Test of Special Relativity from K Physics
Extracted source text ยท arXiv hep-ph/9709350
\documentstyle[12pt]{article}
\begin{document}
\vfill
\begin{center}
{\Large \bf
Test of Special Relativity from K Physics} \\ \vfill
T. Hambye$^{(a)}$\footnotemark\footnotetext{email:
hambye@hal1.physik.uni-dortmund.de},
R.B. Mann$^{(b)}$\footnotemark\footnotetext{email:
mann@avatar.uwaterloo.ca}
and U. Sarkar$^{(c)}$\footnotemark\footnotetext{email:
utpal@prl.ernet.in}\\
\vspace{2cm}
(a) Institut f\"{u}r Physik, Universit\"{a}t Dortmund,
D-44221 Dortmund, Germany \\
(b) Physics Department, University of Waterloo,
Waterloo, Ontario, Canada N2L 3G1\\
(c)Theory Group, Physical Research Laboratory,
Ahmedabad, 380 009, India\\
\end{center}
\date{\today \\ WATPHYS TH-97/14}
\vfill
\begin{abstract}
A breakdown of the Local Lorentz Invariance and hence the
special theory of relativity in the Kaon system can, in
principle, induce oscillations between the $K^0$ and $\bar{K}^0$ states.
We construct a general formulation in which simultaneous
pairwise diagonalization of mass, momentum and weak eigenstates
is not assumed and the maximum attainable speeds of the
momentum eigenstates are different. This mechanism permits
Local Lorentz Invariance violation in a manner that may or may
not violate CPT. In the $CPT-$conserving case, we show that violation of
special relativity could be clearly tested experimentally
via the energy dependence of the $K_L-K_S$ mass difference
and we discuss constraints imposed by present experiments. In
the $CPT$-violating case the $K^0$--$\bar{K}^0$ system also
allows the possiblity of testing different Lorentz properties of matter
and antimatter.
\end{abstract}
\vfill
The special theory of relativity has been tested to a high
degree of precision from various types of experiments
\cite{spexp}. These experiments probe for any dependence of the
(non-gravitational) laws of physics on a laboratory's
position, orientation or velocity relative to some preferred
frame of reference, such as the frame in which the cosmic
microwave background is isotropic. Such a dependence would
constitute a direct violation of (respectively) Local Position
Invariance and Local Lorentz Invariance (LLI), and hence of the
Equivalence Principle \cite{will}.
A characteristic feature of LLI-violation is that every
species of matter has its own maximum attainable speed. This
yields several novel effects in various sectors of the standard
model \cite{cathugh}, including vacuum Cerenkov radiation
\cite{gasp}, photon decay \cite{cole} and neutrino oscillations
\cite{cole,glash}. In case of neutrino oscillations
constraints on the violation of the equivalence principle
\cite{gasp,utrobb} can be directly translated into constraints
on the violation of LLI \cite{glash}. Here we extend these
arguments to the particle/antiparticle sector. Specifically, we
consider the $K^0$--$\bar{K}^0$ system and point out that a
violation of special relativity here will in general induce
an energy dependent $K_L - K_S$ mass difference; an empirical
search for such effects can therefore be used to obtain bounds
on the violation of LLI in the Kaon sector of the standard
model. The approach we will follow to this problem in the Kaon
system is phenomenological: we shall assume that the mass or
the weak eigenstates are not {\it a-priori} simultaneously
diagonalisable with the momemtum eigenstates and that the maximum
attainable velocities of the different momentum eigenstates are
different.
The present study of violation of LLI in the Kaon system, in
addition to previous studies in other sectors, is motivated
by the simple fact that there is no logically necessary reason
why special relativity must be valid in all sectors of the
standard model of elementary particle physics. Rather its
validity must be empirically checked for each sector separately
\cite{cathugh}. In particular in the $CPT$-conserved case we
will discuss, where the momentum eigenstates
of the Kaon system may have differing maximal speeds,
the bound obtained is of the same order as the ones
obtained in other sectors of the standard model \cite{spexp,cole}.
On the other hand the $K^0$--$\bar{K}^0$ system is also a
matter-antimatter system in which we can test for possible
violations of LLI stemming from different maximum attainable
speeds of matter and antimatter (which consequently induce
$CPT$ violation). Our formalism contains both the $CPT$-conserved
and $CPT-$violating cases.
More explicitly, for relativistic pointlike Kaons the
general form of the effective Hamiltonian associated with the
Lagrangian in the $(K^0 \hskip .10in \bar{K}^0)$ basis will be
\begin{equation}
H = U_W H_{SEW} U_W^{-1} + U_v H_v U_v^{-1} \label{h}
\end{equation}
with,
\begin{equation}
H_{SEW} = \frac{(M_{SEW})^2}{2 p} = \frac{1}{2 p} {\pmatrix{
m_1 & 0 \cr 0 & m_2}}^2 \label{hsew}
\end{equation}
and
\begin{equation}
H_v = \pmatrix{ v_1 & 0 \cr 0 & v_2} p \label{hg}
\end{equation}
to leading order in $\bar{m}^2/p^2$ with $p$ the momentum and
$\bar{m}$ the average mass, where for a quantity $X$, $\delta X
\equiv(X_1-X_2)$, $\bar{X} = (X_1+X_2)/2$. The constants $v_1$
and $v_2$ correspond to the maximum attainable speeds of each
eigenstate. If special relativity is valid within the Kaon
sector these are both equal to their average $\bar{v}$, which
we normalize to unity. If $\bar{v}$ is equal to the speed of
electromagnetic radiation then special relativity is valid
within the Kaon--photon sector of the standard model. Hence
$v_1 - v_2 = \delta v$ is a measure of LLI violation in the
Kaon sector. $H_{SEW}$ is the matrix coming from the strong,
electromagnetic and weak interactions, whose absorptive ({\it
i.e.} antihermitian) parts we shall neglect for the moment. In
the limit $v_1=v_2$, weak interactions are responsible for $m_1
\not= m_2$, which are interpreted as the $K_L$ and $K_S$ masses.
Since $H_{SEW}$ and $H_v$ are hermitian, $U_v$ and $U_W$ are
unitary. {}From the general form of a 2x2 unitary matrix
$$
U = e^{i\chi}
\pmatrix{ e^{-i\alpha} & 0 \cr 0 & e^{i\alpha}}
\pmatrix{ \cos\theta & \sin\theta \cr -\sin\theta & \cos\theta}
\pmatrix{ e^{-i\beta} & 0 \cr 0 & e^{i\beta}}
$$
it is straightforward to show that
$$
H = p I + \frac{1}{2 p} { \pmatrix{ M_{+} & M_{12} \cr
M_{12}^\ast & M_{-} }}^2
$$
where I is the unit matrix and
\begin{eqnarray}
M_{\pm} &=& \bar{m} \pm \frac{cos2\theta_W}{2}
\delta m \pm \frac{p^2}{\bar{m}} \frac
{\cos2\theta_v}{2}\delta v \nonumber \\
M_{12} &=& -(e^{-2i\alpha_W} \sin2\theta_W \delta m
+ e^{-2i\alpha_v}\frac{p^2}{\bar{m}}\sin2\theta_v
\delta v)/2 \nonumber \\
\label{mtot}
\end{eqnarray}
where we have absorbed additional phases into the $K^0$ and
$\bar{K}^0$ wavefunctions. Since in this paper we will be
considering effects for which CP-violation is negligible, for
simplicity we shall take $\alpha_v$ = $\alpha_W$ =
0.\footnote{A more general analysis containing $CP-$violating
effects will be presented elsewhere \cite{new}.}.
In the basis of the
physical states $K_L$ and $K_S$, the Hamiltonian becomes
\begin{equation}
H = \pmatrix{p + \frac{m_L^2}{2 p} & 0 \cr 0 & p +
\frac{m_S^2}{2 p}} = \pmatrix{\tilde{E} & 0 \cr 0 &
\tilde{E}} + {1 \over 2}
\pmatrix{ \Delta E & 0 \cr 0 & - \Delta E } \label{he}
\end{equation}
where $\tilde{E} = ( p + \frac{\bar{m}^2}{2 p} )$,
and
\begin{equation}
\frac{p}{\bar{m}} \Delta E = m_L - m_S = \left[
( \delta m )^2 + {\left( \delta v {p^2 \over \bar{m}}
\right)}^2 + 2 \delta m \delta v \frac{p^2}{\bar{m}}
\cos(2(\theta_W - \theta_v)) \right]^{1 / 2}
\label{mls}
\end{equation}
where $m_L$ and $m_S$ are the experimentally measured masses of
$K_L$ and $K_S$ respectively. {}From the above it is clear that
the LLI violation implies that the mass difference $m_L - m_S$
is energy dependent. (The possibility of energy dependence of
the various parameters in the Kaon system has been previously
considered in different contexts \cite{cathugh,aron}).
The amount of CPT--violation is given by
\begin{equation}
\Delta_{CPT} = M_{+} - M_{-} = \cos (2 \theta_W)\delta m +
\cos (2 \theta_v) \delta v \frac{p^2}
{\bar{m}} \label{dcpt}
\end{equation}
{}From this expression we see that it is not possible to
conserve CPT for all momenta unless $\theta_W = \theta_v = {\pi
\over 4}$ (modulo $\pi \over 2$), thereby separately conserving
CPT. In the following we will discuss in detail this
$CPT-$conserving case because it is the less constrained case
and because our results can be compared with earlier ones
where $CPT$ conservation has been
assumed. We also consider briefly the interesting maximal
$CPT-$violating case where $\theta_W$ = $\pi /4$ and
$\theta_v$ = $0$.
In the $CPT-$conserving case the mass difference is
\begin{equation}
m_L - m_S = \delta m + \delta v {{p^2} \over
{\bar{m}}}
\label{bef}
\end{equation}
which as noted above is energy dependent. What constraints do
present experiments place on $\delta m$ and $\delta v$? In the
review of particle properties \cite{pdg} six experiments were
taken into account. Two of them are at high energy
\cite{gib,sch} with the Kaon momentum $p_K$ between 20 GeV and
160 GeV. The weighted average of these two experiments is
\cite{sch}: $\Delta m_{LS} = m_L - m_S = (0.5282 \pm
0.0030)\times 10^{10} \hbar s^{-1}$. The four other experiments
\cite{cullen,gew,gjes,adler} are at lower energy, with $p_K
\approx 5$ GeV, or less. The weighted average of these low
energy experiments is $\Delta m_{LS} = (0.5322 \pm
0.0018)\times 10^{10} \hbar s^{-1}$. A fit of equation
(\ref{bef}) with the high and low energy value of $\Delta
m_{LS}$ gives : $\delta m = (3.503 \pm 0.012) \times 10^{-12}
MeV$ and $\delta v = -(1.6 \pm 1.4) \times 10^{-21} \times
\left( \frac{90}{E_{av}} \right)^2$, (where $E_{av}$ is the
average energy for the high energy experiment which we take to
be 90 GeV). We obtain consequently:
\[
|\delta v | \leq 3 \times 10^{-21}.
\]
The fitted value above
differs from zero by 1.15 standard deviations.
While it is certainly premature to regard this as evidence for
LLI violation,
these values do show that it is possible to test the
special theory of relativity in the Kaon sector.
A precise fit
of mass difference per energy bin in present and future high
energy experiments would be extremely useful in constraining
the violation of Lorentz invariance parameter $\delta v$,
particularly since the present experimental situation at low
energy is not clear. Indeed one of the low energy experiments
\cite{adler} published last year found $\Delta m_{LS} =
(0.5274 \pm 0.0029 \pm 0.0005)\times 10^{10} \hbar s^{-1}$, a
value lower than the weighted average $\Delta m_{LS} = (0.5350
\pm 0.0023)\times 10^{10} \hbar s^{-1}$ of the three (previous)
low energy experiments. Without this new experiment, a similar
fit of the other five experiments yields $\delta v = -(2.76 \pm
1.54) \times 10^{-21} (90/E_{av})^2$. In this case $\delta v$
is different from 0 by 1.8 standard deviations. Alternatively
taking only the new experiment \cite{adler} at low energy we
would obtain a value compatible with 0 at less than 1 standard
deviation.
We now briefly discuss the case where $CPT$ is conserved in the
strong and the electromagnetic sectors ($\theta_W$ = $\pi /4$)
but maximally violated by the momentum eigenstates ($\theta_v$
= $0$). A bound on $\delta v$ can be obtained
from Eq.(\ref{dcpt}) (with $\theta_W$ = $\pi /4$ and $\theta_v$
= $0$) and $|M_+ - M_- |/m_K$ $<$ $9 \times 10^{-19}$
\cite{pdg} with $p \simeq 100$ $GeV$:
\[
| \delta v | \leq 2.3 \times 10^{-23}.
\]
The upper bound we obtain by looking
at the energy dependence of $m_L \ - \ m_S$, through
Eq.(\ref{mls}) as in the $CPT-$conserving case, is relatively
less stringent than the one from Eq.(\ref{dcpt}) by 2 to 3
orders of magnitude.
In the above analysis we have not included the effect of the
absorptive part of the Hamiltonian. Inclusion of the
absorbtive part entails the replacement of $m_i$ by $m_i - i
\Gamma_i/2$. With this change the definitions of $\tilde{E}$
and $\Delta E$ are modified to
\begin{eqnarray}
\tilde{E} &= & \left( p + \displaystyle \frac{(\bar{m} -
i \bar{\Gamma}/2)^2}{2 p} \right) \nonumber \\
\frac{p}{\bar{m}} \Delta E &=& {1 \over
\sqrt{2}} \left[ \sqrt{F^2 + G^2} + F \right]^{1/2}
+ i {1 \over \sqrt{2}} \left[ \sqrt{F^2 + G^2} - F \right]^{1/2}
\nonumber \\
F & = & (\delta m)^2 + (\delta v {{p^2} \over {\bar{m}}})^2 + 2
\delta m \delta v {{p^2} \over
{\bar{m}}} \cos (2 \theta_W - 2 \theta_v)
- ( {{\delta \Gamma} \over 2})^2 \nonumber \\
G &=& - ( \delta m \delta \Gamma) - \cos (2 \theta_W -
2 \theta_v) [ \delta \Gamma \delta v {{p^2} \over {\bar{m}}} ]
\end{eqnarray}
We also have,
\begin{eqnarray}
m_L - m_S &= & \frac{p}{\bar{m}} {\rm Re} (\Delta E) \label{ls} \\
\Gamma_S - \Gamma_L &=& 2 \frac{p}{\bar{m}} {\rm Im} (\Delta E)
\label{ps} \end{eqnarray}
In deriving these equations we neglected terms in $\delta m
\Gamma$, $\delta m \delta \Gamma$ and $\Gamma^2$ with respect
to the terms in $m \delta m$ or $m \delta \Gamma$. It can be
shown that in the $CPT$--conserving case the above mass
difference (equation (\ref{ls})) reduces to equation
(\ref{bef}). So in our present analysis the results above are
not affected by inclusion of the widths. In this case the
difference $\Gamma_S - \Gamma_L = -\delta \Gamma$ is
independent of energy. This is consistent with experiment,
which indicates that the low and high energy measurements of
$\Gamma_S - \Gamma_L$ are fully compatible \cite{pdg}.
To summarize, in constructing our formalism to test the
violation of Local Lorentz Invariance in the Kaon sector
we have taken a
phenomenological approach, making the general hypothesis that
momentum eigenstates can be a priori any orthogonal states in
the $K^0-\bar{K}^0$ system, and that these eigenstates have
differing momentum eigenvalues. This mechanism can be tested
experimentally by searching for an energy dependence in $m_L -
m_S$, yielding a stringent bound on LLI violation in this
sector. Previous bounds on LLI violation
\cite{spexp,cole,glash} are comparable to the bound obtained
from the $K^0-\bar{K}^0$ system, but occur in different sectors
of the standard model. More precise and detailed tests in the
Kaon system should provide us with important empirical
information on the validity of the special theory of relativity.
\vskip 1.5in
\noindent
{\bf Acknowledgements}
This work was supported in part by the Natural Sciences and
Engineering Research Council of Canada. One of us (TH)
acknowledges financial support from Bundesministerium f\"ur
Bildung, Wissenschaft, Forschung und Technologie, under
Contract \hbox{No. 057 DO 93P(7)}.
\vskip 1.5in
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\baselineskip 16pt
\bibitem{spexp} V.W. Hughes, H.G. Robinson, and V.
Beltran-Lopez, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 4} (1960) 342; R.W.P.
Drever, Philos. Mag. {\bf 6} (1961) 683; D. Newman, G.W. Ford,
A. Rich and E. Sweetman, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 40} (1978)
1355; A. Brillet and J.L. Hall, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 42}
(1979) 549; J.D. Prestage, J.J. Bollinger, W.M. Itano, and
D.J. Wineland, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 54} (1985) 2387; S.K.
Lamoureaux, J.P. Jacobs, B.R. Heckel, R.J. Raab, and E.N.
Fortson, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 57} (1986) 3125.
\bibitem{will} C. M. Will, {\it Theory and Experiment in
Gravitational Physics}, 2nd edition (Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1992).
\bibitem{cathugh}C. Alvarez and R.B. Mann, Phys. Rev. {\bf D 55}
(1997) 1732.
\bibitem{gasp}M. Gasperini, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 62} (1989)
1945.
\bibitem{cole} S. Coleman and S.L. Glashow, report no.
HUTP-97/A008 (hep-ph/9703240).
\bibitem{glash} S.L. Glashow, A. Halprin, P.I. Krastev, C.N.
Leung, and J. Panteleone, report no. UDHEP-03-97 (hep-ph/9703240).
\bibitem{utrobb} M. Gasperini, Phys. Rev. {\bf D 39} (1989)
3606; H. Minakata and H. Nunokawa, Phys. Rev. {\bf D 51} (1995)
6625; J.N. Bahcall, P.I. Krastev and C.N. Leung, Phys. Rev.
{\bf D 52} (1996) 1770; R.B. Mann and U. Sarkar, Phys. Rev. Lett {\bf
76} (1996) 865; A. Halperin, C.N. Leung and J. Panteleone,
Phys. Rev. {\bf D 53} (1996) 5365; H. Minakata and A. Smirnov,
Phys. Rev. {\bf D 54} (1996) 3698; J.R. Mureika, Phys. Rev. {\bf D56} (1997) 2408;
R.B. Mann and J.R. Mureika, Phys. Rev. {\bf D54} (1996) 2761;
R.B. Mann and J.R. Mureika, Phys. Lett. {\bf B368} (1996) 112.
\bibitem{new}T. Hambye, R.B. Mann and U. Sarkar, in preparation.
\bibitem{aron} M.L. Good, Phys. Rev. {\bf 121} (1961) 311; O.
Nachtmann, Acta Physica Austriaca, Supp. VI {\sl Particle
Physics} ed. P. Urban, (1969) p. 485; S.H. Aronson, G.J.
Bock, H-Y Cheng and E. Fishbach, {\bf 48} (1982) 1306; Phys.
Rev. {\bf D28} (1983) 495; I.R. Kenyon, Phys. Lett. {\bf
B237} (1990) 274; R.J. Hughes, Phys. Rev. {\bf D46} (1992)
R2283;
\bibitem{pdg}Review of Particle Properties, Phys. Rev. {\bf
D54} (1996) 1.
\bibitem{gib} L.K. Gibbons, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 70}
(1993) 1199.
\bibitem{sch} B. Schwingenheuer et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 74}
(1995) 4376.
\bibitem{cullen} M. Cullen, et al., Phys Lett. {\bf 32 B} (1970) 523.
\bibitem{gew} C.Geweniger et al., Phys. Lett. {\bf 48 B} (1974) 487.
\bibitem{gjes} Gjesdal et al., Phys. Lett. {\bf 52 B} (1974) 113.
\bibitem{adler} R. Adler et al., Phys. Lett. {\bf B 363} (1995) 237.
\end{thebibliography}
\end{document}