A note on half-supersymmetric bound states in M-theory and type IIA
Extracted source text ยท arXiv hep-th/0105083
\documentstyle[11pt]{article}
\textwidth=5.2in
\parindent=0pt
\begin{document}
\def \beq {\begin{equation}} \def \eeq {\end{equation}}
\def \bea {\begin{eqnarray}} \def \eea {\end{eqnarray}}
\newcommand\mx[4]{\left#1\begin{array}{#2}#3\end{array}\right#4}
\begin{center}\Large \textbf{A note on half-supersymmetric bound states in
M-theory and type IIA}
\end{center}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\begin{center}
\textbf{Henric Larsson}
\normalsize
\vspace{0.2cm}
\emph{Institute for Theoretical Physics \\
G\"oteborg University and Chalmers University of Technology \\
SE-412 96 G\"oteborg, Sweden \\
E-mail: solo@fy.chalmers.se}
\end{center}
\vspace{0.5cm}
\begin{center}
\large {\bf Abstract} \end{center} \small
By using $O(7,7)$ transformations, to deform D$6$--branes, we obtain
half-supersymmetric bound state solutions of type IIA supergravity,
containing D6, D4, D2, D0, F1-branes and waves. We lift the solutions
to M-theory which gives half-supersymmetric M-theory bound states, e.g.
KK6--M5--M5--M5--M2--M2--M2--MW. We also take near horizon limits for
the type IIA
solutions, which gives supergravity duals of 7--dimensional
non-commutative open string theory
(with space-time and space-space non--commutativity), non--commutative
Yang-Mills theory (with space-space and light-like non--commutativity) and
an open D4--brane theory.
\vspace{0.5cm}
\normalsize
\section{Introduction}
Many different dual supergravity solutions corresponding to bound states have
been constructed
\cite{sugra1,cederwall1,has}, using different solution generating methods
\cite{sugra1,cederwall1,has,per,solo}.
Most of these bound states have D3, D4, D5, NS5 or M5--branes as the
highest rank brane.
These bound states are of interest since they are useful in the
investigation of non--commutative Yang-Mills theory (NCYM)
\cite{has,NCYM,al,solo},
non--commutative open string theory (NCOS) \cite{sei,NCOS,solo},
OM/ODp/$\widetilde{\rm ODq}$ theory \cite{OM,ODp,al1,ODq,solo1} and
wound string theory \cite{WST}. More
specifically, they are used to construct supergravity duals of
non--commutative open brane (or gauge) theories, by taking appropriate near
horizon limits. E.g., for a bound state which has been obtained by an NS-NS
$B_{01}$ deformation of a D$p$--brane, one has to take an `electric' near
horizon limit, while
for a bound state with $B_{12}$ one has to take a `magnetic' near horizon
limit. In the first case one obtains the supergravity dual of
$(p+1)$-dimensional space-time non--commutative open string theory,
which can be seen
by investigating the properties of
the open string quantities (see e.g. \cite{solo})
\begin{equation}\label{NCOS}
\frac{G_{\mu\nu}}{\alpha'}=\frac{1}{\alpha'_{\rm eff}}H^{-1/2}\eta_{\mu\nu}\ ,
\quad
G^{2}_{OS}=gH^{\frac{3-p}{4}}\ ,\quad \Theta^{01}=\alpha'_{\rm eff}\ ,
\end{equation}
where $G_{\mu\nu}$ is the open string metric, $G^{2}_{OS}$ is the open string
coupling constant and $\Theta^{01}$ is the non--commutativity parameter.
Note that the open string metric and coupling constant approach constant
values in the decoupling limit $\frac{r}{R}\rightarrow\infty$, since
$H=1+\Big(\frac{R}{r}\Big)^{7-p}\rightarrow 1$. This implies that
the tension of open strings, in the
decoupling limit, is $T=1/\alpha'_{\rm eff}$, which means that massive open
string modes are kept in the spectrum.
In the second case one obtains the supergravity dual of non--commutative
super-Yang-Mills, with $\Theta^{12}\neq 0$ and not an open string theory, since
the massive open strings decouple.
For a more detailed introduction to supergravity duals and the definition
of `electric' and `magnetic' near horizon limits, see Section
3.2 below and \cite{solo,solo1}.
In this note, the main interest is to construct supergravity solutions,
corresponding to half-supersymmetric bound states, for which
the D6--brane (IIA) or the KK6--brane (M-theory) is the brane of highest
dimensionality\footnote{For D6--brane bound states with lower supersymmetry,
see e.g. \cite{sato}.}. All these bound states are
half-supersymmetric since we start with a half-supersymmetric D6--brane and
use $O(7,7)$ transformations to obtain the bound states (more specifically we
only use T-duality and gauge transformations, see Section 2 and
\cite{per,solo} for details). We also construct a half-supersymmetric type
IIB supergravity solution, corresponding to a
D7--D5--D5--D5--D3--D3--D3--D1--F1 bound state (see Appendix A). This bound
state is included since it can not be obtained from the
D6--brane bound states, by using T-duality.
The next step, towards constructing all possible supergravity solutions,
corresponding to M-theory and IIA/B bound states, would be to construct bound
states where the D8--brane is the brane of highest dimensionality. However,
since the
D8--brane only exists in massive type IIA supergravity, one would have to
adjust the deformation procedure that is used in this note (see Section 2),
in order to be able to deform
the D8--brane. Bound states containing D8--branes will not be discussed
further in this note (except in Section 5 Discussion).
As an application, we take near horizon limits of
the type IIA bound states and obtain supergravity duals of NCOS (with
space-time
and space-space non--commutativity), NCYM (with space-space and light-like
non--commutativity) and an open D4--brane theory.
This note is organized as follows: In Section 2 we give an introduction to
the most important features of
the solution generating technique that we will use in Section 3 and 4.
In the next Section we construct various bound
states containing D6--branes and lower rank D--branes as well as F-strings
and waves. We also take various near horizon limits, which give supergravity
duals of different non--commutative open brane (or gauge) theories.
In Section 4 we lift the type IIA bound state solutions to 11
dimensions, which gives half-supersymmetric (since uplifting to 11
dimensions preserves supersymmetry) bound states containing
KK6, M5, M2--branes and M-waves. We conclude with section 5 which is
discussion.
\section{Deformation of D$p$--branes}
The solution generating technique that we will use was derived in
\cite{per} (see also \cite{solo}) following earlier work in \cite{has}. For
an NS deformation of a
general D$p$--brane one first T-dualizes
in the directions where one wants to turn on NS fluxes, and then one
shifts $B_2$ with a constant in these directions. After this
one T-dualizes back again. In a more precise
language, the
deformation with parameter $\theta^{\mu\nu}$ is generated by
the following $O(p+1,p+1)$ T-duality group element\footnote{See
\cite{per,solo} for conventions and definitions of the
various elements of $O(p+1,p+1)$ appearing in the following discussion. Note
that in this note $\theta^{\mu\nu}$ is dimensionless while in
\cite{per,solo,solo1},
$\frac{\theta^{\mu\nu}}{\alpha'}$ were dimensionless.}
\beq \Lambda=\Lambda_0\dots
\Lambda_p\Lambda_{\theta}\Lambda_p\cdots \Lambda_0=
J\Lambda_{\theta}J=\Lambda_{-\theta}^T =
\mx{(}{ll}{1&0\\ \theta&1}{)}\ , \eeq
where $\theta^{\mu\nu}$ is dimensionless and carries indices
upstairs since it starts life on the T-dual world volume \cite{per}.
Starting with a D$p$--brane solution\footnote{We are using
multi-form notation such that $C$ is a sum of forms while $B$ (see below)
has fixed rank $2$. Note also that in this example the
exact form of e.g. $g_{\mu\nu}$ and $e^{2\phi}$ is not important.}
\begin{eqnarray}
ds^{2}&=&g_{\mu\nu}dx^{\mu}dx^{\nu}+g_{ij}dy^{i}dy^{j}\ ,\quad e^{2\phi}\ ,
\nonumber\\
C&=&\omega dx^{0}\wedge \cdots \wedge dx^{p}+\gamma_{7-p}\ ,
\end{eqnarray}
where $x^{\mu}$, $\mu=0,\ldots ,p$, are coordinates in the brane directions
while $x^{i}$, $i=p+1,\ldots ,9$, are coordinates in the transverse
directions.
$\gamma_{7-p}$ is a transverse form, i.e., $i_{\mu}\gamma_{7-p}=0$, where
$i_{\mu}$ denotes the inner derivative in the $\mu$ direction.
Now following the above deformation procedure gives the following deformed
configuration \cite{solo}:
\begin{eqnarray}\label{def}
\tilde{g}_{\mu\nu}&=&g_{\mu\rho}\Big[(1-(\theta g)^{2})^{-1}\Big]^{\rho}_{}
{\nu}
\ , \quad \tilde{g}_{ij}=g_{ij}\ , \nonumber\\
\tilde{B}_{\mu\nu}&=&-g_{\mu\rho}\theta^{\rho\sigma}g_{\sigma\lambda}
\Big[(1-(\theta g)^{2})^{-1}\Big]^{\lambda}_{}{\nu}\ ,\\
e^{2\tilde{\phi}}&=&\frac{e^{2\phi}}{\sqrt{{\rm det}(1-(\theta g)^{2})}}=
e^{2\phi}\Big(\frac{{\rm det}\tilde{g}}{{\rm det}g}\Big)^{\frac{1}{2}}\ ,
\nonumber\\
\tilde{C}&=&e^{-\frac{1}{2}\tilde{B}_{\mu\nu}dx^{\mu}\wedge dx^{\nu}}\big(
\omega e^{\frac{1}{2}\theta^{\mu\nu}i_{\mu}i_{\nu}}dx^{0}\wedge\cdots \wedge
dx^{p}+\gamma_{7-p}\big)\ .\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
There are two types of deformations that are possible: $\theta^{0i}$ and
$\theta^{ij}$, where $i,j=1,2,\ldots,p$. The first one is called `electric'
since we mix the time direction with a spatial direction,
while the second is called `magnetic' since the time direction is not included.
Electric deformations are used if one would like to include F1--strings in the
bound state, while magnetic deformations are used to include D$q$--branes,
where $q=p-2,p-4,\ldots,p-2n$, and $n$ is the number of magnetic deformations
(i.e., one turn on $\theta^{12},\theta^{34}\ldots,\theta^{2n-1,2n}$).
To include waves, one has to mix an electric and a magnetic deformation with
equal `strength', i.e., turn on e.g. $\theta^{01}$ and $\theta^{12}$ where
$\theta^{01}=\pm \theta^{12}$.
\section{Type IIA bound states and non--commutative theories}
\subsection{Type IIA bound states}
In this section, we will apply the above deformation procedure to the
D$6$--brane. The undeformed, half-supersymmetric,
D$6$--brane configuration is given by
\begin{eqnarray}
ds^2&=&H^{-1/2}(-(dx_{0})^{2}+\ldots +(dx_{6})^{2}) + H^{1/2}(dr^{2}+r^{2}
d\Omega^{2}_{2})\ ,\nonumber\\
C&=&\frac{1}{gH}dx^0\wedge\cdots dx^6+\frac{1}{g}R\epsilon_{1}\ ,\\
e^{2\phi}&=&g^{2}H^{-3/2}\ ,\quad H=1+\frac{R}{r}\ , \quad
R=gN\sqrt{\alpha'}\ ,\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
where $d\epsilon_{1}$ is the volume form of the 2-sphere and $g$ is the
closed string coupling constant. We will now apply
an $O(7,7)$ transformation on a D6--brane (see above and \cite{per} for more
details) in order to obtain bound states containing D$6$--branes and lower
dimensional D--branes and possibly F-strings and waves.
Deforming the D6-brane by turning on $\theta^{01}$, $\theta^{12}$,
$\theta^{34}$ and $\theta^{56}$, gives the following deformed
configuration:\footnote{For $\theta^{01}=0$ the metric,
NS-NS 2-form, dilaton and the RR 1- and 3-forms have been obtained
in \cite{al,oz}, using a different solution generating technique.}
\begin{eqnarray} \label{D6W}
d\tilde{s}^{2}&=&\frac{H^{-1/2}}{h}(-h_{12}(dx^{0})^{2}+(dx^{1})^{2}
+h_{01}(dx^{2})^{2})-2\frac{H^{-3/2}}{h}\theta^{01}\theta^{12}
dx^{0}dx^{2}\nonumber\\
& &+H^{-1/2}\Big(\frac{1}{h_{34}}((dx^{3})^{2}+(dx^{4})^{2})+\frac{1}{h_{56}}
((dx^{5})^{2}+(dx^{6})^{2})\Big)\nonumber\\
& &+H^{1/2}(dr^{2}+r^{2}d\Omega_{2}^{2})\ ,\nonumber\\
e^{2\tilde{\phi}}&=&g^{2}\frac{H^{-3/2}}
{hh_{34}h_{56}} \ ,\nonumber\\
\tilde{B}&=&{\theta^{01}\over Hh}dx^0\wedge dx^1
-{\theta^{12}\over Hh}dx^1\wedge dx^2
-{\theta^{34}\over Hh_{34}}dx^3\wedge dx^4
-{\theta^{56}\over Hh_{56}}dx^5\wedge dx^6\ ,\nonumber\\
g\tilde{C}_7&=&{1\over Hhh_{34}h_{56}}dx^0\wedge\cdots \wedge
dx^6+\frac{\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{H^{3}hh_{34}h_{56}}\Big(\theta^{12}dx^{1}
\wedge dx^{2}\\
& &-\theta^{01}dx^{0}\wedge dx^{1}\Big)\wedge dx^{3}
\cdots dx^{6}\wedge R\epsilon_{1}
\ ,\nonumber\\
g\tilde{C}_5&=& -\frac{\theta^{56}}{Hhh_{34}}dx^{0}\wedge
\cdots \wedge dx^{4}-\frac{\theta^{34}}
{Hhh_{56}}dx^{0}\wedge dx^{1}\wedge dx^{2}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6}
\nonumber\\
& &-\frac{1}{Hh_{34}h_{56}}\Big(\theta^{01}
dx^{2}\wedge \cdots \wedge dx^{6}+\theta^{12}dx^{0}\wedge
dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6}\Big)\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{1}{H^{2}}\Big(\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{34}}
{hh_{34}} dx^{1}\wedge dx^{2}\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}
+\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{56}}{hh_{56}} dx^{1}
\wedge dx^{2}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6}\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{h_{34}h_{56}} dx^{3}
\wedge dx^{4}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6}-\frac{\theta^{34}\theta^{01}}
{h_{34}h} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{1}\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}\nonumber\\
& &-\frac{\theta^{56}\theta^{01}}{h_{56}h} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{1}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6}\Big)\wedge R\epsilon_{1}\ ,\nonumber\\
g\tilde{C}_{3}&=&\frac{\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{Hh} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{1}\wedge dx^{2}+\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{56}}{Hh_{34}} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}+\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{34}}{Hh_{56}} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6}\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{34}}{Hh_{56}} dx^{2}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge
dx^{6}+\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{56}}
{Hh_{34}} dx^{2}\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}-\tilde{B}\wedge R\epsilon_{1}
\ ,\nonumber\\
g\tilde{C}_{1}&=&R\epsilon_{1}-\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{H}
dx^{0}-\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{H}dx^{2}\ ,\nonumber \\
\mbox{with}& & h_{i,i+1}=1+(\theta^{i,i+1})^{2}H^{-1}\
, \quad i=1,3,5\ ,\quad h_{01}=1-(\theta^{01})^{2}H^{-1}\ ,\nonumber\\
& & h=1-(\theta^{01})^{2}H^{-1}+(\theta^{12})^{2}H^{-1}\ .\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
This solution gives rise to many different bound states depending on the
values
of the $\theta$ (deformation) parameters. If
$\theta^{01}=\pm \theta^{12}\neq 0$ there is a wave included in the
bound state. E.g., if all the other
parameters are nonzero then we have a
D6--$(\rm D4)^{3}$--$(\rm D2)^{3}$--D0--F1--W
bound state\footnote{Here $(\rm D4)^{3}$ means that there are three
D4--branes in the bound state.}.
In this case the metric can be
rewritten in the following way (with $\theta^{01}=-\theta^{12}=\theta$ and
$h=1$):
\begin{eqnarray}\label{W}
d\tilde{s}^{2}&=&H^{-1/2}\Big[(-dx^{0}+dx^{2})(dx^{0}+dx^{2})+(dx^{1})^{2}-
H^{-1}\theta^{2}(-dx^{0}+dx^{2})^{2}\nonumber\\
&+&\frac{1}{h_{34}}((dx^{3})^{2}+(dx^{4})^{2})+\frac{1}{h_{56}}
((dx^{5})^{2}+(dx^{6})^{2})+H(dr^{2}+r^{2}d\Omega_{2}^{2})\Big],\
\end{eqnarray}
which implies that there is a wave in the 2nd direction. This can be seen by
going to light-like coordinates $x^{\pm}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(x^{2}\pm x^{0})$.
Instead if
$|\theta^{01}|>|\theta^{12}|$ one can perform a Lorentz transformation to a
frame where $\theta^{01}\neq 0$ and $\theta^{12}=0$\footnote{We thank P.
Sundell for pointing this out to us. See also \cite{wu,LLNCYM}.}. Then if all
the other
parameters are nonzero, we have a D6--$(\rm D4)^{2}$--D2--F1 bound state.
Finally,
if $|\theta^{01}|<|\theta^{12}|$, one can perform a Lorentz transformation
to a frame where $\theta^{01}=0$ while $\theta^{12}\neq 0$, which gives a
D6--$(\rm D4)^{3}$--$(\rm D2)^{3}$--D0 bound state provided also
$\theta^{34}$ and $\theta^{56}$ are nonzero. In Table 1 we
show in
which directions the different branes are oriented (for the
D6--$(\rm D4)^{3}$--$(\rm D2)^{3}$--D0 bound state).
\begin{table}
\begin{center}
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline
Brane & $x^{1}$ & $x^{2}$ & $x^{3}$ & $x^{4}$ & $x^{5}$ & $x^{6}$ \\
\hline
D6 & X & X & X & X & X & X \\ \hline
D4 & X & X & X & X & $-$ & $-$ \\ \hline
D4 & $-$ & $-$ & X & X & X & X \\ \hline
D4 & X & X & $-$ & $-$ & X & X \\ \hline
D2 & X & X & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ \\ \hline
D2 & $-$ & $-$ & X & X & $-$ & $-$ \\ \hline
D2 & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ & X & X \\ \hline
D0 & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ & $-$ \\ \hline
\end{tabular}
\end{center}
\caption{The D6--$(\rm D4)^{3}$--$(\rm D2)^{3}$--D0 bound state}
\label{D64442220}
\end{table}
Using T-duality, all these bound states can be used to obtain bound
states in type IIB with a D5--brane (see \cite{cederwall1} for the complete
$(p,q)$ 5--brane bound states) or a D7--brane as the highest rank brane.
However, T-duality of the deformed D6--brane solution (\ref{D6W}) can not be
used in order to obtain a D7--brane bound state, with a rank 8
($\theta^{i,i+1}$ $i=0,2,4,6$) deformation. This
D7--$(\rm D5)^{3}$--$(\rm D3)^{3}$--D1--F1
bound state is therefore included in Appendix A.
\subsection{Non--commutative theories}
In the three different cases above it is possible to take near horizon limits,
e.g., if one wants to obtain supergravity duals of non--commutative open brane
(or gauge) theories. In the first case, with
$\theta^{01}=-\theta^{12}=\theta$ (which correspond to a light-like
deformation, since $B_{-1}\neq 0$ and $B_{+1}=0$)
and $\theta^{i,i+1}\neq 0$ ($i=3,5$), one has to take a magnetic near
horizon
limit \cite{per}, i.e., keeping the following quantities fixed:\footnote{
This limit gives a finite supergravity lagrangian, since
$d\tilde{s}^{2}/\alpha'$,
$\tilde{B}_{2}/\alpha'$ and $\tilde{C}_{q}/(\alpha')^{q/2}$ are kept fixed in
the $\alpha'\rightarrow 0$ limit.}
\begin{equation}\label{mag}
x^{\mu}\ ,\quad u=\frac{r}{\alpha'}\ ,\quad \tilde{\theta}=\alpha'\theta\ ,
\quad
\tilde{\theta}^{i,i+1}=\alpha'\theta^{i,i+1}\ ,\quad
g^{2}_{\rm YM}=g(\alpha')^{3/2}\ ,
\end{equation}
in the $\alpha' \rightarrow 0$ limit.
Taking this limit for the $\theta^{01}=-\theta^{12}$ case, gives the
supergravity dual of NCYM theory with
light-like ($\Theta^{+1}=\sqrt{2}\tilde{\theta}$, $\Theta^{-1}=0$), as well as
space-space non--commutativity ($\Theta^{i,i+1}=\tilde{\theta}^{i,i+1}$,
$i=3,5$)\footnote{For other NCYM theories with light-like non--commutativity
see e.g. \cite{al1,LLNCYM}.}. This can be seen from the metric (\ref{W}) by
going to light-like coordinates $x^{\pm}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(x^{2}\pm x^{0})$.
The above limit can also be used in all other cases when
$\theta^{01}=0$. Then one obtains supergravity duals of NCYM with
space-space non--commutativity ($\Theta^{i,i+1}=\tilde{\theta}^{i,i+1}$,
$i=1,3,5$), which was shown in \cite{al}.
In the case when
$\theta^{01}=\theta^{12}=\theta^{34}=0$ and \mbox{$\theta^{56}\neq 0$},
one can also
interpret the supergravity solution as being dual to an open D4--brane theory
(since there is a critical RR 5-from in the solution, which is responsible for
the finite tension $T=\frac{1}{\ell^{5}_{D4}}=\frac{1}{g^{2}_{\rm YM}
\tilde{\theta}^{56}}$ of an open D4--brane),
containing light open D4--branes analogous to the open D$q$--brane theories
in \cite{ODq,solo1}\footnote{In \cite{solo1} it was shown that the
supergravity dual of $(q+3)$--dimensional NCYM (with one non-zero $\theta$) is
identical to the supergravity dual of an open D$q$--brane theory, provided
one makes the identification (25) in \cite{solo1}. Note that the case $q=4$
was not discussed in \cite{solo1}, but that equation (25) is still valid in
this case. For a more thorough investigation of open
D$q$--brane theories ($q$=0,1,2,3), see \cite{solo1}.}. Using the results in
Section 4 in \cite{solo1}
(defining the coupling in a similar fashion) gives that the open D4--brane
theory, with length-scale $\ell_{\rm D4}$ and coupling constant
$G^{2}_{\rm D4}$,
and the 7--dimensional NCYM theory (with only $\tilde{\theta}^{56}\neq 0$) are
related as follows:
\begin{equation}\label{openD4}
g^{2}_{\rm YM}=G_{\rm D4}^{4/5}\ell_{\rm D4}^{3}\ ,\quad
\Theta^{56}=\tilde{\theta}^{56}=G_{\rm D4}^{-4/5}\ell_{\rm D4}^{2}\ .
\end{equation}
This implies that 7-dimensional NCYM (with only $\tilde{\theta^{56}}\neq 0$)
arises in the limit of small $G^{2}_{D4}$ and small length scale
$\ell_{D4}$ (keeping $\tilde{\theta}^{56}=G_{\rm D4}^{-4/5}\ell_{\rm D4}^{2}$
fixed), which is the weakly coupled low energy limit of the open
D4--brane theory, where we expect to have an effective field theory
description.
When $\theta^{01}\neq 0$ and $\theta^{12}=0$
one has to take an
electric near horizon limit, i.e., keeping the following quantities
fixed \cite{solo,solo1}\footnote{To be more
precise, $\theta^{01}=k$ where $k$ is the constant in the harmonic function
$H$. In this note we always set $k=1$.}:
\begin{equation}\label{el}
\tilde{x}^{\mu}=\sqrt{\frac{\alpha'_{\rm eff}}{\alpha'}}x^{\mu}\ ,\quad
\tilde{r}=\sqrt{\frac{\alpha'_{\rm eff}}{\alpha'}}r\ ,\quad \theta^{01}=1\ ,
\quad \theta^{i,i+1}\ ,\quad g\ ,
\end{equation}
in the $\alpha'\rightarrow 0$ limit.
Note that this limit is very different from (\ref{mag}) since the limit is
obtained by making the electric field critical (i.e., $\theta^{01}=1$). In the
$\theta^{01}\neq 0$ and $\theta^{12}=0$ case this
limit gives the supergravity dual of 7--dimensional NCOS with the following
open string quantities:
\begin{eqnarray}
\frac{G_{\mu\nu}}{\alpha'}&=&\frac{1}{\alpha'_{\rm eff}}H^{-1/2}\eta_{\mu\nu}
\ ,\quad
G^{2}_{OS}=gH^{-3/4}\ ,\nonumber\\
\Theta^{01}&=&\alpha'_{\rm eff} ,\quad
\Theta^{34}=\theta^{34}\alpha'_{\rm eff}\ ,
\quad \Theta^{56}=\theta^{56}\alpha'_{\rm eff}\ ,
\end{eqnarray}
which means that we have both space-time and space-space non--commutativity.
However, since all the above theories are world volume theories of
a deformed D6--brane, it is possible that some or all of them do not
decouple from the bulk gravity. This is a possibility since the undeformed
super-Yang-Mills theory on the D6--brane does not decouple \cite{mal}.
In e.g.
\cite{LLNCYM} it was suggested that NCYM theory with light-like
non--commutativity does not decouple, and in \cite{oz} it was shown that
NCYM with space-space non-commutativity is not a decoupled theory.
For NCOS on the other hand it was argued in \cite{sei,witten} that NCOS
decouple for all D$p$--branes with $p<7$.
Whether the open D4--brane theory decouples or not is unclear, but since it has the
same supergravity dual as NCYM (with only $\theta^{56}\neq 0$) it indicates
that it is not a decoupled theory. A further investigation of this will be
presented elsewhere.
\section{M-theory bound states}
Next, we lift the type IIA bound state solutions (\ref{D6W})
to obtain half-supersymmetric M-theory bound state solutions\footnote{Note
that uplift to 11 dimensions does not reduce supersymmetry.}.
Lifting the type IIA solution (\ref{D6W}) to 11 dimensions on a circle with
radius $R_{11}=g\sqrt{\alpha'}$ gives\footnote{
We use the conventions used in \cite{solo1}. Note also that we do not include
the auxiliary 6-form.}
\begin{eqnarray} \label{KK6}
ds^{2}_{11}&=&(hh_{34}h_{56})^{1/3}\Big[\frac{1}{h}(-h_{12}(dx^{0})^{2}+
(dx^{1})^{2}+h_{01}(dx^{2})^{2})-2\frac{1}{Hh}\theta^{01}\theta^{12}
dx^{0}dx^{2}\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{1}{h_{34}}((dx^{3})^{2}+(dx^{4})^{2})+\frac{1}{h_{56}}
((dx^{5})^{2}+(dx^{6})^{2})+H(dr^{2}+r^{2}d\Omega_{2}^{2})\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{1}{Hhh_{34}h_{56}}\Big(dx^{10}-R\epsilon_{1}+
\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{H}
dx^{0}+\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{H}dx^{2}\Big)^{2}\Big]\ ,
\nonumber \\
A_{3}&=&\frac{\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{Hh} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{1}\wedge dx^{2}+\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{56}}{Hh_{34}} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}+\frac{\theta^{12}\theta^{34}}{Hh_{56}} dx^{0}
\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6} \nonumber\\
& &+\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{34}}{Hh_{56}} dx^{2}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge
dx^{6}+\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{56}}
{Hh_{34}} dx^{2}\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}
\\
& &+\Big({\theta^{01}\over Hh}dx^0\wedge dx^1
-{\theta^{12}\over Hh}dx^1\wedge dx^2
-{\theta^{34}\over Hh_{34}}dx^3\wedge dx^4 \nonumber\\
& &-{\theta^{56}\over Hh_{56}}dx^5\wedge dx^6\Big)\wedge (dx^{10}-
R\epsilon_{1})
\ , \quad H=1+\frac{R}{r}\ .\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
Depending on the values of the $\theta$ parameters, we obtain several different
bound states, e.g., $\theta^{01}=0$, and $\theta^{i,i+1}\neq 0$ ($i=1,3,5$)
gives a half-supersymmetric KK6--$(\rm M5)^{3}$--$(\rm M2)^{3}$--MW bound
state (i.e., uplifting of the
D6--$(\rm D4)^{3}$--$(\rm D2)^{3}$--D0 bound state).
With $\theta^{01}=\pm \theta^{12}$ and
$\theta^{i,i+1}\neq 0$ ($i=1,3,5$) we instead obtain a half-supersymmetric
KK6--$(\rm M5)^{3}$--$(\rm M2)^{4}$--$(\rm MW)^{2}$ bound state
(which is uplifting to M-theory of the
D6--$(\rm D4)^{3}$--$(\rm D2)^{3}$--D0--F1--W bound state). In this case the
metric can be
rewritten in the following way (with $\theta^{01}=-\theta^{12}=\theta$ and
$h=1$):
\begin{eqnarray}\label{W1}
d\tilde{s}^{2}_{11}&=&(h_{34}h_{56})^{1/3}\Big[(-dx^{0}+dx^{2})(dx^{0}+dx^{2})
+(dx^{1})^{2}-H^{-1}\theta^{2}(-dx^{0}+dx^{2})^{2}\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{1}{h_{34}}((dx^{3})^{2}+(dx^{4})^{2})+\frac{1}{h_{56}}
((dx^{5})^{2}+(dx^{6})^{2})+H(dr^{2}+r^{2}d\Omega_{2}^{2})\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{1}{Hh_{34}h_{56}}\Big(dx^{10}-R\epsilon_{1}+
\frac{\theta\theta^{34}\theta^{56}}{H}(-dx^{0}+dx^{2})\Big)^{2}\Big]\ ,
\end{eqnarray}
where the waves are in the 2nd and 10th directions.
Finally, if we have $\theta^{01}\neq 0$, $\theta^{12}=0$ and
$\theta^{i,i+1}\neq 0$,
$i=3,5$, we obtain a KK6--$(\rm M5)^{2}$--$(\rm M2)^{2}$ bound state
(i.e., uplifting of D6--$(\rm D4)^{2}$--D2--F1).
\section{Discussion}
In this note we have obtained type IIA bound states, containing D6, D4, D2,
D0, F1--branes and waves, using $O(7,7)$ transformations on D6--branes.
Lifting
these bound states to M-theory gives bound states containing KK6, M5,
M2--branes and M--waves. In an Appendix we have also included a type IIB
D7--$(\rm D5)^{3}$--$(\rm D3)^{3}$--D1--F1 bound state.
For the type IIA bound states we take electric
(\ref{el}) and magnetic (\ref{mag}) near horizon limits, which give us
supergravity duals of NCOS (with $\Theta^{01}=\alpha'_{\rm eff}$,
$\Theta^{34}=\theta^{34}\alpha'_{\rm eff}$ and
$\Theta^{56}=\theta^{56}\alpha'_{\rm eff}$) and NCYM (with light-like and
space-space non-commutativity). In the case of NCYM with only
$\tilde{\theta}^{56}\neq 0$
we argue that the supergravity dual can also be interpreted as supergravity
dual of a theory containing light open D4--branes, where the relation between
the open D4--brane theory and NCYM is given in (\ref{openD4}). This suggest
that NCYM (with only $\tilde{\theta}^{56}\neq 0$) is the low energy limit of
the
open D4--brane theory, i.e., the open D4--brane theory is the UV completion
of 7-dimensional NCYM.
In \cite{oz} it was shown that NCYM on the D6--brane does not decouple. For
NCOS on the other hand it was argued in \cite{sei,witten} that NCOS decouple
for all D$p$--branes with
$p<7$. The possible decoupling of the open D4--brane theory has to be
investigated further. However, the fact that it has the same supergravity dual
as NCYM (with only $\tilde{\theta}^{56}\neq 0$) might indicate that it is
not a decoupled theory.
Next, to study the strong coupling of NCOS (with only $\Theta^{01}\neq 0$),
one has to lift the D6-F1 bound state to M-theory, which gives the KK6-M2
bound state, and take the appropriate near horizon limit\footnote{The easiest
way
to obtain this supergravity dual is to lift the D6-F1 bound state after one
has taken an electric near horizon limit.}. What complicates this set up is
that the KK6--brane is in the $x^{1}-x^{6}$ directions while the M2--brane
has one direction in the periodic $x^{10}$ direction, i.e., transverse to the
KK6--brane. For large $\tilde{r}$ the metric approaches a smeared membrane,
which in the case of the near horizon region of the M5-M2 bound state
indicates the existence of an open membrane theory. In this case, however,
one can not adopt the same interpretation since one of the membrane directions
is transverse to the KK6--brane. It remains to be seen what the strong
coupling limit of 7-dimensional NCOS is, but we do not expect it to be an
open membrane theory.
As the next step, it would be interesting to find out if NCOS and/or the open
D4--brane theories really are decoupled or not, and also what their strong
coupling limits are. One can also further investigate
the M-theory bound states KK6--$(\rm M5)^{3}$--$(\rm M2)^{3}$--MW and
KK6--$(\rm M5)^{3}$--$(\rm M2)^{4}$--$(\rm MW)^{2}$, in order to find dual
theories. However, these theories are probably not decoupled, since they
are strong
coupling limits of NCYM with space-space non--commutativity and NCYM with
space-space as well as light-like non--commutativity, respectively.
Deformations of a type IIA D8--brane should also be possible, but since the
D8--brane only exists in massive type IIA, one would have to adjust the
deformation procedure in order to include these deformations. This has not yet
been done, but we expect that it is possible to deform the D8--brane with
e.g. a magnetic rank 8 deformation $\theta^{i,i+1}$, $i=1,3,5,7$, which
should give a half-supersymmetric
D8--$(\rm D6)^{4}$--$(\rm D4)^{6}$--$(\rm D2)^{4}$--D2 bound state.
\vspace{0.5cm}
\Large {\bf Acknowledgments}
\normalsize
\vspace{0.3cm}\\
We thank M. Cederwall, U. Gran, M. Nielsen,
B.E.W. Nilsson and P. Sundell for discussions and comments.
\appendix
\section{Deformation of the D7--brane}
In this appendix we will deform the D7--brane with a rank 8 deformation, by
turning on $\theta^{01},\theta^{23},\theta^{45}$ and $\theta^{67}$. Note that
a rank 8 deformation is not possible for the D6-brane. The resulting
D7--brane bound state can therefore not be obtained from
the deformed D6--brane (\ref{D6W}), using T-duality. The undeformed D7--brane
configuration is given by (see e.g. \cite{ort})\footnote{Note that
we do not include the auxiliary RR $C_{0}$ potential. For an introduction to
\mbox{7--branes} and their transformations properties under $SL(2,Z)$, see
\cite{ort}.}
\begin{eqnarray}\label{7}
ds^2&=&H^{-1/2}(-(dx_{0})^{2}+\ldots +(dx_{7})^{2}) + H^{1/2}(dr^{2}+r^{2}
d\Omega^{2}_{1})\ ,\nonumber\\
C_{8}&=&\frac{1}{gH}dx^0\wedge\cdots dx^7\ ,\\
e^{2\phi}&=&g^{2}H^{-2}\ ,\quad H=k+\frac{g}{2\pi}\log{\frac{r}{R}}\ ,
\nonumber \end{eqnarray}
where $k$ is an arbitrary constant.
Deforming the D7--brane
with $\theta^{01},\theta^{23},\theta^{45}$ and $\theta^{67}$ gives
\begin{eqnarray} \label{D7M}
ds^{2}&=&H^{-1/2}\Big(\frac{1}{h_{01}}(-dx^{2}_{0}+dx^{2}_{1})
+\frac{1}{h_{23}}(dx^{2}_{2}+dx^{2}_{3})+\frac{1}{h_{45}}(dx^{2}_{4}
+dx^{2}_{5})\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{1}{h_{67}}(dx^{2}_{6}+dx^{2}_{7})\Big)+H^{1/2}(dr^{2}+
r^{2}d\Omega^{2}_{1})\ , \nonumber\\
e^{2\tilde{\phi}}&=&\frac{g^{2}H^{-2}}{h_{01}h_{23}h_{45}h_{67}} \ ,\nonumber\\
\tilde{B}&=&{\theta^{01}\over Hh_{01}}dx^0\wedge dx^1
-{\theta^{23}\over Hh_{23}}dx^2\wedge dx^3
-{\theta^{45}\over Hh_{45}}dx^4\wedge dx^5
-{\theta^{67}\over Hh_{67}}dx^6\wedge dx^7\ ,\nonumber\\
g\tilde{C}_8&=&{1 \over Hh_{01}h_{23}h_{45}h_{67}}dx^0\wedge
\cdots \wedge dx^7\ ,\\
g\tilde{C}_6&=& -\frac{\theta^{01}}{Hh_{23}h_{45}h_{67}}
dx^{2}\wedge\cdots \wedge dx^{7}-\frac{\theta^{23}}
{Hh_{01}h_{45}h_{67}}dx^{0}\wedge dx^{1}\wedge dx^{4}\wedge\cdots
\wedge dx^{7}\nonumber\\
& &-\frac{\theta^{45}}{Hh_{01}h_{23}h_{67}}
dx^{0}\wedge\cdots\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{6}\wedge dx^{7}
-\frac{\theta^{67}}
{Hh_{01}h_{23}h_{45}}dx^{0}\wedge\cdots \wedge dx^{5}\ ,\nonumber\\
g\tilde{C}_{4}&=&\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{23}}{Hh_{45}h_{67}}
dx^{4}\wedge dx^{5}\wedge dx^{6}\wedge dx^{7}+\frac{\theta^{01}
\theta^{45}}{Hh_{23}h_{67}} dx^{2}
\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{6}\wedge dx^{7}\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{67}}
{Hh_{23}h_{45}} dx^{2}\wedge dx^{3}\wedge dx^{4}\wedge dx^{5}
+\frac{\theta^{23}\theta^{45}}{H
h_{01}h_{67}} dx^{0}\wedge dx^{1}\wedge dx^{6}\wedge dx^{7}\nonumber\\
& &+\frac{\theta^{23}
\theta^{67}}{Hh_{01}h_{45}} dx^{0}\wedge dx^{1}\wedge
dx^{4}\wedge dx^{5}+\frac{\theta^{45}
\theta^{67}}{Hh_{01}h_{23}} dx^{0}\wedge dx^{1}\wedge
dx^{2}\wedge dx^{3}\ ,\nonumber\\
g\tilde{C}_{2}&=&-\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{23}\theta^{45}}
{Hh_{67}}dx^{6}\wedge dx^{7}-\frac{\theta^{01}
\theta^{23}\theta^{67}}
{Hh_{45}}dx^{4}\wedge dx^{5}\nonumber\\
& &-\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{45}\theta^{67}}
{Hh_{23}}dx^{2}\wedge dx^{3}-\frac{\theta^{23}\theta^{45}\theta^{67}}
{Hh_{01}}dx^{0}\wedge dx^{1}\ ,\nonumber \\
g\tilde{C}_{0}&=&\frac{\theta^{01}\theta^{23}\theta^{45}\theta^{67}}
{H}\ ,\nonumber\\
\mbox{with}& & h_{i,i+1}=1+(\theta^{i,i+1})^{2}H^{-1}\ , \quad i=2,4,6\ ,
\quad h_{01}=1-(\theta^{01})^{2}H^{-1}\ . \nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
For $\theta^{i,i+1}\neq 0$ ($i=0,2,4,6$) we obtain a
D7--$(\rm D5)^{3}$--$(\rm D3)^{3}$--D1--F1 bound state. If $\theta^{01}=0$
the F1--string will no longer be included. Instead, if one magnetic $\theta$
vanishes
the D1--brane is removed, while two magnetic $\theta'$s equal to zero removes
the D1 and D3--branes and finally, all three equal to zero removes the D1, D3
and D5--branes.
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\small
\bibitem{sugra1}
J.M. Izquierdo, N.D. Lambert, G.Papadopoulos and
P.K. Townsend, Nucl.\ Phys.\ {\bf B460} (1996) 560, [hep-th/9508177].\\
J.C. Breckenridge, G. Michaund and R.C. Myers, Phys. Rev. {\bf D55} (1997)
6438, [hep-th/9611174]. \\
M.S. Costa and G. Papadopoulos, Nucl. Phys. {\bf B510} (1998) 217,
[hep-th/9612204]. \\
J.G. Russo and A.A. Tseytlin, Nucl.\ Phys.\ {\bf B490} (1997) 121,
[hep-th/9611047].\\
N. Ohta and J-G. Zhou, Int. J. Mod. Phys. {\bf A13} (1998) 2013,
[hep-th/9706153].\\
M. Cederwall, U. Gran, M. Holm and B.E.W. Nilsson, JHEP {\bf 9902} (1999)
003, [hep-th/9812144].\\
J.X. Lu and S. Roy, Nucl. Phys. {\bf B560} (1999) 181, [hep-th/9904129]. \\
J.X. Lu and S. Roy, JHEP {\bf 0001} (2000) 034, [hep-th/9905014]. \\
E. Bergshoeff, R. Cai, N. Ohta and P.K. Townsend, Phys. Lett. {\bf B495}
(2000) 201, [hep-th/0009147].
\bibitem{cederwall1}M. Cederwall, U. Gran, M. Nielsen, and B.E.W. Nilsson,
JHEP {\bf 0001}
(2000) 037, [hep-th/9912106].
\bibitem{has}A. Hashimoto and N. Itzhaki, Phys. Lett. \textbf{465B} (1999) 142,
[hep-th/9907166].
\bibitem{per} P. Sundell, hep-th/0011283, to be published in Int. J. Mod.
Phys. {\bf A}.
\bibitem{solo}D. Berman, V.L. Campos, M. Cederwall, U. Gran, H. Larsson
M. Nielsen, B.E.W. Nilsson and P. Sundell, JHEP {\bf 0105} (2001) 002,
[hep-th/0011282].
\bibitem{NCYM}
J.Maldacena and J.G. Russo, JHEP {\bf 9909} (1999) 025, [hep-th/9908134].\\
J.F.L. Barbon and E. Rabinovici, JHEP {\bf 9912} (1999) 017, [hep-th/9910019].
\\
T. Harmark and N. Obers, JHEP {\bf 0003} (2000) 024, [hep-th/9911169].\\
R-G. Cai and N. Ohta, JHEP {\bf 0003} (2000) 009, [hep-th/0001213].
\bibitem{al}M. Alishahiha, Y. Oz and M.M. Sheikh-Jabbari, JHEP {\bf 9911}
(1999) 007, [hep-th/9909215].
\bibitem{sei}R. Gopakumar, J. Maldacena, S. Minwalla and A. Strominger, JHEP
{\bf 0006} (2000) 036, [hep-th/0005048].
\bibitem{NCOS}
N. Seiberg, L. Susskind and N. Toumbas, JHEP {\bf 0006} (2000) 021,
[hep-th/0005040].\\
J.X. Lu, S. Roy and H. Singh, JHEP {\bf 0009} (2000) 020, [hep-th/0006193].\\
T.~Harmark, JHEP {\bf 0007} (2000) 043, [hep-th/0006023].\\
J.~G.~Russo and M.~M.~Sheikh-Jabbari, JHEP {\bf 0007} (2000) 052,
[hep-th/0006202].\\
R-G. Cai and N. Ohta, Prog. Theor. Phys. {\bf 104} (2000) 1073,
[hep-th/0007106].\\
J.X. Lu, S. Roy and H. Singh, Nucl. Phys. {\bf B595} (2001) 298,
[hep-th/0007168].\\
J.G. Russo and M.~M.~Sheikh-Jabbari, hep-th/0009141.\\
U. Gran and M. Nielsen, hep-th/0104168.\\
J.L.F. Barb$\acute{\rm o}$n and E. Rabinovici, hep-th/0104169.
\bibitem{OM}
R. Gopakumar, S. Minwalla, N. Seiberg and A. Strominger, JHEP {\bf 0008}
(2000) 008, [hep-th/0006062].\\
E. Bergshoeff, D.S. Berman, J.P. van der
Schaar and P. Sundell, Phys. Lett. {\bf B492} (2000) 193, [hep-th/0006112].\\
D.S. Berman and P. Sundell, JHEP {\bf 0010} (2000) 014, [hep-th/0007052].\\
Y. Michishita, JHEP {\bf 0009} (2000) 036, [hep-th/0008247].
\bibitem{ODp} T. Harmark, Nucl. Phys. {\bf B593} (2001) 76 , [hep-th/0007147].
\bibitem{al1}M. Alishahiha, Y. Oz and J.G. Russo, JHEP {\bf 0009} (2000) 002,
[hep-th/0007215].
\bibitem{ODq} J.X. Lu, JHEP {\bf 0108} (2001) 049, [hep-th/0102056].
\bibitem{solo1}H. Larsson and P. Sundell, JHEP {\bf 0106} (2001) 008,
[hep-th/0103188].
\bibitem{WST}J. Gomis and H. Ooguri, hep-th/0009181.\\
U.H. Danielsson, A. Guijosa and M. Kruczenski, JHEP {\bf 0010}
(2000) 020, [hep-th/0009182].\\
U.H. Danielsson, A. Guijosa and M. Kruczenski, JHEP {\bf 0103}
(2001) 041, [hep-th/0012183].
\bibitem{sato}M. Sato, hep-th/0101226.
\bibitem{oz}M. Alishahiha, H. Ita and Y. Oz, JHEP {\bf 0006} (2000) 002,
[hep-th/0004011].
\bibitem{wu}G-H. Chen and Y-S. Wu, Phys. Rev. {\bf D63} (2001) 086003,
[hep-th/0006013].
\bibitem{LLNCYM}O. Aharony, J. Gomis and T. Mehen, JHEP {\bf 0009} (2000) 023,
[hep-th/0006236].\\
R-G. Cai and N. Ohta, JHEP {\bf 0010} (2000) 036, [hep-th/0008119].
\bibitem{mal}O. Aharony, S.S. Gubser, J. Maldacena, H. Ooguri and Y. Oz,
Phys. Rept. {\bf 323} (2000) 183, [hep-th/9905111].
\bibitem{witten}S.S. Gubser, S. Gukov, I.R. Klebanov, M. Rangamani and
E. Witten, hep-th/0009140.
\bibitem{ort}P. Meessen and T. Ortin, Nucl. Phys. {\bf B541} (1999) 195,
[hep-th/9806120].
\end{thebibliography}
\end{document}