Thermodynamical characterization of heavy ion reactions
Extracted source text ยท arXiv nucl-th/9902004
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%% This is an example file for the Hirschegg Proceedings in Latex %%
%% with the standard style-file article.sty; %%
%% Please use the here defined textwidth and height and also the %%
%% command redefinitions for \section and \subsection; %%
%% format the title page as given here; all other Latex commands %%
%% are available as usual %%
%% %%
%% PLEASE bring along a photo ready hardcopy of your contribution, %%
%% including all figures, to Hirschegg or submit the paper as %%
%% one plain postscript file to hirschegg@gsi.de before end of January %%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\documentstyle[12pt,epsfig]{article}
\pagestyle{empty} %%
\textwidth=14cm \textheight=20cm \topmargin=0cm \oddsidemargin=1cm %%
\let\section=\subsection \let\subsection=\subsubsection %%
\renewcommand\thesubsection{\arabic{subsection}} %%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% Start here your own paper %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\begin{document}
\bigskip
\begin{center}
{\large \bf THERMODYNAMICAL CHARACTERIZATION}\\[2mm]
{\large \bf OF HEAVY ION REACTIONS}\\[5mm]
T.~GAITANOS${}^{a}$, C.~FUCHS${}^{b}$, H.~H.~WOLTER${}^{a}$ \\[5mm]
{\small \it ${}^{a}$Sektion Physik, Universit\"at M\"unchen \\
D-85748 Garching, Germany \\[8mm] }
{\small \it ${}^{b}$Institut f\"ur Theoretische Physik, Universit\"at T\"ubingen \\
D-72076 T\"ubingen, Germany \\[8mm] }
\end{center}
\begin{abstract}\noindent
An detailed study of the thermodynamical state of nuclear matter in
transport calculations of heavy--ion reactions is presented.
In particular we determine temperatures from an analysis of the local
momentum space distribution on one hand, and from a fit to fragment energy
spectra in terms of a blast model with radial flow and temperature on the
other. We apply this to spectator and participant matter. In spectator we
find regions of spinodal instability with temperatures and densities which are
consistent with experiments. In the participant we find different
temperatures for different fragment masses, indicating that the fragments
are not emitted from a source in thermal and chemical equilibrium.
\end{abstract}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\section{Introduction}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
One of the challenges in the study of heavy--ion collisions is the
understanding of multifragmentation in relation to liquid--gas
phase transitions. In spite of many experimental and theoretical
efforts these processes have not been fully understood yet.
This is largely due to the fact that a heavy ion collision is
a dynamical
process where the state of nuclear matter varies strongly in space and time,
and which during much of the
reaction is not in global or even local equilibrium.
This is, e.g. seen by looking at local momentum space distributions in
transport calculations \cite{gait,erice} which are found to be highly
anisotropic even during the compression phase of the collision.
Only at the
later stages of the reaction the local momentum distributions become
more and more thermalized without neccessarily leading to global
thermal equilibrium. Therefore, non--equilibrium effects are important for
a reliable description of heavy ion collisions \cite{gait,essler}.
The influence of these non--equilibrium effects on the determination of the
equation of state of nuclear matter has been discussed in Ref. \cite{gait}.
In this contribution we concentrate on the question of the applicability
of thermodynamical concepts in the non--equilibrium situation of
heavy ion collisions \cite{essler} and,
in particular, with respect to phase transitions and multifragmentation. We
want discuss the question whether, starting from a transport description of
a heavy ion collision, where in principle everything is known about the
system, a thermodynamical picture of multifragmentation can be deduced.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\section{Determination of temperature}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
In this work we make use of two different methods of determining temperature:
In the first, we determine local temperatures by fitting the local momentum
distributions (obtained in our case from relativistic transport
calculations) to covariant
Fermi--Dirac distributions at finite temperature in the local
rest frame \cite{essler}.
Non--equilibrium effects are taken into account by allowing a parametrization
of the momentum space distribution in terms of two thermalized Fermi spheres
\cite{gait} (or covariantly by ellipsoids). With this method we obtain a
local microscopic temperature, $T_{loc}$.
In the second method we follow the experimental
method of fitting fragment energy spectra. These are generated in our
calculations by applying a phase space coalescence algorithm
\cite{gait} to the final stages of the transport calculations.
As in experimental analyses these spectra are interpreted in a
Siemens--Rasmussen \cite{sira} or blast model \cite{fopi}, which assumes a
thermalized freeze--out configuration
of nucleons and fragments with a collective radial flow profile and a
unique temperature \cite{fopi,eos}. In this model the fragment spectra
are given by
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\begin{eqnarray}
\frac{dN}{dE} & \sim & pE \int \: \exp(-\gamma E/T) \:
\Bigg[ \frac{ \sinh{\alpha} }{ \alpha }\left( \gamma+\frac{T}{E} \right) -
\frac{T}{E} \cosh{\alpha} \Bigg] \nonumber\\
& \times& n(\beta)\beta^{2} d\beta
\label{fit}
\qquad .
\end{eqnarray}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
where $n(\beta)$ is the flow profile, $\gamma=\sqrt{1-\beta^{2}}$ and
where T is the global temperature ($\alpha \equiv \gamma \beta p/T$).
The flow profile is obtained from the simulation. Then the remaining
parameter is the temperature $T$ which is fitted to experimental,
resp. generated fragment spectra. In experimental analyses
a global temperature is assumed, which characterizes the shapes of all fragment
spectra. This is not obvious and should be clarified in the analyses of our
transport calculations.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\section{Analysis of spectator matter (semi--central collisions)}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
We first discuss the thermodynamical properties of spectator matter in
semi--central Au on Au reactions at intermediate energies. This reactions
has been studied extensively by the ALADIN collaboration \cite{aladin}.
We determine the spectator temperature from fits to
local momentum distributions (for more details see
Ref. \cite{essler}). Fig. 1 shows the time evolution of the temperature
in the spectator (left side) for different beam energies. When the
spectators are clearly
developed in the transport calculations after about
$40$ fm/c, their temperatures approach a rather constant value of
about $T \approx 5$ MeV which remains fairly stable up to about
80 fm/c, and furthermore is rather independent on the incident energy
considered.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\begin{center}
\begin{minipage}{13cm}
\baselineskip=12pt
\unitlength=1cm
\begin{picture}(12,5)
\put(0.0,-0.5){\makebox{\epsfig{file=Fig2.eps,width=12.0cm}}}
\end{picture}
\\
{\begin{small}
Fig. 1. Left: Temperature evolution in the spectator in semi--central Au on Au
reactions at different beam energies indicated in the figure.
Right: Density-pressure trajectories for the spectator matter for the
same reaction at 600 AMeV. The solid and dashed curves represent londitudinal and transverse pressure, respectively. The squares and circles are the values at different times
starting from $t=35$ fm/c in steps of $5$ fm/c.
The dotted curves are the nuclear matter isothermal equation of state
for $T=5$ and $7$ (lower and upper curve, respectively).
\end{small}}
\end{minipage}
\end{center}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
These results are in good agreement with experiments of
the ALADIN collaboration, which from measurements
with different "thermometers" determine the same value of $T \approx 5$ MeV,
depending only moderately on the beam energy of the reaction.
We also generate pressure--density trajectories for the spectator matter
as a function of time
(right side of Fig. 1). Dynamical instabilities should arise when
the pressure increases with decreasing density indicating a
negative effective compressibility, which occurs here at
$t \geq 50$ fm/c. The system at this stage
therefore enters an instability region and should break up into fragments.
Comparing to the nuclear matter isothermal equation of state for temperatures of
$T=5$ and $7$ MeV corresponding to the range of spectator temperatures
in Fig. 1 one sees that the thermodynamical conditions, as determined here,
are close to but not identical to those of equilibrated nuclear matter. Only at
the final stages the spectator closely follows the nuclear matter behavior at
temperatures of about $T \approx 5$ MeV. The densities at the instability
condition are about $1/3-1/2$ of saturation density. It thus appears that the
spectator closely approaches a freeze--out configuration in thermal and
chemical equilibrium.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\section{Analysis of the fireball (central collisions)}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\begin{center}
\begin{minipage}{13cm}
\baselineskip=12pt
\unitlength=1cm
\begin{picture}(12,5)
\put(-0.3,-0.5){\makebox{\epsfig{file=Fig4.new.eps,width=12.0cm}}}
\end{picture}
\\
{\begin{small}
Fig. 2. Temperatures (left) and radial flow (right) obtained from blast model
fits to fragment energy spectra as function of the beam energy.
The theoretical results are shown for two mean field models (see text).
The data are taken from \protect\cite{fopi,eos}.
\end{small}}
\end{minipage}
\end{center}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
In central collisions the situation is rather different. If very central events
are selected experimentally using
charged particle multiplicities \cite{fopi} or theoretically
at polar angles near mid rapidity \cite{eos}, there is no
spectator matter. Rather one observes a hot dense fireball which expands isotropically as found by our calculations and also by other
groups \cite{fopi}. Thus,
assuming thermalization one can use Eq. (\ref{fit}) to extract the mean collective
radial flow $\beta_{f}=<\beta>$ and a slope temperature $T_{slope}$ from fits to the fragment
energy
spectra. Fig. 2 shows the energy dependence of these quantities as
determined from
our calculations and from experiments for central
Au on Au collisions. Two parametrizations of the mean field
(non--linear Walecka model and configuration dependent Dirac--Brueckner
mean fields \cite{gait}) were used in the calculations to demonstrate
the moderate dependence of of
$\beta_{f}$ and $T$ on the mean field. As seen in Fig. 2 the experimental
data for the radial flow are reproduced very well. The
comparison of the extracted slope temperatures $T_{slope}$ (left side of Fig. 2) is,
however, only qualitative.
It is of interest, to discuss the relation of these slope temperatures to the
local temperatures $T_{loc}$ determined from the momentum distribution of the
calculation (we used a Maxwell--Boltzmann distribution here, in order
to be consistent with eq. (\ref{fit}), but the difference is $\leq 5$ MeV in the
final stages of the collision). It is also of interest to make the comparison
separately for different fragment masses in order to determine whether a
freeze--out szenario with a unique temperature is realistic.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\begin{center}
\begin{minipage}{13cm}
\baselineskip=12pt
\unitlength=1cm
\begin{picture}(12,6)
\put(0.5,-0.5){\makebox{\epsfig{file=Fig5.eps,width=12.0cm}}}
\end{picture}
\\
{\begin{small}
Fig. 3. Temperatures (left) and radial flow (right) for fragments of different mass as determined from blast model fits.
Also simultaneos fits to all fragments including nucleons (filled circle)
and only to fragments with $A_{f} \geq 2$ (filled triangle) are shown.
The open diamond in the left figure is the local temperature at freeze--out
obtained from a fit to local momentum space distributions (see text).
\end{small}}
\end{minipage}
\end{center}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
The results of this analysis are shown in Fig. 3. Here we show the slope
temperatures and radial flow velocities from blast model fits to the spectra
of different fragment masses $A_{f}$. The temperature increases and the radial flow
decreases with increasing mass. In the coalescence picture such a behavior is
reasonable, since a larger fragment has to be generated more inside the fireball, where
the flow velocity is smaller and the temperature higher. In Fig. 3 we also
show the result of a simultaneous blast model fit to all fragments and to fragments
with mass $A_{f} \geq 2$. Since the fragment multiplicities are roughly
exponential and thus dominated by the nucleons the results for all fragments
are close to those for $A_{f}=1$ alone. On the other hand the fit to the heavier
fragments alone has lower radial flow and higher temperature and is the one compared
in Fig. 2 to the corresponding experimental value.
Also shown in Fig. 3 is the local temperature from the momentum distributions
determined at about $35$ fm/c. At this time the fireball in the
calculations approaches a freeze--out configuration (nucleon--nucleon
collisions cease) in equilibrium (pressure isotropic). It is then a consistent
check that the local temperature for this situation agrees approximately
with the one determined from a blast model fit to the $A_{f}=1$ energy spectra.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\section{Conclusions}
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
We have studied the thermodynamical state of nuclear matter in
heavy ion collisions by
analyzing local phase space configurations and by analyzing fragment
energy spectra. For the spectator a consistency with temperatures and
breakup conditions with results of the ALADIN
collaboration was found. For the participant matter we have applied in
addition a blast model analysis to fragment spectra generated in the
coalescence model. We see that the slope temperatures in such a description
do not yield a unique value for all fragments. This does not favour the
picture of a freeze--out configuration in thermodynamical equilibrium. Rather
it appears that fragment emission is a dynamical process which occurs during
a longer stage of the heavy ion reaction.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\itemsep=0cm
\bibitem{gait}
T.~Gaitanos, C.~Fuchs, H.~H.~Wolter, Nucl.~Phys. {\bf A} (1999) in print.
\bibitem{erice}
H.~H.~Wolter, C.~Fuchs, T.~Gaitanos, Progr. in Part. and Nucl. Phys., in print.
\bibitem{essler}
C.~Fuchs et al., Nucl.~Phys. {\bf A626} (1997) 987.
\bibitem{sira}
P.~J.~Siemens and J.~O.~Rasmussen, Phys.~Rev.~Lett. {\bf 42} (1979) 880.
\bibitem{fopi}
W.~Reisdorf and H.~G.~Ritter, Annu.~Rev.~Nucl.~Part.~Sci. {\bf 47} (1997) 663,
and references there.
\bibitem{eos}
M.~Lisa (EOS collaboration), Phys.~Rev.~Lett. {\bf 75} (1995) 2662.
\bibitem{aladin}
J.~Pochodzalla (ALADIN Collaboration),
Phys.~Rev.~Lett. {\bf 75} (1995) 1040;
W.~Trautmann (ALADIN Collaboration),
Proc. of the 35th International
Winter Meeting on Nuclaer Physics, Bormio, Italy, 1997,
ed. by I. Iori.; W.~Serfling et al. (ALADIN collaboration),
Phys.~Rev.~Lett. {\bf 80} (1998) 3928.
\end{thebibliography}
\end{document}