Area constrained SOS models of interfaces
Extracted source text ยท arXiv cond-mat/0701062
\magnification=\magstep1
\vsize=8.5truein
\hsize=6.3truein
\baselineskip=18truept
\parskip=4truept
%\parindent=0.3truept
\vskip 18pt
\def\today{\ifcase\month\or January\or February\or
March\or April\or May\or June\or July\or
August\or September\or October\or November\or
December\fi
\space\number\day, \number\year}
\centerline{\bf Area constrained SOS Models of Interfaces. }
\medskip
\centerline{by }
\centerline{J. Stecki }
\vskip 20pt
\centerline{ Department III, Institute of Physical Chemistry,}
\centerline{ Polish Academy of Sciences, }
\centerline{ ul. Kasprzaka 44/52, 01-224 Warszawa, Poland}
\bigskip
\centerline{\today}
\vskip 60pt
\centerline{\bf{ Abstract}}
The solid-on solid (SOS) model in two dimensions ($d=2$)
is now solved under the constraint of constant
energy and then under the new constraint of constant total area.
From the combinatorial factors $g(E;L,M)$, the new ensemble is constructed
with its free energy $F(A_{tot},T)$ of a membrane of
constant (onedimensional) area $A_{tot}$.
The entropy per column
$Y=(1/L)\log g(E;L,M)$ of rectangular
$L\times M$ strips reduces to a common curve in reduced variables.
Definitions of the "area"
and of the interfacial tension, are compared or discussed.
Analytical calculations are
supported with numerical ones and vice versa.
Overall the constraint reduces the ratio of $A_{tot}$ to the projected
area $L$, as compared with canonical calculation, strongly at high
temperatures.
\vfill\eject
{\bf I. Introduction}
The solid-on-solid (SOS) model originated very long time ago in
connection with crystal surfaces and crystal growth; its first extensive
description is found in the classical paper of Burton, Cabrera, and Frank[1].
It was later realized that the model of irregularities of a crystal face
could be fashioned into a theory of morphology and also of fluctuations
of surfaces. Then it was discovered that the SOS model of equilibrium
surface could be solved exactly in two dimensions, {\it i.e.} for a
one-dimensional interface, by the method of transfer matrix [2-7].
There are reviews available[8-10].
The solution could be applied to free energy calculations and to the theory
of capillary waves[7,11,12] of interfaces.
Here we apply the SOS model to the difficult problem of membrane fluctuations.
% These are shape fluctuations at long wavelengths.
All interfaces and all membranes as well, undergo shape fluctuations. These
necessarily result from thermal motion and are intertwined with all
thermal fluctuations.
However, there are important distinctions between interfaces and membranes.
An interface is an open system, also open with
respect to particle exchange. A flat liquid surface increases its surface
area and takes a wavy form by inducing the diffusion of molecules
from either bulk phase. Similarly a crystal surface is formed and reformed
by processes of evaporation - by particle exchange with the surroundings.
In fluctuating membranes such diffusion does not occur or is very rare.
Commonly membranes and bilayers are formed by self-assembling
surfactant (am\-phi\-phi\-lic) molecules and embedded in a liquid solvent.
Although in principle the mo\-le\-cu\-les forming
a bilayer are soluble to some extent in the liquid solvent,
in reality their concentration is exceedingly low. It is hardly
possible for a bilayer or a membrane to absorb or release molecules in
the process of locally changing its shape; consequently the shape
fluctuations (also long-wavelength fluctuations, such as capillary
waves) take
place {\it under the constraint} of a constant particle number $N_s$ forming
the sheet of surfactant.
This constraint translates to a constraint of constant membrane area.
%Introducing this constraint into the theory has proved exceedingly difficult;
%There are other (d-1)-dimensional objects imbedded in a d-dimensional
%space, e.g. Langmuir monolayers, solid sheets, etc.
% in particular the constraint of a constant intrinsic area of a fluctuating
%interface has never
%been discussed (let alone implemented) for an SOS model either in
%two ($d=2$) or three ($d=3$) dimensions.
Such considerations will make distinction between the true area and the
"projected area". The exact and formal results provided so far by the Gibbs
statistical mechanics, always refer to the area defined in terms of the
geometry of the macroscopic volume $V$ enclosing the system under
consideration. For example in d=3 the volume may be a parallelepiped and
the area its $x-y$ edge. A constant-volume increment $\delta F$ of
the free energy $F$ provides the interfacial tension $\gamma$
through
$$ \delta F =\gamma \delta A~. \eqno(1.1)$$
$A$ is often called the "projected area", to emphasize
that, because of the undulations of the interface, its "true area" is
larger and, when projected onto the edge of the box, produces $A$.
The "true interface area" is something the external world does not
have control of; contrariwise, the projected area $A$ is under
the control of
external forces just as the volume, temperature, or overall density is.
Thus (1.1) defines $\gamma$ in terms of a measurable quantity $A$.
% MENTION THIS in the reply
Such reasoning clearly applies to an interface; we examine
the other case of a membrane with a constant intrinsic area.
These observations prompted us to consider a new set of SOS models
with constraints. In this paper we limit ourselves to one-dimensional
string embedded in two dimensions, {\it i.e.} to a model which is exactly
soluble[2-7] albeit without constaints.
We solve below (for the first time)
the microcanonical {\it i.e. } constant-energy version
of the SOS model which we use to obtain the combinatorial factors;
these are used to construct the new ensemble of constant interface
length. Therefore we proceed via exact enumeration.
In Section II
the SOS model is defined and solved; this provides the
combinatorial factor $g(E;L,M)$ - the
basic building block for subsequent calculations.
These results/calculations have many ramifications, some of
which are reported in Section II and in the Appendix
because of their novelty and possible usefulness.
In Section III
the definitions of the total area are compared and
then
the relation between total area $A_{tot}$ and the projected area
$L$ is compared for the unconstrained calculation and for the
new calculations under the constraint of a given constant $A_{tot}$.
Also, the
derivative of the free energy with respect to either area
(defining the tension $\gamma$) is calculated and discussed.
Finally Section IV is the summary and brief discussion.
\bigskip
%\vfill\eject
{\bf II. The Solid-On-Solid Model and its Solution. }
In the two-dimensional Solid-on-Solid (SOS) model[1-9]
a one-dimensional interface is drawn along a strip of a square lattice
as illustrated in Fig.1. The interface is
reduced to a one-dimensional string.
The standard $L\times M$ strip is made
of $L$ columns of height $M$; the interface crosses each column
once and only once.
A microscopic configuration of the interface is then specified by a
collection of heights
$$ \{h_j\}, j=1,L ;~~ 1\le h_j \le M . \eqno(2.1)$$
Clusters and overhangs are absent.
The "vertical" variable is $h$ or $z$ at the horizontal position
$x=a_0 j$, $1\le j\le L$ and we take the lattice constant $a_0=1$.
The "height" is limited to $1\le h\le M$.
In the standard SOS model[2,5,6] the energy of
a microscopic configuration is
$$E_{tot}=E_0 +E \eqno(2.2)$$
with
$$ E_0 =\epsilon_0 L;~~~ E=\epsilon A_v. \eqno(2.3)$$
In general $\epsilon_0 \ne \epsilon$ and both are positive.
$E_0$ is the energy of a perfectly flat interface.
The total length of the interface is its one-dimensional area;
it is a sum of its horizontal part, $A_h$ and its vertical part, $A_v$.
$$ A_{tot} = A_h +A_v = L + A_v \eqno(2.4)$$
The first part is the trivial contribution equal to $L$. The vertical
part is the sum of absolute values of the height jumps
$$ A_v = \sum_i\Delta_{i,i+1} = \sum_i \vert h_{i+1} - h_i \vert \eqno(2.5)$$
where
$$ \Delta_{i,i+1}\equiv \vert h_{i+1} - h_i \vert ~,~ \eqno(2.6)$$
Thus the energy of the strip and of the interface is directly
related to the vertical part of the interface area, $A_v$.
This is not essential.
In more general SOS models where
$$ E = \epsilon \sum \vert h_{i+1} - h_i \vert ^n~~~~\epsilon >0~ \eqno(2.7)$$
e.g. when $n=2$ in the Gaussian model, the simple proportionality of
$E$ and $A_v$, is lost.
Also, other definitions of the total area, can be given (see Section III) but
are numerically close to (2.4).
We define the following partition functions and their associated
thermodynamic potentials.
For the finite strip $L$ columns long and $M$ rows high, we have
{\item {(A)} the microcanonical constant-energy ensemble }
$$ Z(L,M,E) = g(A_v;L,M) ~~~~~~ S=k\log Z \eqno(2.8)$$
where $g$ is the number of microscopic configurations and $S$ is the
entropy. $k$ is the Boltzmann constant, $E=\epsilon A_v$.
Given $\epsilon_0$, one can use interchangeably $E_0$ or $L$.
Given $\epsilon$, one can use interchangeably $E$ or $A_v$.
{\item {(B)} The canonical (constant temperature) partition function is}
$$ Z(T,L,M) =\sum_{A_v\ge 0} g(A_v;L,M)\times \exp^{-\beta E_{tot} }\eqno(2.9)$$
$$ \beta F = (-)\log Z \eqno(2.10)$$
where $F$ is the free energy. This usually is written subtracting
the energy of the flat interface $\epsilon_0 L$ as the trivial term, defining
$$ Z(T,L,M) =\sum_{A_v\ge 0} g(A_v;L,M)\times \exp^{-\beta E } \eqno(2.11)$$
so that $F=-kT\log Z$ is now the free energy of interface deformations.
By introducing the quantity $Q = \exp[-\beta\epsilon]\in [0,1] $
we rewrite (2.11) as
$$ Z(T,L,M) =\sum_{A_v\ge 0} g(A_v)\times Q^{A_v} \eqno(2.12)$$
emphasizing that $Z$ is the generating function for combinatorial
factors $g$.
Here, $L$ being fixed, the total length of the interface $A_{tot}$
is directly given by $A_v$ and conversely.
$E$, $A_v$, and $A_{tot}$ fluctuate - appropriately for an interface.
Generalizing the partition function for fixed $L$, we construct now
{\item{(C)} the new partition function for total interface area.}
%\hfill\break
That is, we consider an ensemble of strips with different lengths $L$
(and common height $M$). Then
$$ Z^\ast(T,A_{tot};M)=\sum_L \sum_{A_v} g(A_v;L,M)\exp[-\beta E_{tot}]
\eqno(2.13) $$
with the implied constraint of a given total area, e.g. defined by (2.4)
(as $A_{tot}= L + A_v $).
Total energy as given by (2.2)-(2.3)
takes into account the energy cost of a horizontal step,
$\epsilon_0$, besides the energy cost of a vertical step,
$\epsilon$. It is convenient to define
$$Q = \exp[-\beta\epsilon]~~~R = \exp[-\beta\epsilon_0], \eqno(2.14)$$
whereby
$\exp (-\beta E_{tot})$ is written as $Q^{A_v}R^L$.
The partition function (2.13) becomes $Z^\ast(Q,R,A_{tot};M)$.
By allowing different energies for vertical and horizontal steps we can
distinguish and treat as different, total lengths that are equal but are made of
different proportions of vertical/horizontal steps.
Both $Q\in [0,1]$ and $R\in [0,1]$. Thus in (2.12) $R=1$ has been
tacitly assumed.
The height $M$ can be made infinite[7,8] for fixed $L$ (Section IId).
Under certain conditions, infinite $M$ can also be introduced into (2.13).
The averages are calculated as usual:
$<L>=-(\partial \log Z)/(\partial \log R)$ and
$<A_v>=-(\partial \log Z)/(\partial \log Q)$.
To summarize, we consider the following geometries:
{\item{(i)} L fixed, M fixed and finite,}
{\item{(ii)} L fixed, M infinite,}
{\item{(iii)} L variable, M fixed and finite,}
{\item{(iv)} L variable, M infinite.}\hfill\break
\noindent
The new partition function for (iii) or (iv)
with the constraint of given constant total area $A_{tot} = L + A_v$,
is calculated in Section IId.
In all cases we need the
basic building blocks: the combinatorial factors $g(A_v;L,M)$ which are
computed in Section IIa,IIb, and $g(A_v;L,M=\infty)$ in Section IId.
\bigskip
{\bf IIa. The Microcanonical Ensemble of Fixed Energy.}
To solve the SOS model in $d=2$ for both $M,L$ finite and given,
one introduces the
$M\times M$ transfer matrix as follows
$$ T(h,h') = Q^{\vert h-h' \vert} \eqno(2.15)$$
with $Q\equiv \exp[-\epsilon /kT] $. The canonical
partition function is expressed as[2]
$$ Z = {\rm Tr}~ T^L = \sum_h (T^L)_{h,h}~. \eqno(2.16)$$
If the
transfer matrix is diagonalized, as a real symmetric positive definite
matrix it admits a representation
$$ T_{hk}= \sum_j \phi_j(h)\lambda_j \phi_j(k) \eqno(2.17)$$
where $\lambda_j$ is the j-th eigenvalue, $j=1,...,M$ and $\phi_j$ the
corresponding eigenvector of the orthonormal and complete set.
Therefore multiplication of $T$'s just raises the power(s) of eigenvalues
and
$$ Z = \lambda_1^L+ \lambda_2^L+\cdots~~ . \eqno(2.18)$$
The largest eigenvalue
dominates in the limit $L\rightarrow\infty$;
then for sufficiently large $M$,~
$F/(LkT)=-(1/L)\log Z = -\log \lambda_1 = -\log(1+Q) +\log(1-Q)$
reproduces the known result, $\log \tanh \beta\epsilon/2$ [2,7,10,12].
Now we want to select from the set of all configurations only those
of given total length $L+A_v$.
If $L$ is fixed this is reduced to a constraint of given $A_v$. The latter is
$$ A_v= \Delta_{12}+ \Delta_{23}+ \cdots+ \Delta_{L,1} ~,~\eqno(2.19)$$
where
$$ \Delta_{i,i+1}\equiv \vert h_{i+1} - h_i \vert ~,~ \eqno(2.6)$$
The last term in (2.19) is
there if one imposes periodic boundary condition $h_{L+1}=h_1$ as we do.
The constraint on $A_v$ can be expressed with the aid of a Kronecker delta
$\delta^{Kr}(j,n)$ equal to 1 for $j=n$ and to 0 otherwise.
Thus
$$ Z(T,L,M;A_v) = \sum_{h_1}...\sum_{h_L}\delta^{Kr}(A_v,\Delta_{12}+...) \times
T_{h_1,h_2}~ T~ T \cdots~~~ . \eqno(2.20)$$
By using the integral representation
$$ \delta^{Kr}(j,n)=\int_{-\pi}^{+\pi} ({{dk}\over{2\pi}}) e^{ik(j-n)}
\eqno(2.21)$$
and taking the integral in front of the sums, we find that to each
T-matrix there corresponds a factor $\exp(ik\Delta)$ so defining
the new matrix
$$ \tau_{h,h'} \equiv T_{h,h'}e^{ik\Delta_{h,h'} }~~~, \eqno(2.22)$$
we have the new expression for the constrained partition function
$$ Z(T,L,M;A_v) =\int_{-\pi}^{+\pi} ({{dk}\over{2\pi}}) e^{-ikA_v} {\rm Tr}~\tau^L~~~
. \eqno(2.23)$$
This is the expression we evaluate. The matrix {\bf $\tau$ }
can be put into the form of the r.h.s. of (2.15);
define $\tilde Q$ as $\tilde Q\equiv Q\exp(ik)$,
so that
$$ \tau(h,h')=\tilde Q^{\vert h-h' \vert}~~~~ \tilde Q\equiv e^{+ik-\beta\epsilon}~~ . \eqno(2.24)$$
The complex $\tilde Q$ has a real part between -1 and 1 and an imaginary part
between -1 and 1.
The matrix {\bf $\tau$ } depends parametrically on the wave-vector $k$, the
integration variable, which is real. It reduces to the original T-matrix at $k=0$,
apparently continuously. By using the package "Eispack"[13], in particular
its program CG for diagonalization of complex general matrices, we were
able to compute $Z$ and log$Z$ from
$$ Z(T,L,M;A_v) = \int_{-\pi}^{+\pi} ({{dk}\over{2\pi}}) e^{-ikA_v} [
\lambda_1(k)^L+\lambda_2(k)^L+\cdots +\lambda_M(k)^L]~ . \eqno(2.25)$$
The eigenvalues depend on $k$. Evaluation was done for $M=5,6,10,20$
and for $L < 41$; several values of $Q$ were used. It could be done for $M=30$.
For odd $A_v$ the result is exactly nil and this is correct because of the
periodic boundary condition at $L$. For $A_v=0$, $Z=M$ for all $Q$.
The general form of the result is
$$Z(A_v)=g(A_v)Q^{A_v}~ . \eqno(2.26)$$
with $g$ independent of $Q$. The Kronecker delta picks up the one
term of the sum (2.12). By dividing (2.26) by $Q^{A_v}$ we obtain $g(A_v;L,M)$.
All numerical results did conform to (2.26); $g$ was obtained accurately
for the very largest systems ($g$ must be an integer) and was
obtained exactly for all other sizes. Numerically, $Q$ cannot be chosen
too small or too close to unity.
In actual calculations we have imposed periodic boundary condition
$h_{L+1}=h_1$ which not only simplified the calculation but also excluded
exotic configurations. For all $A_v$ odd, $g$ is nil.
The combinatorial factor $g(A_v)$ always follows the same
pattern starting from $g(0)=M$, going through a maximum near $A_v\sim LM/3$
and then falling down to 0 for $A_v >(M-1)L$. Being the number of microscopic
configurations, $g$ very soon reaches horrendously large numbers and for
that reason Fig.2 shows an example of $g(A_v)$ for very small $M,~ L$.
The pattern seen in Fig.2 is general; starting with $g(0)=M$ and after a
very rapid increase, $g$ goes through a maximum and falls to a low value,
often terminating with a value of~~2. Afterwards for all values of $A_v$
the correct value is $g=0$.
This characteristic dependence becomes continuous for large $L$
(and not too small $M$ ) in the following variables: $ Y=(1/L)\log (g)$
and $a\equiv A_v/Ln_1$. The quantity $a\equiv A_v/Ln_1$ varies between
0 and 1~~, $n_1$ being equal to $M-1$.
Since the energy is not allowed to fluctuate, the logarithm of the
partition function is the thermodynamic potential of the
constant-energy microcanonical ensemble
$$ S(L,M,E) = k \log g(A_v;L,M) ~~~ E=\epsilon A_v \eqno(2.27)$$
An extension of the numerical results to larger systems, can be based
on a simple scaling in reduced variables.
We have already introduced the scaled, or reduced area (simply area per site)
$a\equiv A_v/L(M-1) $ and we find that $Y=(1/L)\log(g)$ fall on a common
curve when plotted against $a$, for different $L$ at each constant $M$.
Fig.3 shows how this simple "scaling" works; the shapes are similar enough so that
for each M different values of L fall on a common curve.
Values of $L<10$ and of $M<10$ are too small to be included.
Eq.(2.27) identifies the function $Y$ as entropy per column. Invoking the
relation
$$ dS/dE = 1/T \eqno(2.28)$$
defining the thermodynamic temperature $T$ in the microcanonical ensemble,
we may rewrite it as $d\log(g)/dA_v = \beta\epsilon = -\log Q$ with $\beta = 1/kT$.
However, as a look at Fig.2 and Fig.3 shows, beyond the maximum in $g$
that interpretation fails (or produces negative temperatures). The
original observation is attributed to L.Landau[14]:
in systems with energy bounded from above, $T<0$ is possible.
Here is one more such example.
The ordinary canonical partition function is calculated by
diagonalizing the real $T-$matrix for given $Q$, {\it i.e.} after (2.16-18).
But it is also equal to (2.12) . Since all terms are positive,
selecting the maximum term leads to $d(\log g)/dA_v -\beta\epsilon =0$
which can be rewritten to a form like (2.28). Now $T$ is an independent
variable, $T>0$ because $Q\in [0,1]$, and $E=E(T), S=S(T)$.
\bigskip
{\bf IIb. An Independent Algebraic Check.}
Turning to the starting point for the solution of the model, (2.15-2.16),
we note that for small $L$ the trace can be computed analytically.
By multiplying out the $T$-matrices, we obtain a polynomial in $Q$:
$$ Z=Tr T^L = c_0 + c_1Q + c_2Q^2+... ~~ . \eqno(2.29)$$
The basic observation is that the power of $ Q$ is just the number of
energy units, identified in the previous subsection as the vertical part
of the total length and denoted by $A_v$. $Z$ containing the total of
all configurations, each term represents the split between different
values of $A_v$. That is , we can identify the coefficients $c_j$ in
(2.29) as the combinatorial factors denoted by $g(A_v)$.
Thus equation (2.29) is rewritten as
$$ Z = \sum_{A_v=0,1,2...} g(A_v)Q^{A_v}~. \eqno(2.12)$$
For example, constructing the 4 by 4 $T$-matrix (whose first row is
$ 1,Q,Q^2,Q^3$) and multiplying it out to obtain $T^6$, taking the
trace, we obtain for $L=6,M=4$~~
$Z=4+90x^2 +510x^4 +1266x^6 +1116x^8 +744x^{10} +310x^{12}
+42x^{14} +12x^{16} +2x^{18} . $
Thus $g(A_v=8) =1116$ etc. See Fig.2. Such exact enumerations, with the
computer-aided algebra, were carried out up to $M=20$
for $L$ up to 30, providing checks on numerical results obtained via the
diagonalization described in previous Subsections.
\bigskip
{\bf IIc. The Constraint of Total Area For Given M}\hfill\break
From the combinatorial factors in the microcanonical ensemble at given $L,M$
we can construct now the partition function with the constraint of total length
$A_{tot}$. We take the ensemble of strips with different $L$'s (and the same
$M$) and implement the constraint of constant $A_{tot}$ in (2.13);
for given $M$
$$ Z^\ast(T,A_{tot};M)=\sum_L \sum_{A_v}\delta^{Kr}(L+A_v, A_{tot})
g(A_v;L,M) Q^{A_v} R^L. \eqno(2.30)$$
That is, the sum $L+A_v$ is held constant.
Maximum value of $L$ is obviously $A_{tot}$
and the mimimum value is 2. To avoid exotic cases, periodic boundary
conditions are imposed $h_L=h_1$. The Kronecker delta is replaced
by these simple restrictions on the sums.
Note that here we do not calculate the average total area
$A_{tot}$ because the procedure
is inverted: for {\it given} fixed total length $A_{tot}$ both $L$ and $A_v$
are allowed to fluctuate and are calculated as averages:
$$ \langle L\rangle=d\log Z^\ast/d\log R~~~\langle A_v\rangle=d\log Z^\ast/d\log Q \eqno(2.31)$$
and $\langle A_v\rangle=A_{tot} -\langle L\rangle $ or conversely.
The averages as $f(Q,R,A_{tot})$ were
computed and are shown below for special cases
such as $u\equiv Q=R$ and $R=1, Q\in [0,1]$.
In the first
case a string of fixed length is allowed to fluctuate in a neutral
environment, where energy of a horizontal step is equal to that of a
vertical step and therefore none is preferred;
in the second case, only the energy of vertical steps is
affecting the choice of configuration.
Interestingly, the conbinatorial factors $g(A_{tot})$ are increasing without
bounds, in contrast to the constant $L,M$ case from Section IIa-IIb.
% No negative temperatures could be defined in this case.
For an ensemble of narrow strips of $M\ge 6$
analytical calculations were done as follows: first traces
of $T^L$ were calculated and stored
(for $L$ up to 40 and nore) and then sums were formed for all even values of
$A_{tot}\in [10,38]$. From the resulting expression
$\beta F, \langle L\rangle, \langle A_v\rangle$ were calculated
analytically and used, in part
to check the results of numerical computations.
A selection of these results is shown in Section III.
The results for finite $M$ are also
compared with the case $M=\infty$ described below.
\bigskip
{\bf IId. The Columnar Strip (M=$\infty$) and its Solution}.\hfill\break
% In this geometry, the deviations from flatness are not limited at all
From the solution[7] of the eigenvalue problem of $T$ for given $L$
and columns of infinite height[7], $M=\infty$, the eigenvalues
are known explicitely
$$ \lambda (\nu) = (1-Q^2)/(1+Q^2 -2Q\cos (\nu) ) \eqno(2.32)$$
where the index $\nu\in [-\pi,+\pi]$ is now continuous.
Because of the translational invariance in the "vertical" $M$
direction, actually exploited in solving the transfer matrix[7],
we must impose a constant $h_1$, e.g. $h_1=0$ and another fixed value
for $h_L$ - which we
choose to be equal to $h_1$. The canonical partition function (2.11) or
(2.12) with $M$ infinite then exists. There are some limitations
in more general cases ($R\neq 1$ and variable $L$ fixed $A_{tot}$)
- because now the excursions of the interface are limited only by
the cost of a vertical step. The
flat configuration $h_i=0$ is the equilibrium configuration
for $Q\rightarrow 0$.
We need the combinatorial factors $g(A_v;L,M=\infty)$. Following
Section IIa, in order to impose the
the constraint of fixed $A_v$ we
replace $Q=\exp(-\beta\epsilon)$ with $\tilde Q \equiv Q e^{ik} $.
The solution[7] goes through as explicit calculation shows.
The partition function becomes a double integral, replacing (2.25) by
$$ Z(Q,A_v;L,M=\infty) = \int_{-\pi}^{+\pi} ({{dk}\over{2\pi}}) e^{-ikA_v}
\int_{-\pi}^{+\pi} ({{d\nu}\over{2\pi}})\lambda (\nu)^L~ . \eqno(2.33)$$
Numerical evaluation is now simpler as the diagonalization step is
not needed - we have the explicit expression (2.32) for the eigenvalues.
For $A_v$ and $L$ integers, we obtain again $Z$ in the form (2.26) {\it i.e.}
$ Z=g\times Q^{A_v} $,
where again $g(A_v)$ comes out an integer. Again $\log g$ has the
interpretation of entropy $S/k$.
In an analytic calculation, all $g(A_v;L)$ result as polynomials in $A_v$.
There is a striking simplification which occurs for $M=\infty$;
$g(A_v;L)$ are
polynomials with highest power equal to $L-2$. For example
$g(x;L=4)=2+(2/5)x^2$ (for all $x>0$), $g(x;L=6)=2 +(35/8)x^2 +(21/32)x^4$
etc.~~($x\equiv A_v$).
Knowing these polynomials we can make computations with {\it any value} of
$A_v$. A few examples are given in the Appendix.
The exact results for $g(A_v;L,M=\infty)$ are used now to construct an
ensemble of columnar strips of infinite heights $M$ and variable
$L$. At given $A_{tot}$,
maximum value of $L$ is $A_{tot}$,
and the mimimum value is 2. Minimum value of $A_v$ is zero; there is no
upper bound other than $A_{tot}-L$.
To avoid exotic cases and to ensure the existence of $Z$,
again $h_L=h_1=0$ for each $L$.
We show here, in Section III, explicit calculations for these two cases: $Q=R\rightarrow u$
and $R=1, Q\in [0,1]$.
\bigskip
{\bf III. Numerical Results and the Comparison of Areas and Free Energies.}
In this section we show a restricted selection of results for the two
most important quantities: the vertical area $A_v$ related to the energy and
the total area of the interface.
We also consider the derivative of the free energy $F$ with respect
to area, all other variables being kept constant; this is interpreted as
the interfacial tension $\gamma$.
Hence
$$ \beta \gamma = (\partial (\beta F) /\partial A)_T \eqno(3.1)$$
The area $A$ can be the projected area $L$, the total area imposed in the
ensemble of all $L$'s, or the average total area defined as $\langle A_{tot}\rangle
\equiv L+\langle A_v\rangle $. All results are given for $R=1,Q\in
[0,1]$ ~(cf.(2.13)-(2.15)).
The other interesting case, $R=Q\in [0,1]$, turns out to be a degenerate
temperature-independent one, in which the interface wiggles randomly in
an energetically neutral environment. These results are also reached in the
limit $Q\rightarrow 1^-$ at constant $R=1$.
First, however, we compare 3 different definitions of the area, or, rather,
two definitions, $A_v$ and $A_{sq}$, and one approximation, $A'$. Our
definition of the total area as $A_{tot}= L+A_v$ corresponds to the
length of the thick line in Fig.1; $L$ is the sum of "horizontal" steps,
and $A_v$ is the
sum of "vertical" steps, $\Delta_{i,i+1}$ (cf. (2.5-6).
The usual definition would
draw a line through $h_i$ and $h_{i+1}$; this approach produces
$$A_{sq}\equiv \sum[-1+\sqrt{1+\Delta_{i,i+1} } ]. \eqno(3.2) $$
where $L$ is subtracted.
Expansion of the square root gives the first term, which is the common
approximation,
$$A' \equiv \sum (1/2)\Delta_{i,i+1}^2 . \eqno(3.3)$$
Definitions $A_v$ and $A_{sq}$ produce always very close results, $A_v$
always slightly larger. Fig.4 shows all
three areas calculated in the canonical ensemble, plotted against $Q$.
$A'$ is a very bad approximation, grossly exaggerating $A_{sq}$ except when
both are very small; this happens here at small $Q$. We have found
earlier in another context[15] the same pattern, with the
commonly used approximation for the area, like (3.3), grossly overestimating
the true area, except in the limit $\Delta A \rightarrow 0$.
Figure 4 also includes the microcanonical results {\it i.e.} the curve of
$A_v$ as independent variable against
$Q=\exp(-\langle\beta\epsilon\rangle )$ with
the inverse temperature computed acccording to (2.28) with (2.27); even
for the small value of $M$ the differences are negligible and invisible
on the scale of the plot. This is a useful check;
the agreement between the canonical and microcanonical ensembles can only
become better for larger $L$ and $M$ and it does.
In conclusion, we use $A_v+L$ as a measure of area, include
canonical averages, and do not quote microcanonical averages.
Fig.5 illustrates the results for the new ensemble of variable $L$ and
constant $A_{tot}$. Three values $A_{tot}=10,20,30$ were chosen.
Since $A_{\rm sq}$ and $A_v$ are so close, only
$\langle A_v\rangle$ is plotted.
The case $M=\infty$ (section IId) is shown with lines; at the infinite
temperature $\langle A_v\rangle$ reaches 4.2, 9.2, and 14.2 for
$A_{tot}=10,20,30$, respectively. Interestingly, squeezing the membrane
with a small $M=6$ does not change $\langle A_v\rangle$ much; these
averages are shown with stars, crosses, and plus signs, and reach 4.0, 8.6,
and 13.0. Unconstrained averages calculated in the canonical ensemble
produce plots of another shape and much larger values at high
temperatures; $\langle A_v\rangle$ for $M=\infty$ diverges. For
fixed $A_{tot}$ it does not.
We choose the inverse temperature as the ordinate for the plot because
of the quasi-linearity at high temperatures of the data with fixed
$A_{tot}$. As can be seen clearly,
fixing $A_{tot}$ limits the vertical excursions of the interface
considerably and - somewhat suprisingly - in a similar fashion for
small $M=6$ and for $M=\infty$.
At low temperatures i.e. at vanishing $Q$ and large $\beta\epsilon$ all
calculations produce $\langle A_v\rangle\rightarrow 0$.
% at high
% temperatures the new fixed-$A_{tot}$ average stays low, whereas all
% unconstrained (canonical) averages produce much bigger values. For
% $M=\infty$, canonical-ensemble $\langle A_v\rangle$ diverges as
% $\beta\epsilon\rightarrow 0^+ $.
At $Q=1$ {\it i.e.} $\beta\epsilon=0$, $\langle L\rangle$ is at 55-57
percent of $A_{tot}$,
practically in all calculations we have done so far for the new ensemble.
The limit
corresponds to the fluctuation of the interface in the neutral environment
where horizontal or vertical steps carry the same cost in energy, now
vanishing in the limit $Q\rightarrow 1, \beta\epsilon\rightarrow 0$.
The divergence of the canonical average for
$M=\infty$ (full line in Fig.5) can be understood as follows.
If $M=\infty$ and $L$ is
fixed whereas $A_v$ and $A_{tot}$ are free to fluctuate and take an
average value, it is only the
energy cost expressed in the value of $Q$ which limits the excursions
of the interface and therefore the number of realized configurations
thus the partition function. When $Q$ ceases to operate, the partition
function and the averages, diverge. This does not happen when a fixed
$A_{tot}$ is imposed.
All partition functions are converted to free energies and all free
energies depend on an area as the independent extensive variable.
The definition (3.1) of the interfacial tension $\gamma$,
is now applied to $\beta F(A_{tot};T)$.
In Fig.6 the derivative (3.1)
w.r.to $A_{tot}$ is plotted against $Q$. For $M=\infty$ or $M=6$
in the ensemble of all $L$, the data points show mild near linear variation
with $Q$.
For comparison, the canonical free energy per column
$\beta F(Q;L,M)/L$
from the largest eigenvalue, is $-\log[(1+Q)/(1-Q)]$ and is
plotted as the dot-dash line. All eigenvalues for $M=6$ produce the
near-linear full line.
Whether the derivative (3.1) applied to $F(A_{tot},T)$ can be interpreted
as an "interfacial tension", is perhaps debatable. Still the derivative
can be calculated and compared with other derivatives of the free
energy with respect to other areas.
\bigskip
{\bf IV. Summary and Discussion.}
As recalled in the introduction membranes keep their area constant,
notwithstanding shape fluctuations. Planar interfaces are also twodimensional
sheets embedded in three dimensions, but are open to particle exchange
with the surroundings and their proper or intrinsic area varies.
Hence the theory of fluctuating interfaces must
be suitably modified to apply to membranes. We examine this
modification by
choosing an existing simple and soluble model,
namely the SOS model in two dimensions, for which exact enumerations were
practical.
By starting from the available results, we introduced the
constraint of constant interface area; first simply into the $L\times M$
strip and then constructing a new {\it ensemble of all projected areas}.
The partition functions, free energies, and the ensemble averages
all were built on the
microcanonical combinatorial factors $g(A_v;L,M)$. Their calculation
was essential.
These were obtained by several means described in Section II.
Of the several calculational schemes, the ensemble of all
lengths $L$ at infinite height $M$ under the constraint of a given total
area $A_{tot}$
produced $\langle A_v\rangle$ and $\langle L\rangle$. The latter has
an interpretation of the average projected area. Practically in all
calculations, the ratio $\langle L\rangle /A_{tot}$ approached 55 percent
in the limit of high temperatures ($Q\rightarrow 1,\beta\epsilon\rightarrow 0$).
We also calculated the derivative of the free energy $F(A_{tot},T)$
with respect to $A_{tot}$. This may be considered an analogue of the
interfacial tension $\gamma$, now
defined with respect to $A_{tot}$. When compared with other calculations
of similar derivatives, the new derivative was the smallest in the absolute
value and did not diverge in the limit of infinite temperature. This was
illustrated by Fig.6.
The mathematical procedures involved some particular features; their
description may be useful.
First, we used a diagonalization of a complex
matrix ${\bf \tau}$ which was symmetric but not unitary. This was followed
by numerical integration. The final result had to be an integer.
The correcteness of the diagonalization procedure was verified by
agreement with the exact algebraic calculations.
The exact enumerations (for the case of infinite $M$) were also spot-checked
by the generating
functions for "partially directed" random walks, obtained by slightly
modifying
the generating functions given by Privman and Svrakic[18]; but introduction
of constraints was, as often is the case, not any more practical.
Extension to two-dimensional membranes embedded in $d=3$ is not impossible though
difficult. A good candidate[17] is the Gaussian SOS model on a square lattice with
each site endowed with a continuous height variable $h_i$; it is readily
soluble without constraints and for various boundaries.
The prediction is that the constraint will damp the fluctuations in a
way similar to the damping seen here.
Finally, it is probably all too obvious that our aim was not to develop further
the Solid-on-Solid model but rather to use it to examine the differences
between membranes and interfaces. Thus we have not
pushed the calculations in order to go to highest possible orders of
calculation . The trends are already visible.
\bigskip
{\bf Acknowledgements.}
The author has greatly benefitted in the past from discussions with
J.S.Rowlinson FRS (Oxford), R.Evans FRS (Bristol), and B. Widom (Cornell).
\bigskip
\medskip
{\bf Appendix.}
{\bf Combinatorial Factors $g$ for Infinite $M$. }
It is a rare and desirable event if combinatorial factors can be generated
by polynomials.
We list the first few combinatorial factors $g(x)$
for $L=$2, 4, 6, 8, 10. These were calculated and are available for $L$ up to 30.
These polynomials are valid for any value
of $x\equiv A_v>0$. For $x=A_v=0$, $g=1$ for any $L$.
Some exact algebraic calculations were done in part with the aid of
an old version of "Mathematica"[16].
See Section IIc for notation and further details.
\item {L= 2} $g=2$
\item {L= 4} $g=2+(5/2)x^2$
\item {L= 6} $g=2+(35/8)x^2 +(21/32)x^4$
\item {L= 8} $g= 2 + (707/120)x^2 + (77/48)x^4 + (143/1920)x^6$
\item {L=10} $g= 2+(14465x^2)/2016+(4147x^4)/1536+(715x^6)/3072+(2431x^8)/516096$
...
\bigskip
{\bf References.}
\item{1.} W. K. Burton, N. Cabrera, and F. C. Frank, Phil. Trans.
Roy. Soc.(London) {\bf 243}, No.866,299-358 (1951);
Nature {\bf 163},398 (1949).
\item{2.} J. M. J. van Leeuwen and H. J. Hilhorst, Physica {\bf A107}, 319 (1981).
\item{3.} S. T.Chui and J. D. Weeks, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 23}, 2438 (1981).
\item{4.} T. W. Burkhardt, J. Phys. {\bf A14}, L83 (1981).
\item{5.} D. M. Kroll and R. Lipowsky, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 28}, 5273 (1983).
\item{6.} A. Ciach, Phys.~Rev.~B {\bf 34}, 1932 (1986).
\item{7.} A. Kooiman, J.M.J. van Leeuwen, R.K.P.Zia, Physica {\bf A170}, 124 (1990).
\item{8.} D. B. Abraham, in {\it "Phase Transition and Critical Phenomena"},
(C. Domb and J. L. Lebowitz, Eds.), Vol.10, Academic Press, London (1986).
\item{9.} V. Privman, Chapter 1 in {\it "Finite Size Scaling
and Numerical Simulation"}, (Singapore, 1990) where further
references can be found.
\item{10.} J. Dudowicz and J. Stecki, in {\it "Fluid Interfacial phenomena"},
(C. A. Croxton, Ed.) J. Wiley 1986, p. 637ff.
\item{11.} A. Ciach, J. Dudowicz, and J. Stecki, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 56}, 1482 (1986).
\item{12.} A. Maciolek and J. Stecki, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 54}, 1128 (1996).
\item{13.} Eispack - Fortran package maintained by Argonne Natl. Laboratory,
version 1983.
\item{14.} L.~D. Landau and L. Lifshitz, {\it "Statistical Physics"} (Pergamon, Oxford 1980).
\item{15.} J. Stecki, J. Chem. Phys. {\bf 114}, 7574(2001), cf.eq.(5.4) ff.
\item{16.} Mathematica - a software package (ver.2.2) by Wolfram Research, Inc. (1994).
\item{17.} J. Stecki, in preparation.
\item{18.} V. Privman and N. M. Svrakic, {\it"Directed Models of Polymers,
Interfaces, and Clusters"}, Springer-Verlag (Lecture Notes in
Physics No.338), Berlin 1989.
%\vfill\eject
\bigskip
\vfill\eject
{\bf Figure Captions}
{\bf Figure 1}
The solid-on-solid (SOS) interface in $d=2$. The strip is $M$ sites wide
in the "vertical" direction and
$L$ sites long in the "horizontal" $x$ direction. The interface is of
length $A=L+A_v$.
\medskip
{\bf Figure 2}
An example of the number $g$ of configurations of the interface
plotted against
the interfacial area $A_v$ at given size of the strip with L=6,M=4.
The numbers (different from zero) are: 4, 90, 510, 1266, 1116, 744,
310, 42, 12, 2,
for areas $A_v$ 0,2,4,6,8,...,18, respectively.
\medskip
{\bf Figure 3}
The "scaling" curve of the microcanonical combinatorial factor $g=g(A_v)$
at fixed $L,M$. The function
$Y=(1/L)\log(g)$ is plotted against $a=A_v/L(M-1)$ for $M=6, 10, 20$, and
$L=10,20,30$. Smaller values of $L$ deviate from
the common curve. The maxima extrapolated to $1/L\rightarrow 0$
with polynomials in $1/L$ were 1.77702, 2.28587, and 2.97979 for $M=6,10,20$,
respectively. Extrapolation to $1/M \rightarrow 0$ was inconclusive.
\medskip
{\bf Figure 4}
Three areas: $A_v/L$, $A_{sq}/L$, and $A'/L$ vs. $Q$ calculated
in the canonical ensemble (see text) are compared. Full line terminating
at 5.8198 - $A_{sq}/L$; bold-dashed line hitting 33.25 - $A'/L$;
fine-dashed line hitting 6.6500 - $A_v$. Plus signs - microcanonical
$A_v$ reaching 6.564 at $Q=1$. $L=30$,$M=20$. $A_v/L$ was independent
of $L$ and weakly depending on $M$ provided $M\ge 10$.
\medskip
{\bf Figure 5}
Average $\langle A_v\rangle$ vs. $\beta\epsilon=\epsilon/kT=-\log Q$
for fixed $A_{tot}=10,20,30$ in the ensemble of all $L$. Fixed $M=6$
shown with points (stars, crosses, plus signs, respectively); $M=\infty$
shown with lines (fine-dashed, dashed, full, respectively). Unconstrained
canonical averages $\langle A_v\rangle$ for constant $L,M$ are
($M=6, L=10,20,30$, - dotted lines; ditto
$M=\infty, L=10$, - full line) . For $\beta\epsilon=0$,
data shown with points hit 4.00, 8.564,
12.980, respectively; data for $M=\infty$ shown with lines, hit
4.205, 9.209, and 14.213, respectively. The dotted lines
(canonical $\langle A_v\rangle$ for $M=6$) hit 19.444, 38.888, 58.333
for L=10,20,30,
respectively. $R=1, Q\in [0,1]$ in all cases.
\medskip
{\bf Figure 6}
Free energy derivatives w.r.to the total area
$(\partial \beta F /\partial A_{tot})_Q $, plotted against $Q$.
The new ensemble of all $L$
and $M=6$ - small plus signs, ditto $M=\infty$ -large plus signs.
For comparison the derivatives w.r.to the projected area $L$,
in canonical ensemble $M=6$ - full line, $M,L\rightarrow\infty$ -
dash-dot line, are plotted.
\bigskip
the end of text. Figures are as 6 *.eps files
\vfill\eject\end
\bye
the junk texts kept in *.bak