Excitations and phase segregation in a two component Bose-Einstein condensate
Extracted source text ยท arXiv cond-mat/0110596
%\documentstyle[prl,floats,aps]{revtex}
\documentstyle[preprint,aps]{revtex}
\begin{document}
\draft
%\twocolumn
\begin{title}
{Excitations and phase segregation in a two component
Bose-Einstein condensate}
\end{title}
\author{A.S. Alexandrov$^{1}$
and V.V. Kabanov $^{1,2}$}
\begin{address}
{$^{1}$ Department of Physics, Loughborough University, Loughborough LE11
3TU, United Kingdom,
$^{2}$Josef Stefan Institute 1001, Ljubljana, Slovenia}
\end{address}
\maketitle
\begin{abstract}
Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) equations and the excitation spectrum
of a two-component Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) are derived with an
arbitrary interaction between bosons, including long-range and short
range forces. The nonconverting BEC mixture segregates into two phases
for some two-body interactions. Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) equations are
solved for the phase segregated BEC. A possibility of
boundary-surface and other localised excitations is studied.
\end{abstract}
\pacs{PACS numbers: 03.75.Fi, 03.75.Be, 74.20.Mn}
\narrowtext
\noindent
Neutral and charged (Coulomb) Bose-gases became
recently of particular
interest motivated by the observations of BEC in an alkali vapor
\cite{and,dav,bra,mew,hag}, and by the bipolaron theory of
high temperature superconductors \cite{alemot}, respectively. Their
theoretical understanding is based on
the Bogoliubov \cite{bog}
displacement transformation, separating a large
matrix element of the condensate field operator, $\phi({\bf r},t)$,
from the total $\psi({\bf r},t)$ and treating the rest
$\tilde{\psi}({\bf r},t)=\psi({\bf r},t)-\phi({\bf r},t)$ as a
small fluctuation. The resulting (Gross-Pitaevskii) equation for the
condensate wave function $\phi({\bf r},t)$ provides the mean-field
description of the ground state and of the excitation
spectrum \cite{edw,bus,gol}. Beyond the mean-field approach the
Bogoliubov-de
Gennes (BdG)-type equations were derived \cite{alekabbee},
describing eigenstates of the 'supra'condensate bosons.
In this letter we extend the Bogoliubov theory to the two-component
nonconverting condensate by deriving GP and BdG
equations and excitation spectrum with an arbitrary two-body interaction,
and solving GP
equations for a phase-segregated BEC. Our motivation originates in the
recent experimental \cite{hag} and theoretical \cite{bus,gol} studies of
BEC of
$^{87}Rb$ atoms in two different hyperfine states, and also in an
observation \cite{alekab} that the condensation temperature of a
$two$-component
charged Bose gas quantitatively
describes the superconducting critical temperature of many cuprates.
Differently from Ref. \cite{bus,gol} we
consider nonconverting components (such as different elements), and an arbitrary
(rather than short-ranged) two-body interaction.
The Hamiltonian of the two-component ($1$ and $2$) mixture of bosons
in an external
field with the vector, $A({\bf r},t)$, and scalar, $U_j({\bf r},t)$,
potentials is given by
\begin{eqnarray}
H&=&\sum_{j=1,2}\int d{\bf r} \psi_j^\dagger({\bf r})\left[-{({\bf
\nabla}-
i q_j
{\bf A({\bf r},t)})^2
\over{2m_j}}+U_j({\bf r},t)
-\mu_j\right]\psi_j({\bf r})\cr
&+&
\frac 1 2 \sum_{j,j'}\int d{\bf r} \int d{\bf r'} V_{jj'}({\bf r} -
{\bf r'})\psi_j^\dagger({\bf r})
\psi_j({\bf r})\psi_{j'}^\dagger({\bf r'})\psi_{j'}({\bf r'}),
\end{eqnarray}
where $m_j$ and $q_j$ are the mass, and the effective charge (if any) of the
boson $j$ ($\hbar=1$).
If the two-body interactions $V_{jj'}({\bf r})$ are weak, the occupation
numbers of one-particle states are not very much different from those in
the ideal Bose-gas. In particular the lowest energy state
remains to be macroscopically occupied and the corresponding
component of the field operator $\psi({\bf r})$ has anomalously large
matrix element between the ground states of the system containing
$N+1$ and $N$ bosons. Hence, it is convenient to consider a grand canonical
ansamble, introducing the chemical
potentials $\mu_j$ to deal with the anomalous averages $\phi({\bf r})$
rather than with the off-diagonal matrix elements. Using the Bogoliubov
displacement transformation in the equation of
motion for the field operators
$\psi({\bf r},t)=\phi({\bf r},t)+\tilde{\psi}({\bf r},t)$
and collecting $c-number$ terms of
$\phi$, and terms linear in the $supracondensate$ boson operators
$\tilde \psi$ one obtains a set of the GP and BdG-type equations
\cite{alekabbee,bus,gol}. The macroscopic condensate wave functions
(i.e the order parameters) obey two coupled GP equations
\begin{equation}
i {\partial \over {\partial t}}\phi_{j}({\bf r},t) =
\hat{h}_{j}\phi_{j}
({\bf r},t)+
\sum_{j'}\int d{\bf r'} V_{jj'}({\bf r} - {\bf r'})|\phi_{j'}({\bf r'},t)|^2
\phi_j({\bf r},t)
\end{equation}
with the single-particle Hamiltonian $\hat{h}_j=-({\bf\nabla}-
i q_j {\bf A}({\bf r},t))^2/2m_j+U_j({\bf r},t)-\mu_j$. The
supracondensate
wave-functions satisfy four BdG equations
\begin{eqnarray}
\sum_{j'}\int d{\bf r'}V_{jj'}({\bf r}-{\bf r'})[|\phi_{j'}({\bf r'},t)|^{2}
u_{j}({\bf r},t)+\phi^{*}_{j}({\bf
r'},t)\phi_{j'}({\bf r},t)u_{j'}({\bf r'},t)+\nonumber \\
\phi_{j}({\bf r'},t)\phi_{j'}({\bf r},t)v_{j'}({\bf r'},t)]
=i {\partial \over {\partial t}}u_{j}({\bf r},t)-
\hat{h}_{j}u_{j}({\bf r},t),
\end{eqnarray}
and
\begin{eqnarray}
\sum_{j'}\int d{\bf r'}V_{jj'}({\bf r}-{\bf r'})[|\phi_{j'}({\bf r'},t)|^{2}
v_{j}({\bf r},t)+\phi_{j}({\bf
r'},t)\phi^{*}_{j'}({\bf r},t)v_{j'}({\bf r'},t)+\nonumber \\
\phi^{*}_{j}({\bf r'},t)\phi^{*}_{j'}({\bf r},t)u_{j'}({\bf r'},t)]
=-i {\partial \over {\partial t}}v_{j}({\bf r},t)-
\hat{h}^{*}_{j}v_{j}({\bf r},t).
\end{eqnarray}
Here we have applied the linear Bogoliubov transformation
for $\tilde{\psi}$
\begin{equation}
\tilde \psi_{j} ({\bf r},t)= \sum_{n}u_{nj}({\bf r},t)(\alpha_{n}+\beta_{n})
+v_{nj}^{*}({\bf r},t)(\alpha_{n}^{\dagger}+\beta_{n}^{\dagger}),
\end{equation}
where $\alpha_{n}, \beta_{n}$ are bosonic
operators annihilating quasiparticles in the quantum state $n$.
There is a sum rule,
\begin{equation}
\sum_{n}[u_{nj}({\bf r},t)u^{*}_{nj}({\bf r'},t)-v_{nj}({\bf r},t)
v^{*}_{nj}({\bf r'},t)]=\delta({\bf r}-{\bf r'}),
\end{equation}
which retains the Bose commutation relations for all operators.
In the homogeneous system with no external fields the excitation wave
functions are plane waves
\begin{equation}
u_{{\bf k},j}({\bf r},t)=u_{{\bf k},j}\exp[i{\bf k}\cdot {\bf r}-i E({\bf
k})t],
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
v_{{\bf k},j}({\bf r},t)=v_{{\bf k},j}\exp[i{\bf k}\cdot {\bf r}-iE({\bf
k})t],
\end{equation}
The condensate wave function is $({\bf r},t)$ independent in this case,
$\phi_j({\bf r},t)\equiv\phi_j$. Solving two GP equations one obtains
the chemical potentials as
\begin{eqnarray}
\mu_1=Vn_1+Wn_2 \cr
\mu_2=Un_2+Wn_1,
\end{eqnarray}
and solving four BdG equations one determines the excitation spectrum,
$E({\bf k})$ from
\begin{equation}
Det\left
[\matrix{\xi_1({\bf k})-E({\bf k}) & V_{\bf k}\phi_1^2 & W_{\bf k}\phi_1
\phi_2^{*} & W_{\bf k}\phi_1\phi_2\cr
V_{\bf k}\phi_1^{*2} & \xi_1({\bf k})+E({\bf k}) & W_{\bf k}\phi_1^{*}
\phi_2^{*} & W_{\bf k}\phi_1^{*}\phi_2\cr
W_{\bf k}\phi_1^{*}\phi_2 & W_{\bf k}\phi_1\phi_2 & \xi_2({\bf
k})-E({\bf k}) & U_{\bf k}\phi_2^2 \cr
W_{\bf k}\phi_1^{*}
\phi_2^{*} & W_{\bf k}\phi_1\phi_2^{*} & U_{\bf k}\phi_2^{*2}
&\xi_2({\bf
k})+E({\bf k})\cr}\right]=0.
\end{equation}
Here $\xi_1({\bf k})=k^2/2m_1 + V_{\bf k}n_1$,$\xi_2({\bf k})=k^2/2m_2
+ U_{\bf k}n_2$, and
$ V_{\bf k}, U_{\bf k}, W_{\bf k}$ are the Fourier components of
$V_{11}({\bf r}), V_{22}({\bf r})$ and $V_{12}({\bf r})$,
respectively, $V\equiv V_0$, $U \equiv U_0$, $W \equiv W_0$,
and $n_{j}=|\phi_j|^2$ the condensate densities. There are
two brunches of excitations with the dispersion
\begin{equation}
E_{1,2}({\bf k})=2^{-1/2}\left(\epsilon_1^2({\bf k})+\epsilon_2^2({\bf
k}) \pm \sqrt{[\epsilon_1^2({\bf k})-\epsilon_2^2({\bf
k})]^2 + {4k^4\over{m_1m_2}} W_{\bf k}^2 n_1n_2} \right)^{1/2},
\end{equation}
where $\epsilon_1({\bf k})=\sqrt{k^4/(4m_1^2)+k^2V_{\bf k}n_1/m_1}$
and $\epsilon_2({\bf k})=\sqrt{k^4/(4m_2^2)+k^2U_{\bf k}n_2/m_2}$
are Bogoliubov's modes of two components.
If the interactions are short-ranged (hard-core) repulsions, so that
$V_{\bf k}=V$, $U_{\bf k}=U$, $W_{\bf k}=W$, the spectrum, Eq.(11) is that
of Ref. \cite{gol}. In the long-wave limit both brunches are sound-like
with the sound velocities
\begin{equation}
s_{1,2}=2^{-1/2}\left(Vn_1/m_1+Un_2/m_2 \pm \sqrt{[Vn_1/m_1
-Un_2/m_2]^2 + 4W^2 n_1n_2/(m_1m_2)} \right)^{1/2}.
\end{equation}
The lowest brunch becomes unstable ($s_2 < 0$) if $W>
\sqrt{UV}$. When $W=\sqrt{UV}$ this brunch is quadratic in the
long-wave limit
\begin{equation}
E_2({\bf k})={k^2\over{2(m_1m_2)^{1/2}}}
\sqrt{{Vn_1m_1+Un_2m_2\over{Vn_1m_2+Un_2m_1}}},
\end{equation}
If $m_1=m_2=m$ it becomes 'collisionless' \cite{gol}, i.e
$E_2({\bf k})=k^2/2m$.
The finite-ranged interactions drastically change the whole
spectrum. In the extreme case of the long-range Coulomb interaction,
$V({\bf k})= 4\pi q_1^2/k^2$, $U({\bf k})=4\pi q_2^2/k^2$, and
$W({\bf k})=4 \pi q_1q_2/k^2$ the upper brunch is the geometric sum of
the familiar plasmon modes
\cite{fol} for $k \rightarrow 0$,
\begin{equation}
E_1({\bf k})=\sqrt{{4\pi q_1^2n_1\over{m_1}}+{4\pi q_2^2n_2\over{m_2}}},
\end{equation}
while the lowest brunch is
\begin{equation}
E_2({\bf k})={k^2\over{2(m_1m_2)^{1/2}}}
\sqrt{{q_1^2n_1m_1+q_2^2n_2m_2\over{q_1^2n_1m_2+q_2^2n_2m_1}}}.
\end{equation}
Remarkably, this mode is 'collisionless' at $any$ charges of the components
if $m_1=m_2$, Fig.1. Physically, it describes neutral oscillations of
condensates, when a charge fluctuation in one component is
nullified by a charge fluctuation in another component, and the total
charge density does not fluctuate. We conclude that while the
Coulomb Bose condensate is a superfluid (according to the Landau criterion),
mixture of two Coulomb Bose condensates is not. In a more general
case the interaction might include both the long-range repulsion and
the hard-core interaction as in the case of bipolarons or any other
preformed bosonic pairs \cite{alemot}. Combination of both
interactions, i.e. $V_{\bf k}, U_{\bf k}, W_{\bf k} \propto
constant +1/k^2$ transforms the lowest quadratic mode into the
Bogoliubov sound. Hence, two component condensate of bipolarons is
a superfluid.
Finally, let us discuss the phase segregated state of the
two-component nonconverting mixture with the hard-core interactions
when $W>\sqrt{UV}$\cite{remark}. In that case chemical potentials determined
in Eq.(9) are no longer correct. Minimizing the free energy with respect to
the equlibrium concentration we find the densities
$n_1^{'}=n_1+\sqrt{U/V}n_2$ and
$n_2^{'}=n_2+\sqrt{V/U}n_1$ of two separated phases.
The phase boundary is described by two coupled one-dimesional GP
equations, Eq.(2),
\begin{equation}
{d^2f_1\over{dx^2}}+f_1-f_1^3 -rf_1f_2^2=0,
\end{equation}
and
\begin{equation}
\kappa {d^2f_2\over{dx^2}}+f_2-f_2^3 -rf_2f_1^2=0.
\end{equation}
where we introduce two real dimensionless order parameters,
$f_1=\phi_1/\sqrt{n_1^{'}}$ and $f_2=\phi_2/\sqrt{n_2^{'}}$, and measure
length in units of the coherence length $\xi_1=(2m_1 Vn_1^{'})^{-1/2}$.
Parameter $r\equiv W/\sqrt{UV}$ is larger than 1, and
$\kappa =m_1Vn_1^{'}/m_2Un_2^{'}$ is the ratio of two
coherence lengths squared. One can solve these equations analytically
in the limit $\kappa \rightarrow 0$, where two coherence lengths
differ significantly or in the case $r \rightarrow \infty$.
In the limit $\kappa \rightarrow 0$ the first term in the second
equation is negligiable, so that $f_2=0$ if $rf_1^2>1$, and
$f_2=\sqrt{1-rf_1^2}$ if $rf_1^2 <1$. Substituting this solution
into the first equation and using $df_1/dx=F(f)$, one can reduce Eq.(16)
to an integerable first order differential equation. The solution
satisfying the boundary conditions, $f_1=1$ at $x=\infty$ and $f_1=0$ at
$x=-\infty$ is
\begin{equation}
f_1(x)=\Theta(x-x_1)\tanh(x/\sqrt{2})+
\Theta(x_1-x){\sqrt{2}\over{(r+1)^{1/2}\cosh[(r-1)^{1/2}(x-x_2)]}},
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
f_2(x)=\Theta(x_1-x)\left(1-{2r\over
{(r+1)\cosh^2[(r-1)^{1/2}(x-x_2)]}}\right)^{1/2},
\end{equation}
where $\Theta(x)$ is the $\Theta$-function, $\tanh(x_1/\sqrt{2})=r^{-1/2}$
and
$\cosh[(r-1)^{1/2}(x_1-x_2)]=\sqrt{2r/(r+1)}$.
Interestingly the $largest$ coherence length (in our case
$\xi_1$) determines profile of $both$ order parameters. The inter-component
mutual repulsion ($r$) only slightly changes the characteristic lengths, as
shown in Fig.2.
The quasiparticle eigenstates of the phase segregated condensate are
determined by the $inhomogeneous$ BdG equations, Eqs.(3,4). Here we
restrict the analysis by surface excitations at the boundary
between two condensates in the limit $r \rightarrow \infty$. Substituting
Eqs.(18,19) into Eqs.(3,4) we obtain 4 coupled linear differential equations.
In the limit $r \rightarrow \infty$ the equations are decoupled in
pairs, so that one can
solve only first two equations at $x>0$. Integration of the equations near zero
provides the boundary condition $u_1(0)=v_1(0)=0$. Then a simple analysis shows
that
there are no excitations localised near the boundary in that limit.
This conclusion seems to be quite general for any gapless Bose liquid. For
example, one can
consider a single component hard-core Bose
gas with attractive impurity potential placed at the origin $x=0$, so that
the GP equation is
\begin{equation}
{d^2f\over{dx^2}}+f-f^3 +\alpha \delta(x)=0,
\end{equation}
where $\alpha>0$ is the (dimensionless) strength of the potential. The
solution
is $f(x)=\coth[(|x|+x_0)/\sqrt{2}]$ where
$\sinh (x_0/2^{3/2})=1/\alpha$.
Substituting this solution into the BdG equations Eqs.(3,4) one can see
that localised excitations do not appear even in that case. The condensate
density increases at $x=0$ and effectively screens out the attractive
potential.
However, localised excitations could appear in the gapped
Bose-liquid, like the charged Bose gas. In that case
they are formed below the plasma frequency.
In conclusion, we have derived the
Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations and the excitation spectrum
of the two-component Bose-Einstein condensate with an
arbitrary interaction between bosons, including long-range and short
range forces. Solving GP equations for segregated condensates we found
the boundary profile,
and showed that localised
surface waves do not exist for strongly repulsive
components.
We greatly appreciate enlightening discussions of the nonlinear GP
equations with Alexander Veselov.
This work has been supported by EPSRC UK, grant R46977.
\begin{references}
\bibitem{and}
M.H. Anderson $et$ $al.$, Science {\bf 269}, 198 (1995).
\bibitem{dav}
K.B. Davis $et$ $al.$, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 75}, 3969 (1995).
\bibitem{bra}
C.C. Bradley $et$ $al.$, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 75}, 1687 (1995).
\bibitem{mew}
M.-O. Mewes $et$ $al.$, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 78}, 582 (1997).
\bibitem{hag}
E.W. Hagley $et$ $al.$, Science {\bf 283}, 1706 (1999).
\bibitem{alemot}
A.S. Alexandrov A S and N.F. Mott
Rep.Prog.Phys. {\bf 57}, 1197 (1994).
\bibitem{bog}
N. Bogoliubov, J.Phys. USSR {\bf 11}, 23-32(1947).
\bibitem{edw}
M. Edwards $et$ $al.$, Phys. Rev. A{\bf 53}, R1950 (1996).
\bibitem{bus}
Th. Busch $et$ $al.$, Phys. Rev. A{\bf 56}, 2978 (1997).
\bibitem{gol}
E.V. Goldstein $et$ $al.$, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 85}, 5030 (2000).
\bibitem{alekabbee}
A.S. Alexandrov, W.H. Beere, and V.V. Kabanov, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 54},
15363 (1996).
\bibitem{alekab}
A.S. Alexandrov and V.V. Kabanov, Phys. Rev. B{\bf 59}, 13628 (1999).
\bibitem{fol}
L.L. Foldy, Phys.Rev. {\bf 124}, 649(1961).
\bibitem{remark}
The condition $W>\sqrt{UV}$, where the lowest branch of the spectrum Eq.(12)
becomes unstable, coinsides with the condition, where compressibility
of the system becomes negative $|\partial \mu_i/\partial n_j| <0$. Phase
segregation also exists in the case of the $Coulomb + hard-core$ interaction.
In that case the condition where the spectrum Eq.(11) becomes unstable
depends on the plasma frequency. It shows that the higher order
corrections to the chemical potential due to the Coulomb interaction are
crucial
\end{references}
\newpage
Figure captions.
Fig. 1. The excitation energy spectrum of the two-component BEC with
the long-range repulsive and hard-core interactions. In this plot
$n_1=n_2=n$, $m_1=m_2$ and $U=V=\omega_p$, $q_1=q_2=e$. Different curves
correspond to the different
values of $W/V=0.1$ (dashed line), $0.5$ (dotted line), and $0.95$
(solid line), respectively. Excitation energy is measured
in units of the plasma frequency $\omega_p=4\pi n e^2/m$ and momentum $k$ is
measured in invers screening length $q_s= (16\pi e^2 nm)^{1/4}$.
Fig. 2. Density profiles of two phase-separated condensates near the
boundary for $r=2$ (solid line) and $r=10$ (dotted line), respectively.
\end{document}