Hybrid states with heavy quarks
Extracted source text ยท arXiv hep-ph/9510285
%Paper: hep-ph/9510285
%From: yufryakov@vitep3.itep.ru
%Date: Fri, 13 Oct 1995 10:07:51 EET
\documentstyle[12pt]{article}
\title{
Hybrid states with heavy quarks
}
\vspace{2cm}
\author{
Yu. B. Yufryakov\thanks
{ e-mail : yufryakov@vxitep.itep.ru}
\\ Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics\\ 117259,
Moscow}
\date{}
\newcommand{\be}{\begin{equation}}
\newcommand{\ee}{\end{equation}}
\begin{document}
\maketitle
\begin{abstract}
Model-independent features of
hybrid states with heavy
quarks and adiabatic approximation
for such systems are discussed.
These general arguments are applied
to the QCD-based constituent gluon model.
The leading-order Hamiltonian is derived from
the general formalism. The masses of
heavy quarks hybrids, including charmonium hybrid states,
are calculated. We predict $c\bar c g$
hybrids at 4.0$\pm$0.1
GeV and
$b \bar b g$
ones at 10.5$\pm$0.1 GeV.
Comparison with some other models
are made.
Model-independent features of
hybrid states with heavy
quarks and adiabatic approximation
for such systems are discussed.
These general arguments are applied
to the QCD-based constituent gluon model.
The leading-order Hamiltonian is derived from
the general formalism. The masses of
heavy quark hybrids, including charmonium hybrid states,
are calculated. We predict $c\bar c g$
hybrids at 4.0$\pm$0.1
GeV and
$b \bar b g$
ones at 10.5$\pm$0.1 GeV.
Comparison with some other models
are made.
\end{abstract}
\newpage
The problem of exotic states with heavy quarks is
widely discussed in the literature. Despite the fact
that there is no unambigous evidence of existence any
exotics even for light quarks sector, intensive theoretical
studies of heavy quarks exotics are carrying out(see [5]
for review). The
reason of this interest is that the heavy flavours
spectroscopy is well understood, much more better than
for light quarks sector. Presence of the slow
nonrelativistic quark subsystem allows one to use the
adiabatic (Born-Oppenheimer) approximation.
So, there are
slow quark subsystem and fast gluonic subsystem . The
only mass parameter for gluonic subsystem is string
tension $\sigma$. Its energy
in the order of magnitude is
$E_{gl}\propto \sqrt{\sigma}$;
radius is
$r_{gl}\propto 1/\sqrt{\sigma}$;
and velocity is
$\dot r_{gl}\propto 1$.
Assume that quarks are confined
by oscillator potential produced by gluonic subsystem
. Then for quark subsystem we can estimate :
\be
E_{q \bar q}\propto \sigma^{3/4}/\sqrt{m};
~~~r_{q \bar q }\propto 1/~^4\sqrt{m\sigma^{3/2}}
\ee
Hence , ratio of
the periods of slow and fast subsystems equals :
\be
T_{q\bar q}/T_{gl}\propto E_{gl}/E_{q\bar q}\propto
\sqrt{m/\sqrt{\sigma}}
\ee
and radii ratio is :
\be
r_{q\bar q}/r_{gl}\propto
~^4\sqrt{\sqrt{\sigma}/m}
\ee
It's easy to see that a typical small
parameter is $\sqrt{\sqrt{\sigma}/m}$.
Unfortunately, because of the numerical reasons estimation ( 3 )
is not satisfied for c- and b-quarks . But the main point we
stress is that the oscillator potential gives us quark
subsystem energy of order
$\sqrt{\sigma}\sqrt{\sqrt{\sigma}/m}$
and any
unharmonic corrections will be of the next orders.
So ,
we propose the following description of hybrids with
heavy quarks . Suppose we have a Hamiltonian for
$q \bar q g$--
system . We'll obtain the leading
approximation in the limit
$r_{q\bar q}\to 0$.
We can
calculate gluon subsystem energy solving Schrodinger-type
equation with our Hamiltonian . To obtain quark subsystem
energy we ought to 1) substract from our Hamiltonian all
terms proportional to the square of the interquark
radius. 2) Averaged over gluon wave function these pieces
of the full Hamiltonian produce us Hamiltonian of the
quark subsystem which in turn gives us quark corrections
to the energy of the gluonic subsystem .
Our starting
point is the constituent gluon model described in [1] .
Using Feynman-Schwinger representation for Green function one
can write effective Lagrangian for $q\bar q g$
system in the Euclidean space-time
(spin degrees of freedom are neglected):
\be
L=\frac{2\mu+\mu_g}{2} +\frac{m^2}{\mu}+\frac{\mu\dot{z}^2}{2}+
\frac{\mu\dot{\bar{z}}^2}{2}+\frac{\mu_g\dot x^2}{2}+
\sigma{r_1}\int^1_0d\beta_1\sqrt{1+l^2_1}+\sigma{r_2}\int^1_0
d\beta_2\sqrt{1+l^2_2}
\ee
$$
l_1^2=(\beta_1\dot{z}+(1-\beta_1)\dot
x)^2-\frac{1}{r^2_1}(\beta_1(\dot z{r_1})+(1-\beta_1)(\dot
z{r_1}))^2 $$
$$ l_2^2=(\beta_2\dot{\bar z}+(1-\beta_2)\dot
x)^2 -\frac{1}{r^2_2}(\beta_2(\dot{\bar z}{r_2})+(1-\beta_2)
(\dot{\bar z}{r_2}))^2 $$
(We consider
equal quark masses case, Coulomb interaction omitted). Here
$\mu$ and $\mu_g$ are effective masses of quark and
gluon respectively ; $z,\bar{z}$ and $x$ are quark,
antiquark and gluon 3-coordinates ;
$r_1=z-x ; r_2=\bar z-x$.
To deal with the square root terms we use the auxiliary
field formalism [2]. Following the method of [2] we obtain the
Lagrangian:
$$
L=\frac{m^2}{\mu}+\mu+\frac{1}{2}[\mu_g(1+\dot x^2)+\mu(\dot z^2+
\dot{\bar z}^2)+(\int^1_0d\beta_1 \nu_1(\beta_1)(1+l^2_1)+
$$
\be
+\sigma^2r^2_1
\int^1_0\frac{d\beta_1}{\nu_1(\beta_1)}+(1\to 2))]
\ee
To
eliminate
center-of -mass motion we can introduce variables (analogously to
the [2]) :
\be
r_{1i}=z_i-x_i;~~
r_{2i}=\bar z_i-x_i;~~
R_{i}=(1-\xi_1-\xi_2)x_i+\xi_1z_i+\xi_2\bar z_i
\ee
where $\xi_{\gamma} (\gamma = 1,2 )$ are parameters to be defined
from the condition that all terms of the type
$(\dot{R}\dot r_1)$ and
$(\dot R \dot r_2)$
cancel ( but not
$(\dot{R} r_1)$ $(\dot{r} r_1)$
type terms!). It's easy to see that
\be
\xi_1=\frac{\mu_1+\int^1_0 d\beta_1\nu_1 (\beta_1)\beta_1}{\mu_1+\mu_2
+\mu_g+\int d\beta_1\nu_1+\int d\beta_2\nu_2};~~
\xi_2=(1\leftrightarrow 2)
\ee
After that the integration over
center-of-mass coordinate $\vec R$ can be
carried out . The resulting Lagrangian reads :
\newpage
$$
L=\frac{m^2}{\mu}+\frac{M}{2}+\frac{\dot r_1^2}{2}
[\mu(1-2\xi_1+2\xi_1^2)+\mu_g \xi^2_1+c_1+
a_2\xi^2_1]+(1\leftrightarrow 2) - M\xi_1\xi_2 (\dot r_1
\dot r_2)+
$$
$$+ \frac{d_1\sigma^2r^2_1}{2}-
\frac{c_1}{2} \frac{(\dot r_1 r_1)^2}{r^2_1}+
(1\leftrightarrow 2 )
-\frac{1}{2A}\{\frac{1}{r^2_1}[b^2_1(\dot r_1
r_1)^2(a_1+M+a_2\frac{(r_1r_2)^2}{r^2_1r^2_1})-
$$
$$
-2\xi_2Mb_1(a_1+\eta)(\dot r_1 r_1)(\dot r_2 r_1)+
\xi^2_2Ma_1(a_1+\eta)(\dot r_2
r_1)^2]+
$$
\be
+(1\leftrightarrow 2) +[b_1(\dot r_1
r_1)-\xi_2a_1(\dot r_2r_1)][b_2(\dot r_2 r_2)-\xi_1
a_2(\dot r_1 r_2)] \frac{2M(r_1r_2)}{r^2_1r^2_2}\}
\ee
where
$$
a=\int^1_0 d\beta \nu (\beta);~~ b=\int^1_0 d\beta \nu
(\beta)(\beta-\xi); ~~ c=\int^1_0d\beta\nu
(\beta)(\beta-\xi)^2; ~~ d=
\int^1_0\frac{d\beta}{\nu(\beta)}
$$
\be
\eta=\mu_1+\mu_2+\mu_g;~~ M=\eta+a_1+a_2;~~A=M\eta +
a_1a_2\frac{|\vec r_1\times \vec r_2|^2}{r^2_1r^2_2}
\ee
We assume that $\nu\sim \sqrt{\sigma}$. Expanding (8) on
the $\sqrt{\sigma}/m$ and using new
variables
\be
r_1=\frac{z_1+\bar z_1}{2}-x_1=\frac{r_{1i}+r_{2i}}{2};~~
\rho_1=z_i-\bar z_i=r_{1i}-r_{2i}
\ee
it's easy to see that in the leading order relative
quark motion (with reduced mass $\mu/2$ ) is
decoupled :
\be
\frac{\mu}{4}(\dot r_1-\dot r_2)^2=\frac{\mu}{4}\dot{\rho}^2
\ee
In the leading order we have for gluonic subsystem :
\be
L_{gl}=\frac{\dot
r^2}{2}(\mu_g+\Pi_1+\Pi_2)-\frac{\Pi_1}{2}\frac{(\dot r
r_1)^2}{r_1^2}-\frac{\Pi_2}{2}\frac{(\dot r r_2)}{r_2^2}+
\frac{1}{2}(\mu_g+a_1+a_2+\sigma^2r^2_1d_1+\sigma^2r^2_2d_2)
\ee
where
\be
\Pi=c-b+a/4=
\int^1_0d\beta\nu(\beta)(\beta-1)^2
\ee
The kinetic term in the Lagrangian (12) is
quadratic in velocities. Hence one can easily obtain Hamiltonian
and all terms proportional to $\rho^2$
can be
separated.The result reads :
$$
\hat T_{gl}=\hat T^{(0)}+\hat T^{(1)}
$$
$$
\hat
T^{(0)}=\frac{1}{2\mu_g}
\frac{(pr)^2}{r^2}+\frac{\hat{\vec{L}}_{gl}^2}{2(\mu_g+\Pi_1+\Pi_2)r^2}
$$
\be
\hat T^{(1)}(\rho)=\frac{\Pi \rho^2}{6}[\frac{\hat{\vec
L}^2_{gl}}{2(\mu_g+2\Pi)^2r^4}-\frac{(\vec p\vec n)^2}{\mu^2_g
r^2}]
\ee
We
assumed S-wave for quarks in ( 14 ) :
\be
<\rho_i\rho_j>=\frac{\rho^2\delta_{ ij}}{3}
\ee
Averaging (14) over chosen gluon wave function we obtain a
contribution to the oscillator potential for quark subsystem. In
fact, the main contribution arise from the "potential" term of
Lagrangian (12) and (14) is only a small correction.
\par Zeroth
approximation Hamiltonian of gluonic subsystem in Minkowski space is:
\be
\hat
H_{gl}=\frac{p^2_r}{2\mu_g}+\frac{\hat{\vec{L}}^2_{gl}}
{2(2\Pi+\mu_g)r^2}+ \int^1_0d\beta\nu(\beta)+\frac{\mu_g}{2}+
\sigma^2r^2\int^1_0\frac{d\beta}{\nu(\beta)}
\ee
Here $\hat{\vec L}_{gl}$
is the angular momentum of the gluon ; $p_r$
is the radial momentum. We believe that physical
states of gluon are electric and magnetic ( see [1]). For lowest
states $<\hat{\vec{L}}_{gl}^2>=2$.
Here we
are to use some variational procedure. We choose an anzats for the
effective string energy $\nu(\beta)$
and
define free parameters from the minimization of gluon subsystem
energy . After that quark correction with this ansatz is
calculated from (11),(12) and (14) . The simplest ansatzes for
$\nu(\beta)$ are :
$$
\begin{array}{ll}
\nu(\beta)= Const&(Ansatz I)\\
\nu(\beta)= C_1+C_2(\beta-1)^2&(Ansatz II)\\
\nu(\beta)= \sigma r &(Ansatz III)
\end{array}
$$
Without Coulomb interaction it's
worthwhile to write out values of interest in the dimensionless
form :
\be
E_{gl}/\sqrt{\sigma}=4.30\pm 0.05;~~
E_{q\bar q}/(\sqrt{\sigma}\sqrt{\sqrt{\sigma}/m})=1.4\pm 0.2
\ee
These values were
obtained by means of trial radial wave function of the Gaussian type.
Numerically gluon energy is about 1.7 GeV , quark correction
value equals hundreds of MeV.
Three Coulomb terms should be added
to the full Hamiltonian:
\be
V_{coul}=
-\frac{3\alpha_s}{2}(\frac{1}{r_1}+\frac{1}{r_2})+\frac{1}{6}
\frac{\alpha_s}{\rho}
\ee
Since $\alpha_s/6\ll 1$
quark-antiquark repulsion gives only small contribution into the
resulting energy .
But the main problem as it is usual for most
of the (potential-like) models is to define absolute scale of mass.
Some additional constants are needed to fit hadronic spestrum and
these constants vary for different sectors of the theory.
Following the recipe described in [ 1 ] we use the constant for
heavy-light sector multiplied by two ( cause we have two strings
vs. one string for heavy-light meson , and one can expect that
perimeter-type terms for Wilson loop or hadronic shifts could be
twice larger than for the only string). The procedure used is :
1) to define constant for heavy-light meson for given heavy quark
mass (light quark is massless) . By means of variational
calculations with known masses of the heavy-light
S-states (1975 Mev for D-meson and 5300 MeV for
B-meson - accuracy more than tens of MeV is not
needed) we define additive negative constant
$C_0$.
2)The resulting mass is:
\be
M_{q\bar{q}g}=2m_q+E_{gl}+E_{q\bar q}+2 C_0
\ee
The main results of this paper are
summarized in Table I . There hybrid masses for various
heavy quark masses are listed. The parameters are
$\alpha_s=0.3;~~\sigma=0.18 GeV^2$
. In
the last column results obtained by method of [ 1 ] are
shown.
\newpage
\begin{center}
{\bf Table I.}
{\it Calculated hybrid masses, GeV}
\end{center}
\begin{tabular}{llllll}
&& Ansatz I& Ansatz II& Ansatz III& Potential\\
$m_c=$&1.2 GeV& 4.008& 3.951& 3.873&
4.089\\
& 1.3& 4.004& 3.95& 3.875& 4.082\\
& 1.5& 3.997& 3.946& 3.878& 4.069\\
& 1.7& 3.991& 3.943& 3.88& 4.058\\
$m_b$= &4.2& 10.828& 10.810& 10.647&
10.647\\
& 4.5& 10.551& 10.521& 10.491&
10.585\\
&4.9& 10.55& 10.521& 10.492&
10.583\\
&5.2& 10.548& 10.519& 10.491&
10.58 \end{tabular}
From Table I one can conclude that our model
anticipate for c.o.m. of hybrid multiplet
\be
M=\left \{
\begin{array}{lll}
4.0\pm 0.1 GeV& for& c\bar c g\\
10.5\pm 0.1 GeV& for& b\bar b g
\end{array}
\right.
\ee
Quantum numbers of hybrids are given in [ 1 ] .
Spin-dependent forces are not considered in this
paper ( the most important are $(\vec L\vec S)$. They will be
discussed in the
forthcoming studies.
The result (19) is in a good
agreement with that ones of [3] and [4].
Unfortunately, this is a rather accident fact cause
in [3], [4] and in this paper various prescriptions
for additive constants in the interquark potential
were used. Thus we believe that there is no
reasons for exceed optimism and additional attempts
should be made to understand the origin of the
constant term.
This research was made possible by Grant N J77100 from the International
Science Foundation and Russian Government.
The support from Russian Fundamental Research Foundation,Grant N
93-02-14937 is also acknoledged.
\newpage
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\bibitem {1}
Yu.S.Kalashnikova, Yu.B.Yufryakov, Preprint
ITEP-35-95 , hep-ph/9506269 ( to be published in Physics Letters
B ).
\bibitem {2}
A.Yu.Dubin, A.B.Kaidalov and Yu.A.Simonov,Phys. Lett.
B323,41(1994); E.L.Gubankova and A.Yu.Dubin, Phys.Lett.
B334,180(1994)
\bibitem {3}
J.Merlin and J.Paton , J. Phys. G11 , 439
(1985) N. Isgur and J.Paton, Phys. Rev. D31, 2910 (1985)
J.Merlin and J.Paton, Phys. Rev. D35, 1668 (1987)
\bibitem {4}
S.Perantonis and C.Michael, Nucl. Phys. B347, 854 (1990)
\bibitem {5}
T.Barnes , F.E.Close and E.S. Swanson , RAL-94-106, hep-ph/9501405
\end{thebibliography}
\end{document}