. IV contains the results with
vacancies introduced at various atomic sites of the grain boundary. The vacancy
formation energy at different sites is calculated and compared to that of
the bulk system. The atomic relaxation due to the grain boundary expansion and
the vacancy-induced contraction will be examined and compared.
In Sec. V we present the energy profile and the atomic structures for the grain
boundary sliding and migration process with and without a vacancy. We find that
the vacancy can significantly increase the grain boundary sliding and migration
energy barrier, and therefore hinder the grain boundary motion. In order to shed
light into the microscopic physics of the combined grain boundary
sliding/migration motion, we have examined in detail some critical atomic
configurations during the sliding/migration process. In Sec. VI a brief summary
and statement of conclusions are presented.
\begin{center}
II. MODEL AND COMPUTATION
\end{center}
The electronic structure of the grain boundary is calculated by means of the
pseudopotential plane wave method based on the density functional theory and the
local density approximation. We employed the exchange and correlation potential
of Ceperly and Alder as parametrized by Perdew and Zunger\cite{perdew} and the
norm-conserving nonlocal pseudopotential of Bachelet, Hamann and Schl\"{u}ter.
\cite{BHS} The Kohn-Sham wave functions are expanded in plane waves with a
kinetic energy cutoff of 14 Ry. The atomic structures are considered fully
relaxed when the Hellmann-Feynman forces on each atom are smaller than 0.001
Ry/au. For the Brillouin-zone sampling, a $k$-point grid consisting of (2,7,1)
divisions along the reciprocal-lattice directions is used according to the
Monkhorst-Pack scheme.\cite{monk} Convergence tests have been performed both for
the number of $k$-points as well as the number of plane waves. The calculated
equilibrium lattice constant ($a_0$), bulk modulus and cohesive energy are 3.93
\AA, 80.59 GPa and 3.26 eV/atom, respectively,
in good agreement with the corresponding
experimental room-temperature values of 4.05 \AA, 76.93 GPa and 3.39 eV/atom.
In this work we consider the symmetric $\Sigma$5 (210) [001] tilt grain boundary
in the coincident-site-lattice (CSL) notation. In the CSL notation, the grain
boundary is formed through rotation of the two fcc grains
about the [001] tilt axis by
36.9$^\circ$. The boundary is oriented along the (210) plane and the inverse
density of CSL sites, $\Sigma$ = 5, characterizes the unit cell volume of the
CSL superlattice. The $\Sigma$5 [001](210) grain boundary of Al is simulated by
the orthorhombic supercell shown in Fig. 1. The supercell contains 60 atoms
distributed in 30 (210) layers parallel to the interface. The large and small
circles represent the atoms on the (001) and (002) planes, respectively. The
dimensions of the supercell along the [\={1}20], [001] and [210] directions are
8.78 \AA $\times$ 3.93 \AA $\times$ 26.35 \AA, respectively.
Because of the periodic boundary conditions, the supercell contains two
equivalent grain boundaries. However, as will be shown in Sec. III, the
separation between the two grain boundaries is large enough to eliminate the
interaction between them. For the modeling of vacancies in the grain
boundary, a single vacancy is placed at all possible independent lattice sites
labeled by an integer {\it n} = 0-7, which represents the {\it n}th
nearest-neighbor layer from the grain boundary plane (the number of independent lattice
sites is reduced due to the symmetry between the (001) and (002) planes and that
between the two grain boundaries). In addition to the grain boundary
calculation, we have also computed the vacancy formation energy for the Al bulk
by employing a simple cubic supercell with 108 atomic sites to model an isolated
vacancy.
\begin{center}
III. PURE GRAIN BOUNDARY
\end{center}
A pure grain boundary in the following is referred to as the grain boundary
without vacancies. The atomic structure of the pure grain boundary before and
after relaxation is shown in Fig. 2. The open and filled circles represent the
atomic positions before and after the relaxation and the large and small circles
correspond to the atoms on the (001) and (002) planes, respectively.
The grain boundary volume expansion is clearly seen near the interface and one
local measure for such an
expansion is the relative normal displacement of the
two atomic planes closest to the interface. The present calculation yields a
local expansion of 0.09 $a_0$, where $a_0$ is the bulk Al
lattice constant. This local expansion of the Al atoms in the pure Al $\Sigma$5
grain boundary is smaller compared to the corresponding expansion of
the Al atoms in the Ni$_3$Al alloy for the same grain boundary.\cite{lu}
This is consistent with the fact that there is charge transfer from the Al atoms
to the nearest-neighbor Ni atoms in Ni$_3$Al, which in turn reduces the
screening charge between the nearest Al-Al ions across the interface, leading to
a stronger electrostatic repulsion between the Al ions in Ni$_3$Al grain
boundary. In Fig. 3 we present the relative variation (strain) of the interlayer
spacing as a function of the layer away from the grain boundary plane.
The strain has a symmetric oscillatory profile that reaches its maximum at the
first layer and decays into the bulk. The nature of this strain profile can be
traced to the Friedel oscillations of the electron distribution which drive the
ions to relax in such an oscillatory pattern.\cite{cho} The negligible strain
for the layers from 6 to 10 clearly indicates that the atomic relaxation is
localized only within 5 layers from the interface. Therefore, the supercell with
15 layers between the two interfaces is large enough to capture the overall
properties of the grain boundary.
It is interesting to notice that even after the relaxation, the distance between
the nearest-neighbor atoms across the interface is 2.44 \AA, about 20\% smaller
than the corresponding distance of 2.78 \AA~ in the bulk system.
This result invalidates
the common misconception that the grain boundary is associated with open space.
On the other hand, as will be shown in Sec. IV, vacancies can be formed
relatively easier in most of the grain boundary region compared to the bulk,
giving rise to more empty space in the region. The grain boundary energy can be determined
from the difference of the energy of a
unit cell containing the grain boundary and a
unit cell containing an equal number of atoms in the bulk environment, divided
by the grain boundary area. We find a grain boundary energy of 502 mJ/m$^2$ for
the $\Sigma$5 grain boundary, which is larger than
the corresponding EAM value of
351 mJ/m$^2$.\cite{chen} This result is consistent with the finding that, overall, the EAM
potential tends to give smaller grain boundary energies compared to {\it ab
initio} calculations.\cite{wright}
\begin{center}
IV. GRAIN BOUNDARY WITH A VACANCY
\end{center}
The relaxed atomic structures of the grain boundary before and after the
introduction of a vacancy are shown in Fig 4.(a), (b), (c), corresponding to the
vacancy placed at the zero-th (interface), first and seventh layers from the
interface. The large and small circles correspond to atoms on the (001) and
(002) planes, respectively. The open (filled) circles represent the relaxed
atomic positions before (after) the introduction of the vacancy, and the arrows
show the direction of the atomic displacements. In order to gain insight into
the interplay between the grain boundary and the vacancies, we have calculated
the displacements due to the grain boundary expansion (u$_{GB}$) and that due to
the vacancy contraction (u$_{V}$). Both u$_{GB}$ and u$_{V}$ are computed for
the nearest-neighbor atoms (first shell) from the defects. For the case
of the vacancy at the interface (Fig. 4(a)), although the atomic
relaxation is small and localized,
the vacancy-induced contraction (u$_{V}$ = -0.12 \AA) is much larger than
the grain boundary expansion (u$_{GB}$ = +0.01 \AA). When the vacancy is placed
at the first layer, the atomic relaxation is more dramatic (Fig. 4(b)).
There are seven atomic layers involved in the relaxation triggered by the
vacancy and the first shell displacements are u$_{V}$ = -0.53 \AA ~
while u$_{GB}$=
+0.34 \AA, respectively. In Fig. 4(c) we show the atomic structure with the
vacancy placed at the seventh layer (bulk like). We find u$_{V}$ = -0.06 \AA,
which is about 2\% of the nearest-neighbor distance of the bulk lattice and is
along the [110] direction. These results are in excellent agreement with the
calculations by Turner {\it et al.} \cite{turner} for a vacancy in Al bulk both
for the magnitude and the direction of u$_{V}$. In other words, the atomic
structure for a vacancy at the seventh layer from the interface completely
reproduces the characteristics of a vacancy in the bulk. Along with the fact
that the grain boundary expansion u$_{GB}$ at the seventh layer is zero as
discussed earlier, we conclude that the selected supercell for the grain
boundary calculations is large enough to yield reliable results. It is also
interesting to note that as far as the nearest-neighbor shell is concerned, the
vacancy-induced atomic relaxation is more pronounced than that due to the grain
boundary.
In order to clarify whether grain boundaries act as sinks or
sources for vacancies,
we have calculated the vacancy formation energy
for various layers from the grain
boundary interface. The results are presented in Fig. 5, where the straight line
denotes
the vacancy formation energy in bulk. The striking feature of the energy curve
is the large reduction
of the vacancy formation energy at the first layer, which strongly suggests the
preference of forming a vacancy at the first layer compared
to bulk. Although the
figure also shows that some other more distant layers in the grain boundary are
also energetically favorable for the vacancy formation, one can clearly see that
the interface itself is {\it not} favorable for forming a vacancy. In fact,
there is more than 0.1 eV energy penalty for creating a vacancy at the interface
compared to bulk.
Note that the vacancy formation energy at the fifth layer from the interface
is close to the bulk value,
showing the convergence of the energy with respect to the supercell size.
In conclusion, the {\it ab initio} calculations support the traditional view
that grain boundaries act as pathways for vacancy diffusion and that vacancies
prefer to segregate to grain boundaries over bulk at low stress. However, we
should also point out that one out of five lattice sites in the grain boundary
region turns out to be energetically unfavorable for vacancies, namely those
sites on the grain boundary plane.
\begin{center}
V. GRAIN BOUNDARY SLIDING AND MIGRATION: EFFECT OF VACANCIES
\end{center}
In this section we present results for the grain boundary sliding and migration,
and the effect of vacancies on the grain boundary motion.
In our {\it ab initio} modeling, the grain boundary sliding is simulated
quasi-statically, namely the top grain is rigidly shifted over the bottom by a series
of small specified distances along the interface. The sliding distance
is described in
percentage of $a_{csl}$, where $a_{csl}$ is the lattice parameter of the CSL
cell along [\={1}20]. Clearly sliding by $a_{csl}$ will bring the
grain boundary back to its original configuration due to the imposed
periodic boundary
conditions. For each rigid shift, atomic relaxation is performed to locate the
closest local energy minimum configuration. In order to understand the effect of
vacancies on the grain boundary sliding and migration process, we have
calculated the grain boundary energy profile as a function of sliding distance
for the pure grain boundary and the grain boundary with a vacancy placed at the
first layer from the interface, corresponding to the lowest vacancy
formation energy at the grain boundary.
The grain boundary energy profile during the sliding process is shown in Fig. 6,
where the filled circles represent the pure grain boundary and the open circles
represent the grain boundary with the vacancy, respectively. The labels (a)-(f)
on both curves indicate the special atomic configurations which will be
explored in detail below. For the pure grain boundary, there are two energy
peaks at 30\% and 80\% $a_{csl}$, the first much broader than the latter;
and one energy
valley at 55\% $a_{csl}$.
It is important to note that the vacancy triples the energy
barrier for sliding and migration, which demonstrates the great hindering effect
of the vacancy on the interface mobility. However, the detailed analysis of the
atomic structures below shows that the vacancy can not prevent or even delay the
occurrence of the grain boundary migration.
The collective motion of atoms during the grain boundary sliding and migration is
essential to understand this seemingly trivial, but in fact complicated process.
To shed light on the related physical process, we next examine the atomic
configurations associated with the special points (a)-(f) in the energy
curves of the pure grain boundary
in Fig. 6. The relaxed atomic structures corresponding to
(a)-(f) are shown clockwise in
Fig. 7, with the filled and open circles representing the atoms on the (001) and
(002) planes, respectively. Note that more atoms are displayed in these figures
than the actual atoms used in the supercell,
which is depicted by the solid frame. In
order to monitor when does grain boundary migration take place, one needs to
locate the position of the interface during the sliding process. However,
since the grain boundary is not symmetric any more during the sliding process,
it is not always obvious to find the new position of the migrating interface.
To overcome this difficulty, we propose a simple scheme which allows us to
identify the moving interface by following the
evolution of the structural unit shown in the
figures. The characteristics of this unit is that it consists of two
sub-units that cross the interface with a common vertex on the interface.
These sub-units are the two-dimensional unit cells of the distorted fcc lattice.
By locating such a unit and the common vertex during the sliding process, one
can identify the position of the grain boundary plane. Applying this scheme, we
find that the migration of the pure grain boundary starts at 35\% $a_{csl}$ and
ends at 55\% $a_{csl}$. After the completion of the first migration, the
grain boundary has to return to its original position at 100\% $a_{csl}$ to
complete the second migration.
For the grain boundary with the vacancy, the migration starts at the exact
same sliding distance, 35\% $a_{csl}$, but ends at about 62\% $a_{csl}$. The
second migration due to the periodic boundary conditions is also observed as in
the pure grain boundary.
Fig. 7(a) shows the initial atomic structure for the pure grain boundary before
sliding. The interface is indicated by a solid line.
The angle $\alpha$ ($\angle$ABC) of the structural unit is slightly distorted
from its value of 90$^\circ$ in the perfect fcc lattice. By examining the various atomic
configurations before the first migration (35\% a$_{csl}$), we find that they
are all similar, being different mostly along the sliding direction. More
specifically, the angle $\alpha$ of all configurations turns
out to be obtuse and
one example of such a configuration is shown in Fig. 7(b). When the interface
starts migrating, however, the grain boundary experiences an abrupt overall
structural transformation, as illustrated in Fig. 7(c). The interface has
clearly moved from its original position (dotted line) to the current solid line
position, and the angle $\alpha$ has changed from obtuse to acute. This
one-layer migration reflects the geometrical necessity for the coupling between
migration and sliding.\cite{bishop,ashby} After the onset of the migration, the
atomic structures remains akin to each other during the sliding until the
migration is fully completed, in which, as shown in Fig. 7(d), the grain
boundary recovers its original symmetric structure. Note, that the angle
$\alpha$ now changes from an acute angle to a right angle. The dotted and solid
lines are the same as in Fig. 7(c). Because of the periodic boundary conditions,
the grain boundary has to return to its original position during the remaining
sliding process. The critical configuration it has to cross is shown in
Fig. 7(e), where the grain boundary experiences the highest energy. The
intriguing feature of this configuration is that no boundary plane can be
identified, while there is a ``mirror'' plane (dashed line) across which the
atoms on the (001) plane are symmetrically situated to those on the (002) plane.
This half-way plane reflects the transient position of the migrating interface
and therefore the energy associated with this configuration gives the energy
barrier for the grain boundary migration. Finally, Fig. 7(f) represents the
completion of the sliding process where the grain boundary returns to its
initial symmetric configuration. The dotted line indicates the position of the
interface after the first migration and the solid line shows the current
position (also the initial position before the sliding) of the interface.
For the case of the vacancy placed at the first layer from the
grain boundary, the sliding energy
profile becomes more irregular, with multiple peaks and valleys (Fig. 6). The
abundance of the fine grain boundary structures reflects the complexity of the
system, so that we shall concentrate only on the most important events. Fig.
8(a) shows the atomic structure before sliding and the vacancy is denoted by the
letter V. The solid line indicates the current position of the interface. It is
found that this initial state no longer corresponds
to the lowest energy, which is
reached after a sliding displacement of 2\% a$_{csl}$. There is an energy
cross-over at 10\% a$_{csl}$, above which the grain boundary energy with the
vacancy becomes larger than the corresponding value of the pure grain boundary,
until the next cross-over occurs at about 75\% a$_{csl}$. Although the energy
value does not return to zero as in the case of the pure grain boundary when the
migration is completed, careful examination of the atomic structures in Fig. 8
indicates the occurrence of the grain boundary migration.
Just like the pure grain
boundary, the atomic structures remain similar to each other during the sliding
process until the first migration takes place at about 35\%. One such
configuration is shown in Fig. 8(b), where the angle $\alpha$ is obtuse. The
highest energy configuration is reached when the interface migrates one atomic
layer upward, shown in Fig. 8(c), in which the dotted and solid lines represent
the original and current positions of the interface, respectively. As in
the case of the pure grain boundary, the
atomic structures at the onset of the migration differ significantly from those
before the migration and the atoms near the interface become severely distorted
from their positions in the underlying fcc lattice. The grain boundary completes
its first migration at about 62\% a$_{csl}$, where the symmetric structure is
recovered (Fig. 8(d)). It is important to notice, however, that this symmetric
structure with the vacancy (labeled by V) at {\it the interface}
is different from the
initial state where the vacancy was at
{\it the first layer} above the interface.
Therefore, the energy difference between the initial state (a) and the current
state (d) reflects simply the difference in the vacancy formation energy
between the vacancy placed at the
interface and the first layer, respectively.
This indicates that the vacancy is trapped in the
first layer and not able to follow
the migrating interface. The grain
boundary develops another peculiar configuration at 92\% a$_{csl}$, just before
the completion of the second migration. A symmetric pattern forms relative
to the previous interface (dashed line) and the free volume associated with the
vacancy disappears. The off-stoichiometry due to the vacancy, however, is
recovered at the symmetry plane (dashed line). The solid line represents the
final (also initial) position of the interface during the entire sliding
process. The atomic structure of the grain boundary at 100\% a$_{csl}$
is shown in Fig. 8(f) with the letter V indicating the vacancy. The dotted
(solid) lines represent the grain boundary position after the first (second)
migration.
\begin{center}
VI. CONCLUSION
\end{center}
We have studied the interaction between vacancies and the $\Sigma$5 tilt grain
boundary in Al, using {\it ab initio} pseudopotential calculations, which
yield reliable results for both the atomic structure and energetics compared
to empirical atomistic approaches. The nearest-neighbor distance across the interface is actually
smaller than that in the bulk even after atomic relaxation. We have calculated
the grain boundary volume expansion and the vacancy-induced
contraction and found
that the latter is larger
than the former for the nearest-neighbor shell. We have also calculated the vacancy formation energy
for a vacancy placed at different layers from the interface. We find that
the grain boundary does not always act as sinks for vacancies. While most of the
grain boundary sites have lower vacancy formation energy compared to bulk, those
at the interface have higher formation energy. We have investigated the combined
grain boundary sliding and migration process with and without a vacancy. We have
introduced a simple scheme to identify the migrating interface during the
sliding process. We have found that although the vacancy can hinder the grain
boundary motion by tripling the energy barrier for sliding and migration, it can
not inhibit or delay the occurrence of migration. In fact, the grain boundary
starts the migration at 35\% a$_{csl}$ regardless if there is a vacancy
or not. We have
analyzed the
atomic configurations during the
sliding process in order to gain
better insight on this complicated process. Interestingly, the vacancy
is found to be
trapped at the first layer and not able to follow
the migrating interface.
\begin{center}
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
\end{center}
The research was supported through the US Army Research Office under Grant No.
DAAG55-97-1-0093.
\newpage
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\bibitem{wolf}
{\it Materials Interfaces - Atomic-level Structure and Properties}, edited by D.
Wolf and S. Yip (Chapman and Hall, London, 1992).
\bibitem{sutton}
{\it Interfaces in Crystalline Materials}, edited by A. P. Sutton and R. W.
Balluffi (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1995).
\bibitem{turner}
D. E. Turner, Z. Z. Zhu, C. T. Chan, and K. M. Ho, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 55}, 13842
(1997).
\bibitem{meyer}
B. Meyer and M. F\"{a}hnle, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 59}, 6072 (1999).
\bibitem{watanabe}
H. Watanabe and M. Ichikawa, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 55}, 9699 (1997).
\bibitem{pankratov}
O. Pankratov, H. Huang, T. Diaz de la Rubia, and C. Mailhiot, Phys. Rev. B {\bf
56}, 13172 (1997).
\bibitem{fazzio}
A. Fazzio, A. Janotti, A. J. R. da Silva and R. Mota, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 61},
R2401 (2000).
\bibitem{wright}
A. F. Wright and S. R. Atlas, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 50}, 15248 (1994).
\bibitem{lu}
G. Lu, N. Kioussis, R. Wu, and M. Ciftan, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 59}, 891 (1999).
\bibitem{mishin}
Y. Mishin and D. Farkas, Phil. Mag. A {\bf 78}, 29 (1998).
\bibitem{hoagland}
R. G. Hoagland and M. I. Baskes, Scripta Mater. {\bf 39}, 417 (1998).
\bibitem{chandra}
N. Chandra and P. Dang, J. Mater. Sci {\bf 34}, 655 (1999).
\bibitem{bishop}
G. H. Bishop, R. Harrison, T. Kwok, and S. Yip, J. Appl. Phys. {\bf 53}, 5596
(1982).
\bibitem{nabarro}
F. R. N. Nabarro and H. L. de Villiers, {\it The Physics of Creep}, (Taylor \&
Francis, London, 1995).
\bibitem{ashby}
M. F. Ashby, Surf. Sci. {\bf 31}, 498 (1972).
\bibitem{molteni1}
C. Molteni, G. P. Francis, M. C. Payne, and V. Heine, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 76},
1284 (1996).
\bibitem{molteni2}
C. Molteni, N. Marzari, M. C. Payne, and V. Heine, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 79},
869
(1997).
\bibitem{perdew}
J. Perdew and A. Zunger, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 23}, 5048 (1984).
\bibitem{BHS}
G. B. Bachelet, D. R. Hamann, and M. Schl\"{u}ter, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 26}, 4199
(1982).
\bibitem{monk}
H. J. Monkhorst and J. D. Pack, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 13}, 5188 (1976).
\bibitem{cho}
J.-H. Cho, Ismail, Z. Y. Zhang, and E. W. Plummer, Phys. Rev. B {\bf59}, 1677
(1999).
\bibitem{chen}
S. P. Chen, A. F. Voter, and D. J. Srolovitz, Scripta Metall. {\bf 20}, 1389
(1986).
\end{thebibliography}
\newpage
\begin{figure}
\caption{Supercell for the $\Sigma$5 (210) [001] tilt grain boundary in Al
viewed along the [001] direction. The large and small circles represent atoms on
the (001) and (002) planes, respectively. The integer (n = 0-7) represents the
nth nearest-neighbor layer from the grain boundary interface
that a vacancy is placed. The grain boundary plane is indicated by the solid line.}
\label{fig1}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\caption{Unrelaxed (open circles) and relaxed(filled circles) atomic structure
for the pure $\Sigma$5 grain boundary. Large and small circles represent atoms
on the (001) and (002) planes, respectively.}
\label{fig2}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\caption{Interlayer strain (percentage) as a function of the number of layers
away from the interface.}
\label{fig3}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\caption{Relaxed atomic structures for the grain boundary before (open circles)
and after (filled circles) the introduction of a vacancy at the interface (a),
the first layer (b) and the seventh layer (c) from the interface, respectively.
The large and small circles represent atoms on the (001) and (002) planes,
respectively. The arrow shows the direction of the atomic displacement due to
the vacancy.}
\label{fig4}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\caption{Vacancy formation energy as a function of the number of
the layer away from the interface on which a vacancy is
placed. The vacancy formation energy in bulk Al is denoted by the solid line.}
\label{fig5}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\caption{Relative grain boundary energy as a function of sliding distance
expressed as percentage of the lattice parameter, a$_{csl}$, of the CSL cell
along [\={1}20]. The filled and open circles correspond to the energies of the
pure grain boundary and the grain boundary with a vacancy at the first layer,
respectively. The labels from (a) to (f) represent the special atomic
configurations displayed in Figs. 7 and 8.}
\label{fig6}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\caption{Evolution of the atomic structure of the pure grain boundary during the
sliding process. The snap shots of the grain boundary structures correspond to
the special points (a)-(f) on the energy curve for the pure
grain boundary in Fig. 6.
Filled and open circles represent atoms on the (001) and (002)
planes, respectively, and the arrow indicates the direction of grain boundary
migration.}
\label{fig7}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\caption{Evolution of the atomic structure of the grain boundary during the
sliding process with a vacancy placed at the first layer above the interface.
The snap shots of the grain boundary structures correspond to
the special points (a)-(f) on the energy curve for the
grain boundary with the vacancy in Fig. 6.
Filled and open circles represent atoms on (001) and (002) planes, respectively,
and the arrow indicates the direction of grain boundary migration.}
\label{fig8}
\end{figure}
\end{document}