Be7(p,gamma)B8 and the high-energy solar neutrino flux
Extracted source text ยท arXiv nucl-th/9704053
% ======================= Do Not Remove These Comments ! ====================
%
% This is 'hip-temp.tex', Ver. 101d,
% Standard LaTeX 2.09 template file for Heavy Ion Physics.
%
%
% It should be used to prepare a manuscript source to be typeset using the
% hip-artc.sty or hip-prep.sty files. Version 100a was developed
% by I. Lovas, Attila Mihaly and Bela Ivanyi, further improvements in version
% 100 are by Laszlo Csernai. Major rewriting from version 101 is due to
% Botond Bako. The style and template file is developed by public bodies
% universities and research institutes, so they are freely distributable and
% do not constitute to copyrighted private property. However, these initial
% comments should not be removed in case of providing the style file to
% further users.
% Commercial use is forbidden without the approval of the developers above.
%
% Eventual suggestions for improvements should be addressed to
% the Editor, Istvan Lovas: lovas@heavy-ion.atomki.hu
%
% Budapest, July 16, 1996
% Debrecen, January 1, 1997
% --------------------------------------------------------------------------
%
\documentstyle[hip-artc]{article}
% for journal manuscripts
%\documentstyle[hip-prep]{article}
% for preprints
% The block below should be completed by the Editors ____________________%|
% %|
\volnumber{5} \edyear{1997} \frompage{000} \topage{000} %|
% \recrevdate{1 Jan. 1991} %|
% or eventually: %|
\recrevdate{1 January 1996; revised version 1 January 1997} %|
%________________________________________________________________________%|
%
\def\rightmark{$^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B and the high-energy solar neutrino
flux} \def\leftmark{Attila Cs\'ot\'o}
\title{$^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B and the high-energy solar neutrino flux}
\authors{
%
{\twerm Attila Cs\'ot\'o %
}\\[2.812mm]
{\normalsize
Theoretical Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, \\
Los Alamos NM 87545, USA\\[0.2ex]
%
}}
\abstract{ The importance of the $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B reaction in
predicting the high-energy solar neutrino flux is discussed. I
present a microscopic eight-body model and a potential model for
the calculation of the $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B cross section.}
\begin{document}
\maketitle
\section{Introduction}
Today the neutron halo structure in some nuclei near the neutron drip
line is well established. The proton drip line is, however, less
well understood. The first (and so far still best) candidate for a
proton halo structure was $^8$B. In this paper I show how important
it is to understand the structure of $^8$B in order to be able to
give precise predictions for the high-energy solar neutrino flux.
The high level of sophistication achieved in standard electroweak and
stellar physics enables us to understand in detail the synthesis and
evolution of the elements of the Universe in the Big Bang and in stars.
The astronomical observations and theoretical predictions are in a very good
general agreement with each other, with a few notable exceptions. Perhaps
the most notorious of these exceptions is the solar neutrino problem.
Despite thirty years of extensive experimental and theoretical work, the
predicted solar neutrino fluxes are still in sharp disagreement
with measurements. The solar neutrino measurements strongly suggest that
the problem cannot be solved within the standard electroweak and
astrophysical theories. Thus, the solar neutrino problem constitutes the
strongest (and so far almost only) evidence for physics beyond the Standard
Model \cite{Bahcall}.
Whatever the solution of the solar neutrino problem turns out to be, it
is of paramount importance that the input parameters of the underlying
electroweak and solar theories rest upon solid ground.
The most uncertain nuclear input parameter in standard solar
models is the low-energy $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B radiative
capture cross section. This reaction produces $^8$B in the
Sun, whose $\beta^+$ decay is the main source of the
high-energy solar neutrinos. Many present and future solar neutrino
detectors are sensitive mainly or exclusively to the $^8$B neutrinos
(Fig.\ 1).
\begin{figure}[bt]
%\vspace*{-0.5cm}
\begin{center}
\leavevmode
\epsfysize=5cm
\epsfbox{fig1.eps}
\end{center}
\vspace*{-0.7cm}
\caption[]{
Solar neutrino fluxes predicted by the solar model of Bahcall
\cite{Bahcall}. The thresholds of the various detectors are indicated.
}
\label{fig1}
\vspace*{-0.5cm}
\end{figure}
The predicted $^8$B neutrino flux is proportional to
$S_{17}$, the $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B astrophysical $S$ factor
($S(E)=\sigma(E)E\exp[2\pi\eta(E)]$), at solar energies ($E_{cm}=20$ keV).
Thus, the value of $S_{17}$(20 keV) is a crucial input parameter
in solar models.
Currently there is a considerable confusion concerning the
value of $S_{17}(0)$. The six direct capture measurements
performed to date give $S_{17}(0)$ between 15 eVb and 40 eVb,
with a weighted average of $22.2\pm 2.3$ eVb, while a recent
Coulomb dissociation measurement give $S_{17}(0)=16.7\pm 3.2$ eVb.
The theoretical predictions for $S_{17}(0)$ also have a huge
uncertainty, as the various models give values between 16 eVb
and 30 eVb. For an experimental and theoretical summary, see \cite{Langanke}.
In order to set tighter theoretical limits on the value of $S_{17}$,
the nonresonant part of the $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B reaction has been
studied in a microscopic eight-body model \cite{micr} and in a $^7$Be$+p$
potential model \cite{pot}, respectively.
\section{$^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B cross section constrained by A=7 and 8
observables}
The relatively low temperature (on nuclear scale) of our Sun means that all
charged-particle reactions in the energy-generating solar p-p chain
take place well below the Coulomb barrier. In such cases the radiative
capture cross section gets contributions
almost exclusively from the external nuclear regions ($r>6-8$ fm). At such
distances the scattering ($^7$Be+$p$) and bound state ($^8$B) wave functions
are fully determined, provided the scattering phase shifts and bound state
asymptotic normalizations are known. At solar energies the
phase shifts coincide with the (almost zero) hard sphere phase shifts, while
the bound state wave function in the external region behaves like $\bar c
W^+(kr)/r$, where $W^+$ is the Whittaker function and $\bar c$ is the
asymptotic normalization. So the only unknown parameters
that govern the solar radiative capture reactions, like
$^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B, are the $\bar c$ values. The $\bar c$ normalization
depends mainly on the effective $^7$Be--$p$ interaction radius.
A larger radius results in a lower Coulomb barrier, which leads to a higher
tunneling probability into the external region, and thus to a higher cross
section. Our aim is to constrain the theoretical interaction radius by
some properties of A=7 and 8 observables.
In the first model \cite{micr} an eight-body three-cluster wave function
is used, which is variationally converged and virtually complete in
the $^4$He+$^3$He+$p$ cluster model space. We find that the low-energy
astrophysical $S$ factor is linearly correlated with the quadrupole
moment of $^7$Be (Fig.\ 2a). A range of parameters is found where the
most important $^8$B, $^7$Be and $^7$Li properties are reproduced
simultaneously; the corresponding $S$ factor at zero energy is $25-26.5$
eVb.
\begin{figure}[bt]
%\vspace*{-0.5cm}
\begin{center}
\leavevmode
\epsfysize=4.0cm
\epsfbox{fig2.eps}
\end{center}
\vspace*{-0.7cm}
\caption[]{
Correlation between (a) the zero-energy astrophysical $S$ factor
of the $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B cross section and the quadrupole moment
of $^7$Be in the microscopic eight-body model \cite{micr}; and (b) the
valence-proton density at 10 fm and the Coulomb displacement energy in
the potential model \cite{pot}.
In Fig.\ (a) the results of several calculations, using various $N-N$
interactions and model spaces, are shown. In Fig.\ (b) the three lines
join points obtained for different values of the diffuseness of the
potential. The crosses show the results of potentials that are previously
used in the literature. The region between the vertical lines are the
range of values allowed by the displacement energy.
}
\label{fig2}
\vspace*{-0.5cm}
\end{figure}
Our second model \cite{pot} describes the $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B process by
assuming a local potential between a structureless $^7$Be and $p$. The
relationship between the Coulomb displacement energy for the A=8, J=2$^{ + }$,
T=1 state and the low-energy astrophysical $S$ factor for the $^{7}$Be($p,
\gamma$)$^{8}$B reaction is studied. The displacement energy is interpreted
in a particle-hole model. The dependence of the particle displacement energy
on the potential well geometry is investigated and is used to relate the
particle displacement energy to the rms radius and the asymptotic
normalization of the valence proton wave function in $^{8}$B. We find
that the theoretical Coulomb displacement energy strongly
constrains the valence-proton density, and thus the asymptotic normalization,
in the external region (Fig.\ 2a). The asymptotic normalization is used to
calculate $S_{17}$. The model predicts $S_{17}$ to be $24.5\pm2.9$ eVb at
zero energy.
\begin{figure}[tb]
%\vspace*{-0.5cm}
\begin{center}
\leavevmode
\epsfysize=5.8cm
\epsfbox{fig3.eps}
\end{center}
\vspace*{-0.7cm}
\caption[]{
Astrophysical $S$ factor for the $^7$Be($p,\gamma$)$^8$B reaction \cite{offsh}.
The symbols show the various experimental data. The solid and long-dashed lines
are the $E1$ components of the $S$ factors in the eight-body model of
\cite{micr} with and without antisymmetrization in the electromagnetic
transition matrix, respectively. The short-dashed line is the result of
a typical potential model.
}
\label{fig3}
\vspace*{-0.5cm}
\end{figure}
The energy dependence of the $S$ factor is also studied \cite{offsh} with
the aim to understand the apparent disagreement between the predictions
of the microscopic eight-body model \cite{micr} and potential models. It
is found that off-shell effects, like antisymmetrization and core-excitation
and deformation, significantly influence the energy dependence of the $S$
factor. The proper treatment of these effects results in a virtually flat
E1 component of the $S$ factor at $E_{cm}=0.3-1.5$ MeV in the present
eight-body model (Fig.\ 3). Off-shell effects can cause 15--20\% changes
in the value of $S_{17}(0)$ extrapolated from high-energy ($E_{cm}>0.7$
MeV) data.
\section{Conclusion}
The zero-energy $S$ factors, predicted by our models, are
slightly higher than but compatible with $S_{17}(0)=22.4\pm 2.1$ eVb,
used in standard solar models \cite{Bahcall}.
\vspace*{0.2cm}
\noindent This work was performed under the auspices of the U.S.\ Department
of Energy, and was also supported by OTKA Grant F019701.
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\bibitem{Bahcall}J~N. Bahcall, {\it Neutrino Astrophysics} (Cambridge
University Press, 1989).
\bibitem{Langanke} K. Langanke, in {\it Solar Modeling} (World
Scientific, Singapore, 1995).
\bibitem{micr} A. Cs\'ot\'o, K. Langanke, S.~E. Koonin, and T.~D.
Shoppa, {\it Phys. Rev.} {\bf C52} (1995) 1130.
\bibitem{pot} B.~A. Brown, A. Cs\'ot\'o, and R. Sherr, {\it Nucl. Phys.}
{\bf A597} (1996) 66.
\bibitem{offsh} A. Cs\'ot\'o, {\it Phys. Lett.} {\bf B394} (1997) 247.
\end{thebibliography}
\vfill\eject
\end{document}